JACK15.05 BARTLEY15.05 -15.05 BLUE15.05 RIBBON15.05 COMMITTEE15.05 CHAIR15.05 -15.05 Good15.05 evening,15.29 everyone.15.7 I16.73 just16.89 want17.14 to17.3 open17.45 the17.7 meeting17.86 of18.1 the18.18 Blue19.3 Ribbon20.02 Committee,20.02 looking20.02 at20.41 the20.57 examination20.65 of21.38 the21.54 Watertown22.34 City22.82 Councilors'23.14 salaries.24.26 At28.68 this28.92 point29.08 in29.32 time,29.4 I29.8 turn30.68 to31 our32.92 secretary33.16 to33.64 see33.8 if33.96 we34.2 have34.36 an34.44 agenda.34.68 Excuse35.88 me.36.2 If36.36 we36.52 have36.68 a37.64 quorum.37.8

39.09 Roll39.09 call,39.33

40.2 SPEAKER240.2 -40.2 please.40.2 Marcy40.52 Murningham.40.92 Here.42.28 Linda43 Scott.43.41

44.36 SPEAKER344.36 -44.36 Here.44.36

44.92 SPEAKER244.92 -44.92 Susan44.92 Falcoff.45.41

46.05 SPEAKER446.05 -46.05 Present.46.05

46.84 SPEAKER246.84 -46.84 Jimine46.84 Mello.47.24 Here.47.88 Christine48.6 Cole.49.56 Here.50.05 Sarah50.77 Baker.51.16 And51.97 chair52.2 Jack52.52 Bartley.52.77

53.32 SPEAKER153.32 -53.32 Thank53.32 you.53.48 Here.53.8 56.23 BARTLEY56.23 -56.23 The56.23 meeting56.39 tonight56.71 is57.27 going57.83 to58.07 be58.23 televised58.55 but59.91 it's60.15 gonna60.31 be60.63 recorded.60.87 So61.59 it61.83 will61.99 ultimately62.31 be62.87 broadcast,63.19 but63.83 it64.79 will64.87 be,65.19 I66.55 don't66.71 know66.87 if67.03 it's67.19 a67.43 conflict67.51 or67.99 what,68.39 but69.28 I69.61 was69.69 informed69.92 that70.33 we70.89 are71.13 being71.28 taped71.53 and72.17 it72.25 will72.41 be72.64 broadcasted72.89 at73.84 some74.48 point74.64 in74.81 time.74.89 So75.13 I75.28 use75.36 the75.53 word75.69 televised75.92 knowing76.33 that76.64 it76.81 will76.89 be77.05 out77.13 on77.36 cable.77.61

78 SPEAKER478 -78 It'll78 be78.33 there's78.89 video?79.2 Right.80.56

81.05 SPEAKER581.05 -81.05 Yes.81.05

82.56 SPEAKER182.56 -82.56 Yes.82.56 Smile.84.16 85.84 DOUG85.84 NEWTON85.84 -85.84 CITY85.84 OF85.84 WATERTOWN85.84 -85.84 And85.84 I'll86.08 take87.36 that87.6 occasion87.76 briefly88.08 because88.48 I88.8 just88.88 did89.04 it.89.2 Please89.6 be89.84 very,90 very90.24 careful90.48 to90.8 speak90.96 into91.12 the91.44 microphone91.6 with91.92 the92.16 microphone92.32 on92.8 lit93.04 up93.2 green.93.44 Just93.97 with94.2 the94.77 last94.92 meeting95.25 it95.56 was95.65 sometimes95.81 hard96.13 to96.44 hear.96.53 I96.84 just97.01 did97.17 it97.33 myself,97.97 so98.2 clearly,98.2 I'm99.41 not99.65 speaking100.13 from100.44 a100.69 glasshouse100.77 here.101.25 But101.41 just101.89 as102.13 much102.2 as102.37 you102.44 can,102.61 please102.77 be103.01 careful103.08 for103.41 that.103.48 104.44 BARTLEY104.44 -104.44 Thank104.44 you104.69 very104.84 much,105.01 Doug.105.25 Next105.81 item106.57 on106.81 the106.97 agenda107.13 is107.61 the107.85 approval108.09 of108.57 minutes.108.73 Everyone109.37 had109.77 copies109.93 of110.25 the110.41 minutes.110.57 Does111.69 anyone111.85 have112.25 a113.53 recommendation113.85 for114.33 an114.57 alteration114.73 or115.13 a115.29 change?115.37 116.09 JIMMY116.09 MELLO116.09 -116.09 BLUE116.09 RIBBON116.09 COMMITTEE116.09 MEMBER116.09 -116.09 I116.09 make116.25 a116.49 motion116.57 we116.81 approve117.05 the117.37 minutes.117.53

