GEORGE15.13 PROAKIS15.13 -15.13 CITY15.13 OF15.13 WATERTOWN15.13 -15.13 If15.13 folks15.38 want15.7 to16.02 come16.02 to16.26 have16.41 a16.57 seat,16.66 we16.98 can17.14 get17.3 started.17.54 You're20.1 welcome20.34 to20.73 sit20.89 here,21.78 at22.34 the22.49 table22.65 back22.98 here,23.3 on24.14 the24.3 bench24.46 over24.78 there,25.02 any25.42 place25.66 you're25.9 particularly26.54 comfortable27.42 and27.9 happy28.06 to28.3 be28.46 assigned28.62 with29.02 me.29.18 I30.46 just30.62 want30.86 to31.02 make31.02 sure31.18 everybody31.42 is32.94 comfortable33.1 and33.58 we'll33.74 get33.98 going.34.22 So34.7 thank35.1 you.35.34 So37.7 first37.86 of37.95 all,38.02 thank38.18 you38.42 everybody38.59 for38.91 attending39.06 tonight.39.46 Happy40.34 to40.74 have41.3 the41.78 team42.02 from42.27 MAPC,42.5 from43.14 our43.3 regional43.46 planning43.78 agency44.1 here44.5 to,44.74 talk45.55 to45.78 us45.95 about46.18 our46.42 affordable46.66 housing47.14 project.47.55 We49.38 have49.64 a49.72 couple49.8 of49.92 city50.04 Councilors50.52 and51 elected51.24 officials51.56 in51.88 the52.04 room.52.2 Councilor52.52 Piccirilli53.08 over53.64 here,53.8 Councilor54.12 Nicole54.68 Gardner,55.08 state57.16 Rep57.4 Steve57.64 Owens,57.96 and58.36 city58.6 council58.84 president59.24 Mark59.56 Sedaris.59.88 When60.6 I60.84 last61 looked,61.32 Councilor62.3 Bays62.53 and62.53 Palomba62.77 were63.26 both63.41 online.63.73 I64.22 don't64.3 know64.53 if64.61 any64.78 others64.94 have65.25 joined65.42 us65.73 at65.9 this66.06 point,66.14 but,66.45 we67.5 got67.66 a67.9 good67.97 group68.45 of68.69 elected68.86 officials69.25 here.69.58 69.73 And69.73 I69.9 want69.97 to70.22 thank70.22 you70.38 along70.61 with70.86 our71.09 members71.58 of71.9 the72.06 Affordable72.22 Housing72.69 Trust,73.02 members73.33 when79.67 the79.91 city80.07 council80.31 approved80.79 the81.11 Watertown81.27 Square81.83 zoning,82.23 one82.55 of82.79 the82.87 things83.03 that83.27 we83.43 committed83.99 to84.47 in84.79 the84.87 city85.03 administration85.43 was86.23 that86.47 we86.63 would86.71 undertake86.95 a87.35 study87.51 of87.83 incentives87.99 to89.08 promote89.23 more89.8 and90.03 or90.28 deeper90.52 affordable90.92 housing.91.48 Now92.03 I93.48 think93.56 I93.67 know93.8 most94.03 of94.28 you.94.36 I'm94.59 a94.83 city94.92 manager.95.23 I95.64 don't95.8 do96.12 affordable96.44 housing96.92 work97.23 every97.48 day97.72 anymore.103.85 But104.57 as104.57 a104.81 city104.97 planner,105.29 I105.61 spent105.77 20105.93 years105.93 working105.93 with105.93 MAPC.106.17 I106.73 was106.81 on106.97 their107.05 executive107.29 committee107.77 for108.09 a108.25 while.108.41 I108.89 had109.05 a109.13 chance109.21 to109.37 really109.53 get109.77 to109.93 know110.09 the110.25 capabilities110.41 of111.05 the111.21 team111.29 at111.45 MAPC.111.85 And112.33 I112.57 know,112.65 this113.69 consulting113.93 team114.49 has114.65 been114.81 working114.97 hard115.29 for115.61 us116.01 for116.33 quite116.98 a117.15 while117.23 to117.55 address117.78 these118.11 particular118.34 issues.118.75 119.78 They119.78 presented120.03 their120.51 research120.67 findings121.06 in121.47 December.121.63 They're122.34 back122.67 tonight122.83 to123.15 present123.31 preliminary123.7 results124.34 of124.75 the124.91 financial125.06 modeling125.47 of125.94 potential126.11 incentives.126.51 This127.7 won't127.94 be128.1 the128.26 last128.43 time128.67 the128.91 community129.06 will129.47 have129.63 an129.78 opportunity129.94 to130.34 comment130.5 on130.82 this130.99 subject131.15 after131.55 a131.79 final131.95 report132.27 is132.59 submitted.132.75 We133.87 expect134.11 to134.43 have134.59 that134.75 publicly134.99 presented135.47 and136.11 anything136.43 the136.83 administration136.99 proposes137.63 to138.11 implement138.27 in138.67 the138.75 recommendations138.91 would139.71 also139.95 include140.27 a140.59 public140.75 process.141.07 So141.47 there141.79 may142.03 be142.19 a142.27 series142.35 of142.67 recommendations142.83 in143.47 the143.55 final143.71 version143.95 of144.27 the144.35 report.144.51 A144.99 lot145.07 of145.23 them145.31 involve145.55 things145.87 like146.11 changing146.38 zoning,146.78 those147.25 go147.5 into147.66 the147.9 city147.97 council,148.29 into148.85 the149.09 planning149.18 board.149.5 So149.81 there's149.97 a150.22 lot150.29 of150.53 steps151.66 to151.97 this152.13 that152.38 involve152.53 the152.94 public.153.09 This153.41 is154.22 not154.38 the155.01 last155.18 time155.5 you155.74 get155.9 a156.06 chance156.13 to156.46 comment,156.53 but156.85 it157.01 is157.18 great157.5 to157.74 look158.22 at158.46 the158.61 preliminary158.78 and159.57 be159.81 able159.97 to160.22 comment160.38 on160.69 it160.85 before161.01 the161.33 report161.5 comes161.82 out.162.06 163.74 There's163.74 one164.14 detail165.5 I166.06 want167.1 to168.38 share,168.38 maybe168.38 a168.86 little171.18 bit171.5 of172.06 an172.38 inside172.54 detail,173.02 but173.34 I173.58 want173.66 to173.9 focus173.9 on174.22 it174.38 before174.46 we174.78 get174.94 into175.1 this175.42 because175.58 I175.82 think175.9 it's176.14 important176.69 to177.81 note177.97 as178.05 we178.28 frame178.53 the178.84 discussions179.09 coming179.65 out179.89 of180.13 this180.21 report180.44 and180.77 going180.93 into181.09 policy181.41 making.181.81 And183.17 that183.56 is183.81 that184.21 MAPC's185.89 research186.61 found187.09 that187.33 the187.49 market187.65 conditions188.05 are188.53 generally188.77 the189.25 same189.41 citywide.189.72 It's190.6 not190.84 particularly191 surprising.191.56 We're192.12 a192.28 four192.44 square192.6 mile192.92 city.193.16 I194.28 know194.52 within194.84 the195.24 day195.56 to195.72 day195.88 work196.12 of197.08 Watertown197.24 and197.8 the197.96 discussions198.2 with198.76 districts199 and199.32 counselors199.56 and200.04 such200.28 people200.52 may200.84 feel201 the201.24 East201.4 End201.64 and201.88 Watertown202.12 Square202.52 and202.92 the203.08 West203.65 End203.97 are204.44 radically204.69 different205.09 in205.49 some205.72 way,205.89 shape,206.21 or206.53 form.206.6 But206.93 for207.49 the207.65 perspective208.37 of209.17 addressing209.41 the209.89 market210.04 conditions210.44 in210.84 the211 city.211.41 And211.56 the211.56 impact211.72 on212.04 housing212.13 affordability,212.6 the213.65 financial213.81 model214.37 and214.69 the214.84 test214.93 results215.25 don't215.72 differentiate216.04 between216.76 different217.09 parts217.41 of217.56 the217.8 city.217.96 218.28 They218.28 don't218.44 differentiate218.76 between219.24 neighborhoods.219.56 They220.04 don't220.12 differentiate220.36 between,221.24 kind222.92 of223.56 character223.88 of225 streets225.16 and225.56 such225.8 things.226.12 But227.32 that227.48 doesn't227.72 mean228.2 that228.76 the229.08 incentives229.24 should230.12 necessarily230.28 be231 uniform231.24 throughout231.72 the232.04 city.232.12 The233.44 solution233.6 in235.04 an235.21 existing235.44 two235.84 family236 district,236.49 the236.81 solution236.97 on237.37 an237.6 existing237.76 corridor,238.09 the238.56 solution238.72 in239.04 the239.13 core239.21 of239.44 Watertown239.53 Square,240 the240.41 solution240.49 on240.81 the240.97 Arsenal241.13 Street241.76 Corridor242 may242.88 be243.13 different243.28 depending243.76 upon244.25 the244.49 zoning,244.65 the245.13 built245.28 environment,245.6 the246.16 way246.32 the246.49 districts246.56 work247.13 together.247.37 Where249.65 the250.13 potential250.37 incentives250.85 should251.33 be251.49 applied251.73 is252.21 a252.53 very252.61 important252.93 question.253.41 It's254.85 not255.25 the255.89 conversation256.21 for256.93 the257.17 particular257.33 study257.89 because258.13 the258.45 study258.61 is258.93 a259.09 city259.25 wide259.57 big260.63 focus.261.5 When263.43 we263.67 get263.82 into264.15 the264.46 nuts264.63 and264.94 bolts265.11 of265.5 the265.75 where,265.9 there's267.9 way268.38 more268.71 discussion268.94 to269.43 have269.59 on269.82 that.269.99 270.46 But270.46 I270.63 want270.79 us270.94 to271.11 allow271.43 the271.67 MAPC271.82 team272.71 to273.11 frame273.35 the273.75 research273.9 on274.38 the274.46 market274.63 conditions275.1 citywide275.42 first.276.14 And277.42 then277.58 as277.82 they278.06 deliver278.22 a278.62 report278.78 to279.1 us279.18 and279.34 we279.58 look279.74 at279.9 which280.3 incentives280.62 to281.1 apply281.34 and281.58 how281.82 to281.98 apply282.14 them,282.38 we282.62 can282.7 make282.86 a283.02 determination283.18 about284.22 where284.46 it284.7 may284.86 or285.02 may285.26 not285.42 make285.66 sense285.9 to286.7 apply286.86 an287.18 incentive287.42 and287.9 how288.14 that288.3 might288.54 work.288.78 So290.37 with290.44 that,290.84 I291.32 will291.49 send291.88 it292.2 over292.28 to292.6 our292.84 team293.56 that293.81 is293.96 presenting294.2 tonight,294.76 and296.37 I296.69 will296.84 let297.08 them297.32 introduce297.72 themselves298.13 and298.76 share299 everything300.52 that301.16 they301.4 have301.64 to301.81 share.302.04 And,302.52 on303.87 behalf304.11 of304.23 all304.35 of304.59 us304.75 in304.91 the304.99 city305.15 administration,305.47 the306.59 city306.75 manager,307.07 the307.47 community307.63 development307.95 and308.35 planning308.43 team,308.83 I309.63 want309.79 to310.35 thank310.35 you310.59 all310.75 for310.99 coming311.31 out311.55 tonight311.71 and312.03 giving312.27 this312.51 presentation.312.67 Alright.313.31 Thank313.79 you.314.03 322.25 ADAM322.25 PLOETZ322.25 -322.25 MAPC322.25 -322.25 Good322.25 evening,322.56 everyone.322.88 Thank324.73 you324.88 for325.05 that325.2 introduction,325.44 George.325.85 I326.25 appreciate326.32 it.326.64 And326.88 thank327.05 you327.2 for327.37 the327.52 framing327.69 of328.4 what329.44 this329.76 is330.73 and330.96 is331.2 not331.37 doing331.61 kind331.93 of332.08 from332.17 a332.32 big332.4 picture332.56 perspective.332.96 It's334.2 good334.36 to334.44 be334.68 back334.76 in335 Watertown.335.24 My335.96 name336.2 is336.44 Adam336.76 Ploetz.337.08 I'm337.48 the337.64 housing337.8 manager338.12 at338.52 MAPC.338.68 I'm339.88 joined340.12 tonight340.44 by341.48 Emma341.64 Udelovich,341.96 a343.4 regional343.56 housing343.96 and344.28 land344.44 use344.68 planner,344.92 with345.64 MAPC,345.96 and346.68 Evelyne347.56 St-Louis,347.88 a347.88 principal348.04 planner348.52 with348.92 MAPC.349.24 And,349.88 we're350.93 going351.08 to351.32 be351.32 talking351.4 a351.65 little351.73 bit351.96 about352.29 the353.08 project,353.32 what354.21 we've354.37 been354.52 working354.76 on355 since355.17 we355.4 last355.73 met356.05 with356.37 some357.56 of357.81 you.357.96 Certainly,358.29 there359.08 were359.4 new359.4 faces359.56 in359.81 the359.88 crowd360.05 too,360.37 but360.61 we360.76 were360.93 back361.08 here,361.81 we362.61 were362.76 here363 first363.32 in,363.73 I364.47 want364.63 to364.87 say364.87 December364.95 where365.59 we365.83 talked365.99 about366.15 some366.31 preliminary366.63 findings.367.91 369.75 The369.75 agenda369.91 tonight370.47 is371.35 to371.59 provide372.55 a372.87 brief373.03 project373.27 overview373.75 of374.71 the375.59 project,375.83 and377.07 then377.24 we're377.4 going377.56 to377.8 get377.8 into377.96 kind378.84 of379.07 the379.16 work379.31 we've379.56 been379.8 doing379.96 since381.07 our381.48 meeting381.63 in382.04 December,382.28 which383.31 includes383.63 reviewing384.84 our385.63 market386.12 rate386.44 financial386.68 feasibility387.16 analysis,387.72 looking388.95 at389.19 our389.67 Pro390.39 Forma390.55 model,390.55 looking390.95 at391.27 a391.43 buy391.59 down391.83 model,392.07 talking392.55 about392.79 some393.03 preliminary393.19 takeaways,393.83 and394.79 then394.95 also395.51 looking395.99 at396.39 our396.79 100%399.75 affordable400.31 housing400.71 development401.03 sources401.51 and402.44 uses403.1 analysis,403.75 and404.42 talk404.62 about404.67 preliminary404.73 takeaways404.78 from404.84 that404.89 research.405.06 And405.38 then405.69 what405.85 we're406.01 talking406.33 about406.65 we'll406.65 be406.89 talking407.06 about407.38 next407.69 steps,407.94 as409.13 we409.21 move409.45 towards409.69 the410.1 conclusion410.25 of410.74 this410.89 project.411.13 So413.54 a413.94 brief414.1 project414.41 overview.414.89 416.69 The416.69 purpose416.93 of417.25 this417.41 study417.65 is418.45 to418.61 assess418.77 voluntary419.41 incentives419.97 that420.77 would421.01 encourage421.17 either421.89 or422.93 both423.17 market423.89 rate424.21 developers424.45 to425.09 produce425.25 more426.21 or426.61 deeper426.85 affordable427.49 units428.69 than429.4 is429.56 already429.81 required430.05 by430.69 Watertown's430.93 existing431.64 mandatory432.2 inclusionary432.76 zoning433.4 policy.433.81 And434.76 the434.93 other435.08 piece435.32 of435.56 this435.73 is436.37 looking436.85 at437.17 ways437.32 to437.73 get438.37 greater438.61 production438.93 of439.64 affordable439.88 housing440.37 developments,440.69 which441.17 are441.4 generally441.64 100%442.2 affordable,442.85 often444.2 kind444.76 of445 like445.08 light445.38 tech445.62 projects445.78 or446.18 light446.42 tech446.58 deals.446.82 I450.18 think450.26 it's450.42 important450.66 to451.7 frame451.86 this452.1 in452.34 Watertown's453.14 existing453.78 policy454.1 context.454.66 So455.46 on455.7 one455.94 hand,456.1 we456.42 have456.58 this456.74 mandatory458.1 inclusionary458.66 zoning459.22 policy.459.62 There's461.54 the461.77 threshold462.01 there,462.5 is463.77 new464.1 developments464.25 with464.74 a464.89 minimum464.98 of465.38 six465.45 units.465.69 466.41 There466.41 is466.65 a466.81 differentiation466.98 between467.69 small468.1 scale468.41 development468.74 and469.29 medium469.54 to469.94 large470.01 scale470.25 development470.57 in471.06 relationship471.21 to472.1 the472.89 percentage473.8 required474.12 units474.68 as475.24 well475.4 as,475.8 the476.6 AMI477.32 point477.8 they're478.2 looking479 to479.32 target.479.48 So481 that's481.24 one481.48 piece481.64 of481.88 it.482.04 And482.28 then482.52 also482.68 looking483.08 at483.56 the484.68 incentives484.92 or485.93 taking486.16 inspiration486.25 for486.32 some486.96 of487.13 the487.2 incentives487.37 for487.76 affordable488 projects488.4 in488.81 Watertown488.96 Square.490.16 And490.64 there491.69 you491.93 have492.08 multifamily492.64 projects493.37 with494.16 at494.4 least494.49 50%494.72 of495.28 units495.37 affordable495.85 at496.4 80%496.56 AMI497.13 are497.52 eligible497.6 for498 incentives,498.25 which498.81 include499.13 things499.76 like500.16 additional500.85 floors.501.41 One502.61 additional502.93 floor,503.41 if503.97 its504.21 affordable504.45 units504.77 are505.09 at505.17 less506.21 than506.45 80%506.53 AMI,507.01 two507.41 additional507.57 floors507.97 if508.29 they're508.45 at508.61 less508.85 than509.01 60%509.17 AMI,509.89 and510.53 also510.77 kind511.41 of511.65 a511.81 ratio511.97 of512.53 reduced512.69 parking513.09 based513.65 on,514.13 through515.17 a515.41 special515.49 permit.515.89 518.18 So518.18 the518.43 context518.67 here519.14 in520.18 relation520.43 to520.83 the520.9 study521.14 is521.63 we've522.5 got522.83 these523.14 Watertown523.38 Square523.95 incentives524.59 that525.23 already525.47 exist.525.87 We're526.9 using527.23 that527.63 to528.11 kind528.35 of528.43 study528.84 some529.4 additional529.64 voluntary530.04 incentives530.52 that531.32 aren't531.64 specific531.96 to532.52 Watertown532.76 Square533.24 or534.2 other534.52 neighborhoods534.84 necessarily,535.48 but536.12 we536.28 are536.36 looking536.52 outside536.84 of537.16 Watertown537.32 Square.537.8 Like,538.12 what's538.28 the538.52 context538.68 for539.08 those539.24 things539.48 to539.72 work539.8 outside540.04 of540.44 the540.52 square?540.68 And541.42 then541.58 looking542.13 at542.54 our542.77 preliminary542.93 takeaways,543.5 I543.98 think544.05 George544.22 kind544.54 of544.7 referenced544.93 that545.34 these545.98 takeaways546.22 are546.7 certainly546.93 not547.34 site548.13 specific,548.46 but549.89 they550.13 could550.38 be550.62 tailored550.77 to551.34 specific551.74 zoning552.13 districts552.62 within553.1 Watertown.553.5 A556.42 recap556.66 of557.06 what557.22 we've557.38 already557.62 done.557.94 So558.9 this559.14 is559.3 the559.38 work559.54 that559.78 we559.86 discussed560.18 with560.74 you560.9 all561.06 in561.3 December.561.46 562.9 We562.9 did563.14 a563.3 zoning563.46 assessment563.78 to564.5 identify564.66 regulatory565.14 constraints565.7 to566.18 housing566.34 production566.66 and567.38 where567.62 zoning567.86 relief568.26 may568.58 be568.74 considered568.9 as569.3 an569.54 incentive.569.7 We571.02 did571.18 a572.07 slew572.38 of572.63 case572.79 study572.95 research573.26 of574.38 voluntary574.63 affordable575.18 housing575.59 incentive576.07 programs576.54 in577.02 other577.26 municipalities577.5 both578.38 in578.63 Massachusetts579.35 and580.23 out580.63 of580.79 state,580.95 to581.99 help582.3 inform582.63 the583.35 decisions583.42 that583.9 Watertown584.14 will584.63 be584.71 making584.87 on585.18 this585.26 issue.585.5 We586.48 interviewed586.8 market587.68 rate588 developers588.24 who589.28 have589.44 done589.68 projects589.92 in590.56 Watertown590.72 to591.36 understand591.52 market592.08 conditions592.48 and,593.2 kind594.56 of594.88 gauge595.12 an595.44 interest595.68 on596.08 the596.72 kind597.52 of597.76 different597.84 incentives598.16 that598.72 are598.88 possible.599.04 We600.04 also600.21 interviewed600.52 with600.92 affordable601.09 housing601.49 developers601.88 for602.61 the602.76 same602.85 reason.603.8 604.04 And604.04 also604.04 to604.28 talk604.45 with605 them605.16 about605.33 barriers605.57 to605.88 affordable606.04 housing606.52 production606.76 in607.49 Watertown,607.64 and608.76 again,609 interest609.4 in609.96 different610.28 potential610.61 incentives.611.09 And612.22 we612.54 also612.7 discussed613.18 some613.9 work614.06 we614.38 did614.54 through615.02 a615.18 focus615.34 group615.66 with616.06 Watertown's616.86 planning617.42 and617.74 zoning617.9 board618.3 membership,618.54 again,620.06 to620.38 get620.54 kind620.86 of621.02 the621.18 municipal621.5 side622.06 of622.3 the622.38 equation622.54 on623.02 this,623.18 to624.18 talk624.26 about624.5 again624.66 kind625.07 of625.3 how625.7 the625.87 review626.02 process626.35 went626.75 as627.23 well627.46 as,627.87 kind628.99 of629.23 different629.38 set629.78 of629.95 options.630.18 I'm631.38 going632.11 to632.99 ask632.99 Emma633.3 Udelovich633.63 to634.18 come634.26 up,634.42 and634.58 she634.82 is634.99 going635.14 to635.38 kind635.54 of635.78 review635.95 our636.58 market637.23 rate637.63 financial637.95 feasibility638.35 analysis.638.9 So,639.46 Emma,639.92 the640.12 floor640.32 is640.56 yours.640.72 Thank641.2 you.641.36 643.28 EMMA643.28 UDELOVICH643.28 -643.28 MAPC643.28 -643.28 Thanks,643.28 Adam.643.68 Hi,644.16 everyone.644.4 So646.24 as646.72 Adam647.12 mentioned,647.52 we648.16 are648.48 focusing648.72 on649.28 both649.44 market649.76 rate650.16 developments650.72 as651.28 well651.44 as651.68 affordable651.92 developments.652.48 In653.36 the653.52 next653.6 section,653.84 I'm654.32 going654.56 to654.88 focus654.88 on655.2 the655.89 market656.05 rate,656.29 developments.657.34 And660.86 the661.01 purpose661.1 here661.41 is661.65 to661.82 test661.98 the662.22 impact662.38 of662.86 voluntary663.1 incentives663.82 on664.62 the664.86 financial665.01 feasibility665.5 of666.29 market666.53 rate666.86 developments667.5 and668.54 asking668.78 whether669.34 they669.66 can669.82 provide670.06 more670.46 or670.78 deeper671.02 affordability,671.42 that's672.54 currently672.86 being673.9 required674.22 under674.7 Watertown's674.94 inclusionary675.74 zoning676.3 policy.676.7 And677.58 we're677.74 going677.98 about678.22 this678.38 in678.62 two678.78 different678.94 ways.679.26 Our679.58 main679.82 focus680.14 was,680.57 to681.21 do681.45 a681.61 zoning681.76 based682.09 and682.49 other682.64 indirect682.88 incentives,683.37 test685.04 or685.45 financial685.68 model,686.16 in687.21 a687.37 Pro688 Forma,689.21 model689.21 approach.689.68 690.25 So690.25 that's690.4 our690.64 first690.8 method.691.04 Our691.76 second692 method,692.33 which692.73 actually692.97 came693.37 out693.61 of693.85 December's694.44 meeting,695.08 there695.8 was696.04 some696.2 interest,696.52 and697.16 curiosity697.4 around,698.2 what699.16 a699.4 buy699.56 down699.8 model700.12 looks700.52 like.700.84 So701.64 exploring701.88 direct702.6 subsidy703.16 incentives703.64 is704.6 our704.76 second705 method705.64 approach.705.96 To709.02 go709.18 into709.59 method710.14 one,710.47 the710.79 Pro711.35 Forma711.43 model.711.43 Just712.55 to712.79 give712.95 a713.18 quick713.43 overview713.83 of714.31 what714.47 is714.63 a714.79 Pro715.26 Forma.715.5 A715.5 Pro715.99 Forma716.07 is716.07 a716.23 tool716.31 that716.55 a716.71 developer716.87 typically717.75 understands718.79 whether719.11 a719.35 real719.43 estate719.67 project719.9 is720.31 likely720.47 to720.87 be720.95 profitable.721.18 This722.69 Pro723.41 Forma723.65 model723.65 usually723.97 uses724.45 a724.77 bunch724.93 of725.17 market725.33 condition727.17 assumptions,727.65 but728.93 is729.09 very729.25 site729.57 specific.729.89 This731.09 tool731.33 can731.57 also731.73 be732.05 very732.21 helpful732.45 for732.85 policy733.09 and733.65 decision733.97 makers,734.37 especially735.73 understanding736.13 how736.85 a737.16 particular737.32 policy737.96 might738.45 impact738.85 the740.04 local740.2 housing740.61 market.740.92 742.37 What's742.37 important742.68 to743 note743.16 here743.49 is743.73 the744.61 Pro745.57 Formas746.04 will746.04 use746.28 some746.52 similar746.85 assumptions,747.57 and748.68 data749.25 inputs.749.73 But751.04 the751.2 difference751.44 between751.84 a752.32 developer's753.28 Pro754.32 Forma754.4 model754.4 and754.64 a754.8 policymaker's754.96 Pro756.08 Forma756.16 model756.16 is756.48 that756.64 it756.96 is757.12 not757.28 site757.6 specific.757.84 So758.4 we758.72 use758.88 a759.04 lot759.2 more759.36 aggregated759.68 data.760.24 We760.64 use760.8 a761.04 lot761.12 more761.28 hypothetical761.52 prototypes,762.97 which763.52 I'll763.68 talk763.85 about,764 a764.8 little764.97 later.765.21 But765.45 I765.61 just765.76 wanted765.93 to766.25 note766.33 here766.57 that766.8 this766.97 is767.13 not767.21 a767.52 one767.76 for768 one,768.33 developer769.76 Pro770.97 Forma771.21 model771.21 to771.52 policymaker771.85 Pro773.21 Forma773.37 model.773.37 And774.75 we774.91 gathered775.15 a775.31 lot775.47 of775.71 our775.87 data776.03 inputs,776.35 from777.47 various778.35 credible778.83 sources,779.23 qualitative780.91 and781.63 quantitative,781.87 that783.63 we'll783.87 get784.03 into784.19 a784.51 little784.59 bit784.75 later784.99 as785.55 well.785.71 So787.8 first,788.21 because790.13 our790.52 Pro791.25 Forma791.33 model791.33 is791.8 built792.04 to792.28 inform792.45 policy.793.73 794.04 We794.04 developed794.04 hypothetical794.52 development795.49 scenarios796.04 or796.68 what797.33 we're797.49 referring797.8 to798.68 as798.92 prototypes.799.49 Basically,801.61 representing802.01 what802.57 could802.89 be803.05 built803.29 in803.77 Watertown804.01 based804.57 on804.81 current804.97 market805.37 conditions.805.77 And,806.25 again,806.41 this806.65 is806.89 not807.05 site807.29 specific807.61 but808.09 based808.25 on808.49 aggregated808.65 data.809.29 Our810.17 first810.41 prototype810.65 is812.65 around812.89 eight813.29 units813.45 with813.77 800814.01 square814.49 feet814.89 of815.13 commercial815.29 space.815.77 This816.75 is816.99 meant817.07 to817.3 represent817.47 a817.87 small817.95 scale818.35 development.818.83 Prototype820.5 two,821.14 25821.47 units821.95 with823.95 3,500824.26 square825.3 feet825.55 of825.71 commercial825.87 space826.35 is826.67 meant826.83 to827.07 represent827.63 a828.11 mid-medium828.99 scale830.02 development.830.02 And831.02 the831.1 prototype831.1 three831.74 60832.14 units832.46 with832.78 5,000833.02 square833.58 feet833.82 of834.06 commercial834.14 space834.62 is835.02 meant835.18 to835.5 represent835.66 a836.3 large-scale837.02 development.837.42 841.82 Next,841.82 we842.14 developed842.3 different843.1 affordable845.68 options.846.33 Again,847.92 testing848.33 to848.73 see848.88 if849.28 more849.52 units849.85 can850.25 be850.4 carved850.57 out850.8 or851.13 even852.49 deeper852.73 affordability,853.13 can854.49 be854.64 carved854.8 out855.13 of855.28 a855.45 market855.52 rate855.85 development.856 So857.13 again,857.2 prototype857.61 one.858.16 The859.34 current859.5 inclusionary859.98 zoning860.62 policy861.02 is861.58 12.5%862.14 of863.26 units,863.42 at864.54 80%864.7 AMI.865.42 We867.02 tested867.34 a868.38 couple868.54 of868.86 different869.02 affordability869.82 options.870.7 Again,871.74 testing872.83 whether873.07 they873.71 can873.88 carve874.12 out874.36 more874.51 or874.83 deeper875 units.875.39 And875.79 then,875.95 prototype876.83 two877.15 and877.39 prototype877.55 three877.95 since,878.36 your879.79 current879.88 inclusionary880.51 zoning881.15 is,881.55 right882.91 now883.15 taking883.39 a883.71 tiered884.03 approach.884.43 The885.55 medium885.79 to886.43 larger886.75 scale887.24 developments887.55 at888.73 10%888.81 of889.37 units889.53 at889.93 80%890.09 AMI890.65 plus891.13 an891.37 additional891.53 5%891.93 of892.57 units892.73 at893.37 65%893.61 AMI894.57 is894.97 the895.13 current895.29 requirement.896.01 And896.73 then,896.89 again,897.13 we897.53 went897.77 broader898.25 or898.73 deeper,898.97 in899.93 our900.17 model.900.41 902.24 So902.24 now902.39 you902.63 know902.72 the902.96 prototypes903.12 that903.6 we903.67 tested903.91 and904.32 the904.55 affordability904.72 options905.43 that905.91 we906.08 tested.906.24 Now907.2 I'm907.36 going907.51 to907.75 talk907.75 a908 little908.08 bit908.32 more908.39 about908.63 the908.88 incentives.909.04 We909.75 came910.08 up910.24 with910.39 a910.55 long912.24 list912.55 of912.96 incentives913.12 that913.67 were913.75 both914 informed914.24 by914.79 developer915.04 interviews915.43 as916 well916.15 as916.39 staff916.55 input.916.96 First,918.78 the919.26 incentives919.5 that920.06 we920.22 tested920.38 were920.94 those921.26 that921.58 reduce921.74 construction922.22 costs.922.78 So923.18 waiving923.74 the924.06 commercial924.22 requirement,924.78 waiving925.74 permitting926.14 fees,926.62 and927.42 reducing927.66 the928.62 parking928.7 ratio.929.18 This931.2 0.5931.51 space932.39 per932.79 unit933.03 came,933.6 or934.32 was934.48 informed934.72 by935.27 what935.51 is935.84 currently936.08 the936.48 base936.55 requirement936.79 in937.51 Watertown938.08 Square.938.72 And941.67 then941.84 we942 also942.15 wanted942.51 to942.67 see942.75 what942.91 these942.99 incentives943.47 look944.03 like944.19 when944.43 we944.67 coupled944.83 them.945.15 So945.39 for945.63 instance,945.79 we,946.51 coupled947.23 waived947.79 commercial948.27 requirements948.75 with,949.39 waiving949.95 permitting950.43 fees.950.91 953.15 Next,953.15 we953.55 wanted953.71 to954.03 test954.19 incentives954.67 that955.31 increase955.47 revenue.956.03 So957.55 that957.72 includes958.04 a958.6 density958.75 bonus.959.08 Why959.88 did960.04 we960.2 pick960.27 a960.51 density960.6 bonus?961.08 Well,961.32 it's,961.6 having962.36 an962.6 extra962.67 density963 bonus963.39 is963.72 actually,963.88 by965.08 far965.24 the965.48 most965.63 common965.88 development966.36 incentive.967.08 We968.75 also,969.08 you969.88 know,970.12 in970.94 our971.18 model,971.34 we971.98 tested972.54 adding973.18 an973.58 extra973.74 height,974.06 but974.3 this974.38 can974.54 look974.7 like974.94 a975.18 lot975.34 of975.5 different975.58 things975.9 when976.38 it976.54 comes976.7 down976.94 to977.1 writing977.26 the977.58 policy.977.74 For979.82 instance,980.06 it980.46 can980.54 look980.78 like980.94 additional981.18 height.981.66 It981.98 can982.14 look982.3 like982.46 an983.03 increased983.91 floor983.91 area984.24 ratio.984.55 It985.51 can985.67 look986.08 like986.32 an986.48 additional986.72 percentage987.03 of987.43 floor987.6 area987.84 or988.24 unit988.48 count.988.79 But,989.03 again,989.2 because989.6 in990.15 Watertown990.32 Square,990.88 the991.2 current991.43 incentives991.75 offer992.55 extra994 height.994.32 Or996.59 I'm996.75 sorry.996.99 In997.47 Watertown997.79 Square,998.27 height998.83 is999.07 Offered.999.63 1002.91 We1002.91 also1003.15 wanted1003.31 to1003.63 show1003.71 what1003.95 this1004.11 looks1004.43 like1004.67 in1004.83 our1004.99 Pro1005.55 Forma1005.71 model.1005.71 So1006.03 just1006.43 taking1006.67 a1006.99 quick1007.07 snapshot1007.39 of1007.79 what1007.87 prototype1008.11 one1008.91 having1009.31 eight1009.63 units1009.87 is1010.19 the1010.35 base1010.43 units,1010.67 adding1012.14 the1012.54 density1012.71 bonus,1013.11 what1013.5 we're1013.66 calling1013.83 is1014.14 the1014.3 (1X)1014.78 An1017.11 additional1017.35 four1017.66 affordable1017.99 units1018.38 would1018.71 be1018.87 added1019.02 to1019.26 prototype1019.5 one,1020.07 with1020.87 a1021.42 density1021.59 bonus1021.99 incentive,1022.63 and1024.07 an1024.31 additional1024.46 eight1024.94 affordable1025.53 units1025.85 would1026.25 be1026.41 offered1026.57 with1026.89 density1027.13 bonus1027.53 two1028.01 times.1028.25 Again,1032.49 similar1032.81 to1033.21 the1033.85 previous1033.93 slide,1034.41 we1034.65 also1034.81 wanted1035.13 to1035.45 see1035.53 what1035.69 coupling1035.85 these1036.25 incentives1036.49 would1037.05 look1037.21 like.1037.37 So1037.61 we,1037.77 coupled1038.41 density1038.89 bonus,1039.37 times1040.58 one1041.06 with1041.46 waiving1041.86 commercial1042.34 requirements,1042.82 waiving1043.93 permitting1044.65 fees,1045.06 or,1046.1 reduced1046.98 parking1047.3 ratio.1047.7 So1050.89 now1051.13 I1051.46 give1051.54 you1051.7 all1051.93 the1052.1 inputs1052.17 into1052.65 our1052.89 Pro1053.54 Forma1053.62 model.1053.62 1054.89 We're1054.89 going1055.2 to1055.44 go1055.44 into1055.52 the1055.76 findings.1056 Because1056.72 the1057.12 inclusionary1057.28 zoning1057.84 policies1058.24 differ,1059.52 between1060.56 small1061.04 scale1061.36 and1061.68 medium1062 to1062.4 large1062.56 scale,1062.88 as1063.2 well1063.36 as1063.6 the1063.68 findings1063.84 drastically1064.4 differed,1064.96 we1065.36 all1065.52 split1066.32 these1066.64 2,1066.96 next1068.52 couple1068.84 slides1069.15 by1069.63 scale.1070.2 So1071.24 first,1071.39 I'll1071.72 talk1071.88 about1072.12 the1072.28 feasibility1072.43 of1073 small1073.15 scale1073.48 development,1073.8 and1074.43 then1074.6 I'll1074.84 go1074.91 into1075.15 medium1075.39 to1075.8 large1075.96 scale.1076.2 So1077.48 the1078.28 findings1078.52 here1080.7 are1081.02 deeper1081.02 affordability.1081.5 So1082.22 50%1082.62 AMI1083.5 is1084.06 not1084.3 generally1084.78 feasible1085.26 for1085.66 small1085.9 scale1086.22 housing1086.62 projects.1087.02 65%1088.62 AMI1089.74 might1090.78 be1090.94 possible;1091.18 density1092.56 bonuses1095.04 were1095.67 allowed.1096.07 Adding1096.46 more1096.85 units1097.24 for1097.63 80%1098.02 AMI1098.8 is1098.84 possible,1098.88 particularly1099.76 if1100.28 the1100.8 commercial1101.32 requirements1101.84 are1102.08 waived.1102.32 And1105.67 density1105.91 bonuses1106.48 can1107.41 definitely1107.73 make1108.21 small1108.53 scale1108.77 developments1109.25 feasible,1110.13 but1110.53 they1110.69 also1110.85 can1111.17 significantly1111.57 change1112.21 the1112.45 project1112.61 size.1113.01 1113.33 So1113.33 what1114.05 once1114.29 could1114.85 have1115.09 been1115.17 a1115.41 small1115.89 scale1116.13 project,1116.45 might1117.49 be1117.73 feasible1117.89 because1118.29 now1118.61 it1118.77 goes1118.85 from1119.09 a1119.25 small1119.33 scale1119.57 to1119.81 a1119.97 medium1120.05 scale1120.45 project.1120.77 So1121.09 something1121.33 to1121.65 consider.1121.81 Our1123.87 preliminary1124.11 takeaways1124.66 here1125.22 are1125.54 more1125.78 affordable1126.02 units.1126.51 So1126.83 501127.07 per1127.46 15%1127.78 of1128.42 units1128.66 at1128.98 80%1129.14 AMI1129.7 can1130.66 be1130.83 carved1131.07 out1131.46 with1131.78 the1132.02 menu1132.11 of1132.51 incentives,1132.74 for1134.18 small1134.42 scale1134.66 developments.1135.07 So1136.35 the1136.51 possible1136.83 menu1137.87 of1138.19 incentives.1138.35 So1138.83 those1138.99 that1139.23 were1139.39 both1139.87 feasible1140.19 but1140.75 also1140.99 attractive,1141.55 as1142.83 incentives1143.23 were1143.87 waiving1144.51 commercial1144.91 requirements1145.39 and1146.11 prohibiting1146.27 fees.1146.91 So1147.23 those1147.39 two1147.63 are1147.87 coupled.1147.87 Providing1149.52 a1149.91 density1150.08 bonus1150.47 with1150.79 the1151.04 option1151.19 to1151.52 couple1151.67 additional1152.47 incentives1152.95 and1153.91 providing,1154.15 twice1155.52 the1155.76 amount1155.91 of,1156.15 a1156.47 density1156.63 bonus.1157.04 1158.39 And1158.39 then1158.55 it's1158.71 also1158.95 important1159.19 to1159.52 note1159.67 here1159.84 too1159.99 that1160.15 small1160.39 scale1160.63 developments1160.95 are1161.52 just1161.67 generally1162.03 hard1162.35 to1162.67 pencil1162.75 out,1163.07 but1163.39 all1163.71 of1163.87 the1164.03 incentives1164.19 proved1165.63 to1165.87 be1166.03 feasible1166.19 and1166.59 attractive1166.83 under1167.47 the1167.87 current,1168.03 inclusionary1168.75 zoning1169.39 policy.1169.79 So,1170.19 this1171.15 is1171.31 also1171.47 an1171.87 important1172.03 thing1172.91 to1173.23 consider1173.31 if,1173.87 you1174.03 know,1174.28 there's1174.52 a1174.67 deal1174.76 for1174.91 a1174.91 small1175.15 scale1175.39 development1175.63 that1176.12 was1176.2 struggling1176.36 to1176.76 pencil1176.84 out1177.15 just1177.39 under1177.56 the1177.8 current1177.96 inclusionary1178.2 zoning.1178.76 All1179.15 of1179.39 these1179.47 incentives1179.71 could1180.28 be1180.43 tools1180.6 to1180.91 help1181.08 a1181.32 small1181.39 scale1181.71 development,1181.96 break1184.04 ground.1184.28 Next,1186.45 talking1186.69 about1186.93 the1187.25 feasibility1187.33 of1187.97 medium1188.21 to1188.61 large1188.77 scale1189.09 developments.1189.49 Our1191.41 study1191.65 found1191.97 that1192.21 medium1192.45 scale1192.77 projects1193.01 were,1194.21 most1195.09 of1195.41 the1195.57 affordability1195.73 options1196.37 were1196.85 feasible1197.09 with1197.65 some1197.97 incentives1198.21 being1198.85 more1199.09 attractive1199.49 than1200.53 others.1200.77 1202.18 For1202.18 large1202.42 scale1202.74 projects,1202.98 all1203.47 affordable1203.79 options1204.35 were1204.74 feasible1204.98 with1205.55 some1205.87 incentives1206.11 being1206.74 more1207.07 attractive1207.31 than1207.79 others.1207.95 And1208.27 we're1208.59 really1208.9 putting1209.07 an1209.31 emphasis1209.47 here1209.87 on1210.11 feasibility1210.35 and1211.47 attractiveness1211.79 because1212.66 these1212.98 are1213.14 voluntary1213.31 incentives.1213.95 And1214.42 if1214.59 a1214.74 developer1214.83 is1215.38 going1215.47 to,1216.2 you1216.76 know,1216.92 want1217.72 to1217.96 opt1218.2 in1218.36 to1218.6 them,1218.68 they1218.92 need1219.32 to1219.56 be1219.64 more1219.8 than1219.96 just1220.12 feasible.1220.36 They1220.68 also1220.84 need1221.08 to1221.32 be1221.4 attractive1221.56 to1222.04 them.1222.2 So1223.48 to1223.96 note1224.2 what1224.44 are1224.68 the1224.84 most1225 attractive1225.24 incentives1227.08 for1227.64 medium1227.96 to1228.36 large1228.52 scale1228.76 developments1229.16 are1229.72 waiving1230.22 commercial1230.7 requirements,1231.27 coupling1232.38 that1232.79 with1233.03 permitting1233.27 fees,1233.83 doing1234.94 a1235.35 one1235.59 times1235.83 density1236.3 bonus1236.7 with1237.03 the1237.27 option1237.35 to1237.74 couple1237.9 additional1238.79 incentives,1239.27 and1239.98 doing1240.14 a1240.38 two1240.54 times1240.79 density1241.18 bonus.1241.59 1244.19 The1244.19 preliminary1244.43 takeaways1244.99 here1245.47 are1245.87 waiving1246.19 commercial1246.59 requirements,1247.07 for1249.31 market1249.63 development1249.95 developments1250.67 that1251.15 opt1251.31 for1251.63 either1251.79 more1252.11 or1252.43 deeper1252.67 affordability1253.07 is1253.87 a1254.19 quite1254.51 attractive1254.91 incentive.1255.47 And1256.8 coupling1256.95 it1257.36 with1257.52 permitting1257.76 feeds,1258.15 provides1258.8 additional1259.19 financial1259.67 cost1260.55 offsets1260.88 particularly1261.52 on1262.15 the1262.32 construction,1262.39 cost1263.76 side.1263.99 Offering1265.19 a1265.6 density1265.67 bonus1266.15 for1266.55 market1266.8 rate1267.12 developments1267.28 that1267.91 opt1268.15 for1268.39 more1268.63 or1268.88 deeper1268.95 is1269.36 also1269.52 quite1269.91 attractive1270.23 to1271.04 market1271.2 rate1271.52 developers.1271.68 And1272.8 then1272.96 a1273.2 similar1273.28 theme1274.8 here1275.04 coupling1275.28 it1275.68 with1275.84 other1276.08 incentives1276.32 does1276.96 increase1277.2 the1277.52 potential1277.76 margin1278.32 of1278.8 profitability,1278.96 allowing1280.16 for1280.48 deeper1281.12 affordability1281.84 gains.1282.8 We1285.79 also1286.03 found1286.18 that1286.42 waiving1286.59 permitting1286.99 fees1287.47 alone1287.95 is1288.35 not1288.51 an1288.83 attractive1288.99 enough1289.47 incentive,1289.79 but1290.83 it1291.07 can1291.23 be1291.47 when1291.63 coupled1291.87 with1292.18 other1292.42 incentives.1292.74 1294.35 Something1294.35 that1294.66 also1294.9 came1295.14 out1295.38 of1295.63 the1295.71 developer1295.95 interviews,1296.51 we1298.66 found1298.9 that1299.23 talking1300.1 when1300.42 talking1300.5 with1300.82 the1300.98 developers,1301.14 auditing1302.1 or1302.5 that1303.14 there1303.22 was1303.38 a1303.62 disconnect1303.94 between1304.58 the1305.06 permitting1305.3 process1305.78 and1306.1 approval1306.34 process.1306.82 There1307.46 seemed1307.7 to1307.94 be1308.02 a1308.1 disconnect1308.18 between1308.66 the1308.98 developers1309.14 and1309.7 the1310.66 zoning1311.06 and1311.46 planning1311.7 board,1312.1 who1313.92 saw1313.92 that1314.16 the1314.4 permitting1314.64 process1315.05 was1315.45 actually1315.61 quick1315.92 and1316.09 efficient,1316.25 but1317.13 the1317.21 developer1317.45 said1317.92 it1318.33 actually1318.49 wasn't.1318.81 So1319.13 our1319.53 preliminary1320.4 takeaway1320.97 here1321.29 is1321.53 that,1321.68 you1321.85 know,1322.01 more1322.88 scrutiny1323.21 needs1323.77 to1324.01 be1324.09 there.1324.25 Auditing1324.57 the1325.05 permitting1325.21 and1325.61 approval1325.68 process1326.25 will1326.88 help1328.33 to1329.03 clarify1329.27 the1329.59 real1329.83 time1330.15 and1330.47 cost1330.63 to1331.03 development.1331.27 Additionally,1333.99 lowering1334.87 the1335.35 floor1335.59 and1335.99 the1336.15 ceiling1336.39 set1336.79 for1337.03 parking1337.19 ratios1337.59 will1338.47 allow1338.63 for1338.95 greater1339.19 flexibility.1339.67 1340.39 We1340.39 didn't1340.55 really1340.79 find1341.03 that1341.35 parking1341.91 reductions1342.47 generated1343.78 enough1344.02 attractiveness1345.7 as1346.34 an1346.58 incentive,1346.73 but1347.38 having1347.78 the1348.1 flexibility1348.26 was1349.3 in1349.78 and1350.02 of1350.1 itself1350.26 enough.1350.73 And1352.26 then1352.41 additionally,1352.65 coupling1353.22 parking1353.7 reduction1354.02 with1354.49 other1354.65 incentive1354.97 incentives,1355.62 did1356.73 make1357.06 parking1357.38 reduction1357.86 a1358.41 meaningful1358.58 incentive.1359.22 And1361.35 then,1361.43 again,1361.75 scaling1362.15 out1362.55 to1362.79 just1362.87 policy1363.27 best1364.07 practices1364.31 in1364.79 general,1365.03 revisiting1365.75 and1366.31 recalibrating1366.55 inclusionary1367.35 zoning1367.99 policies1368.39 and1369.19 incentives1369.43 periodically1370.07 will1370.71 be1370.87 important,1371.19 particularly1372.65 as1373.29 market1373.78 conditions1374.1 change1374.65 at1374.89 a1375.05 faster1375.21 pace1375.53 than1375.93 policy.1376.1 So1377.05 having1377.53 a1377.93 recalibration1378.97 built1379.86 in1380.17 will1380.49 be1380.65 very1381.45 crucial1381.78 to1382.34 having1382.82 these1383.13 incentives1383.38 remain1384.1 feasible1384.49 and1384.89 attractive.1385.13 Next,1387.5 I'm1387.74 going1387.98 to1388.22 pass1388.22 it1388.46 to1388.54 Evelyn1388.78 to1389.1 go1389.26 through1389.42 our1389.66 second1389.98 method,1390.3 the1390.7 buy1390.86 down1391.1 model.1391.34 1404.07 EVELYNE1404.07 ST-LOUIS1404.07 -1404.07 MAPC1404.07 -1404.07 So1404.07 hi,1404.38 everyone.1404.63 I'm1405.03 Evelyne.1405.35 So1406.63 as1407.11 Emma1407.42 mentioned,1407.74 we1408.55 explored1409.18 a1409.9 second1410.87 model1411.74 or1412.22 sort1412.47 of1412.63 approach1412.87 to1413.59 voluntary1414.07 incentives,1414.71 which1416.31 we're1416.63 calling1416.79 here1417.11 the1417.35 buy1417.51 down1417.66 model.1417.98 So1419 this1419.24 came1419.48 out1419.72 from1420.12 the1420.92 last1421.08 meeting.1421.48 It1422.2 kind1422.36 of1422.6 came1422.76 up1423 through1423.4 discussion.1423.8 So1424.44 it's1425.32 a1425.8 preliminary1426.28 analysis1427 that1427.56 we've1427.72 done1427.96 here.1428.12 It1428.52 wasn't1428.68 something1428.92 that1429.32 we1429.48 were1429.64 able1429.8 to1430.04 ask1430.2 the1430.44 developers1430.6 about,1431 and1431.24 we1431.4 didn't1431.56 do1431.8 as1431.96 much1432.12 of1432.36 a1432.44 deep1432.6 dive1432.84 on1433.16 this1433.32 as1433.98 the1434.07 other1434.22 incentives.1434.63 But1435.11 we1435.27 did1435.42 want1435.59 to1435.9 show1435.9 sort1436.63 of1436.7 our1436.87 preliminary1437.11 work1437.83 on1438.07 this,1438.14 and1439.66 sort1439.9 of1441.51 preliminary1441.66 takeaways.1442.38 So1444.07 a1445.03 buy1445.27 down1445.42 program1445.66 is1446.38 an1446.7 indirect1457.21 incentive1457.93 like1458.73 waiving1459.21 commercial1460.21 ground1460.38 floor1460.69 requirement1461.01 or1461.49 reduced1461.73 parking,1462.05 a1462.86 buy1462.93 down1463.1 program1463.34 actually1463.82 involves1464.13 a1464.53 direct1464.62 payment1464.93 to1465.58 the1465.82 developer1465.97 by1466.62 the1466.86 municipality.1467.01 1468.77 So1468.77 that1469.01 could1469.1 be1469.25 a1469.41 direct1469.49 payment1469.82 to1470.38 add1471.49 an1471.82 extra1472.05 affordable1472.45 unit1473.25 in1473.72 a1473.88 market1473.96 rate1474.2 project1474.44 or1474.92 to1475.16 buy1475.4 down1475.64 an1476.68 affordable1476.84 unit1477.32 that's,1477.64 say,1477.8 at1478.12 80%1478.2 AMI1478.92 to1479.4 60%1479.64 AMI.1480.36 And1481.72 so1481.88 that's1482.12 what1482.28 this1482.52 buy1482.84 down1483 model1483.24 tool1483.64 is1483.88 estimating1484.12 is1484.76 the1485.4 fee1485.72 that1486.04 would1486.2 be1486.36 needed1486.52 to1486.92 pay1487.08 the1487.4 developer.1487.56 And1490.41 as1490.65 I1490.82 said,1490.89 this1491.13 is1491.3 sort1491.38 of1491.54 preliminary,1491.69 and1492.73 more1492.97 work1493.3 would1493.54 be1493.78 needed1495.45 especially1495.86 around1496.34 how1497.86 to1498.1 implement1498.26 this1498.73 kind1498.89 of1499.13 program.1499.3 There's1499.69 different1500.02 ways1500.26 to1500.58 do1500.65 it.1500.82 So1501.21 we1501.38 didn't1501.45 dive1501.69 too1502.02 much1502.1 into1502.34 that1502.58 part1502.73 of1503.05 the1503.21 work.1506.24 In1506.64 this1506.88 methodology,1507.04 we1508 expressed1508.48 the1509.2 potential1509.6 fee1510.24 to1510.56 buy1510.72 down1510.96 units1511.28 as1511.84 a1512 range.1512.08 This1513.28 is1513.52 to1513.68 reflect1513.92 the1514.32 fact1514.48 that1514.72 there's1515.6 a1515.92 lot1516 of1516.16 complexity1516.4 and1517.12 variability1517.28 in1518.16 how1518.4 to1518.56 estimate1518.9 this1519.22 kind1519.3 of1519.54 fee.1519.87 1520.42 Depends1520.42 on1520.83 the1520.9 site,1521.07 on1521.38 the1521.54 developer,1521.78 on1522.26 market1522.51 conditions.1522.9 And1524.66 if1525.22 you1525.46 are1525.7 familiar1526.02 with1526.42 how1526.59 in1526.83 lieu1526.98 fee1527.22 payments1527.46 are1527.94 estimated1528.18 or1528.83 can1528.98 be1529.22 set,1529.54 it's1530.02 sort1530.26 of1530.42 a1530.59 similar1530.74 concept1531.14 to1531.7 that.1531.78 And1532.26 there's1532.42 different1532.66 ways1532.9 of1533.22 doing1533.3 that1533.54 calculation1534.14 as1534.62 well.1534.78 And1536.22 for1536.7 the1536.94 purpose1537.02 of1537.34 this1537.42 analysis,1537.66 we1538.3 used1538.54 the1538.94 prototype1540.06 three1540.7 that1540.94 Emma1541.1 mentioned.1541.42 So1541.82 that1541.98 was1542.14 the1542.38 larger1542.54 scale,1542.94 apartment1545.1 building1545.74 type.1546.14 This1550.6 is1550.84 sort1550.99 of1551.23 the1551.39 very1551.47 detailed1551.79 methodology1552.27 on1552.99 the1553.15 three1553.39 methods,1553.71 for1554.6 those1554.76 of1554.99 you1555.15 who1555.39 really1555.47 want1555.71 to1556.03 be1556.03 in1556.12 the1556.27 weeds1556.43 on1556.84 the1557.15 calculations.1557.39 The1558.6 first1558.76 method1559.47 uses1559.88 an1560.84 affordability1560.99 gap1561.88 calculation.1562.12 So1563.18 that's1563.34 the1563.42 difference1563.66 between1564.14 the1564.54 fair1564.78 market1565.02 value1565.74 of1567.5 a1567.74 