119.58 Second?119.58 Wait120.55 a120.78 minute.120.86 I'll121.03 get121.1 you,121.27 Mark.121.34

121.67 SPEAKER7121.67 -121.67 Okay.121.67

121.98 SPEAKER1121.98 -121.98 2nd?121.98 I'm122.7 we123.19 have123.34 a123.58 second123.67 on124.31 that.124.55 Bosi.125.42 127.02 MARCY127.02 MURNINGHAN127.02 -127.02 BLUE127.02 RIBBON127.02 COMMITTEE127.02 MEMBER127.02 -127.02 Yes.127.02 I127.42 had,127.58 there129.19 was129.43 one129.66 small129.91 correction,130.94 my131.19 printer131.19 wasn't131.5 working,132.54 it133.25 is133.25 in133.97 relation134.13 to134.69 the134.93 question135.17 I135.57 addressed135.81 to137.09 Councilor137.17 Feltner.138.05 And139.17 I139.41 apologize,139.73 I140.37 am140.61 not140.69 able140.93 to141.25 pull141.33 it141.57 up141.73 on141.89 my142.13 phone143.09 right143.41 now.143.65 But144.61 if145.01 you145.25 look145.49 on146.63 the146.87 minutes,147.03 if147.5 you147.59 have147.75 it147.91 in147.99 front148.15 of148.39 you,148.47 Doug,148.87 you'll149.5 see149.91 that150.15 I150.63 asked150.87 Councilor151.19 Feltner151.82 how152.47 she152.71 felt153.03 about153.34 interacting153.82 or154.47 something154.63 like155.11 that,155.26 the155.67 word155.82 felt.156.22 As158.06 I158.31 recall158.47 that158.94 whole159.19 exchange,159.5 my160.8 question160.96 revolved162.4 around162.8 interacting164.16 with164.64 other164.88 councilors165.2 to165.68 learn165.92 things.166.24 So166.64 I166.96 had167.2 modified167.44 the168 sentence168.16 to169.84 say,170.08 Marcy171.12 Murningan171.6 asked172.32 Councilor172.64 Feltner173.2 to175.56 describe175.89 how176.37 she176.76 learns177 from177.41 other177.72 Watertown178.13 and178.93 area179.25 councilors.179.81 183.72 NEWTON183.72 -183.72 Would183.72 you184.04 like184.13 me184.28 to184.37 read184.53 the184.69 original184.84 language185.17 just185.49 so185.72 everybody's185.81 perfectly186.28 clear186.69 on187.39 that?187.39 187.39 MURNINGHAN187.39 -187.39 Sure.187.39 187.95 NEWTON187.95 -187.95 So187.95 the188.19 original188.35 language188.75 was,189.15 Marcy189.55 Murningham190.03 asked190.75 Councilor190.99 Feltner191.47 if191.87 she192.11 feels192.27 as192.51 though192.67 she193.07 works193.23 with193.63 other193.79 elected194.19 and194.59 appointed194.75 officials195.23 frequently.195.63 And196.19 I'm196.35 sorry,196.51 Marcy,196.99 will197.15 you197.15 just197.31 reread197.47 what197.79 you197.95 wanted198.03 to198.35 change198.43 to?198.75 200.72 MURNINGHAN200.72 -200.72 It200.72 was200.96 not201.11 how201.44 she201.67 feels202 about202.31 interacting202.72 frequently,204.16 it204.31 was204.31 about204.56 how205.11 she205.35 learns205.67 from206.39 interacting206.96 frequently.207.91 So208.47 even208.79 if209.03 feels209.59 is210 replaced210.16 from210.72 learn,210.96 it212.09 just212.25 shifts212.41 the212.81 whole212.97 meaning213.21 of213.53 that213.69 because213.93 that's214.17 been214.49 kind214.73 of214.89 a215.05 theme215.29 of215.61 mine,215.77 to217.61 facilitate218.01 opportunities218.73 for219.45 councilors219.69 to220.17 learn220.41 more220.65 from220.89 each221.13 other221.29 as221.61 well221.77 as222.01 other222.33 councilors222.73 in223.37 the223.61 area,223.77 as224.66 well224.81 as225.29 other225.38 groups227.13 because228.41 of228.81 the228.97 complexity229.13 of229.78 the229.94 job.230.17 232.17 BARTLEY232.17 -232.17 Okay.232.17 Doug,232.66 do232.89 you232.97 have233.13 that?233.29 235.29 NEWTON235.29 -235.29 As235.29 I235.53 spilled235.61 my235.94 water,236.33 yes.236.5 I236.5 do236.66 have236.81 that.236.97

237.13 SPEAKER5237.13 -237.13 And237.13 I237.22

237.29 SPEAKER2237.29 -237.29 made237.29 the237.45 Okay.237.69

238.01 SPEAKER7238.01 -238.01 We're238.01 in238.17 a238.41 bounty238.5 ad.238.89 239.38 BARTLEY239.38 -239.38 With239.38 that,239.94 I240.51 just240.75 returned241.15 back242.11 to244.43 Jim244.67 Mello244.67 and244.67 Christine,244.83 could245.39 we245.55 take245.63 that245.79 as246.03 a246.11 friendly246.19 amendment246.51 to246.99 yours?247.39 Great.249.07 Okay.249.39 So249.63 we249.79 have249.95 a250.11 motion250.27 made250.59 and251.39 second251.63 for252.11 the252.35 minutes253.47 as254.38 amended254.45 as254.94 proposed255.25 by257.33 Marcy.257.5

258.77 All258.77 in259.01 favor,259.1 signify259.41 by259.89 saying260.06 aye.260.29

260.77 SPEAKER4260.77 -260.77 Aye.260.77

261.33 SPEAKER7261.33 -261.33 Oh,261.33 you261.57

261.65 SPEAKER1261.65 -261.65 have261.65 a261.89 question?261.98 Okay.262.69 Before263.33 that263.74 discussion.264.29 Further264.77 discussion.265.1 267.44 SUSAN267.44 FALKOFF267.44 -267.44 BLUE267.44 RIBBON267.44 COMMITTEE267.44 MEMBER267.44 -267.44 I267.84 don't268 under268.24 could268.64 you268.8 read268.96 the269.2 amended269.44 sentence,270.16 please?270.72 276.16 NEWTON276.16 -276.16 You276.16 want276.32 me276.4 to276.56 read276.64 it276.8 as276.96 it277.12 currently277.2 stands?277.6 278.24 BARTLEY278.24 -278.24 No,278.8 as279.2 proposed.279.36 280.16 FALKOFF280.16 -280.16 As280.16 will280.64 be280.88 in281.04 the281.12 final281.28 version.281.68 282.08 NEWTON282.08 -282.08 Okay.282.08 Thank282.49 you.282.64 Marcy283.69 Murninghan284.25 asked284.88 Councilor285.13 Feltner285.61 how286 she286.17 learns286.32 from286.64 interacting286.88 frequently287.37 with287.85 other288 elected288.32 and288.64 appointed288.81 officials.289.37 290.96 FALKOFF290.96 -290.96 Thank290.96 you.291.2

292.88 SPEAKER1292.88 -292.88 Any292.88 other293.13 further293.44 discussion?293.76 Seeing294.98 none,295.3 all295.54 in295.7 favor295.86 signify296.1 by296.5 saying296.74 aye.296.98 Opposed297.14 no,297.46 the297.7 ayes297.78 have298.02 it.298.18 299.14 BARTLEY299.14 -299.14 Okay.299.14 Next299.62 item299.86 on300.18 the300.34 agenda300.42 is300.9 a301.78 question301.94 and302.34 answer302.42 with302.74 Mary302.98 Flanders303.3 Aicardi,304.1 call304.9 from305.38 Collins305.54 Center305.94 For306.26 Public306.5 Management.306.98 Welcome308.31 back308.71 to308.87 Watertown.309.11