unit1567.9 and1568.38 the1568.62 value1568.78 of1569.1 the1569.18 affordable1569.34 unit.1569.82 The1571.42 second1571.58 method1571.9 is1572.46 based1572.7 on1573.18 the1574.22 loss1574.38 income1574.78 over1575.26 201575.5 years1575.9 plus1576.46 the1576.78 cost1576.94 of1577.89 compliance1578.22 of,1579.26 like,1579.65 affordability1579.89 compliance.1580.62 1582.22 And1582.22 then1582.38 the1582.7 third1582.86 method1583.17 is1583.58 based1583.89 on1584.3 total1584.78 development1585.17 costs.1585.65 So1589.57 the1589.89 findings1589.97 here,1590.61 you1591.09 can1591.17 see,1591.41 we're1592.45 showing1592.77 results,1593.17 as1594.13 a1594.29 range,1594.45 again,1594.85 on1595.17 the1595.33 right1595.49 hand1595.73 side.1595.97 And,1596.93 and1598.61 we're1599.17 showing1599.41 three1599.73 options.1599.97 So1600.45 the1600.69 cost,1600.93 to1601.89 buy1602.05 a1602.53 unit1602.61 from1603.77 market1604.1 rate1604.34 to1604.82 60%1605.05 AMI,1605.69 which1606.58 ranges1606.89 from1607.29 about1607.53 375,0001607.86 to1609.29 450,0001609.53 per1610.89 unit.1611.13 In1612.65 the1612.82 second1612.97 row,1613.38 we're1613.53 showing1613.77 the1614.1 cost1614.26 to1614.58 buy1614.73 down1614.97 a1615.13 market1615.29 rate1615.62 unit1615.77 to1616.01 80%1616.26 AMI.1616.89 So1618.24 that's1618.32 around1618.88 215,0001619.28 to1620.56 290,0001621.12 per1622.48 unit.1622.72 And1624.16 in1624.4 the1624.56 last1624.72 row,1624.96 we're1625.2 showing1625.44 the1626.16 cost1626.32 to1626.56 buy1626.72 down1626.88 deeper1627.2 affordability1627.52 of1628.24 an1628.4 existing1628.56 IZ1629.12 unit,1629.52 so1630.16 80%1630.4 to1631.04 60%1631.2 AMI.1631.92 And1632.85 that's1632.92 around1633.16 $158,0001633.64 per1634.85 unit.1635.09 And1641.96 so1642.29 I1643.33 guess1643.48 what1643.72 we1643.88 are1644.92 taking1645.16 away1645.32 preliminarily1645.96 from1646.68 this1646.92 analysis1647.16 is1647.72 that1647.88 buy1648.2 down1648.36 payments1648.6 are1649.64 definitely1650.04 a1650.52 potential,1650.6 viable1651.88 incentive,1652.36 especially1653.48 for1654.04 that1654.2 last1654.52 row,1654.84 the1655.24 80%1655.48 to1656.12 60%1656.28 AMI,1657.17 buying1658.21 down1658.54 that1658.69 deeper1658.86 affordability.1659.17 1660.78 But1660.78 it1661.1 does1661.26 require,1661.58 again,1662.13 you1662.62 know,1662.78 a1663.02 direct1663.17 subsidy1663.58 from1664.05 the1664.29 city,1664.45 which1665.49 is1665.73 a1665.89 bit1666.05 different1666.21 than1666.54 how1666.69 the1667.02 incentives1667.26 that1667.97 Emma1668.78 presented1669.1 work.1669.58 So1672.04 Watertown1672.12 may1672.52 want1672.76 to1673 continue1673 exploring1673.4 this,1673.8 further1674.68 and1675.48 especially,1675.64 you1676.68 know,1676.84 assessing1677.16 developer1677.56 interest1678.04 and1678.52 thinking1678.84 through1679.16 some1679.88 of1680.04 the1680.2 specifics1680.36 of1680.92 how1681.08 this1681.24 would1681.4 be1681.64 actually1682.36 implemented.1682.76 Okay.1688.21 So,1689.02 that1690.21 concludes1690.45 our1690.93 market1691.17 rate1691.49 analysis.1693.26 Now1694.86 we're1695.1 going1695.26 to1695.58 shift1695.58 to1695.97 affordable1697.01 projects.1697.25 So1697.81 shifting1698.45 gears,1698.77 so1699.09 100%1699.41 affordable1700.05 projects.1700.61 So1705.17 in1705.57 the1705.73 case1705.89 of1706.21 100%1706.61 affordable1707.25 projects,1707.81 we1708.69 use1709.89 a1710.78 different1710.87 method1711.42 to1712.07 test1712.3 what1712.7 kinds1712.94 of1713.18 incentives1713.42 are1714.07 most1714.3 impactful.1716.07 We1718.3 call1718.54 this1718.7 a1719.03 sort1719.18 of1719.35 a1719.51 simplified1719.66 sources1720.38 and1720.7 uses1720.94 model,1721.42 which1722.22 is,1722.54 a1723.66 way1723.83 to1724.07 estimate1724.3 the1724.87 general1725.03 costs1725.51 and1726.26 the1726.42 general1726.66 sources1727.06 or1727.46 the1727.7 revenues1727.86 for1728.5 what1729.38 you1729.62 might1729.7 expect1729.94 for,1730.34 like,1730.5 a1730.66 typical1730.82 tax1731.54 credit1731.86 100%1732.42 project,1733.22 in1734.74 in1735.06 a1735.54 market1735.86 like1736.26 Watertown.1736.42 1738.02 And1738.02 the1738.97 difference1739.13 with1740.49 a1740.65 Pro1740.82 Forma1740.82 model,1740.82 which1741.13 is1741.38 what1741.45 Emma1741.69 presented1742.01 on,1742.41 is1742.82 that1742.97 a1743.29 Pro1743.86 Forma1743.93 model1743.93 tests1744.34 the1744.73 profitability1744.89 of1747.21 or1747.86 compares1748.1 the1748.58 profit1748.73 profitability1749.21 across1750.1 different1750.49 incentives.1751.05 For1753.07 sources1753.39 and1753.71 uses1753.95 models1754.27 for1754.91 an1755.15 affordable1755.31 project,1755.87 what1757.47 we1757.71 are1757.95 looking1758.19 at1758.51 is1758.83 how1759.87 much1760.11 an1760.35 incentive1760.51 helps1761.15 to1761.55 close1761.71 the1762.11 funding1762.27 gap.1762.67 So,1763.63 because1765.16 the1765.48 financing1765.72 of1766.29 affordable1766.53 housing1766.92 and1767.33 market1767.57 rate1767.81 housing1768.13 is1768.44 very1768.61 different,1768.85 in1769.57 this1769.81 case,1769.88 we're1770.13 really1770.37 focused1770.68 on,1771.09 okay,1771.33 does1771.72 an1771.88 incentive1772.13 help1772.68 to1773.33 reduce1773.48 that1773.81 funding1774.05 gap1774.37 that1774.61 the1774.77 developer1774.92 needs1775.48 to1775.81 fill.1777.58 And1779.03 so,1779.27 we1780.87 also1781.19 supplemented1781.51 this1782.39 kind1782.95 of1783.19 quantitative1783.43 model1784.07 with1784.47 developer1785.03 interviews1785.59 since1786.07 we1786.39 do1787.27 realize1787.51 that1787.83 there's1787.99 a1788.23 lot1788.31 of1788.55 qualitative1789.03 information1789.67 that1790.31 we1790.63 didn't1790.79 want1791.03 to1791.35 lose,1791.35 by1792.99 just1793.23 looking1793.47 at1793.79 a1794.11 model.1794.83 1797.14 So1797.14 just1797.63 to1797.87 do1798.03 a1798.18 quick1798.27 affordable1798.66 housing1799.14 finance1799.55 1011803.07 we1803.07 just1803.23 wanted1803.38 to1803.71 quickly1803.87 kind1804.27 of1804.42 explain1804.66 what1805.23 we1805.38 mean1805.63 by1805.95 funding1806.18 gap.1806.59 So1807.23 when1808.03 you1808.29 think1808.45 about1808.53 a1808.77 typical1808.93 market1809.33 rate1809.65 project,1809.97 on1812.45 the1812.69 cost1812.93 side,1813.25 you1813.89 know,1813.97 total1814.13 cost1814.45 includes1815.09 soft1815.65 costs,1815.89 hard1816.37 costs,1816.69 line1817.09 costs.1817.41 And,1818.29 typically,1819.33 a1819.97 developer1820.21 would1821.01 be1821.57 able1821.73 to1822.05 get1822.21 a1822.45 permanent1822.61 debt,1823.17 and1824.57 equity1825.68 about1826.57 in1827.13 the1827.29 60%1827.53 range1829.05 for1829.45 debt1829.61 and1829.92 40%1830.09 range1830.73 for1830.97 equity.1831.13 And1832.01 that1832.24 debt1832.49 is,1832.81 you1834.09 know,1834.33 being1834.57 leveraged1834.88 against1835.37 the1835.68 market1835.85 rate1836.09 rents.1836.33 In1839.17 a1839.49 100%1839.73 affordable1840.37 project,1840.85 the1841.81 capital1841.97 stack1842.45 looks1843.01 quite1843.33 different.1843.57 Total1844.85 development1845.25 costs1845.73 are1846.29 generally1846.61 the1847.17 same,1847.33 if1847.73 not1848.05 higher,1848.37 actually,1849.17 for1849.49 affordable1849.73 housing.1850.21 But1851.73 on1852.05 the1852.29 sources1852.45 or1852.93 revenue1853.17 side,1853.73 the1855.09 debt1855.33 that1855.72 a1856.05 project1856.21 can1856.53 get1856.77 is1857.09 generally1857.4 much1858.05 as1858.61 much1858.77 smaller1859.09 percent,1859.57 because1860.92 the1861.96 affordable1862.29 rents1862.77 are1863.09 much1863.24 lower1863.48 than1863.81 the1863.96 market1864.05 rate1864.45 rents.1864.61 1865.16 So1865.16 you1865.33 can't1865.48 get1865.72 as1865.88 much1866.13 debt,1866.37 which1866.68 means1866.92 you1867.24 have1867.4 a1867.81 large1868.05 funding1868.53 gap.1868.92 So1869.63 that's1869.79 just1870.03 the1870.19 difference1870.43 between1870.83 total1871.31 allotment1871.55 costs1872.03 and1872.67 the1872.99 debt.1873.23 And1874.51 this1875.71 is1875.95 what1876.27 developers1876.67 have1877.39 to1877.71 bill1878.51 with1878.91 various1879.31 funding1879.79 sources1880.27 like1880.75 federal1881.07 or1881.55 state1881.71 tax1882.03 credits,1882.27 state1883.82 subsidies,1884.13 local1884.78 subsidies.1885.17 They1886.86 kind1887.1 of1887.34 layer1887.49 all1887.97 these1888.06 sources1888.38 to1888.86 fill1889.1 the1889.34 funding1889.41 gap.1889.89 Equity1892.54 tends1893.97 to1894.3 be1894.46 coming1894.7 from1895.02 tax1895.34 credits1895.58 or1896.06 sometimes1896.22 the1896.7 developer's1896.86 own1897.34 equity,1897.58 but1898.53 regardless1898.77 it's1899.41 an1899.81 important1900.05 part1900.77 of1901.09 what1901.49 it1901.73 takes1901.81 to1902.21 make1902.37 affordable1902.53 housing1903.01 happen.1903.41 It's1903.81 filling1904.13 that1904.37 funding1904.53 gap.1904.85 And1906.13 so,1906.37 anything1907.41 to1907.81 help1907.97 close1908.21 the1908.53 gap1908.61 is,1909.17 you1910.82 know,1910.89 meaningful1911.06 and1911.62 can1912.17 be1912.34 helpful1912.41 for1912.89 a1913.22 project1913.38 to1913.78 move1914.02 forward.1914.26 Okay.1917.54 So,1920.02 just1920.41 a1920.65 quick1920.82 recap1921.13 on1921.54 the1921.7 prototypes,1921.93 very1922.73 similar1923.06 to1923.46 what1923.62 Emma1923.86 presented.1924.17 These1925.38 are1925.62 two1926.29 prototypes1926.37 that1927.01 we1927.17 used1927.41 for1927.73 this1927.89 model.1928.05 1929.41 Again,1929.41 they're1929.73 hypothetical.1930.05 They're1930.77 not1931.01 site1931.33 specific,1931.57 but1932.13 they're1932.29 meant1932.45 to1932.69 sort1932.93 of1933.09 reflect1933.33 what1934.21 a1934.45 typical1934.69 tax1935.17 credit1935.41 project1935.73 could1936.21 look1936.45 like.1936.61 The1937.97 first1938.13 is1938.45 a1938.69 30-unit1939.17 project,1939.49 at1941.31 an1941.7 average1941.95 of1942.27 55%1942.42 AMI,1943.46 and1944.98 the1945.31 second,1945.46 prototype1946.18 b,1946.66 is1947.14 a1947.31 60-unit1947.79 project,1948.11 and1949.31 both1949.55 have1949.79 a1950.18 little1950.27 bit1950.42 of1950.66 ground1951.07 floor1951.38 commercial1951.63 space1952.18 and1954.53 different1955.09 kind1955.41 of1955.57 construction1955.89 types1956.45 and,1957.41 parking1958.13 types,1958.53 which1958.93 generally1959.49 prototype1960.21 b1960.61 would1960.93 be1961.17 more1961.41 expensive1961.65 having1962.45 podium1962.85 parking,1963.33 and1963.97 prototype1964.21 a1964.77 little1965.17 bit1965.41 less1965.57 expensive1965.81 with1966.29 being1966.45 wood1966.77 frame.1966.93 This1972.63 slide1973.03 just1973.51 sorts1973.98 of1974.14 sets1974.3 the1974.63 baseline1974.87 development1975.51 costs1975.98 and1976.3 funding1976.54 gap.1977.03 So1977.42 you1977.59 can1977.74 see1977.9 that1978.14 the1978.38 total1978.54 development1978.94 costs1979.42 are1979.83 around1980.07 600,0001981.66 per1982.63 unit.1982.94 And1986.54 the1986.62 funding1986.78 gap1987.18 here1988.62 again1988.94 is1989.26 around1990.06 kind1990.62 of1990.94 80%1990.94 of1991.58 that1991.74 total1991.98 development1992.3 cost.1992.78 So1994.14 that's1994.3 the1994.54 baseline.1994.78 1996.84 We1996.84 then1997.08 brought1997.71 in,1998.04 again,1998.91 incentives1999.63 that2000.2 we2000.6 wanted2001.15 to2001.63 test2001.8 here2002.12 based2002.52 on2002.76 developer2003.56 input2004.12 and2004.52 staff2005.32 input.2005.71 So2006.84 similar2007.15 to2007.63 the2007.96 market2008.2 rate2008.6 model,2009.52 we2009.76 tested2010.16 waiving2010.64 commercial2011.12 requirements,2012.16 waiving2013.28 permitting2013.68 fees,2014.16 reducing2015.2 parking,2015.76 both2016.96 to2017.84 0.52018.16 and2018.96 0.252019.12 spaces2020.56 per2021.04 unit.2021.2 And,2021.92 again,2022.16 kind2024.19 of2024.36 a2024.52 nod2024.6 to2024.91 the2025.08 Watertown2025.23 Square2025.8 incentives,2026.19 being2028.84 currently2029.32 0.252030.04 spaces2031.15 per2031.55 unit2031.71 for2032.19 affordable2032.6 projects.2033.08 And2034.6 one2035.15 other2035.47 incentive2036.04 that2036.52 we2036.67 brought2036.84 in2037.15 in2037.32 this2037.39 case2037.55 is2037.88 free2038.12 publicly2038.36 owned2038.91 land.2039.23 We2043.28 also2043.52 tested2043.84 density2044.24 bonuses,2044.8 similar2045.84 to2046.32 what2047.44 we2047.68 presented2047.84 in2048.32 previous2048.48 slides,2048.88 and2049.76 we2050.16 also2050.4 coupled2050.72 density2051.2 bonuses2051.68 with2052.24 reduced2052.48 parking.2052.88 So2056.8 for2057.53 the2057.84 results,2061.44 again,2061.76 we2062.32 are2062.48 showing2062.72 the2064.24 two2064.57 prototypes.2065.36 Again,2065.92 the2066.24 prototype2066.32 A2066.89 is2067.13 the2067.36 30-unit2067.76 project.2068.09 2069.06 Prototype2069.06 B2069.46 is2069.78 the2069.94 larger2070.18 60-unit2070.9 project2071.3 and2072.34 the2072.66 various2072.82 incentives2073.14 that2074.18 we2074.5 looked2074.9 at.2075.14 And2076.9 the2077.7 numbers2077.86 here2078.34 are2078.74 essentially2078.98 showing2079.62 how2081.38 much2081.62 the2081.94 funding2082.02 gap2082.5 is2082.74 closed2082.9 as2083.73 a2083.97 relative2084.21 change2084.78 to2085.09 that2085.26 baseline2085.49 that2086.05 I2086.21 showed.2086.38 So2087.26 a2087.82 larger2087.97 percent2088.7 decrease2089.18 is2089.66 good2089.82 because2090.14 it2090.53 means2090.7 the2091.26 funding2091.34 gap2091.73 is2091.97 closed2092.21 more.2093.41 Yeah.2094.93 The2098.5 incentive2098.9 helps2099.54 to2099.86 close2099.94 the2100.18 funding2100.26 gap2100.66 more2100.9 than,2101.06 you2101.62 know,2101.78 without2102.34 it.2102.66 So2104.5 you2104.9 can2105.06 see2105.22 that2105.46 offering2105.78 publicly2106.18 owned2106.66 land2106.9 is2107.46 definitely2108.58 showing2109.7 a2110.26 big,2110.42 percent2111.78 decrease,2112.34 almost2113.72 20%.2114.11 So2116.11 that2116.36 is2116.59 by2116.84 far2117.07 the2117.32 largest2117.47 impact.2117.95 Reducing2120.03 parking2120.52 and2121.07 waiving2121.24 commercial2121.72 requirements2122.2 has2122.99 about2123.32 five2123.72 to2123.95 6%2124.11 cause2126.45 is2127.49 associated2127.73 with,2128.21 like,2128.37 a2128.61 5%2128.69 to2129.25 6%2129.49 decrease2130.13 in2130.69 the2130.93 funding2131.01 gap.2131.41 2132.61 And2132.61 you2132.85 can2132.93 see2133.17 again2133.41 that2133.81 the2136.29 0.252136.93 ratio2138.61 is2140.89 a2140.97 little2141.14 bit2141.3 more2141.53 impactful2141.78 than2142.26 0.5.2142.41 And2145.45 then2145.61 we2146.97 also2147.93 wanted2148.34 to2148.66 just2148.82 point2149.05 out2149.3 that2149.53 density2149.69 bonuses2150.18 are2150.89 interesting2152.49 in2153.3 the2153.45 case2153.61 of2153.78 an2153.93 affordable2154.18 housing2154.57 project2154.89 because2155.38 they2155.86 help2156.87 close2157.19 the2157.35 funding2157.51 gap2157.91 on2158.55 a2158.79 per2159.19 unit2159.43 basis.2159.91 But2162.95 because2163.43 you're2163.75 adding2164.15 more2164.55 units,2164.79 overall,2166.31 you're2166.87 actually2167.11 also2167.51 increasing2168.39 the2168.95 total2169.19 funding2169.51 gap.2169.99 So2170.86 you're2171.03 achieving2171.51 economies2171.98 of2172.46 scale,2172.63 in2173.74 a2173.91 way,2174.07 which2174.3 is2174.55 a2174.63 good2174.78 thing.2174.86 The2175.98 per2176.22 unit2176.39 cost2177.18 is2177.43 going2177.59 down,2177.91 but2178.78 you2179.03 are2179.26 in2180.39 a2180.63 way2180.7 increasing2183.69 total2184.17 costs2184.65 as2184.89 well.2185.05 So2185.29 it2185.53 has2186.33 benefits,2186.73 and2187.45 it's2187.61 helpful,2188.73 but,2189.21 it's2189.93 not2190.25 quite2190.65 apples2190.97 to2191.29 apples2191.45 with2191.69 the2191.93 other2192.01 incentives2192.25 in2192.81 terms2192.89 of2193.13 how2193.29 to2193.45 think2193.61 about2193.85 the2194.17 impact2194.33 of2194.65 a2194.81 density2194.89 bonus.2195.29 2199.82 Yeah.2199.82 So,2200.14 that's2200.95 what2201.26 I2201.43 was2201.51 just2201.66 explaining.2202.07 So2205.03 just2205.66 to2205.91 conclude2206.14 on2206.63 this,2206.86 these2207.59 are2207.82 our2208.07 last2208.14 few2208.47 slides2208.7 here.2209.11 So2210.22 in2210.95 terms2211.11 of,2211.43 what2212.07 is2212.86 coming2213.1 out2213.34 both2213.58 from2213.9 the2214.06 model2214.22 and2214.46 from2214.7 our2214.94 developer2215.1 interviews2215.58 is2216.22 that2216.46 the2216.86 most2216.86 impactful2217.18 action2217.74 or2218.3 incentive2218.46 is2219.66 offering2219.98 publicly2220.86 owned2221.34 land2221.66 at2222.22 low2222.54 or2222.7 no2223.02 cost.2223.18 This2224.86 also2225.18 has2225.42 other2225.74 benefits.2225.98 Publicly2228.47 owned2228.86 land2229.11 is2229.34 often2229.66 considered2229.91 like2230.47 a2230.7 local2230.78 funding2231.27 match,2231.66 in2232.95 terms2233.18 of2233.43 getting2233.51 tax2233.82 credit,2234.14 and2234.95 having2235.27 a2235.59 patient2235.66 land2236.14 seller,2236.39 is2238.7 beneficial2238.95 for2239.43 an2239.59 affordable2239.82 housing2240.14 developer2240.55 as2240.95 well2241.03 as2242.91 they2243.15 go2243.31 through2243.47 all2243.71 of2243.87 the2244.03 predevelopment2244.11 work2244.83 that2245.07 is2245.31 needed.2245.47 2249.23 Waived2249.23 commercial2249.63 requirements2250.03 are2251.15 somewhat2251.55 impactful2251.95 and,2252.83 this2253.71 was2253.95 also2254.11 kind2254.59 of2254.75 vetted2254.91 by2255.23 the2255.39 developers2255.55 and2256.11 they2256.35 agreed2256.51 that2256.91 this2257.07 was2257.23 something2257.47 that2257.79 they2258.03 thought2258.49 was2258.82 appealing,2258.97 and2260.74 could2260.97 make2261.22 a2261.38 difference.2261.54 We2264.82 classified,2265.3 as2266.66 somewhat2266.97 impactful2267.45 but2268.02 varied2268.26 the2269.14 reduced2270.09 parking2270.57 and2271.05 density2271.22 bonuses.2271.7 Sort2272.88 of2272.96 similar2273.2 to2273.28 what2273.6 Emma2273.76 explained2274.08 for2274.4 the2274.64 reduced2274.8 parking,2275.2 it's2275.84 generally2276.32 seen2276.96 very2277.2 positively2277.52 in2278.08 that2278.24 it2278.4 provides2278.64 a2278.96 lot2279.12 of2279.28 flexibility,2279.36 and2280.72 developers2281.04 are2281.92 generally,2282.08 very2283.76 open2284.08 to2284.32 that.2284.48 But2285.68 because2286.24 a2287.55 developer2287.72 might2288.28 still2290.03 choose2290.36 to2290.68 provide2290.84 a2291.24 little2291.32 bit2291.55 more2291.72 parking,2291.95 depending2292.76 on2293.16 the2293.24 site2293.39 or2293.88 the2294.91 location2295.07 relative2295.64 to2296.11 transit,2296.28 it2297.64 could2297.88 vary2298.2 based2298.68 on2298.99 specific2299.68 conditions.2299.92 2300.56 And2300.56 sort2300.8 of2300.96 similarly2301.12 with2301.6 the2301.84 density2302 bonus,2302.4 it's2303.68 great2303.92 and2304.24 then2304.32 it2304.48 provides2304.64 a2305.04 lot2305.12 of2305.28 flexibility2305.44 and2306.16 economies2306.48 of2306.96 scale2307.04 are2307.36 really2307.44 important,2307.68 but,2308.24 again,2308.8 the2309.6 actual2309.76 impact2310.08 could2310.72 be2310.96 different2311.28 depending2311.6 on2312 the2312.16 developer2312.32 or2312.8 the2312.96 site.2313.12 And2314.84 then2314.99 wave2315.23 permitting2315.63 fees2316.03 are2317.47 a2317.95 little2318.03 bit2318.28 less2318.43 impactful2318.67 on2319.23 their2319.39 own.2319.55 But,2319.95 again,2320.19 if2320.51 they're2320.67 coupled2320.91 with2321.23 other2321.47 things,2321.63 they2321.95 can2322.43 definitely2323.15 be2323.63 interesting.2323.63 And2327.12 finally,2327.28 we2328 also2328.24 just2328.48 wanted2328.72 to2329.28 call2329.44 to2329.84 your2330 attention2330.16 a2330.4 few2330.64 other2330.96 considerations2331.2 that2332 came2332.24 up2332.48 from2332.88 our2333.12 developer2333.28 interviews,2333.84 things2335.52 that2335.76 we2335.92 didn't2336.08 explicitly2336.48 test2337.12 in2337.36 the2337.52 model,2337.68 but2338.16 that2338.48 just2338.72 came2338.96 up2339.12 in2339.28 the2339.44 conversations.2339.6 2340.96 Some2340.96 of2341.2 the2341.28 most2341.44 impactful2341.68 actions2343.49 that2343.89 folks2344.21 noted2344.61 were,2345.01 mechanisms2345.82 that2346.38 allow2346.61 multifamily2347.41 affordable2348.05 housing2348.45 to2348.86 be2349.01 allowed2349.49 by2349.82 right.2350.05 Definitely,2351.73 developers2353.17 emphasized2353.49 that2354.38 discretionary2354.78 review2355.73 can2356.3 cause2357.18 a2357.34 lot2357.5 of2357.58 uncertainty2358.46 and2358.94 risk2359.18 in2359.42 the2359.58 process2359.74 and2363.02 that2363.02 having2363.26 that2363.58 approval2364.46 by2364.94 right2365.1 makes2365.34 a2365.58 big2365.66 difference.2365.82 And,2367.26 of2367.58 course,2367.74 having2368.06 a2368.3 local2368.38 funding2368.7 match2369.18 is2369.66 often2370.46 very2370.94 important2371.18 in2371.66 terms2371.82 of2372.06 securing2372.42 tax2372.66 credits2372.9 and2374.03 is2374.42 often2375.7 needed2376.9 to2376.9 fill2377.39 that2377.63 funding2377.78 gap.2378.18 And2379.78 finally,2380.03 kind2381.22 of2381.46 other2382.03 impactful2382.42 actions,2383.07 just2383.63 having2383.94 staff2384.42 that2384.82 is2385.07 available2385.3 to2385.78 help2385.94 shepherd2386.18 projects.2387.43 2387.59 Through2387.59 the2387.59 development2387.75 process2388.23 and2389.35 continuing2389.67 to2390.23 foster2390.79 a2391.51 network2391.83 of2392.47 affordable2393.35 developers2394.15 who2394.55 are2394.71 active2394.79 in2395.11 Watertown2395.27 was2395.91 also2396.15 noted2396.39 as2396.79 a2397.35 potential2397.59 action.2398.07 So,2400.84 that2402.2 concludes2402.52 our2403.16 presentations.2403.88 Would2405.72 you2405.95 like2406.11 me2406.28 to2406.43 just2406.52 present2406.68 it2407.08 to2407.16 you?2407.24 Okay.2407.64 So,2409.12 Adam2411.08 mentioned2411.32 this2411.64 at2411.88 the2412.04 beginning,2412.11 but2412.43 so2412.68 our2412.84 next2412.99 steps2413.24 after2413.72 this2414.04 is,2414.6 we'll2415.3 be2415.54 taking2415.7 feedback,2416.34 from2417.46 today,2417.7 from2418.98 the2419.14 public2419.3 and2420.1 incorporating2420.34 that2420.9 into2421.22 our2422.02 final2423.14 recommendations,2423.54 and2424.26 then2424.5 we'll2424.66 be2424.9 finalizing2425.14 the2425.94 report.2426.1 And,2427.14 the2429.02 final2429.34 public2429.74 meeting2430.06 date2430.45 is2430.78 still2431.02 TBD,2431.26 but2431.74 there2431.89 will2432.06 be2432.22 another2432.45 chance2432.86 for2433.18 public2434.38 comment.2434.7 So2436.93 thank2437.34 you2437.49 very2437.74 much.2437.97 I2440.22 think2440.38 we'll2440.7 open2440.93 it2441.18 up2441.34 for2441.49 questions.2441.74 Yes.2444.26 Thank2444.58 you.2448.34 2453.78 Q&A.2454.26