309.67 SPEAKER8309.67 -309.67 Thank309.67 you.310.23

318.23 SPEAKER9318.23 -318.23 This318.23 is318.46 for318.63 taller318.94 people.319.26 319.82 MARY319.82 AICARDI319.82 -319.82 EDWARD319.82 COLLINS319.82 CENTER319.82 FOR319.82 PUBLIC319.82 MANAGEMENT319.82 -319.82 Good319.82 evening.320.06 How320.31 y'all320.46 doing320.79 tonight?321.11 I'll322.92 give323 you323.16 a323.32 brief323.4 introduction.323.72 My324.28 name324.44 is324.6 Mary324.76 Flanders325.08 Aicardi.325.48 I326.04 lead326.2 the326.44 HR326.68 practice327 for327.32 the327.56 Collins327.64 Center328.04 of328.76 Public329 Management329.48 at329.88 the330.04 McCormick330.2 School330.6 of330.84 Government331.16 at331.56 UMASS331.8 Boston.332.28 I333.16 quit333.32 my333.64 job333.8 as334.04 the334.2 HR334.36 director334.68 in335 Watertown335.16 20335.88 years336.28 ago.336.52 My338.26 son338.5 is338.75 now338.99 20,339.23 so339.63 I339.87 know339.94 it340.19 was340.26 20340.5 years340.82 ago,340.99 and341.63 it's341.79 great342.1 to342.4 be342.7 back343.31 in343.46 this343.63 chamber.343.87 It344.35 feels344.5 a344.75 little344.82 different.345.14 But346.5 one346.66 of346.66 the346.82 things346.99 that347.38 we347.79 do348.02 at348.19 the348.26 Collins348.43 Center,348.99 we've349.76 certainly,350 I350.4 think350.48 many350.64 of350.88 you351.12 are351.28 familiar,351.84 we352 do352 a352.16 lot352.24 of352.32 charter352.48 work.352.88 I353.76 lead353.92 the354.16 HR354.32 practice.354.8 We355.2 do355.44 classification,356.8 we356.96 do356.96 surveys,357.84 recruitments,358.56 succession359.84 planning,360.56 a361.52 lot361.76 of362 professional362.16 development,365.75 and365.82 thrilled365.82 to365.9 be365.99 back366.14 here.366.31 So367.1 when367.58 I369.67 was369.82 contacted,370.14 I370.7 said,370.79 well,370.94 you371.19 know,371.35 we've371.5 just371.82 recently372.06 done372.54 this372.79 massive373.02 survey373.43 for373.82 mayors,374.06 city374.46 councils,374.79 and375.58 happy376.54 to376.87 share377.02 our377.43 data.377.66 So377.99 I378.23 was378.31 able378.54 to378.79 forward379.1 that379.5 to379.82 you.379.99

380.91 SPEAKER4380.91 -380.91 1380.91 minute.381.07 I381.47 I381.87

382.03 SPEAKER3382.03 -382.03 am382.03 hearing382.19 you.382.59 I383.23 think383.39 you383.63 have383.79 a384.03 very384.11 you386.19 have386.27 a386.51 very386.83 solid387.15 voice.387.63 I'm388.11 just388.27 make388.51 is389.23 the389.47 speaker389.63 on?389.95 Because390.51 if390.83 it's390.99 not,391.07 they're391.39 not391.63 gonna391.79 hear392.03 it392.19 when392.35 it's392.51 re392.83 I393.99 Is394.15 it394.31 on?394.63

394.94 SPEAKER1394.94 -394.94 I394.94 I395.19 I395.35 defer395.5 to395.75 Doug.395.9

396.38 SPEAKER3396.38 -396.38 Okay.396.38 You396.71 know?396.87 Okay.397.03 Yeah.397.35 I397.5 was397.59 just397.82 making397.9 sure.398.15 Otherwise,398.38 people398.87 will399.19 watch399.35 your399.5 mouth399.67 move.399.9

400.31 SPEAKER2400.31 -400.31 We400.31 did400.47 recently400.63 have401.03 it401.19 fixed.401.43 It402.79 should402.94 be403.19 working.403.35

404.23 SPEAKER9404.23 -404.23 Okay.404.23 Okay.404.63 So405.26 my405.67 problem405.9 is406.38 because406.63 I407.03 do407.19 have407.43 a408.15 robust408.38 voice,409.03 I409.65 don't409.81 usually410.13 use410.61 microphones.410.93 So411.41 I'm411.65 really411.81 not412.05 good.412.29 And412.77 I'm413.01 half413.25 deaf413.49 in413.65 1413.89 ear.414.13 So414.37 just414.61 give414.93 me415.17 a415.33 flag415.49 if415.73 I'm415.89 either416.21 whispering416.69 or,417.41 or418.69 shouting.418.93 So420.13