2457.66 We2457.66 just2457.82 threw2458.07 a2458.22 lot2458.3 of2458.47 stuff2458.63 at2458.86 you.2459.03 We've2459.82 only2460.07 been2460.22 working2460.39 on2460.55 this2460.7 for2460.86 a2460.98 couple2461.11 days.2461.43 I2461.79 hate2462.14 it2462.46 so2462.46 much.2462.78 So,2463.43 Gideon2465.11 or2465.51 Will,2465.66 can2467.11 they2467.34 hear2467.66 in2468.22 a2468.55 remote2468.55 world2468.95 if2469.18 they're2469.34 at2469.51 the2469.66 table,2469.74 or2469.98 should2470.07 we2470.3 be2470.39 coming2470.55 up2470.78 to2470.95 the2471.03 podium2471.18 to2471.59 answer?2471.74

2473.9 I'm2473.9 going2474.14 to2474.46 we2474.94 we2475.1 can2475.18 move2475.34 the2475.58 light2475.74 over2475.98 to2476.22 the2476.38 there's2476.62 a2476.86

2477.02 I2477.02 mean,2477.18 we2477.26 can2477.42 also2477.58 kind2477.9 of,2478.06 like,2478.22 round2478.46 robins.2479.02 It2479.26 just2479.26 depends.2480.06 This2481.02 little2481.26 This2481.74 I2482.22 might2482.3 just,2482.46 like,2482.62 drop2482.94 that2483.18 down.2483.42

2483.82 Yeah.2483.82 I2484.06 wouldn't2484.14 drop2484.46 it.2484.62

2484.95 Oh,2484.95 no.2485.03 No.2485.19 No.2485.99 No.2486.23 No.2486.28 Just2486.32 kind2486.47 of2486.71 throw2486.71 it2486.95 against2487.03 the2487.28 wall.2487.36 Let's2487.59 see2487.76 what2487.84 happens.2487.99 That2489.36 there2489.67

2490.16 Okay.2490.16

2490.8 Was2490.8 that?2491.03

2491.67 Okay.2491.67 Great.2492.23

2493.51 Yeah.2493.51 I2493.71 don't2493.91 think2494.16 so.2494.55

2499.05 Button2499.05 at2499.09 the2499.13 top.2499.29 There.2501.45 Perfect.2502.65 And2503.69 I'm2503.85

2504.01 going2504.01 to2504.49 stop2504.49 share.2504.89 Okay.2505.29 No.2507.21

2510.25 Yeah.2510.25 They2511.52 can't2511.76 see2511.99 you2512.24 online2512.8 when2513.36 it's2513.59 being2513.76 shared.2513.99 Okay.2514.32 So2514.56 we2514.8 can2514.88 pop2515.04 it2515.28 back2515.36 up.2515.52

2515.84 Okay.2515.84 Alright.2517.76 Questions,2519.59 comments,2521.43 thoughts?2521.99 2527.13 UNIDENTIFIED2527.13 SPEAKER12527.13 -2527.13 RESIDENT2527.13 -2527.13 Yeah.2527.13 So2527.53 I2527.77 think2527.93 when2528.17 Emma2528.41 was2528.73 presenting2529.53 on2530.17 the2530.33 Pro2532.49 Forma2532.65 model,2532.65 and2533.05 I2533.45 just2533.53 talked2533.77 about,2534.01 not2536.25 why2536.49 it's2536.73 just2536.89 feasible,2537.29 but,2537.85 you2538.25 know,2538.41 moving2540.15 towards2540.39 incentive.2541.36 But2542.07 with2542.39 the2542.64 buy2542.8 down2542.95 direct2543.28 payment2543.59 and2543.99 you're2544.23 talking2544.39 about2544.64 the2544.88 different2545.03 cost,2545.43 is2546.71 there2546.88 a2547.11 distinction2548.95 as2549.59 well2549.76 between2550.07 sort2550.39 of2551.19 feasible2551.36 versus2551.91 incentivizing2553.18 and2554.14 developing2555.1 for2555.42 the2556.94 use2557.1 and2557.42 buy2557.58 down?2557.82 Or2558.46 is2558.7 it2558.86 in2559.18 other2559.34 words,2559.5 you2559.74 made2559.82 that2560.06 distinction2560.3 for2560.7 the2560.86 Pro2561.34 Forma,2561.5 but2561.5 I2561.74 didn't2561.82 know2562.14 if2562.38 you2562.46 knew2563.66 that.2563.9 If2566.34 that2566.51 makes2566.74 sense.2567.07 I2571.39 think2571.63 you2571.86 have2571.95 that2572.18 slide2572.34 and2572.91 Yeah.2573.39 The2573.95 cost2574.11 for2574.51 the2574.66 direct2575.31 payments.2575.7 What2576.18 was2576.43 it?2576.59 What2577.64 was2577.88 it?2578.52 2578.92 UDELOVICH2578.92 -2578.92 I2578.92 can2579.08 maybe2579.32 start,2579.64 and2579.96 then2580.04 I'll2580.2 pass2580.36 it2580.52 to2580.68 you.2580.84 I2581.08 think2581.24 what's2583.16 very2583.48 interesting,2583.8 was2584.76 a2585 very2585.16 interesting2585.4 language2585.72 exercise2586.2 for2586.68 us2586.84 in2587.16 all2587.32 of2587.48 these2587.64 different2587.88 methodologies2588.2 is,2589 like,2589.16 how2589.4 do2589.56 we2589.72 describe2589.96 the2590.6 incentives?2590.84 For2592.22 the2592.38 Pro2592.93 Forma2593.09 model2593.09 because2593.34 it2593.57 is2593.74 based2593.89 on2594.38 profitability,2594.61 I2596.7 think2596.86 that's2597.09 where2597.34 the2597.89 feasible2598.3 and2598.78 attractive2599.09 language2599.66 came2600.05 in.2600.3 The2600.93 buy2601.09 down2601.34 model2601.57 because,2601.89 you2602.45 know,2602.53 it2602.78 is2602.93 direct2603.18 cash2603.57 being2603.97 given2604.22 to2604.61 a2604.86 developer,2605.02 you2606.47 know,2606.79 one2607.11 could2607.43 sit2607.83 and2608.15 argue2608.23 like2608.55 that2608.71 could2608.87 be2609.11 attractive2609.19 no2609.67 matter2609.83 how2610.07 much2610.23 money,2610.47 you2610.71 know,2610.87 it2611.03 is.2611.19 But,2611.35 I2612.39 don't2612.47 think2612.71 we2612.87 use2613.03 the2613.35 same2613.43 language.2613.67 I2614.23 don't2614.39 know2614.47 if2614.63 you2614.79 want2614.87 to2615.19 speak2615.19 more2615.35 to,2615.59 like,2615.75 how2615.99 that2616.79 how2617.43 we2617.67 talk2617.83 about2618.07 that2618.31 range.2618.55 2619.76 UNIDENTIFIED2619.76 SPEAKER12619.76 -2619.76 So2619.76 should2620.07 we2620.11 I'm2620.32 sorry.2620.47 So2621.52 interpret2621.76 the2622.64 buy2622.8 down2623.04 file2623.59 as2623.91 being2623.91 that2624.72 those2625.36 figures2625.59 would,2625.99 in2626.32 theory,2626.55 be2626.95 attractive2627.28 to2627.91 the2629.36 developer2629.59 or2630.07 it's2631.52 not2631.84 really2632.07 apples2632.39 to2632.8 apples.2632.88 2633.38 UDELOVICH2633.7 -2633.7 I2633.7 don't2633.86 think2633.94 it's2634.18 apples2634.34 to2634.74 apples.2634.98 I2636.1 think2636.34 because2636.82 one2637.38 is2637.7 an2637.94 indirect2638.18 subsidy2638.66 and2639.14 the2639.38 other2639.54 is2639.78 a2640.1 direct2640.26 subsidy.2640.58 So2642.34 for2642.66 that2642.9 reason,2643.06 I2643.38 don't2643.46 think2643.62 it2643.86 can2644.02 be2644.18 compared.2644.5 I2646.02 think2646.1 we're2646.42 in2647.09 our2647.34 preliminary,2647.49 assessment2649.01 of2649.57 the2649.66 buy2649.89 down2650.05 model,2650.3 we're2650.61 finding2650.78 that2651.09 it2651.26 is2651.49 it2652.3 can2652.7 be2653.01 an2653.18 incentive2653.41 that2654.38 is2654.61 attractive2654.86 to2655.73 developers,2655.97 but2656.7 further2656.93 assessment2657.49 will2658.14 be2658.3 needed2658.45 because,2658.86 you2659.88 know,2659.96 this2660.2 came2660.36 out2660.68 of2660.76 the2660.92 December2661.08 meeting,2661.48 and2661.8 we2663.08 only2663.32 have2663.64 so2663.88 much2663.96 time2664.28 to2664.68 really2665.08 dive2665.8 deep.2666.04

2668.2 Do2668.2 you2668.36 want2669.08 to2669.24 speak2669.4 more?2669.96 Did2669.96 I2670.2 miss2670.28 anything?2670.52

2673.34 Okay.2673.34

2673.82 Good.2673.82 Good.2674.07 Thank2674.3 you.2674.7 Did2674.86 that2675.03 help?2675.18 Yeah.2675.51 Okay.2675.74 That2675.91 was2676.14 so2676.3 great.2676.39 Other2678.14 questions?2678.3

2685.6 Well,2685.6 is2685.76 there2685.84 stuff2686.08 online?2686.4

2687.44 No.2687.44 We2687.76 also2687.92 haven't2688.16 asked2688.48 people2688.8 in2689.2 the2689.28

2689.36 audience2689.36 if2689.68 they2689.84 would2689.92 like2690.08

2690.24 to2690.24 make2690.32 this2690.48 question,2690.64 if2690.88 they2691.04 could2691.12 raise2691.36 their2691.52 hand.2691.68 Okay.2692.08 I2692.48 don't2692.56 know2692.72 how2692.8 well2692.96 I2693.12 can,2693.2 I2693.28 mean,2693.36 heard2693.68 back2693.84 here2694 online?2694.24 So2694.56 if2694.88 somebody2695.04 can2695.36 like,2695.44

2695.68 I2695.68 would2695.76 also2695.92 be2696.16 use2696.4 my.2696.64

2700.51 if2700.51 anyone2700.82 in2701.3 the2701.55 digital2701.7 audience2702.11 would2702.51 like2702.66 to2702.82 make2702.99 comments2703.3 or2703.63 ask2703.78 questions,2704.03 please2704.51 raise2704.99 your2705.3 hand2705.47 using2706.43 the2706.82 raise2707.22 hand2707.63 button2708.03 on2708.99 the2709.22 screen,2709.47 and2709.86 we2710.11 will2710.34 call2710.74 on2711.14 you2711.55 to2711.95 speak.2712.11

2713.78 Well,2713.78 that's2713.86 QAO.2714.1 I2714.74 think2714.9 we2715.14 have2715.22 a2715.38 question2715.46 back2715.78 here.2715.94

2716.98 Very2716.98 cool.2717.94 Let2718.66 me2718.82 pass2718.9 that.2719.06 May2719.54 have2719.7 been2719.94 one2720.26 second.2720.42 I'm2721.46 sorry.2721.7 I2722.1 thought2722.26 2726.26 UNIDENTIFIED2726.26 SPEAKER22726.26 -2726.26 RESIDENT2726.26 -2726.26 I2726.26 wasn't2726.42 part2727.22 of2727.45 the2727.61 early2727.78 process,2728.26 and2728.74 I2728.97 was2729.14 just2729.38 here2729.61 to2729.86 listen2730.01 to2730.34 the2730.49 options.2730.74 I'm2732.34 just2732.57 curious2732.82 as2733.38 to2733.61 whether2735.22 or2735.61 not2735.78 or,2736.18 the2737.7 tax2737.93 exemption2738.34 provision,2739.05 of2740.72 the2741.44 mass2741.52 law2741.84 that2742.24 has2742.48 to2742.72 do2742.8 with2743.04 affordable2743.28 housing2743.84 was2744.32 taken2745.2 into2745.6 account2745.92 and2746.48 how2746.96 that2747.2 was2747.36 evaluated.2748.48 2753.76 PLOETZ2753.76 -2753.76 Yeah.2753.76 We2754.07 did2754.32 talk2755.28 about2755.59 that2755.84 as2755.99 a2756.16 potential2756.32 option,2756.8 but2757.11 we2757.36 did2757.51 not2757.68 test2757.91 it,2758.23 if2759.84 that2759.99 helps.2760.72 But2761.11 we2761.68 did2761.84 take2762.55 a2762.72 look2762.8 at2762.95 it,2763.11 and2763.28 we2763.36 decided2763.51 it2763.91 was2764.07 not2764.39 something2765.36 that2765.59 we're2765.76 going2765.99 to2766.47 specifically2766.47 look2767.11 at2767.28 as2767.51 an2767.68 incentive.2767.84 Yeah.2770.44 I2771 mean,2771.24 where2771.72 do2771.72 we2771.72 go2773.48 ahead?2773.72 2775.48 UNIDENTIFIED2775.48 SPEAKER22775.48 -2775.48 Why2775.48 did2778.44 you2778.6 decide2778.68 not2779.08 to2779.32 look2779.56 at2779.72 it?2779.88 2780.2 PLOETZ2780.2 -2780.2 I2780.2 think2780.28 it2780.52 was2780.6 decided2781.8 that2782.28 we2783.53 talked2785.78 about2786.09 it.2786.26 We2786.66 thought2786.82 it2787.05 was2787.14 a2787.38 potential2787.53 option.2787.93 We2788.97 decided2789.21 that2789.69 they're2790.34 working2791.05 with2791.38 the2791.53 town,2791.78 and2792.49 I2792.73 would2792.82 like2793.05 the2793.21 city2793.38 to2793.69 kind2793.78 of2793.93 maybe2794.01 tie2794.26 pipes2794.41 in2794.66 here2794.82 too,2795.05 that2796.47 it2796.63 was2796.87 probably2797.11 not2797.43 the2797.59 best2797.83 way2798.23 to2798.95 look2799.03 at2799.27 this.2799.43 And2800.47 that's2801.35 my2801.75 recollection.2802.07 Larry,2802.95 did2803.27 you2803.43 have2803.59 any2803.75 comment2804.07 on2804.39 that?2804.55 2810.32 LARRY2810.32 FIELD2810.32 -2810.32 CITY2810.32 OF2810.32 WATERTOWN2810.32 -2810.32 So2810.32 a2810.64 friendly2810.71 amendment2811.19 to2811.76 what2811.84 you2811.99 said.2812.23 2812.64 PLOETZ2812.64 -2812.64 Yeah.2812.64 Sure.2813.11 2813.68 FIELD2813.68 -2813.68 Was2813.68 that2813.91 it2814.07 was2814.16 not2814.39 tested,2814.88 in2816.32 the2816.55 modeling2816.88 you2817.36 did.2817.59 It2818.32 is2818.55 something2818.71 that2819.19 you're2819.51 going2819.76 to2819.99 discuss2820.23 in2821.03 the2821.11 report.2821.28 Some2823.42 of2823.66 the2824.06 factors2824.3 that2824.78 go2824.94 into2825.18 the2826.14 decision2826.3 not2826.62 to2826.86 test2827.1 is2827.98 that2828.14 right2828.94 now,2829.18 any2829.66 affordable2830.06 unit2830.7 in2831.58 Watertown,2832.3 whether2832.94 it2833.26 is2835.02 an2835.5 inclusionary2835.5 unit2836.22 in2836.78 a2836.94 market2837.1 rate2837.5 development2837.82 or2838.86 it2839.09 is2839.34 in2840.22 a2840.45 100%2840.53 affordable2841.26 area2842.45 is2842.45 assessed2842.93 at2843.97 a2844.14 rate2844.3 that2845.01 takes2845.57 into2845.89 account2846.22 the2847.26 capped2847.57 income2848.78 stream.2849.34 So2850.53 there2850.7 already2850.93 is2851.34 a2851.66 very2851.74 substantial2852.05 discount2853.18 for2853.87 any2854.11 affordable2854.27 units.2854.83 2855.47 PLOETZ2855.47 -2855.47 Yep.2855.47 And,2856.19 absolutely,2857.31 thank2858.35 you,2858.59 Larry.2858.83 We2859.23 will2859.39 be2859.71 writing2859.87 about2860.19 this2860.51 in2860.75 our2860.91 memo.2861.15 Yes.2862.83 2864.51 UDELOVICH2864.51 -2864.51 So2864.51 because2864.75 we2865.87 did2866.67 consider2866.91 it,2867.32 we2868.28 did2868.51 actually2868.84 bring2869.15 it2869.39 up2869.55 to2869.8 the2870.11 market2870.51 rate2870.76 and2870.99 affordable2871.23 housing2871.8 developers2872.28 in2872.76 our2872.91 interviews2873.07 with2873.47 them.2873.71 So2874.19 we2874.43 do2874.59 have2874.76 qualitative2875.15 data2875.88 on2876.28 how2876.43 attractive2876.67 the2877.15 incentive2877.39 would2877.95 be.2878.11 Both2879.55 said,2879.88 you2880.59 know,2880.83 yes.2881.87 But2882.35 when2882.59 we2882.75 talked2882.91 to2883.23 in2883.71 our2883.87 focus2884.03 groups2884.43 with,2884.83 planning2888.83 board,2889.15 zoning2889.47 board,2889.95 like,2890.27 folks2890.51 who2890.75 are2891.71 more2892.03 on2892.27 the2892.35 internal2892.51 side,2893.07 it2893.39 was2893.47 less2893.71 of2894.03 an2894.11 attractive2894.61 incentive,2895.01 you2895.41 know,2895.49 because2895.73 the2896.05 tradeoff2896.38 there2896.61 is2896.86 if2897.34 you2897.49 don't2897.57 get2897.82 the2898.14 property2898.3 taxes2898.69 and2899.09 that's2899.34 less2899.57 revenue2899.89 coming2900.3 to2900.61 the2900.78 actual2900.93 municipality.2902.14 And2902.93 so2903.17 that2904.05 kind2904.38 of2904.53 you2904.78 know,2904.86 with2905.17 everything,2905.34 there's2905.82 a2906.14 tradeoff.2906.53 And2906.78 so2907.01 because2907.88 it2908.2 was2908.28 such2908.52 a2908.76 polarizing2908.92 incentive2911.64 and2913 because2913.16 of2913.64 what2914.2 Larry2914.52 mentioned2914.84 and2915.4 also2915.64 just,2916.04 there2917.08 would2917.4 be2917.56 more2918.2 complications2918.68 or2919.56 it2919.8 was2919.88 not2920.7 complications,2920.86 but,2921.58 it2922.93 would2923.26 have2923.49 been2923.82 a2924.93 more2925.09 complicated2925.41 financial2926.7 model2927.26 had2927.82 we2927.97 tested2928.22 it.2928.54 So2928.78 for2929.49 those2929.97 reasons,2930.22 we2930.7 decided2930.86 against2931.97 it.2932.3 But2932.45 it2932.61 was2932.78 a2932.93 debate.2933.09 It2933.41 definitely2933.58 was2933.97 something2934.14 we2934.38 considered.2934.61 2935.62 PLOETZ2935.62 -2935.62 It2935.62 was2935.86 heavily2936.74 covered2937.14 in2937.46 the2937.62 December2937.78 meeting,2938.18 now2938.58 I2938.74 remember,2938.82 that2940.02 you2940.18 weren't2940.42 at,2940.58 obviously.2940.9 So2941.3 you2941.54 didn't2941.94 have2942.18 that,2942.5 that2943.06 background,2943.3 but,2943.78 yeah,2944.42 for2944.66 sure2944.9 it2945.06 wasn't2945.22 discussed.2945.54 2946.1 UDELOVICH2946.1 -2946.1 But2946.1 I2946.26 believe2946.42 our2946.82 very2947.7 hefty2948.1 appendix2948.58 includes2949.3 the2949.86 slides2950.61 from2950.84 the2951.24 last2951.41 meeting.2951.8

2956.53 We2956.53 have2956.76 a2956.93 question2957.09 online2958.45 from,2959.64 Linda2960.53 Scott.2961.24 Linda,2962.61 you2963.01 should2963.16 be2963.32 able2963.49 to2963.72 talk2963.8 now.2964.05 2965.97 LINDA2965.97 SCOTT2965.97 -2965.97 RESIDENT2965.97 -2965.97 Okay.2965.97 Thank2966.29 you.2966.53 Very2966.85 quick2967.09 question.2967.41 Maybe2968.45 I2968.77 missed2968.93 it.2969.17 How2969.65 many2969.81 developers,2970.45 nonprofit,2971.41 and2972.37 market,2973.01 were2974.45 interviewed?2974.85 And2976.21 were2976.37 there2976.53 a2976.77 set2976.85 of2977.09 questions2977.17 that2977.57 they2977.81 were2977.89 all2978.13 asked2978.29 in,2978.61 you2978.93 know,2979.09 in2979.49 a2979.65 kind2979.73 of2979.97 a2980.13 formalized2980.89 way?2981.38 2982.97 PLOETZ2982.97 -2982.97 There2982.97 was.2983.3 We2983.61 interviewed2983.86 four2985.38 private2985.78 sector2986.09 developers.2986.49 What2987.3 does2987.61 that2987.86 ring2987.93 right?2988.18 Three2990.34 or2990.49 four2990.66 private2991.05 sectors2991.45 and2991.93 three2992.26 affordable.2993.14 And2994.26 we2994.41 did2994.66 a2997.86 list2997.94 of2998.26 questions2998.42 that2998.82 we2998.98 asked2999.22 each.2999.7 Those3001.22 questions3001.54 also3002.26 were3003.86 very3004.1 similar3004.34 to3004.66 the3004.82 questions3005.14 we3005.54 asked,3005.7 the3006.98 zoning3007.22 board3007.62 and3007.94 planning3008.1 board3008.5 focus3008.74 group3009.06 as3009.38 well.3009.54

3019.68 Other3019.68 questions?3019.99

3021.68 I3021.68 don't3021.84

3022.07 see3022.07 if3022.39 I3022.56 can3022.72

3024.55 can3024.64 try3024.8 to3024.95 speak3025.2 up?3025.43 So3026.95 I3027.27 think3027.35 I3027.59 have3027.67 two3027.91 clarification3028.23 questions.3028.79 So3029.27 the3029.51 first3029.67 for3029.99 the3030.15 density3030.39 be3031.03 able3031.11 to3031.43 hear3031.51 you3031.67 on3031.75 my3031.91 Yes.3032.23 It's3032.87 just3033.19 the3033.35 We'll3033.75 just3033.99

3034.23 They3034.23 can.3034.39 3037.19 UNIDENTIFIED3037.19 SPEAKER33037.19 -3037.19 So3037.19 for3037.51 the3037.67 density3038.63 bonuses3039.11 that3039.59 you3039.75 mentioned,3039.91 I3040.31 just3040.39 didn't3040.63 catch.3040.87 You3041.19 said3041.35 one3041.59 x3041.75 and3041.99 two3042.22 x.3042.47 Is3042.63 that3042.79 referring3043.03 to3043.35 the3043.59 number3043.74 of3043.99 stories3044.14 or3044.79 something3045.18 else?3045.59 3047.35 PLOETZ3047.35 -3047.35 Yeah.3047.35 I3047.35 might3047.43 have3047.59 mentioned3047.91 that.3048.07 3049.03 UDELOVICH3049.03 -3049.03 So3049.03 in3049.43 our3049.66 particular3050.47 financial3051.51 model,3051.99 we3052.47 computed3053.66 it3054.07 as3054.22 additional3054.55 stories.3055.27 Again,3056.61 was3056.93 informed3057.17 by3057.81 what's3058.77 currently3059.09 allowed3059.57 in3059.97 Watertown3060.29 Square,3061.01 zoning3062.45 district.3062.85 But3064.05 in3064.93 terms3065.09 of3065.41 implementation,3065.65 that3067.73 can3067.97 look3068.13 like3069.01 anything3069.26 that3069.97 you3070.3 all3070.61 like,3070.86 within,3071.34 public3073.34 discourse,3073.65 and3074.61 planning3074.93 discourse.3075.26 It3076.3 could3076.45 look3076.61 like3076.78 additional3077.01 height,3077.41 but3077.57 it3077.73 also3077.89 can3078.14 look3078.3 like3078.53 increase,3079.09 unit3079.89 or,3080.61 I'm3080.78 sorry,3081.01 increase3081.69 in3082.25 FAR,3082.57 floor3083.29 to3083.45 area3083.61 ratio.3083.93 It3084.41 can3084.49 also3084.65 look3084.89 like3085.05 a3085.21 percentage3085.37 increase3085.85 of3086.25 units3087.21 or3087.61 floor3087.85 area.3088.17 So3090.01 density3090.73 bonus,3091.21 we3091.69 kind3091.85 of3092.01 ground3094.57 it,3094.82 we3095.05 definitely3095.22 did3095.53 it3095.7 in3095.93 extra3096.26 stories,3096.66 but3097.14 I3097.38 don't3097.45 think3097.7 that,3098.01 that3099.05 has3099.38 to3099.53 be3099.7 the3099.86 end3100.01 all3100.18 be3100.34 all.3100.49 It3100.66 was3100.82 just3100.97 kind3101.14 of3101.3 our3101.45 proxy3101.61 for3102.09 what3103.22 a3103.45 density3103.61 bonus3104.09 could3104.57 look3104.73 like.3104.89 3105.38 UNIDENTIFIED3105.38 SPEAKER33105.38 -3105.38 So3105.38 in3105.53 your3105.7 model,3105.93 one3106.34 x3106.57 was3106.82 one3106.97 story3107.22 and3107.45 two3107.61 x3107.78 was3107.93 two3108.09 stories.3108.26 3108.57 UDELOVICH3108.82 -3108.82 Yeah.3108.82 3109.31 UNIDENTIFIED3109.31 SPEAKER33109.31 -3109.31 Okay.3109.31 And3109.31 my3109.39 other3109.63 question3109.71 is,3110.19 about3111.95 the3112.27 buy3112.75 down3112.99 model.3113.23 Is3114.51 there3114.75 any3114.91 world3115.07 in3115.39 which3115.47 that3115.79 could3116.03 be3116.11 combined3116.35 with3116.75 some3116.99 of3117.07 the3117.23 other3117.39 incentives,3117.71 or3118.19 are3118.35 those3118.51 sort3118.75 of3118.99 two3119.23 alternatives3119.55 that3120.19 you3120.59 considered?3120.83 Like,3121.39 is3121.79 there3121.95 any3122.11 way3122.35 that3122.51 you3122.67 could3122.75 combine3122.91 buy3123.47 down3123.71 and3123.95 density3124.67 bonuses,3124.99 for3125.64 example?3125.8