424.38 Okay.424.38 Yeah.425.19 Here's425.43 here425.9 we426.06 go.426.31 Here426.63 we426.87 go.427.02 All428.14 right.428.31 Well,428.54 thank428.78 you428.94 for429.19 that.429.35 430.46 AICARDI430.46 -430.46 So430.46 we430.78 have431.02 done431.35 this431.58 work431.82 before432.22 and432.78 certainly433.1 as433.82 we434.38 love434.63 to434.87 share435.17 the435.33 information435.49 we435.97 collect,436.53 we436.69 have436.69 a436.93 public437.01 mission,438.93 we439.09 have439.09 a439.25 lot439.33 of439.41 affinity439.65 for440.13 this440.21 town,440.69 so440.93 we're440.93 very441.09 happy441.33 to441.65 share441.73 all441.97 of442.13 this442.29 public442.53 information442.93 that443.41 we443.65 have443.81 collected.444.05 So,445.89 I'm446.21 happy446.37 to446.69 answer446.93 any447.25 questions.447.49 Some447.97 of448.21 the448.37 points448.69 that449.09 we449.56 would449.81 think450.05 that450.29 you450.44 wanna450.69 consider451.09 is452.53 the453.56 different453.81 forms454.37 of454.69 government.454.93 You455.4 all455.65 have455.88 gone456.13 through456.37 this456.53 transition456.93 to458.61 the458.85 city459 manager.459.4 It's459.88 always460.05 been460.29 a460.53 manager460.76 council.461.25 When462.61 you462.85 look463.09 at463.41 the463.73 quote,464.13 we465.33 don't465.57 like465.81 to465.97 use466.05 the466.29 word466.45 comparables467.01 because468.45 very469.33 few469.65 municipalities470.05 are470.93 truly471.17 comparable.471.73 They472.85 tend473.09 to473.33 be473.49 region473.81 and474.37 they474.61 tend474.77 to475.09 be475.25 structure.475.65 So476.71 when476.87 we477.19 do,477.35 for477.75 example,478.06 when478.55 you478.71 do478.94 your479.03 salary480.06 surveys,480.79 you481.75 typically482.06 don't482.94 do,483.5 oh,484.23 it484.38 has484.63 to484.79 be484.94 the485.11 same485.19 population,485.5 it486.15 has486.31 to486.55 be486.63 the486.79 same487.03 budget.487.26 It488.06 also488.56 has488.72 to488.8 be488.88 the489.2 same489.36 region,489.6 the490.16 cost490.32 of490.56 living,490.72 those491.52 kinds491.76 of492.08 things.492.24 493.04 But493.04 stipends493.44 for494.32 elected494.72 officials495.28 really496.32 are496.64 about496.96 the497.28 internal497.6 organization498.4 and499.84 who500.08 you500.32 akin500.8 yourselves501.2 to,502.77 not502.94 necessarily503.25 what504.38 is504.62 the504.86 market.505.1 It506.06 really506.3 is506.69 an507.18 intrinsic507.57 value508.46 that509.65 you509.9 all510.13 get510.38 to510.62 determine510.86 what511.9 the512.22 stipends512.38 should513.01 be.513.25 Some513.89 call514.22 them514.46 salaries.514.77 I'm515.34 gonna515.5 use515.82 the516.14 word516.22 stipend516.62 for517.18 the517.34 sake517.5 of517.74 it517.9 only518.22 because518.54 as519.98 elected520.14 officials,520.86 you're521.98 exempt522.3 from522.86 the523.1 salary523.26 laws,523.9 all524.78 those525.02 kinds525.26 of525.5 things.525.74 So526.06 we526.54 don't526.78 count527.34 you527.74 as528.06 quote,528.58 a528.82 regular528.98 employee,529.62 even530.1 though530.34 you530.5 are530.74 an530.89 employee,531.13 but531.53 we531.7 call531.86 it532.1 a532.25 stipend.532.5 It's533.38 not533.62 based533.93 on534.25 minimum534.41 wage,535.38 it's535.62 not535.62 based535.93 on536.25 hours.536.58 Sometimes537.53 we538.17 see538.5 organizations538.89 wanna539.86 say,540.17 well,540.88 if541.2 we541.44 give541.6 them541.76 minimum541.92 wage542.48 for542.72 10542.96 hours543.2 a543.52 week,543.6 that544 would544.16 be544.32 $150545.2 a545.76 week.545.92 And546.32 then546.64 we546.88 multiply547.12 it547.6 by547.76 52,548.08 sometimes548.72 52.2.549.28 You550 know,550.72 you551.12 can551.28 come551.52 up551.76 with551.92 whatever552.4 you553.12 want.553.28 554.67 The554.67 different554.91 theories555.55 of556.12 this,556.36 you556.67 need556.84 to557.08 decide,558.51 are558.75 we558.75 trying559 to559.32 incentivize559.72 people560.6 to561.08 run561.32 for561.55 office561.88 and563.63 have563.96 it564.2 be564.36 a564.6 salary?564.75 Or566.03 are566.36 we566.51 saying,566.84 this567.72 is567.96 not568.75 just569.07 an569.39 honorarium,569.63 but570.59 an571.31 appreciation571.63 stipend572.59 for573.07 the573.23 hours573.47 that573.95 you574.11 give574.35 in574.59 and574.91 the575.07 dedication575.31 that576.03 you576.27 give577.07 to577.39 this577.55 role?577.87 So578.91 it579.07 really579.31 is579.63 a579.87 small580.03 P,580.75 political581.31 decision,582.11 that582.89 you583.13 have583.21 to583.62 make.583.7 Now584.82 one585.05 thing585.21 I585.45 would585.53 point585.77 out586.1 in586.33 the586.58 data586.74 is587.77 that588.01 we589.05 do589.29 find,589.7 you590.17 can590.33 throw590.58 your590.74 phone590.98 at591.13 me.591.21 It's591.45 okay.591.7 We593.45 do593.7 find594.1 looking594.89 at595.38 the596.52 structures596.68 with597.48 a597.8 mayor598.04 council598.44 is599.64 different599.96 with600.84 a601 manager601.24 council.601.8 You602.84 will603 see603.24 in603.72 the603.96 data,604.12 if604.84 there605 is605.24 a605.48 mayor605.64 council,606.12 the607 council607.32 stipends608.36 tend609.24 to609.56 be609.72 higher.610.2 There's611.02 more611.26 of611.75 them,612.63 they're612.94 more612.94 robust.613.26 The615.99 theory616.23 or616.78 the616.94 hypothesis617.26 to618.14 that618.3 is,618.7 a619.75 mayor,619.99 while620.54 many621.02 are621.42 very621.66 professional,622.14 do623.99 not624.3 need624.54 to624.94 be625.11 professional625.82 managers.635.93 635.93 So635.93 the635.93 history,635.93 because635.93 I635.93 don't635.93 think635.93 it's635.93 as635.93 true635.93 now635.93 as635.93 it635.93 was635.93 but635.93 we've635.93 got635.93 to635.93 look635.93 at635.93 what635.93 the635.93 history635.93 was,635.93 that635.93 the635.93 mayor635.93 could636.33 be636.49 anyone636.81 and637.77 the638.01 city638.17 council638.65 has639.69 to639.93 be640.01 more640.73 involved.641.37 So642.29 we642.54 tend642.62 to643.1 see,643.25 when643.82 you644.05 see644.22 the644.46 sorting644.7 that645.01 I645.17 did645.34 in645.58 the645.74 tabs,645.89 you646.7 tend646.93 to647.25 see647.42 that648.13 those648.54 with648.86 a649.17 mayor649.42 council,649.82 the650.77 council651.01 is652.29 paid652.54 a652.86 higher653.01 rate.653.42 If654.26 you654.5 look654.66 just654.98 at655.38 the656.02 manager658.42 council,660.1 the660.1 rates660.26 are660.66 lower,660.9 notwithstanding661.54 Cambridge,662.82 Worcester,663.54 and664.34 Lowell.664.58 Those665.46 are665.7 the665.86 ones666.02 that666.34 have666.58 the666.98 double667.22 whammy667.62 of668.58 the669.12 city669.36 manager669.51 and670.88 a671.92 mayor,672.96 so673.2 those673.2 are673.51 much674.08 larger.674.48 They675.92 certainly676.39 incentivize678.48 people679.27 to679.67 want679.84 to680.15 be680.32 on681.04 the681.75 council682.08 and683.63 they're683.79 paid684.11 a684.51 little684.59 bit684.83 more.684.99 Lowell685.63 not685.95 so686.19 much686.35 as687.07 Worcester687.79 and688.35 Cambridge.688.59 You690.27 know,690.43 but690.83 I691.07 figure691.31 if691.87 you're692.19 running692.51 in693.07 Cambridge,693.23 your695.15 housing695.39 costs695.95 are696.27 a696.43 lot696.51 more.696.75 So697.27 maybe697.51 that's698 an698.32 incentive698.55 to699.03 stay.699.27 699.83 But699.83 I700 would700.07 not700.24 compare700.63 yourselves701.27 to701.83 that.702 I702.32 think702.39 in703.03 most703.27 salary703.67 surveys,704.24 we704.88 never705.12 include705.51 them705.91 because706.24 they706.55 are706.79 an706.95 entity707.19 to708.32 themselves708.55 as709.19 they709.43 should709.6 be.709.75 They710 work710.24 hard710.48 for710.71 it710.88 and711.03 it's711.19 a711.43 wonderful,711.51 community.712.9 So713.86 if714.1 you714.34 look714.5 only714.82 at715.3 the716.1 manager716.74 council,717.46 there720.9 are721.14 many721.3 that721.7 don't.722.02 There's722.34 a722.58 handful722.74 that723.22 don't723.54 actually724.02 pay724.5 a724.82 stipend.724.98 We736.26 did736.26 get736.26 confirmation736.26 that736.26 North736.26 Attleborough736.26 does736.26 not736.26 pay736.26 any736.26 for736.26 their736.26 council.736.26 So736.26 the736.26 theory736.26 is,736.26 just736.26 like736.26 when736.26 there's736.26 a736.26 Mayor,736.26 the737.23 theory737.38 was737.79 the738.11 council738.35 needed738.9 to739.6 do739.84 more739.92 work.740.4 It's742.08 transferable743.68 to744.56 when744.96 there745.12 is745.36 a745.52 professional745.68 manager.746.56 Certainly,747.92 this748.48 municipality749.04 has750 changed750.32 in751.28 adding751.76 professional752.32 management753.12 to754.12 its754.67 roles.755 Having757 said757.55 that,757.79 your759.71 rate760.03 is760.36 of761.08 the761.32 lowest761.48 around.761.88 So763.08 you763.39 clearly763.71 need764.2 to764.36 do764.51 something764.83 and766.13 I766.53 would766.69 certainly766.93 recommend767.41 that.767.97 I768.61 think768.69 you769.01 need769.09 to769.33 come769.49 up769.81 with770.05 what770.53 it770.77 is770.93 you're771.25 trying771.57 to771.81 capture772.69 and773.17 what773.41 it773.57 is773.73 you773.97 want774.21 to775.01 do775.09 with775.25 it.775.41 775.97 There775.97 is776.21 not776.45 a776.77 formula.776.93 We777.41 did777.65 this777.81 survey778.05 for778.45 a778.61 mayor,778.77 which779.09 the779.33 city779.49 I779.81 will779.97 not780.13 name,780.71 who782.15 really782.48 felt782.88 they783.27 should783.6 be783.84 paid784.08 like785.2 a785.43 city785.67 manager.786.39 The787.36 people787.51 pushed787.91 back788.24 on788.48 that.788.71 That789.27 was789.51 not789.75 successful.791.43 Wanted792.71 to793.2 say,793.43 well,794.11 in794.43 my794.51 region,794.83 the796.03 surrounding796.27 managers797.07 make797.71 this.797.95 We798.83 don't798.99 recommend799.39 you799.87 compare800.19 the801.71 mayors801.95 to802.35 managers.802.59 And803.23 similarly,803.87 you805.07 just805.31 need805.63 to805.87 look806.03 at806.75 the807 data.807.71 I808.51 did808.67 see808.91 some809.15 of809.39 the809.48 work809.63 that809.95 you810.12 did810.36 with811.07 other811.31 scattergrams811.88 and,812.83 you813.31 know,813.48 rates815.07 in815.39 other815.55 states.815.95 I817 would817.24 suggest817.88 to818.51 you,818.67 with820.71 all820.95 due821.27 respect821.43 to821.83 everybody821.91 who822.39 did822.55 that822.79 hard823.03 work,823.27 I823.67 think823.75 you're823.99 laying824.23 the824.55 table824.63 now825.03 to825.59 just825.83 use826.15 your826.39 gut826.71 and827.27 go827.51 with827.67 what827.91 you828.15 think828.31 is828.63 best,828.87 because830.55 you831.43 also831.67 have832.31 constituencies832.79 that833.99 you834.31 need834.82 to834.98 get835.21 to835.45 support835.77 this.836.17 And836.41 not838.17 one838.58 of838.82 the839.38 council839.53 members840.01 are840.82 in841.05 it841.21 for841.45 the841.7 money843.29 because843.7 if843.7 they843.86 were,844.01 they844.25 wouldn't844.41 be844.65 doing844.89 it845.13 because845.53 the845.86 money846.1 is846.89 not847.13 that847.45 great.847.77 I848.84 do849.08 see849.48 room850.44 for850.84 improvement851.16 and852.52 room852.84 to853.16 maybe853.48 increase854.52 to855.48 a855.72 certain855.88 amount.856.44 In858.12 most858.36 cases,858.68 you859.24 will859.48 see859.72 there's860.52 not861.08 a861.4 different861.56 rate861.96 for862.2 the862.36 vice862.52 chair.863 It's863.41 usually,863.65 you864.01 know,864.38 the864.82 president865.5 or866.05 the866.29 chair866.45 that866.7 makes866.86 a867.1 few867.25 thousand867.98 dollars868.45 more.868.45 One869.74 city,870.05 I870.86 think871.01 it's871.25 Newton,871.57 pays872.13 councilors872.53 10%873.17 of873.74 the873.98 mayor's874.13 pay.874.7 That's876.39 a876.95 little877.11 interesting.878.95 You879.27 know,879.27 that's879.27 a879.27 gift879.35 that879.59 keeps879.83 on880.15 giving880.31 so880.71 I'm880.95 not881.11 quite881.35 sure881.67 that882.39 that882.63 would882.79 be882.95 a883.11 recommendation883.27 I884.47 would884.55 give884.79 to885.03 people.885.19 886.15 I886.15 think886.31 what886.63 you886.87 should887.11 do887.43 is888.4 come889.13 up889.37 with889.52 your889.76 balance890.08 of890.57 a890.96 rate891.13 for891.45 members,891.68 a892.64 rate892.8 for893.13 the893.68 council893.85 president894.32 who894.96 does895.28 have895.61 that895.85 added896.25 responsibility.896.8 Not897.92 50%898.32 more899.28 but899.85 a900.08 differential,900.4 like901.13 a901.37 rank901.45 differential901.76 in902.88 our902.96 beloved903.2 police903.84 and904.16 fire904.4 departments,905.44 you905.6 know?905.6 So906.08 you906.72 can906.88 see907.2 that907.44 they907.68 do908.4 have908.64 more908.88 responsibility.909.36 And910.96 you911.2 could911.36 have911.6 a911.84 differential912 there912.72 of,913.04 you913.84 would914 do914.16 it914.32 whatever914.48 you914.88 decide,915.04 a915.44 few915.6 thousand916.08 dollars.917.88 I917.88 would918.12 argue918.6 that,919.08 you921.08 know,921.24 87922.12 and922.91 12923.08 are923.79 low.924.04 And924.67 you924.91 can925.08 see925.24 that925.39 in925.72 all925.96 of926.2 the926.36 data926.6 even927.55 when927.88 you928.12 look928.27 at928.6 the928.91 mayors,929.08 the929.72 manager929.88 councils.930.43 So931.08 I'm931.55 happy931.79 to932.04 answer932.2 any934.47 questions.934.47 I934.47 don't934.63 know934.79 where935.03 you935.59 all935.75 are935.99 in936.15 your936.39 thought936.55 process,936.87 but937.19 I'm937.59 happy937.91 to938.23 entertain938.47 any939.03 questions.939.27