3127.32 Do3127.32 you3127.47 want3127.64 to3127.95 take3127.95 that,3128.19 or3128.51 do3128.84 you3128.95 You3132.76 go.3132.99 3134.76 ST-LOUIS3134.76 -3134.76 I3134.76 guess3134.76 we'll3134.91 say3135.23 we3138.43 didn't3138.67 test3139.31 how3140.11 it3140.35 would3140.59 look3140.75 to3141.07 combine3141.31 them,3141.71 but,3141.95 certainly,3142.91 it's3143.39 something3143.63 that3143.95 could3144.27 be3144.43 possible.3144.59 And3146.19 we3147.47 know3149.48 of3149.8 a3149.89 few3150.05 places3150.53 that3151.09 are3151.24 trying3151.48 to3151.89 do3152.45 buy3152.84 downs,3153.09 with3154.68 their3154.93 affordable3155.41 housing3155.8 trust,3156.13 kind3156.45 of3156.61 negotiating3156.84 those3157.41 buy3157.72 down3157.89 fees.3158.13 So3159.48 I3160.36 think.3160.76 3161.67 PLOETZ3161.67 -3161.67 I3161.67 think3161.83 the3161.91 answer3162.15 is3162.47 yes.3162.79 Yeah.3163.27 I3164.55 think3164.71 the3164.95 answer3165.03 is3165.27 yes.3165.51 And3166.07 particularly,3167.35 I3169.67 kind3170.15 of3170.39 view3170.47 buy3170.71 downs3170.79 as,3171.11 like,3171.19 almost3171.67 a3171.99 negotiating3172.15 tool3172.79 on3173.03 top3173.19 of3173.43 an3173.99 IZ3174.15 policy.3174.63 Like,3175.35 it3175.59 can3176.23 be3176.47 done.3176.63 I3178.39 mean,3178.56 what's3178.8 really3179.43 attractive3179.76 to3180.32 me,3180.39 and3180.72 I3180.88 think3181.04 we3181.2 kind3181.28 of3181.59 mentioned3181.59 in3181.84 the3181.91 presentation,3182.07 is3182.88 that3182.95 the3184.24 cost3184.47 related3184.8 to3185.2 the3185.28 buy3185.43 down3185.68 of3185.99 803186.16 to3186.47 60,3186.64 I3187.36 think,3187.52 is3187.76 really3187.91 attractive.3188.32 And,3189.28 that3190.73 scale3191.37 of3191.77 dollars3191.93 is3192.33 something3192.57 that3193.05 you're3194.89 really3195.21 getting3195.53 a3195.93 lot3196.09 when3196.57 you3196.73 go3196.81 from3196.97 803197.21 to3197.53 60%,3197.69 especially3198.81 at3199.21 that3199.37 price3199.53 point3199.77 that3200.01 we3200.17 kind3200.33 of3200.49 identified.3200.65 3201.61 But3201.61 to3201.85 me,3201.93 that3202.17 would3202.33 more3203.3 often3203.53 than3203.78 not3203.93 probably3204.26 fall3204.57 within3204.82 an3205.61 inclusionary3205.78 zoning3206.26 like3206.89 an3207.05 existing3207.14 inclusionary3207.45 zoning3207.93 policy3208.26 as3208.82 well3209.05 as3209.3 potentially3209.61 a3210.34 situation3210.57 where3211.05 you3211.14 might3211.3 have3211.45 incentives3211.61 on3212.09 top3212.26 of3212.41 it3212.57 too.3212.73 I3213.78 don’t3215.05 think3215.21 the3215.53 IZ3215.69 or3216.18 excuse3216.41 me3216.66 the3216.82 buy3216.97 down3217.14 stuff3217.45 is3217.69 every3218.59 project3218.83 walking3219.23 through3219.47 the3219.71 door3219.79 is3220.11 going3220.27 to3220.59 do3220.75 a3221.07 buy3221.23 down.3221.47 But3221.71 I3221.87 think3221.95 in3222.11 certain3222.27 instances,3222.59 it3222.99 is3223.15 a3223.31 good3223.39 thing3223.55 to3223.67 have3223.79 in3223.95 your3224.11 back3224.27 pocket3224.51 as3224.91 a3225.39 tool3225.55 to3225.87 try3225.95 to3226.19 squeeze3226.35 out3226.67 either3227.31 an3227.71 additional3227.95 unit3228.43 or3228.99 a3230.43 unit3230.67 at3231.47 a3231.79 deeper3231.79 affordability.3232.19 And3235.16 then3235.32 in3235.56 the3235.8 back.3235.95 3238.43 UNIDENTIFIED3238.43 SPEAKER43238.43 -3238.43 Hi.3238.43 Prickpal,3240.11 thanks3240.59 so3240.84 much3240.91 for3241.08 your3241.24 work3241.39 on3241.56 this.3241.72 This3241.88 is3242.11 really,3242.28 really3242.59 very,3242.99 very3244.43 interesting3244.68 and3245.08 very3245.72 relevant.3245.95 I'm3246.84 going3246.99 to3247.39 do3247.39 something3247.56 a3247.8 little3247.88 unfair3248.11 because3249.02 you3249.34 can't3250.06 predict3250.14 the3250.54 future.3250.7 But3251.74 there3252.06 are3252.22 two3252.38 things3252.54 that3252.86 may3253.26 happen3253.42 over3253.9 the3254.06 course3254.22 of3254.46 the3254.62 next3254.78 year3255.58 or3255.82 so.3257.26 I3257.5 wonder3257.74 if3258.14 it3258.7 will3258.7 impact3258.7 your3259.1 model3259.34 at3259.66 all.3259.74 And3259.98 one3260.22 is3260.38 that3260.62 the3261.02 courts3261.18 may3261.58 decide3261.74 that3262.06 inclusionary3262.54 zoning3263.26 is3263.66 not3263.9 something3264.06 that3264.34 we're3264.51 allowed3264.82 to3264.98 do3265.14 anymore.3265.39 And3266.66 2,3266.98 the3267.3 voters3267.47 may3267.86 decide3268.11 to3268.59 implement3268.82 statewide3269.3 rent3269.86 control.3270.11 Yeah.3270.98 Either3271.55 of3271.86 those3272.03 have3272.51 had3272.82 either3272.98 of3273.22 those3273.3 been3273.63 in,3273.86 you3274.11 know,3274.26 been3275.14 thought3275.39 about3275.63 as3275.95 how3276.18 that3276.34 might3276.59 interact3276.82 with3277.22 the3277.47 model3277.78 that3278.03 you've3278.18 put3278.4 together.3278.64 And,3279.28 you3279.52 know,3279.68 maybe3279.84 nothing3280.08 happens3280.32 and3280.64 maybe3280.8 it's3280.96 the3281.2 status3281.36 quo,3281.6 but3281.92 maybe3282.08 one3282.96 or3283.12 two3283.28 of3283.44 those3283.52 things3283.76 change3284.56 the3284.88 housing3285.12 market,3285.44 I'm3287.28 going3287.52 to3287.76 say3287.76 measurably,3287.92 over3289.04 the3289.28 next3290 little3291.31 while.3291.63 3291.86 PLOETZ3291.86 -3291.86 I3291.86 think3292.03 those3292.27 would3292.51 be3292.66 things3292.83 like3293.14 driving3293.39 a3293.79 truck3294.03 and3294.43 I3294.66 see3294.83 positives.3295.07 Right?3295.79 So,3296.11 yeah.3297.31 I3297.63 think3297.79 that3298.18 those3298.91 are3299.14 two3299.31 things3299.55 that3299.86 could3300.03 absolutely3300.35 shake3303.07 the3303.31 ground3303.47 of3303.86 all3304.03 this.3304.27 I3307.48 don't3307.56 think3307.72 I'm3307.88 going3308.04 to3308.28 opine3308.28 on3308.76 either3309 one3309.32 or3309.64 two,3309.88 but3310.28 I3310.44 think3310.52 it's3310.76 fair3310.92 to3311.16 say.3311.24 I3311.4 would3312.92 refer3313.16 back3313.56 to3313.8 one3314.04 of3314.2 the3314.36 slides3314.6 that3315.08 didn't3316.76 say3317.08 it3317.16 specifically,3317.4 but3317.96 I3318.12 think3318.2 IZ3318.52 policies3318.84 are3319.32 iterative3319.56 because3320.63 they3321.03 are3321.26 so3321.51 driven3322.07 by3322.47 what's3322.7 happening3323.03 in3323.66 a3323.91 market.3324.07 And3325.11 even3325.82 if3326.47 you3326.63 took,3326.78 you3327.82 know,3327.91 courts3328.3 throwing3328.7 this3329.03 out3329.26 or,3330.07 you3330.78 know,3330.95 statewide3331.91 rent3332.47 control,3332.78 like,3333.59 putting3334.3 those3334.62 aside,3334.78 there3335.58 are3335.82 all3335.9 sorts3336.06 of3336.22 things3336.38 that3336.7 could3336.78 affect3337.02 where3337.9 these3338.14 where3338.54 these,3338.86 where3340.38 these3340.54 numbers3340.78 end3341.1 up3341.34 and3341.5 wind3341.74 up3341.98 from3342.06 a3342.22 Pro3342.7 Forma3342.78 from3342.78 a3343.02 Pro3343.58 Forma3343.74 financial3343.74 feasibility3344.22 analysis.3344.78 So3345.26 I3345.34 think3345.42 that3345.58 the3345.82 takeaway3345.98 on3346.38 that3346.54 slide3346.7 is,3347.02 like,3347.26 this3347.82 is3348.06 iterative,3348.22 and3348.97 it3349.14 really3349.3 needs3349.45 to3349.7 be3350.02 it3350.66 is3350.89 not3351.14 it3352.1 is3352.34 not3352.49 a3352.74 policy3352.89 that3353.22 you3353.45 put3353.61 and3354.18 say3354.41 we3354.66 are3354.82 done.3354.97 We3355.22 have3355.45 created3355.61 an3356.02 IZ3356.26 policy,3356.58 and3357.06 we3357.22 will3357.38 never3357.61 look3357.86 at3358.02 this3358.18 again.3358.34 It3359.14 has3359.3 to3359.54 be3359.61 looked3359.78 at3360.1 I3361.64 mean,3361.8 realistically,3362.52 every3363.08 couple3363.32 years3363.64 at3364.04 the3364.28 furthest3364.44 is3365 probably3365.24 five3365.56 years.3365.72 It3366.04 should3366.12 be3366.36 cracked3366.44 open3366.68 and3367 reviewed.3367.16 Yes.3369 3369 ST-LOUIS3372.12 -3372.12 Just,3372.12 for3373.72 we3374.34 did3374.57 look3374.89 at3375.22 in3375.61 our3375.86 December3376.02 presentation3376.49 at3377.45 some3377.7 case3377.93 studies3378.18 outside3378.57 of3378.89 Massachusetts3379.05 in3379.78 states3380.02 where3380.34 inclusionary3380.89 zoning3381.54 is3381.93 illegal.3382.97 And3384.02 so3384.26 there3384.57 are3384.82 examples3385.05 of3385.61 cities3385.7 like3386.02 Salt3386.34 Lake3386.57 City,3386.82 for3387.14 instance,3387.3 that3387.86 have3389.03 essentially3389.03 a3389.51 fully3389.83 voluntary3390.31 model3391.67 because3392.39 they3392.71 can't3392.87 have3393.19 anything3393.35 be3393.99 mandatory.3394.31 So3394.87 I3396.15 also3396.31 won't3396.63 apply3396.87 what3397.99 might3398.15 happen,3398.31 but3398.71 just3398.95 to3399.83 throw3399.91 that3400.07 out3400.31 there.3400.47 Yeah.3401.19 3402.76 UNIDENTIFIED3402.76 SPEAKER53402.76 -3402.76 And3402.76 if3403.89 I3404.13 could3404.2 just3404.44 add3404.76 I've3405.32 done3405.64 planning3405.96 work3406.2 in3406.44 New3406.53 Hampshire,3406.68 which,3407.09 like3407.41 some3407.57 of3407.72 the3407.8 other3407.89 examples3408.13 they3408.44 have3408.61 done,3408.76 does3409.16 not3409.41 allow3409.57 mandatory3410.05 inclusionary3410.61 zoning.3411.16 And3411.8 so3412.05 I3412.2 think3412.28 if3412.61 something3412.76 like3413.09 that3413.24 were3413.41 to3413.72 happen,3414.05 it3414.53 would3414.68 be3414.84 the3415.16 kind3415.32 of3415.57 distinction3415.64 they3416.05 were3416.2 making3416.44 between3416.76 what's3417.6 incentivizing3418 and3418.64 what3418.8 is3418.96 really3419.12 feasible3420.16 versus3420.56 incentivizing3420.88 becomes3421.68 an3422 even3422.16 more3422.32 important3422.56 conversation3423.44 because3423.92 then,3424.24 you3424.56 know,3424.8 you're3424.88 not3425.12 looking3425.2 at3425.44 just3425.52 what3425.76 makes3425.84 it3426.08 feasible.3426.24 You're3426.56 looking3426.8 at3427.12 what3427.12 we3427.44 can3427.68 actually3427.68 do3428 to3428.24 get3428.4 people3428.56 to3428.88 invest3429.04 in3429.28 this3429.44 because3429.6 we3429.92 don't3430.08 have3430.24 the3430.4 option3430.56 of3430.88 making3431.04 them.3431.36 And3433.28 then3433.43 online,3433.91 we3434.71 have3434.88 Angeline3436.07 Cunellis.3436.8 Angeline,3438.39 if3438.95 you3439.11 can3439.28 go3439.51 ahead.3439.76 3443.11 ANGELINE3443.11 KOUNELIS3443.11 -3443.11 RESIDENT3443.11 -3443.11 Oh,3443.11 thank3443.36 you3443.59 so3443.84 much3443.99 for3444.23 the3444.39 opportunity.3444.55 Is3446.22 your3446.46 data3446.78 based3447.18 on3447.58 predominantly3448.38 rental3449.18 units?3449.66 Are3450.22 there3451.18 any3451.34 for3451.74 purchase3451.98 sale3452.54 units3452.86 included3453.26 in3454.78 the3455.02 formulas,3455.58 or3456.54 is3456.78 it3456.86 a3457.02 combination3457.18 of?3457.82 3459.84 UDELOVICH3459.84 -3459.84 That's3459.84 a3460.09 great3460.24 question.3460.48 I3460.8 think3460.96 it3461.2 may3461.44 have3461.76 got,3462.01 maybe3464.41 missed3465.44 or3465.76 folded3466.09 in3466.48 with3466.8 a3467.13 lot3467.2 of3467.36 the3467.53 information3467.68 we3468.24 threw3468.41 at3469.2 you3469.36 today.3469.53 This3470.09 study3470.41 focuses3471.05 on3472.16 rental.3472.41 Watertown's3474.95 inclusionary3475.59 zoning3476.15 does3476.87 take3477.35 into3477.59 consideration3477.91 homeownership,3478.71 but3480.07 for3480.23 the3480.39 purpose3480.55 of3480.87 this3480.95 study,3481.19 we3481.59 do3481.83 not.3481.99 We're3482.23 only3482.47 focusing3482.79 on3483.35 rental,3483.75 both3485.35 on3485.67 the3485.83 market3485.91 rate3486.31 side3486.47 as3486.79 well3486.95 as3487.11 the3487.35 affordable3487.35 side.3488.07 3491.18 PLOETZ3493.98 -3493.98 And3493.98 APC3494.22 is3494.7 doing3494.78 some3495.11 work3495.26 in3495.59 Revere,3495.91 which3496.47 is3496.7 I3500.3 think3500.39 we're3500.63 looking3500.86 a3501.11 little3501.18 closer3501.43 at3501.74 kind3501.91 of3502.07 the3502.22 homeownership3502.3 side3503.03 of3503.18 this,3503.34 but3503.82 that3505.01 doesn't3505.17 necessarily3505.65 help3506.13 Watertown3506.37 at3506.85 this3506.93 point3507.17 in3507.41 time.3507.49 But3508.29 we3508.45 are3508.93 looking3509.17 at3509.49 it.3509.65

3512.37 Other3512.37 questions?3512.69

3520.09 Yes.3520.09

3524.09 Oh,3524.09 sorry.3524.41 Here.3527.45 3530.66 UNIDENTIFIED3530.66 SPEAKER63530.66 -3530.66 RESIDENT3530.66 I3530.66 was3530.82 somewhat3532.26 surprised3532.74 at3533.53 the3533.86 different3535.09 impact3535.41 density3535.89 bonuses3536.29 seem3536.77 to3537.09 have3537.17 on3537.41 the3537.57 two3538.13 the3538.37 market3538.53 rate3538.77 versus3539.09 affordable.3539.41 It3539.89 seems3540.05 affordable,3540.69 but3541.17 they're3541.41 really3541.57 not3541.89 that3542.21 impactful.3542.45 Am3543.73 I3543.97 reading3544.21 that3544.45 correctly?3544.77 3546.29 PLOETZ3546.29 -3546.29 Yeah.3546.29 3546.45 UNIDENTIFIED3546.45 SPEAKER63546.45 -3546.45 And3546.77 on3547.57 the3547.81 market3548.29 rate3548.61 side,3548.93 you3549.59 know,3550.14 because3550.22 the3550.55 incentives3552.22 were3552.86 rated3553.26 somewhat3553.66 differently,3554.07 are3554.86 they3555.03 are3555.26 very3555.66 impactful,3555.98 mildly3556.7 impactful,3557.18 not3558.78 that3558.95 impactful,3559.18 or3559.59 they3559.74 really3559.91 have3560.07 to3560.3 be3560.39 used3560.55 in3560.78 combination3560.95 with3561.43 other3561.66 factors.3563.6 3565.36 PLOETZ3565.36 -3565.36 So3565.36 I'll3565.68 say,3566.24 when3567.92 we3568.16 did3568.4 the3568.72 affordable3569.52 developer3570.08 interviews,3570.56 they3572.08 all3572.32 said3572.56 that3573.44 adding3573.92 density3574.24 or3574.72 adding3574.88 units3575.2 is3575.68 not3575.84 necessarily3576.08 something3576.72 they3577.12 look3578.02 for.3578.34 So3579.14 we3579.3 have3579.38 it3579.54 qualitatively,3579.7 but3580.34 I3580.49 also3580.57 think3580.82 Evelyn's3581.06 work3581.45 kind3581.7 of3581.93 shows3581.93 it3582.18 quantitatively.3582.41 I'll3583.3 let3583.45 her3583.78 talk3583.93 about3584.18 that3584.34 a3584.49 little3584.57 bit,3584.82 and3584.89 then3585.06 I3585.22 think3585.3 Emma3586.57 can3586.89 swing3587.14 back3587.45 around3587.7 on3588.18 the3589.22 market3589.45 rate3589.86 question3590.34 that3590.74 you3590.97 asked.3591.22 3595.5 ST-LOUIS3595.5 -3595.5 Yeah.3595.5 So3595.9 I3596.86 think3597.02 you3598.22 think3598.38 about3598.62 it3598.86 too3599.02 in3599.26 terms3599.5 of3599.74 adding3599.98 units.3600.3 You're3601.02 adding3601.26 a3601.9 development3601.98 cost,3602.46 and3603.5 so3604.61 you're3604.86 adding3605.02 more3605.34 cost.3605.58 On3606.06 the3606.14 market3606.3 rate3606.54 side,3606.78 you're3607.02 adding3607.26 a3608.06 market3608.22 rate3608.45 rent.3608.86 So3609.18 you're3609.34 adding3609.58 a3609.89 lot3609.97 of3610.14 rental3610.3 revenue3610.7 that's3611.09 making3611.41 up3611.66 for3611.82 that3611.97 cost.3612.14 On3612.86 the3613.02 affordable3613.18 housing3613.58 side,3613.89 you're3614.78 adding3615.02 the3616.47 cost3616.47 of3616.71 a3616.79 unit,3616.87 which3617.27 is3617.43 expensive,3617.67 but3618.15 you're3618.31 only3618.55 bringing3618.95 in3619.35 a3619.51 little3619.59 bit3619.83 of3619.99 rent.3620.15 So3620.55 you're3621.43 achieving3621.75 a3622.63 more3622.87 efficient3623.11 project3623.51 because,3624.15 if3626.23 you3626.47 can3626.63 build3626.87 403627.19 units3627.43 instead3627.83 of3628.15 303628.31 units,3628.55 that's3629.74 you3630.63 have3630.78 economies3631.03 of3631.42 scale3631.59 for3631.9 your3632.07 soft3632.22 costs3632.46 or3632.78 your3632.94 land3633.26 costs3633.51 on3633.9 a3634.07 per3634.22 unit3634.46 basis.3634.78 3636.3 But,3636.3 your3637.9 total3638.14 funding3638.46 gap3638.86 is3639.11 still3639.26 going3639.51 up,3639.82 so3640.22 that3640.46 means3640.63 you3640.94 might3641.26 need3641.51 more3641.82 tax3642.3 credits3642.63 or3643.03 you3643.31 might3643.55 need3643.71 a3644.03 little3644.11 bit3644.35 more3644.43 of3644.75 a3644.91 local3644.99 match3645.31 from3645.79 the3646.19 city.3646.43 So3647.47 it3647.95 is3648.11 helpful,3649.63 I3650.19 think,3650.27 because3650.59 developers,3650.99 if3651.55 they3651.95 say3651.95 they3652.11 have3652.27 a3652.51 small3652.59 site3652.91 and3653.55 they3653.79 need3653.87 to3654.11 fit3654.19 in3654.43 a3654.59 few3654.67 more3654.83 units,3655.15 like,3655.63 that3656.27 can3656.43 be3656.67 helpful.3656.75 Or,3657.31 I3658.51 think,3658.59 like,3659.2 in3659.45 the3659.68 state's3660.49 QAP,3661.05 I3661.61 think3661.68 there3661.84 are3662.16 certain3662.24 expectations3662.72 for,3663.45 like,3663.61 cost3664.81 per3665.13 unit3665.36 being3665.84 efficient.3666.41 So,3667.68 like,3667.93 having3668.24 an3668.49 economy3668.72 of3669.13 scale3669.36 and3669.68 an3669.93 efficient3670.09 project3670.49 is3670.97 a3671.13 good3671.29 thing.3671.84 But3673.34 it's3673.74 a3673.98 little3674.06 bit3674.3 different3674.46 than3674.7 on3674.86 the3675.02 market3675.1 rate3675.34 side3675.58 where3675.82 you're3675.98 really3676.14 getting3676.38 that3676.7 extra3676.94 market3677.66 rate3678.06 rent3678.46 and3678.7 the3678.94 revenue3679.1 from3679.74 those3680.06 Units.3682.94 Does3682.94 that3683.18 and,3683.9 Emma,3684.22 do3684.62 you3684.7 want3684.78 to3685.18 add3685.18 about3685.34 the3685.58 extra3686.39 feasibility3686.78 that3687.51 3687.99 UDELOVICH3687.99 -3687.99 Yes.3687.99 Yeah.3688.47 So,3689.27 yeah,3690.3 to3690.55 kind3690.78 of3690.95 continue3691.11 the3691.66 thread3691.91 of,3692.3 you3692.7 know,3692.86 on3693.11 the3693.27 market3693.43 rate3693.82 side,3693.91 it's3695.18 all3695.43 about3695.59 profitability.3695.82 You3696.7 know?3696.86 In3697.18 order3697.43 for3697.74 a3697.99 market3698.07 rate3698.47 developer3698.55 to3698.95 build,3699.11 they3699.34 have3699.51 to,3699.66 like,3699.91 at3700.59 least3700.75 break3701.23 even3701.63 if3702.03 not3702.19 make3702.51 a3702.67 little3702.75 bit3702.99 more3703.15 money.3703.31 And3703.55 so3703.71 when3703.95 you're3704.11 asking3704.27 for3704.59 affordable3704.83 units,3705.23 you're3705.63 lowering3705.79 the3706.19 market3706.27 rate3706.59 rent,3707.31 which3707.55 then,3707.79 you3708.51 know,3708.67 lowers3709.47 the3709.79 amount3709.95 of3711.15 money3711.31 that3711.63 will3711.95 eventually3712.27 cover3712.83 their3713.23 debt.3713.55 And3714.35 so3714.51 when3714.75 we're3714.99 talking3715.53 about3715.84 feasibility,3716.89 the3717.61 way3717.76 again,3718.01 this3718.24 kind3718.49 of3718.72 goes3718.72 back3718.97 to,3719.05 like,3719.28 this3719.45 language3719.68 exercise.3720.16 For3721.36 the3721.53 market3721.68 rate3722.09 side,3722.64 we're3722.97 talking3723.28 about3723.61 feasible.3724.01 So3724.57 can3724.8 it3725.05 be3725.2 built?3725.36 3725.76 Can3725.76 it3725.93 break3726.16 even3726.49 at3726.72 the3726.89 very3726.89 least?3727.2 And3727.61 then3727.76 feasible3728.01 plus3728.57 very3728.89 attractive.3729.2 Does3730.63 it3730.87 actually3730.95 offer3731.59 enough3732.39 of3732.87 a3733.03 financial3733.19 offset3733.83 so3734.87 that3735.11 a3735.35 developer3735.59 will3736.07 say,3736.31 okay.3736.63 I'm3737.03 losing3737.75 money3738.15 on3738.79 the3738.95 market3739.11 rate3739.43 rents3739.67 because3740.07 I3740.31 have3740.47 more3741.43 affordable3741.75 units,3742.31 but3743.3 at3743.61 least3743.86 I'm3744.09 getting3744.34 enough3744.57 of3744.89 a3745.05 financial3745.3 offset3745.86 through3746.82 these3747.05 incentives3747.69 to3749.05 still3749.3 make3749.61 it3749.78 work3750.26 in3750.89 terms3751.3 of3751.78 my3751.93 financial3752.18 Pro3753.05 Forma.3753.61 So3753.61 we3755.15 didn't3756.51 really3756.75 show3756.91 up3757.15 on3757.39 the3757.63 slide.3757.87 We3758.19 got3758.35 some3758.51 feedback3758.75 that3759.07 it3759.23 was3759.31 too3759.55 technical.3759.79 So3760.35 but,3760.75 in3763.23 the3763.47 final3763.87 report,3764.27 you'll3764.59 see3764.91 more3765.23 of3765.71 you3766.11 know,3766.27 we3766.75 have3766.99 these3767.23 metrics3767.55 that,3768.35 the3770.09 internal3770.32 rate3770.8 of3770.97 return3771.13 or3771.45 the3771.68 return3771.84 on3772.24 cost.3772.48 3772.97 So3772.97 we3773.61 have3775.45 kind3775.76 of3776.01 qualitatively3776.24 determined3777.13 what3777.76 that3778.09 range3778.32 looks3778.89 like3779.13 if3779.45 it's,3779.61 an3780.24 additional3780.48 1%3781.68 to3782.8 the3782.97 internal3783.13 rate3783.61 at3785.92 a3786.12 certain3786.36 metric.3786.6 So3787 for3787.08 most3788.04 Pro3788.6 Formas,3788.92 definitely3788.92 by3789.32 EOHLC3789.56 standard,3790.36 it's3790.76 15,3790.92 percent3791.88 IRR3792.44 is3792.92 the3793.08 metric3793.24 of3793.64 feasibility.3793.88 If3795.64 it's3795.8 an3796.04 additional3796.2 1%,3796.68 then3797.8 we3798.04 see3798.2 it3798.36 as3798.6 very3798.76 attractive,3799.08 because3800.68 they're3801.07 that3801.47 margin3801.8 of3802.51 profitability3802.76 has3803.64 increased3803.88 to3804.36 a3804.51 point3804.59 where3804.84 it's3805.72 okay3805.95 if3806.28 they3806.43 lose3806.59 a3806.76 little3806.91 bit3807.16 of3807.32 money3807.88 on3808.11 the3808.28 rent3808.51 side3808.76 because,3809.07 you3809.39 know,3809.55 they're3809.8 gaining3810.43 some3810.84 money3811.07 on3811.39 the3811.8 cost3811.95 or3812.59 additional3813.45 revenue3813.77 from3814.33 additional3814.65 units3815.13 or3815.53 you3815.85 know?3815.93 So,3816.17 does3818.97 that3819.13 answer3819.37 your3819.85 question?3820.09 3820.65 UNIDENTIFIED3820.65 SPEAKER63820.65 -3820.65 Yeah.3820.65 I3820.89 mean,3820.97 it3821.13 is3821.69 interesting3821.85 because3822.25 I3822.49 think3822.57 a3823.93 lot3824.09 of3824.25 the3824.41 discussion3824.57 here3825.05 is3825.29 focused3825.45 on3825.93 density3826.73 bonuses,3827.05 and3827.53 it3827.93 sounds3828.09 like3828.34 we3828.49 really3828.66 need3828.89 to3829.05 be3829.14 working3829.21 well3830.41 beyond3830.66 that,3831.05 particularly3831.7 on3832.18 the3832.26 affordable3832.34 side.3832.82 3833.78 UDELOVICH3833.78 -3833.78 Yeah.3833.78 And3833.93 that3834.57 was3834.82 also3834.97 the3835.21 tricky3835.38 part3835.7 here3835.93 is3836.09 the3836.41 market3836.82 rate3837.14 approach3837.45 is3838.41 going3838.66 to3838.97 be3839.14 and3839.3 needs3839.53 to3839.86 be3839.93 different3840.09 from3840.57 affordable3840.73 housing3841.89 propulsion.3842.05 3842.05 UNIDENTIFIED3842.05 SPEAKER63842.05 -3842.05 The3842.85 scale3843.49 of3843.81 the3843.97 difference,3844.05 I3844.25 think,3844.45 is3844.77 a3845.81 little3845.89 surprising3846.05 to3846.53 me3846.61 looking3846.85 at3847.09 this,3847.17 but3847.33 it3847.57 makes3847.65 sense3847.89 as3848.13 you3848.29 explain3848.45 it.3848.77 3849.09 UDELOVICH3849.09 -3849.09 Yeah.3849.09 And3849.89 for3850.21 market3850.53 rate,3850.93 density3851.57 bonuses3852.05 actually,3852.53 in3853.81 all3854.05 cases,3854.53 were3855.17 quite3855.65 feasible3855.97 and3856.37 attractive.3856.69 Completely,3858.76 contrast3859.72 too.3860.28 Or3860.61 not3860.84 completely,3861.09 but3861.57 it3862.2 differs3862.76 enough3863.24 from3863.64 the3863.89 affordable3864.13 housing3864.53 results.3865.24 3867.01 UNIDENTIFIED3867.01 SPEAKER63867.01 -3867.01 Thank3867.41 you.3867.57 3867.89 ST-LOUIS3867.89 -3867.89 Yeah.3867.89 It's3868.13 sort3868.2 of3868.45 like3868.53 the3868.68 density3868.76 bonus,3869.16 I3869.57 think,3869.64 you3869.96 would3870.13 maybe3870.45 say3870.76 for3871.01 the3871.24 affordable3871.41 housing3871.96 is3872.28 definitely3873.14 a3873.54 plus.3873.62 It's3874.1 just3874.34 it3874.58 might3874.74 not,3874.98 you3879.22 know,3879.38 make3880.74 or3880.98 break3881.22 something3881.54 happening3881.94 or,3882.5 like,3882.66 have3882.9 it3883.14 as3883.3 Yeah.3883.54 Really,3884.02 you3884.42 know,3884.58 going3885.06 from,3885.46 oh,3885.86 it's3886.18 really3886.42 hard3886.66 to,3886.82 oh,3886.98 it's3887.06 really3887.3 easy.3887.54 I3888.18 mean,3888.38 not3888.61 that3888.69 it's3888.78 ever3888.86 very.3889.18 3889.57 UNIDENTIFIED3889.57 SPEAKER63889.57 -3889.57 Well,3889.57 not3889.74 that3889.89 it's3890.86 ever3891.09 easy.3891.34 It3891.66 sounds3891.89 like3892.14 it3892.22 can3892.38 go3892.53 from3892.7 not3893.09 very3893.34 easy3893.57 to3893.82 even3894.05 harder3894.3 potentially3894.7 with3895.41 the3895.57 dispute.3895.74 3896.05 PLOETZ3896.05 -3896.05 I3896.05 think3896.14 that's3896.38 a3896.53 good3896.61 takeaway.3896.78 3897.41 UNIDENTIFIED3897.41 SPEAKER63897.41 -3897.41 Yeah.3897.41

3898.38 Yeah.3898.38 Sure.3899.66 Will.3900.86

3902.65 We3902.65 have3902.97 online3903.53 counselor3904.57 Paloma.3905.45 You3907.05 can3907.21 go3907.37 ahead.3907.53 Yeah.3908.09

3912.41 Sorry.3912.41

3913.53 Uh-huh.3913.53

3915.09 ANTHONY3915.09 PALOMBA3915.09 -3915.09 CITY3915.09 COUNCIL3915.09 -3915.09 Thank3915.09 you.3915.41 You3916.53 know,3916.69 it3916.86 always3917.57 seems3918.3 difficult3918.3 to3918.93 look3919.09 at3919.26 both3919.41 options.3919.82 I3920.45 mean,3920.61 there3921.17 are3921.34 affordability,3921.66 there3922.61 are3922.78 affordable3922.86 units3923.26 and3923.66 the3923.89 market3923.97 rate3924.38 units3924.61 and,3925.01 you3925.57 know,3925.73 the3925.97 goal,3926.21 obviously,3926.61 is3927.34 to3927.57 increase3928.69 as3929.25 many3929.41 afford3929.81 well,3930.13 I3930.77 would3931.01 think3931.17 that3931.49 one3931.65 of3931.81 the3931.89 goals3932.05 is3932.45 to3932.69 increase3933.81 the3934.77 number3935.01 of3935.33 affordable3935.57 units.3936.21 So3937.33 in3937.49 a3937.73 place3937.89 like3938.21 Watertown,3938.53 particularly3939.17 with3939.81 the3940.05 Watertown3940.21 Square3940.85 project3941.17 over,3941.65 you3942.29 know,3942.45 the3942.69 next3942.85 four3943.25 to3943.41 three3943.93 or3944.18 five3944.41 years,3944.66 we3946.41 might3946.74 actually3947.3 create3948.18 more3949.45 affordable3951.7 units3952.26 through3953.06 market3953.54 rate3954.02 incentives3954.41 than3955.14 we3955.38 would,3955.61 creating3957.58 100%3958.14 affordable3959.26 units.3960.22 Though3961.58 I'd3961.82 bet3961.98 it3962.22 to3962.3 me3962.46 is3962.7 a3962.94 constant,3963.42 trade3965.66 off3965.98 or3966.54 various3967.18 options.3967.66 Now3968.14 in3968.38 Watertown,3968.54 we3969.82 have3970.14 well,3970.46 one3970.7 of3970.86 the3971.02 other3971.18 problems3971.42 with3971.98 the3972.22 affordable3973.64 units3974.13 is3974.53 how3974.76 long3974.92 it3975.16 takes.3975.32 3976.2 You3976.2 know,3976.44 our3976.61 Willow3976.84 Park3977.57 project3977.96 did3979.32 not3979.64 make3979.89 it3980.13 through3980.28 the3980.61 first3980.76 state3981.16 effort3982.13 to3982.53 get3982.68 credits.3983.01 And3983.48 I3983.64 think3983.8 in3984.05 the3984.05 second3984.2 round,3984.61 it3984.92 will.3985.09 Part3985.57 of3985.8 that3985.96 has3986.2 to3986.44 do3986.61 with3986.76 whether3987.01 the3987.75 state3987.99 puts3988.23 more3988.63 money3988.87 into3989.75 affordable3990.15 housing.3990.71 But3991.99 I3992.39 think3992.55 we're3992.79 trying3993.03 to3993.35 do3993.43 both3993.67 at3993.91 the3994.07 same3994.23 time.3994.55 Look3994.95 at3995.43 what3995.51 the3996.71 developments3996.87 are,3998.39 you3998.71 know,3998.79 new3999.03 market4000.36 rate,4000.76 and4001.32 we4001.47 have4001.64 quite4001.88 a4002.11 few4002.19 online.4002.43 And4003.55 what4003.8 we4003.95 can4004.11 do4004.28 to4004.51 incentivize4004.76 those4005.64 to4005.95 get4006.11 more4006.28 affordable4006.59 units4007.16 at4007.55 the4007.71 same4007.88 time,4008.19 though4008.76 it's4008.99 taken4009.23 three4010.11 or4010.51 more4010.76 years4010.99 to4011.39 get4011.55 Willow4012.28 Park4012.67 funded,4013.07 We're4015.55 trying4015.71 to4016.03 do4016.19 both.4016.35 Are4016.67 there4017.23 other4017.47 communities4017.87 that4018.59 you4018.83 know4018.99 are4019.39 trying4019.63 to4020.11 do4020.27 both4020.59 at4021.23 the4021.55 same4021.71 time?4021.95 4024.99 PLOETZ4024.99 -4024.99 Yes.4024.99 I4027.07 would4027.23 say4027.47 most4029.22 of4029.53 the4029.78 peer4030.02 communities4030.41 geographically4032.89 within,4033.45 you4034.09 know,4034.26 certainly4034.74 within4035.14 the4035.3 inner4035.45 core4035.78 of,4035.93 you4036.18 know,4036.41 Greater4036.57 Boston4036.97 are4038.09 trying4039.14 to4039.38 juggle4039.53 both4039.93 of4040.18 these,4040.34 both4042.65 the4042.89 kind4043.53 of4043.77 affordable4044.09 side4044.57 as4044.97 well4045.21 as4045.53 the4046.17 kind4046.17 of4046.33 creating4046.73 units4047.13 through4047.53 inclusionary4047.93 zoning.4048.65 I4050.49 think,4050.73 you4052.09 know,4052.33 we're4052.65 seeing4052.97 generally.4053.45 I4055.09 think4055.26 we4055.41 generally4055.57 see4055.97 interest.4056.3 As4058.3 you4058.45 get4058.61 further4058.86 out,4059.18 you4060.14 get4060.3 less4061.49 of4061.74 it,4061.82 but4061.97 I4062.14 still4062.22 think4062.45 you're4062.7 seeing4062.86 genuine4063.89 and4064.38 general4064.93 interest4065.26 in4065.66 doing4065.82 both,4066.22 even4067.66 beyond4067.89 01/28.4068.3 So4069.26 I4069.41 don’t4070.77 think4070.93 it's4071.01 an4071.25 unusual4071.41 thing4071.97 to4072.21 try4072.45 to4072.69 do.4073.01 I4073.33 will4073.49 say4073.65 that,4073.89 like4075.49 this4075.73 project,4076.05 I4076.77 think4077.49 the4078.69 city4078.93 of4079.33 Watertown4079.49 has4080.05 put4080.21 a4081.65 lot4081.73 of4081.89 effort4082.05 into4082.45 really4082.85 thinking4083.09 about4083.49 it,4083.73 maybe4084.36 more4084.61 so4085.01 than4085.16 some4085.41 other4085.57 communities.4085.8 And4086.36 I4086.53 think4086.61 part4086.76 of4087.01 that4087.16 is,4087.49 I4089.57 think4089.72 part4089.97 of4090.13 that's4090.2 related4090.53 to4091.01 maybe4091.89 resort4092.28 like,4092.68 available4092.84 resources,4093.24 particularly4093.8 on4094.2 the4094.36 affordable4094.45 side.4094.93 I4095.16 mean,4095.32 you4095.49 guys4095.64 have4095.89 access4096.13 to4096.52 some4098.47 affordable4098.71 resources,4099.27 but4099.75 you're4099.99 not4100.15 Boston.4100.39 You're4100.87 not4101.03 Cambridge.4101.27 You4103.27 know,4103.35 you4103.67 guys4103.83 have4104.07 to4104.23 kind4104.79 of4105.11 hunt4105.11 for4105.27 your4105.43 food4105.59 on4105.91 this,4105.99 and4106.23 I4106.35 think4106.47 that4106.71 makes4106.95 it4107.11 a4107.27 little4107.35 harder.4107.67 And4108.15 I4109.03 think4109.11 it4109.35 kind4109.51 of4109.67 points4110.39 to4110.71 the4112.35 more4112.6 intense4112.76 level4113.07 of4113.31 research4113.48 you4113.88 want4113.95 to4114.19 do4114.19 on4114.27 both4114.44 sides4114.6 of4114.91 the4114.99 equation.4115.15