941.75 SPEAKER1941.75 -941.75 Thank941.75 you,941.91 Mary.942.07 Questions943.03 from943.51 the943.75 from944.07 the944.31 committee?944.39 Susan.946.39 951.74 FALKOFF951.74 -951.74 Thank951.74 you.952.06 Currently,955.58 the956.38 council957.89 president958.3 salary958.77 is959.34 determined959.82 by960.46 getting961.29 a961.49 councilor961.69 salary962.17 plus962.57 a963.05 school963.13 committee963.37 salary,964.65 so964.81 it's964.81 not965.05 a965.37 differential965.69 for966.25 being966.49 the967.05 council967.21 president.967.61 In968.73 thinking968.97 it969.29 over,969.53 it969.85 has970.01 occurred970.33 to970.73 me970.89 that971.53 he972.41 should972.73 have972.97 a973.13 differential973.29 because974.46 he974.62 does974.77 do975.01 a975.17 lot975.25 more975.5 as975.82 a976.21 councilor976.38 aside976.93 from977.25 his977.5 school977.89 committee978.21 responsibilities.978.53 So979.41 I979.74 just979.89 wonder980.05 if980.29 you980.46 have980.62 a980.77 comment980.86 on981.17 that.981.34 982.21 AICARDI982.21 -982.21 I982.21 would982.29 agree982.53 with982.77 you.983.01 985.01 FALKOFF985.01 -985.01 Okay.985.01 985.58 AICARDI985.58 -985.58 Yes.985.58 I985.98 mean,986.05 when986.64 you986.88 look987.04 at987.28 the987.44 role987.6 of987.92 the988.16 council988.32 members,988.72 I989.2 did989.36 not989.6 know989.76 that990 was990.24 the990.4 differential990.56 because991.12 as991.76 you992 see,992.32 in992.64 many992.88 cases,993.2 there994.08 is994.32 a994.48 differential994.72 in995.76 recognition.996 And996.88 that's997.04 true997.36 with997.6 select997.76 boards998.16 as998.48 well.998.64 You999.34 know,999.41 so999.65 when999.74 you999.98 see1000.13 the1000.29 chair1000.46 of1000.77 the1000.86 select1001.1 boards1001.34 in1001.74 municipalities,1002.38 it's1003.34 usually1003.74 a1004.22 two1004.46 to1004.7 three,1005.74 maybe1006.13 50001006.62 more,1007.25 but1007.65 not1007.98 much1008.22 more1008.46 than1008.7 that.1008.86 So1009.17 it's1009.5 just1010.77 a1011.01 differential.1011.17 You're1012.05 right,1012.7 the1013.41 school1013.41 committee1013.41 obligation1014.13 should1014.9 be1015.14 on1015.3 top1015.38 of1015.62 that1015.86 because1016.1 that1016.5 is1016.66 a1016.82 separate1016.98 role.1017.46 1018.66 FALKOFF1018.66 -1018.66 Thank1018.66 you.1018.9 1020.02 BARTLEY1020.02 -1020.02 So1020.02 as1020.18 a1020.42 follow-up1020.82 to1021.14 that,1021.22 would1021.46 you,1021.7 contemplate1022.42 a1024.58 differential1024.98 for1026.74 his1027.38 role1028.04 of1028.2 putting,1028.61 his1029.16 or1029.4 her1029.57 role1029.72 of1029.96 putting1029.96 together1030.2 the1030.53 agenda,1030.68 working1031.24 and1031.72 presiding,1031.88 which,1032.85 I1033.33 can1033.4 say1033.57 firsthand1033.8 can1034.29 be1034.44 difficult.1034.61 So1035.96 you1036.44 have1036.61 that1037.72 differential1037.96 plus1038.77 the1039.16 school1039.4 committee,1041.24 right?1041.88 So1041.88 it1042.12 doesn't1042.28 have1042.52 to1042.76 yeah.1043 Okay.1043.24 1043.64 AICARDI1043.64 -1043.64 That's1043.64 correct.1043.88 1044.2 BARTLEY1044.2 -1044.2 Yeah.1044.2 Thank1044.52 you.1044.68 That's1045 a1045.24 great1045.56 idea.1045.8