4125.18 Well,4125.18 hold4125.82 on.4125.94 I'm4126.06 calling4126.46 you.4126.54 Hold4126.78 on.4126.94 I4127.34 got4127.5 it.4127.66 Good.4127.9 You4128.54 take4128.7 that,4128.86 and4129.1 I'll4129.18 hand4129.26 it4129.5 big4129.58 a4129.74 nail4129.82 on4129.98 that.4130.06 4132.38 UNIDENTIFIED4132.38 SPEAKER74132.38 -4132.38 This4132.38 might4132.62 be4132.86 a4133.1 slightly4133.26 ignorant4133.74 question,4134.06 but4134.46 I'm4134.7 curious4134.86 about4135.5 the4137.11 recent4137.35 research4137.84 that4138.31 shows4138.55 more4139.35 of4139.59 a4139.76 demand4139.91 for4140.4 smaller4140.64 units.4141.03 And4141.99 so4142.23 when4142.47 you4142.64 talk4142.8 about4143.03 density,4143.44 is4144.88 there4145.11 any4145.35 way4146.47 to4146.72 factor4146.95 in,4147.35 or4147.84 did4148.23 you4148.4 think4148.72 about,4149.11 especially4150.32 on4150.8 the4150.96 affordable4151.12 side,4151.6 the4152.24 option4152.56 to4152.96 have4153.2 smaller4154.48 units?4154.88 And4156.24 with4156.48 that4156.72 I4158.08 mean,4158.24 I4158.48 know4158.56 that4158.8 you're4158.96 saying4159.2 that4159.44 with4159.68 more4159.92 units,4160.48 that's4160.88 not4161.12 necessarily4161.36 attractive4162.16 for4163.76 the4163.84 affordable.4164.07 The4165.35 other4165.6 question,4165.84 and4166.15 this4166.31 is4166.56 another4166.72 I4167.35 feel4167.44 a4167.68 little4167.76 bit4167.91 like4168.23 I4168.56 should4168.72 know4168.95 more4169.11 about4169.35 this,4169.6 but4169.76 I'm4170.72 always4170.88 looking4171.19 at,4171.68 like,4171.99 the4173.03 housing4173.19 that's4173.6 more4173.91 income4174.15 based4174.48 because4175.27 I4175.68 have4176.31 strong4176.64 feelings4176.95 about4177.44 how4177.68 even4178.21 80%4179.01 really4179.65 ends4180.61 up4180.85 really4181.01 not4181.25 being4181.49 affordable.4181.81 So4182.69 I'm4183.01 just4183.17 curious4183.41 about4184.13 how4184.53 I'm4186.45 assuming4186.69 the4187.09 market4187.25 rate4187.57 incentives4187.89 only4188.53 relate4188.85 to4189.25 fixed4189.49 supposedly4190.69 below4191.25 market4191.65 rate.4191.97 So4192.77 anything4193.01 that's4193.41 income4193.73 based4193.97 would4194.3 have4194.53 to4194.69 come4194.77 from,4195.01 nonprofit4197.49 combined4198.85 with4199.34 right?4199.65 4200.45 PLOETZ4200.45 -4200.45 No.4200.45 Okay.4200.94 But4201.41 we4201.65 can4202.38 talk4202.61 about4202.85 all4203.09 of4203.26 those4203.34 things.4203.57 4203.73 UNIDENTIFIED4203.73 SPEAKER74203.73 -4203.73 Okay.4203.73 Thank4203.97 you.4204.14 4204.38 PLOETZ4204.38 -4204.38 So4204.38 the4205.18 first4205.18 question4205.5 was4205.82 about4206.14 the4206.46 kind4206.46 of4206.7 unit4207.18 size.4207.58 Did4208.14 we4208.38 capture4208.54 that4208.94 at4209.1 all?4209.18 I4209.3 don't4209.42 think4209.66 we4209.9 did4210.06 necessarily.4210.38 4211.1 UDELOVICH4211.1 -4211.1 Yeah.4211.1 I4211.34 would4211.5 love4211.66 to,4211.9 you4212.3 know,4212.46 clarify4214.54 your4214.94 question.4215.1 Are4215.5 you4215.74 talking4215.82 more4216.14 about4216.38 the4216.62 actual4216.78 size4217.1 of4217.42 the4217.58 unit4217.74 or4218.22 the4218.62 size4218.78 of4219.1 the4219.34 development?4219.58 4221.11 UNIDENTIFIED4221.11 SPEAKER74221.11 -4221.11 The4221.11 size4221.27 of4221.44 the4221.68 units.4221.99 4222.48 PLOETZ4222.48 -4222.48 So,4222.48 like,4222.64 one4222.95 bedroom,4223.11 two4223.76 bedrooms4224.16 that4224.16 or?4226.23 4226.48 UNIDENTIFIED4226.48 SPEAKER74226.48 -4226.48 Just4226.48 like,4226.48 a4226.72 normal4226.88 one4227.27 bedroom,4227.84 a4228.56 lot4228.72 of,4228.95 like4229.11 especially,4229.68 like,4230.16 elderly4230.31 people.4230.72 They're4231.11 like,4231.84 I4232.23 could4232.31 go4232.48 into4232.72 a4233.03 really4233.2 small4233.44 one4233.84 bedroom4233.99 and4234.48 be4234.64 really4235.29 happy,4235.61 and4235.85 I4236.09 don't4236.17 care4236.41 how4236.57 small4236.81 it4236.97 is.4237.13 That4237.37 type4237.53 of4237.77 thing,4239.93 recently4240.41 graduated4240.41 college,4241.21 you4241.69 know,4241.93 that4242.17 type4242.33 of4242.49 thing.4242.65 4243.37 UDELOVICH4243.37 -4243.37 Yeah.4243.37 It's4244.81 a4245.05 great4245.13 question.4245.37 I4245.77 think4245.85 well,4246.57 first4246.97 to4247.21 answer4247.94 it4248.09 in4248.26 the4248.57 more4248.73 technical4248.98 side4249.38 of,4249.53 like,4249.69 what4249.85 we4250.02 did4250.18 in4250.34 our4250.41 Pro4251.05 Forma.4251.3 So4251.3 when4251.77 we4252.02 do4252.34 our4252.65 Pro4253.3 Forma,4253.53 we4253.53 take4253.77 data4255.61 from4255.94 CoStar4256.18 that4256.73 shows4256.9 the4257.14 unit4257.38 mix4257.69 of4258.26 the4260.64 municipality.4260.88 So4261.84 that's4262.16 how4262.4 we4262.56 kind4262.8 of4262.96 break4263.12 down.4263.44 So4263.76 in4264 our4264.24 Pro4264.72 Forma,4264.8 we4264.8 do4264.96 distinguish4265.2 between,4265.68 like,4266.08 a4266.4 studio,4266.56 one4267.04 bedroom,4267.2 two4267.76 bedrooms.4268.4 And4268.4 then4268.56 what4268.72 we4268.88 do4269.04 is4269.2 we4269.36 do4269.52 a4269.68 qualitative4269.84 data4270.64 collection4271.6 where,4272.24 we4273.28 take,4273.44 you4273.76 know,4273.92 the4274.08 costar4274.4 or4274.88 the4275.04 quantitative,4275.12 data4276.65 sources,4276.97 but4277.36 then4277.52 we4277.69 also4277.76 comb4278.09 through4278.4 different4279.44 postings4279.93 such4281.05 as,4281.28 like,4281.44 through4281.69 Zillow4281.93 to4282.56 see.4283.52 4283.6 What4283.6 is4283.6 the4283.76 aggregate4284.01 unit4284.56 size4284.97 that's4285.28 currently4285.52 on4286.24 the4286.4 market?4286.56 So4286.89 I4287.13 would4287.2 say4287.36 this4287.6 question4287.84 around4288.16 unit4288.48 size4288.73 is4289.13 very4289.55 subjective4289.79 because4290.99 I4291.63 think4291.71 it's4291.87 one,4292.99 dependent4293.63 on4293.95 the4294.11 developer4294.27 of,4294.83 like,4295.07 what4295.31 they4295.63 see4295.95 as4296.51 what4297.15 will4297.79 be4298.03 attractive4298.43 to4299.07 potential4299.23 renters4299.79 or4300.35 buyers.4300.51 And4302.84 then4303.07 two,4303.15 I4303.31 think4303.55 there's4303.64 also4303.88 an4304.11 equity4304.27 component4304.68 here4305.07 too,4305.72 you4305.95 know,4306.03 you4306.43 don't4306.59 yes.4307.23 Making4307.55 a4307.88 smaller4308.03 unit4309.07 will4309.64 eventually4309.88 save4310.51 costs4311.07 and4311.64 then,4311.8 you4312.19 know,4312.35 either4312.99 save4313.88 costs4314.19 or4314.51 make4314.76 more4315.55 units4316.03 available,4316.51 but4316.99 I4320.43 think4320.59 there4321.63 is4321.95 maybe4322.27 something4322.75 to4323.23 be4323.39 said4323.55 about,4323.79 well,4324.11 do4324.43 the4324.67 affordable4324.83 units4325.23 need4325.63 to4325.79 be4325.95 the4326.03 smaller4326.27 units?4326.67 You4327.23 know?4327.39 So.4327.63 4331.72 PLOETZ4331.72 -4331.72 It's4331.72 actually4332.84 I4333.72 think4333.89 you4334.05 were4334.2 talking4334.36 about,4334.6 like,4334.76 a4334.93 lowercase4335.01 e4335.64 equitable.4335.8 It's4336.28 actually,4336.44 like,4336.76 fair4337.01 housing4337.24 law,4337.64 and4338.05 there4338.6 are4338.76 laws4338.84 related4339.24 to4339.64 that.4339.8 But4340.05 I4340.28 think4342.81 I4343.05 hear4343.09 what4343.13 you're4343.37 saying.4343.69 Well4344.09 Ex4344.49 exactly.4344.81 That's4345.21 what4345.37 I4345.53 thought4345.61 you4345.77 were4345.93 talking4346.09 about.4346.49 Sorry.4346.49 4347.53 UDELOVICH4347.53 -4347.53 No.4347.53 No4347.77 worries.4348.01 Yeah.4350.17 So4350.41 when4350.65 we4350.89 do4351.05 our4351.29 Pro4351.85 Forma4351.93 analysis,4351.93 we4352.41 do,4352.65 taking4353.53 the4354.01 aggregate4354.33 of4354.89 the4355.05 unit4355.53 sizes.4355.85 So4356.33 we4356.65 are4356.81 more4357.13 focused4357.53 on4358.01 what4358.86 the4359.02 market4359.1 conditions4359.51 are4359.9 currently4360.06 telling4360.47 us.4360.78 That4361.51 being4361.66 said,4361.82 you4362.15 know,4362.23 this4362.47 may4363.98 be4364.23 a4364.23 broken4364.31 record,4364.7 but4364.94 market4365.19 conditions4365.51 change4366.06 all4366.55 the4366.7 time,4366.86 and4367.1 so4367.27 therefore,4367.51 the4367.82 policy4367.9 needs4368.39 to4368.7 be4368.78 updated4369.35 accordingly.4369.9 So4370.47 and4372.8 then4372.96 your4373.2 second4373.28 question4373.68 was,4374.16 along4375.2 the4375.44 lines4375.6 of4376.08 income4376.96 based?4377.36

4377.84 Income.4377.84 And4378.48 I4378.72 think4378.8 about4379.36 base4379.52 rents.4379.76 Yeah.4380.24

4380.56 Yeah.4380.56

4380.8 Fix.4380.8

4381.52 And4381.52 Do4382.08 you4382.24 want4382.32 to4382.56 take4382.56 it?4382.72

4382.96 I4383.12 can.4383.28 4384 PLOETZ4384 -4384 Thanks.4384 I4384.8 think4384.96 the4386.69 same4386.85 standard4387.18 for4387.65 income,4388.38 like4389.02 certifying4389.34 income4389.9 and4390.22 certifying,4390.45 like,4391.1 low4391.73 income4392.06 is4392.94 the4393.18 same4393.34 in4393.49 an4393.73 IZ4393.9 unit4394.22 or4394.53 if4394.77 it's4394.94 a4395.1 100%4395.18 deed4395.73 restricted4395.98 affordable4396.3 unit.4396.77 It's4397.02 the4397.18 same4397.34 standard.4397.57 It's4398.38 derived4398.81 from4399.77 a4400.09 methodology4400.25 step4400.89 by4401.21 the4401.29 US4401.45 Department4401.61 of4401.85 Housing4401.93 or4402.25 Urban4402.41 Development.4402.57 They're4403.37 using4403.53 the4403.85 same4403.93 thing.4404.49 There's4404.81 no4404.81 difference4405.05 between4405.45 the4405.77 two.4405.93 I4406.09 think4406.25 what4406.49 you4406.73 are4406.89 more4407.21 often4407.61 going4407.85 to4408.17 find4408.17 in4408.41 a4408.57 100%4408.73 affordable4409.29 unit4409.77 is4410.49 kind4410.65 of4410.89 that4410.97 potentially4411.21 that4411.69 deeper4411.93 affordability4412.17 where4413.19 you're4413.35 getting4413.59 down4413.68 into,4413.99 like4414.31 you4414.88 referenced4415.27 the4415.68 80%,4415.84 and4416.31 we4416.4 hear4416.55 that4416.8 all4416.95 the4417.11 time.4417.19 4417.51 And4417.51 I4417.76 can4417.99 see4418.15 it4418.4 when4418.47 I4418.64 look4418.72 at4418.88 the4418.95 numbers,4419.03 like,4419.35 80%4419.59 AMI.4420.4 You're4421.51 definitely4422.95 working4423.44 to4424.31 make4424.47 that4424.72 income.4425.76 As4426.15 you4426.4 get4426.55 down4426.72 into4426.95 kind4428.07 of4428.31 504429.17 and4429.41 below,4429.73 that's4430.69 when4430.93 you're4431.09 getting4431.33 into4431.65 people4432.05 who4432.37 are4432.61 certainly4432.85 on4433.25 fixed4433.41 income,4433.73 potentially4434.21 living4434.77 off4435.09 of4435.41 SSI4435.81 or4436.29 some4436.45 other4436.61 sort4436.93 of,4437.41 either4439.01 Social4439.73 Security4440.05 or4440.61 disability.4440.93 And4442.89 I4443.05 it's4443.28 I4443.77 to4444.09 me,4444.32 it's4444.49 it4444.81 I4445.13 my4445.69 sense4445.85 is4446.16 that4446.32 it's4446.81 generally4447.13 more4447.6 common4447.77 for4448.16 those4448.41 that4448.81 have4448.97 deeper4448.97 affordability4449.28 to4449.85 be4450.01 on4450.16 a4450.32 100%4450.41 deed4450.97 restricted.4451.13 Like4453.69 affordable4454.09 housing4454.65 rather4455.05 than4455.36 IZ4455.69 units.4456.16 4456.65 UNIDENTIFIED4456.65 SPEAKER74456.65 -4456.65 Oh,4456.65 yeah.4456.81 4457.2 PLOETZ4457.2 -4457.2 Yeah.4457.2

4459.9 Other4459.9 questions?4460.3 Yeah.4460.78 4462.46 UNIDENTIFIED4462.46 SPEAKER84462.46 -4462.46 So4462.46 in4463.18 your4463.42 pool4463.82 of4464.54 affordable4465.02 developers,4466.62 do4467.9 any4468.14 of4468.38 those4468.46 developers4468.94 make4469.5 projects4469.66 that4470.14 might4470.46 even4470.78 use4471.1 market4472.3 rate4472.63 units4473.18 to4473.66 cross4473.82 subsidize4474.06 or4474.55 about4474.7 market4474.86 rate4475.1 units4475.34 to4475.59 cross4475.9 subsidize,4476.15 for4477.9 more4478.06 affordable4478.3 units?4478.78 And4480.3 I'm4480.78 not4481.82 I4482.15 think4482.3 based4482.63 on4482.86 the4482.94 language4483.1 we're4483.43 using,4483.66 probably4484.21 not.4484.37 I'm4484.53 not4484.61 sure.4484.85 But4485.17 if4485.33 not,4485.57 do4485.89 you4486.05 see4486.13 those4486.37 projects,4486.69 and4487.97 other4488.13 work4488.29 that4488.53 you're4488.69 doing?4488.93 4490.53 PLOETZ4490.53 -4490.53 Evelyn,4490.53 thoughts?4491.09 4494.45 ST-LOUIS4494.45 -4494.45 I4494.45 do4494.61 believe4494.85 we4495.25 asked4495.41 at4496.05 least4496.13 two4496.45 of4496.61 the4496.77 affordable4496.93 housing4497.41 developers,4497.81 and4498.77 the4499.35 ones4499.52 we4499.84 spoke4499.91 to4500.31 said4500.64 that4501.11 they4501.27 would4501.52 be4501.76 unlikely4501.91 to4502.64 have4502.95 that4503.19 model4503.44 because4503.84 I4504.07 think4504.15 they're4504.4 more4504.64 they,4504.88 like,4505.11 classic4505.27 nonprofit,4506.4 like,4508.4 going4508.88 for4509.19 tax4509.35 credits,4509.68 doing4510.72 100%4511.03 affordable.4511.6 I4512.88 can't4513.03 speak4513.35 as4513.6 much4513.84 as4514.23 examples.4515.12 I4516.64 don't4516.72 know4516.88 if4517.04 either4517.12 of4517.36 you4517.44 have4517.76 any4517.92 that4518.08 come4518.32 to4518.48 mind,4518.64 for,4521.92 like,4522.48 where4522.8 it's4523.04 majority4523.28 affordable4523.84 and,4524.48 like,4525.44 minority4525.68 market4526.24 rate.4526.56 4526.88 PLOETZ4526.88 -4526.88 Yeah.4526.88 Like,4527.12 a4527.28 604527.36 to4527.76 404527.84 split.4528.39 You4528.59 don't4528.78 see4529.1 that4529.27 that4529.51 often.4529.74 It's4530.15 not4530.39 to4530.55 say4530.63 it4530.86 doesn't4530.95 happen,4531.27 but4531.66 I4532.31 feel4532.39 like4532.63 a4532.78 lot4532.86 of4533.03 this4533.19 is4533.43 like,4533.82 Evelyn4534.31 was4534.63 alluding4534.78 to,4535.19 like,4535.35 the4535.91 LITEC4536.15 program,4536.55 like,4537.74 you4537.99 really4538.47 are4538.78 going4538.86 to4539.19 go4539.19 100%4539.43 affordable.4540.06 There4540.39 are4540.55 other4540.7 forms4540.95 of4541.27 funding4541.35 that4541.66 would4541.82 allow4541.99 for4542.31 that,4542.39 but4542.63 it's4542.78 just4542.95 it's4543.59 not4543.83 as4543.99 there's4544.31 not4544.55 as4544.71 much4544.79 of4545.03 it4545.11 out4545.27 there.4545.43 And,4545.91 again,4546.95 like,4547.27 you4548.23 should4548.39 see4548.63 it.4548.87 I've4549.27 seen4549.51 it,4549.75 but4549.91 it's4550.15 not4550.31 something4550.47 that's4550.79 super4551.03 common.4551.35 Yeah.4552.55 Other4554.63 questions?4554.95 Yes.4556.95 4562.18 UNIDENTIFIED4562.18 SPEAKER64562.18 -4562.18 Did4562.18 you4562.57 think4563.7 about4564.02 whether4566.57 your4566.9 conclusions4567.94 would4568.41 apply4568.66 equally4568.98 to4569.3 age4569.61 restricted4569.85 housing4570.41 as4570.9 to4571.14 housing4571.61 for4572.02 the4572.18 general4572.26 population?4572.66 Would4573.76 there4573.84 be4573.9 a4573.96 difference4574.02 there?4574.08 4578.64 UDELOVICH4578.64 -4578.64 Short4578.64 answer,4579.04 no.4580.16 At4580.96 least4581.12 for4581.36 the4581.44 market4581.6 rate.4582 Again,4583.36 the4585.68 Pro4586.96 Forma4587.12 model4587.12 at4587.44 least,4587.6 and4588.97 this4589.2 might4589.36 also4589.6 pertain4590.01 a4590.4 little4590.56 bit4590.65 to4590.8 the4590.97 sources4591.13 and4591.44 uses4591.6 model.4592.01 For4592.89 these4593.13 tools,4593.36 we4593.84 try4594.01 not4594.24 to4594.48 be4594.56 so4594.8 specific4596.09 because,4596.8 again,4597.13 we're4597.52 testing4597.76 how4598.4 this4600.4 policy4600.72 will4601.28 impact4601.6 development.4602.32 And,4602.97 really,4603.13 it's4603.44 more4603.6 of4603.76 will4604.74 development4605.06 be4605.7 built4606.02 or4606.34 will4606.5 it4606.66 not4606.74 be4606.9 built?4606.98 And4607.3 in4607.46 this4607.62 case,4607.78 will4608.34 it4608.5 be4608.66 built4608.74 and4609.06 is4609.54 it4609.62 an4610.34 additional4610.42 attractive4610.98 incentive4611.62 to4612.18 carve4612.42 out4612.66 more4612.82 affordable4613.06 units?4613.54 So4614.34 in4614.5 that4614.66 way,4614.82 we4615.14 didn't4615.7 really4616.58 have4616.98 any4617.14 specificity4617.46 around4619.02 income.4619.82 We4620.78 definitely4621.02 looked4621.98 at4622.23 the4622.47 HUD4622.63 income4622.94 limits4623.27 for4623.66 20254623.82 as4625.02 really4625.51 our4625.74 only4625.98 source4626.47 of,4626.86 particular4629.66 AMIs.4630.7 But4631.98 in4632.23 terms4632.47 of4632.94 looking4633.58 at,4633.98 any4634.78 specific4635.18 groups4635.74 or,4636.62 any4639.26 other4639.58 income4640.06 related,4640.54 specifics,4642.3 we4642.78 didn't4642.94 look4643.26 at4643.42 that.4643.58 4646.06 UNIDENTIFIED4646.06 SPEAKER64646.06 -4646.06 Thank4646.06 you.4646.3 4646.86 UDELOVICH4646.86 -4646.86 Yeah.4646.86 4649.93 PLOETZ4649.93 -4649.93 Will4649.93 anything4650.24 be4650.65 left4650.65 online?4650.97 I4653.28 see4653.44 no4653.76 hands4654.01 raised.4654.24 Other4656.32 questions,4656.56 comments?4657.13 Oh4669.34 Larry,4669.66 go4669.9 ahead.4670.06 4670.78 FIELD4670.78 -4670.78 I4670.78 have4670.86 a4671.02 question,4671.1 but,4671.58 if4673.02 anyone4673.34 had4673.9 written4674.22 comments4674.78 they4675.18 would4675.34 like4675.5 to4675.74 say4675.9 after4676.06 this,4676.38 what's4677.94 a4678.26 reasonable4678.34 date,4678.81 Adam,4679.45 for4679.85 you?4680.02 4681.3 PLOETZ4681.3 -4681.3 To4681.3 have4681.38 them4681.61 in4681.85 by?4682.02 4682.98 FIELD4682.98 -4682.98 We4682.98 said4682.98 the4683.14 end4683.22 of4683.38 the4683.45 month.4683.53 4683.85 PLOETZ4683.85 -4683.85 I4683.85 think4683.94 that's4684.18 what4684.41 I4684.65 was4684.73 going4684.9 to4685.14 say.4685.14 So4685.38 yes.4685.61 4685.94 FIELD4685.94 -4685.94 March4685.94 31.4686.53 4687.14 PLOETZ4687.14 -4687.14 Yes.4687.14 4688.26 FIELD4688.26 -4688.26 And4688.26 you4688.41 can4688.57 email4688.81 either4690.41 wdownie,@watertownme.gov.4693.98 Why4700.78 don't4701.02 we4701.42 just4701.66 say4702.06 Will4703.5 Downie.4703.74 Okay.4704.3 4707.24 PLOETZ4707.24 -4707.24 Yeah.4707.24 Happy4707.65 to4707.97 get4708.13 written4709.01 comments.4709.41 We've4710.28 been4710.6 taking4711.09 notes4711.56 on4712.05 the4712.45 comments4712.6 tonight.4713.16 We'll4714.6 take4716.45 a4716.69 look4716.77 at4716.93 those4717.01 and4717.41 see4717.73 where4718.28 that4719.39 might4719.63 lead4719.75 us4719.87 in4720.11 respect4720.27 to4720.59 the4720.67 final4720.83 document.4721.23 But4721.71 I4722.03 really4722.03 appreciate4722.27 your4722.67 time4722.83 this4722.99 evening.4723.15 Thank4725.15 you4725.31 guys4725.47 for4725.63 all4725.87 coming4726.03 out4726.27 and4726.67 being4726.99 an4727.31 attentive4727.47 and4728.11 interested4729.31 audience.4729.71 I4730.11 appreciate4730.67 it.4730.67 Have4730.83 a4731.07 good4731.15 night,4731.31 everyone.4731.47 Thank4731.95 you.4732.19