1048.44 Linda.1048.44

1049.56 LINDA1049.56 SCOTT1049.56 -1049.56 BLUE1049.56 RIBBON1049.56 COMMITTEE1049.56 MEMBER1049.56 -1049.56 Okay.1049.56 One1050.92 of1051.16 the1051.24 councilors1051.4 has1052.04 repeated1052.92 several1053.56 times1053.96 that1054.44 the1055.51 differential1055.83 between1056.38 what1056.71 the1056.95 president1057.11 makes1057.59 and1057.83 they1057.98 make,1058.22 you1058.47 know,1058.71 the1058.87 21059.03 a1059.27 half1059.35 percent1059.59 each1059.9 year,1060.07 eventually,1060.95 it1061.51 starts1061.74 to1062.07 do1062.14 this,1062.55 it1062.71 doesn't1062.71 go1063.18 parallel.1063.51 Would1064.46 you1064.71 recommend1064.95 keeping1068.3 the,1068.78 for1069.18 instance,1069.42 if1070.14 the1070.62 councilors1070.86 get1071.34 a1071.58 raise1071.66 of1071.9 10%,1072.14 let's1072.7 say,1073.02 that1074.78 whatever1075.74 follows1076.38 the,1077.74 I1078.22 don't1078.38 know1078.46 if1078.62 I'm1078.78 saying1079.02 this1079.18 correctly,1079.82 the1079.98 president1079.98 will1080.46 always1080.82 be1081.13 within1081.38 a1081.86 certain1082.02 percentage1082.41 of1082.89 that1083.05 rather1083.38 than1083.69 having1083.93 it1084.1 skew1085.45 at1085.78 some1085.93 point,1086.1 if1086.41 you1086.65 know1086.73 what1086.82 I1086.97 mean?1087.05 You1087.3 know,1087.45 if1087.54 he's1087.69 making1087.93 10,0001088.49 more1089.05 than1089.21 they1089.45 are,1089.62 let's1089.78 say,1090.02 21090.41 a1090.65 half1090.82 percent1091.05 is1091.38 gonna1091.54 get1092.26 bigger1092.49 and1092.82 bigger1092.89 and1093.21 bigger1093.3 faster1093.69 than1094.1 theirs.1094.34 So1095 I'm1095.16 wondering1095.24 if1095.64 there's1095.8 a1095.96 way1096.12 to1096.36 make1096.44 it1096.68 parallel1096.84 so1097.4 that1097.64 they're1097.8 always1098.12 getting1099.48 something1099.8 that's1100.12 within1101.56 the1101.88 same1102.12 range.1102.36 1103.72 AICARDI1103.72 -1103.72 That's1103.72 a1104.04 great1104.12 question.1104.44 In1105.4 the1105.64 world1105.8 according1106.12 to1106.52 Mary,1106.68 a1107.6 happy1107.84 place,1108.08 I1111.28 wouldn't1111.36 do1111.67 percentage1111.91 increases.1112.48 I1113.43 think1113.6 you1113.76 should1113.91 look1114.15 at1114.32 flat1114.56 rates1114.8 every1115.2 few1115.52 years1115.76 and1116.24 adjust1116.48 them1116.8 by1117.52 the1117.76 flat1117.91 rate.1118.24 So1118.8 I1119.12 would1119.28 keep1119.6 that1120 2500,1120.63 30001121.84 difference.1122.56 So1123.07 if1123.23 you1124.03 go1124.11 to1124.51 121125.31 and1127.55 15,1127.55 and1127.55 you1127.71 look1127.87 at1128.11 it1128.19 in1128.43 five1128.75 years,1128.99 and1129.71 you1129.87 go1130.11 to1130.27 151130.59 and1131.79 181131.79 or1131.79 181132.19 and1134.35 20,1134.35 I1134.35 would1134.51 recommend1134.83 that1135.39 because1135.71 it's1136.41 a1136.65 stipend,1137.13 not1137.7 a1137.93 cost1138.1 of1138.41 living,1139.46 right?1139.93 It's1139.93 an1140.26 honorarium,1140.58 almost.1141.46 And1141.93 I1142.17 don't1142.26 mean1142.49 it's1142.89 a,1143.13 thank1143.54 you1143.78 for1143.93 the1144.17 favor,1144.41 but1145.13 I1145.38 mean1145.54 it1145.78 in1146.02 terms1146.17 of1146.74 the1147.54 value1147.78 of1148.34 time,1149.22 it's1149.54 not1149.54 a1149.78 salary.1150.02 So1151.24 I1151.64 would1151.8 stay1152.04 away1152.36 from1152.76 automatic1153.88 increases1154.68 or1155.64 tied1156.04 percentages1156.52 tying1158.68 it1159.08 to1159.4 the1160.12 consumer1160.68 price1161.24 index,1161.64 which1162.04 some1162.36 of1162.52 them1162.68 you1162.84 can1163 see1163.24 in1163.4 the1163.56 data1163.8 do1164.36 that.1164.6 That's1165.54 really1166.02 risky1166.49 because1166.89 it's1167.21 hard1167.38 to1167.62 pull1167.78 back1168.17 from1168.41 that.1168.65 Say1169.45 we1169.62 go1169.78 through1169.93 a1170.17 rough1170.34 time,1170.65 do1170.97 you1171.21 cut1171.45 it?1171.69 So,1173.21 like1174.17 in1174.49 longevity,1174.89 in1177.05 the1177.29 world1177.38 according1177.69 to1178.1 Mary,1178.26 don't1178.73 ask1178.97 my1179.21 union1179.45 friends,1179.86 having1180.75 longevity1181.07 be1181.71 a1181.87 percentage1182.03 of1182.51 pay1182.75 is1183.15 regressive.1183.47 And1184.67 I1184.83 think1184.99 that1185.31 it's1185.47 a1185.95 value1186.27 to1187.15 the1187.39 role.1187.63 And,1188.51 yes,1188.83 it,1189.15 I1190.03 won't1190.27 ask1190.59 you1190.75 when1190.99 the1191.23 last1191.39 time1191.63 this1191.87 was1192.03 adjusted,1192.35 but1194.07 I1194.22 can1194.38 guess.1194.63 It's1195.18 been1195.35 a1195.66 while.1195.74 So,1196.31 1199.03 SCOTT1199.03 -1199.03 Recently,1199.74 but1199.98 it1199.98 wasn't1200.14 adjusted1200.55 before1201.03 that1201.35 for1201.66 a1201.9 very1201.98 long1202.22 time.1202.55 1202.79 AICARDI1202.79 -1202.79 Okay.1202.79 So1204.55 I1204.7 don't1204.87 even1205.03 wanna1205.35 ask1205.59 what1205.83 it1205.98 was1206.14 before1206.31 then.1206.7 This1207.55 gentleman1207.79 down1208.19 here1208.43 has1208.59 been1208.67 raising1208.91 his1209.23 hand.1209.47 1212.89 MELLO1212.89 -1212.89 Alright.1212.89 That's1214.03 interesting1214.35 what1214.67 you1214.83 just1214.99 said.1215.31 One1215.55 of1215.71 the1215.79 problems1215.87 we've1216.27 had,1216.51 this1216.75 is1216.91 why1217.07 this1217.31 commission1217.55 was1217.87 established1218.11 for1219.23 the1219.47 councilors1219.63 to1220.11 give1220.27 themselves1220.59 a1221.07 pay1221.23 raise1221.39 or1221.71 whatever,1221.87 increased1222.65 stipend,1224.26 it1224.49 has1224.49 to1224.73 be1224.89 they1225.38 have1225.53 to1225.69 vote1225.86 on1226.1 it,1226.26 which1227.29 put1227.93 them1228.1 in1228.34 a1228.41 tough1228.58 position1228.82 to1229.21 vote1229.38 an1229.62 increase,1229.77 and1230.89 it1231.13 takes1231.29 effect1231.62 for1232.02 the1232.17 next1232.34 council.1233.13 I1234.41 made1234.65 a1234.89 proposal1235.05 that1236.02 would1236.17 be1236.41 the1237.56 increase1237.8 that1238.2 the1238.52 city1238.92 employees1239.4 get.1239.88 So1241.08 if1241.32 there1241.56 is1241.72 a1241.96 time1242.12 that1242.36 financially1242.84 we1243.4 struggle,1243.64 it's1244.36 not1244.6 an1244.76 automatic1244.92 based1245.48 on1245.72 the1245.88 cost1246.04 of1246.36 living.1246.44 It'd1246.92 be,1248.04 employees1248.2 in1248.6 this1248.76 city1249.32 average1249.88 2%1250.28 to1251.36 3%.1251.6 It1252.63 may1253.03 be1253.19 2%,1253.43 2%,1254.08 3%1254.63 on1255.19 a1255.36 three1255.51 year1255.76 contract,1257.51 and1257.67 that's1257.67 the1257.91 way1258.08 I1258.23 looked1258.39 at1258.55 it.1258.71 If1258.88 there's1259.03 a1259.27 financial1259.43 time,1259.91 and1260.15 this1260.32 happened1260.71 back1261.12 a1261.91 while1262.08 back1262.32 yeah,1263.29 is1263.61 that1263.85 they1264.17 froze1264.33 everybody.1264.73 So1265.29 nobody1265.69 get1266.01 a,1266.25 including,1266.33 you1266.81 know,1266.97 nobody1267.13 get1267.45 a1267.69 pay1267.77 raise.1267.93 So1268.25 it1268.57 wouldn't1268.73 be1268.97 automatic.1269.13 My1270.25 proposal1270.65 is1271.37 to1271.61 set1271.85 pay1272.57 raises1272.73 and1273.61 then1273.77 change1275.13 our1275.53 charter1275.77 that1277.38 reflects1277.63 that1278.18 it's1278.42 based1279.07 on1279.38 what1280.11 employees1280.35 get,1283.55 what1283.71 the,1283.71 you1283.95 know,1284.03 the1284.35 average1284.59 employee1284.9 gets,1285.31 which1285.55 is1285.79 the1286.11 percentage1286.35 that's1286.83 agreed1287.07 to1287.31 in1287.55 collective1287.63 bargaining.1288.51 1290.74 AICARDI1290.74 -1290.74 You1290.74 certainly1291.14 have1291.62 every1291.94 right1292.42 to1292.66 do1292.82 that.1292.98 I'm1293.78 here1294.02 to1294.18 answer1294.34 any1294.74 questions.1295.62 That1295.86 is1295.86 not1296.18 something1296.58 that1297.62 I1298.42 see1298.66 as1298.9 a1299.14 best1299.3 practice1299.62 for1300.82 elected1301.14 official1301.7 stipends.1302.26 I1303.33 think1303.48 it1303.64 falls1304.29 into,1304.61 I1307.72 think1307.88 it1308.05 makes1308.29 it1308.53 a1308.77 little1308.85 tricky1309.16 for1310.05 council1310.37 members1310.85 to1311.4 be1311.57 approving1311.88 union1313.09 contracts1313.72 and1314.37 agreements1314.77 that1315.57 will1315.81 impact1316.13 them,1318.49 so1318.73 that1318.73 is1318.97 a1319.29 little1319.45 risky.1319.85 I1320.97 would1321.21 suggest1321.53 that1322.25 a1323.21 committee1323.45 like1323.93 this1324.17 be1324.57 standing1324.89 every1325.53 five1326.41 years,1326.73 four1327.21 years,1327.45 whatever1327.69 you1328.17 decide.1328.49 I1329.61 think1329.77 that1330.09 having1332.06 calculated1332.46 and1333.26 costed1333.58 out1333.97 hundreds1334.78 of1335.34 collective1335.49 bargaining1336.06 agreements,1336.7 which1338.21 number1338.62 do1338.86 you1339.1 use?1339.34 The1340.13 one1340.3 that1340.54 gets1340.7 a1341.1 low1341.26 COLA1341.58 and1342.06 then1342.3 a1342.7 stipend1342.93 for1343.41 something1343.65 else?1343.97 Do1345.73 you1345.97 have1346.68 different1347 years?1347.48 Do1348.12 you1348.36 have1348.68 different1349.16 clothing1349.8 allowances?1350.28 I1351.32 would1351.56 not1351.88 tie1352.52 anything1352.92 for1353.48 elected1353.8 officials1354.44 to1356.04 employees1356.6 in1357.56 bargaining1358.44 units.1359.32 1360.36 Sometimes1360.36 I1361 would1361.08 recommend1361.4 to1362.57 tie1362.64 nonunion1364.48 employees1365.37 to1366.01 bargaining1366.16 unit1366.73 pay1367.45 rates1367.68 and1368.24 increases1368.64 to1369.61 keep1369.85 up1370.09 with1370.33 that1370.57 compression,1370.81 which1371.45 is1371.61 exactly1371.85 what1372.81 you1372.97 were1373.21 talking1373.37 about.1373.85 You1374.7 know,1374.86 where1375.74 do1376.06 the1377.02 positions1377.18 catch1377.82 up1378.14 if1378.46 you1378.7 don't1378.86 keep1379.18 an1379.58 eye1379.82 on1380.06 it?1380.22 We1380.86 would1381.1 recommend1381.34 that1381.9 you1382.14 use1382.38 a1382.54 subcommittee1382.78 or1383.42 something1383.66 like1384.06 this1384.22 to1384.54 maybe1385.18 do1385.5 this1385.74 exercise1386.14 every1387.02 few1387.34 years1387.74 to1388.22 say1388.46 what1389.32 are1389.55 we1390.03 doing?1390.36 I1391.08 think1391.15 you1391.39 also1391.71 need1392.19 to1393.08 ask,1393.23 and1393.71 I1393.88 bet1394.03 you1394.19 did1394.36 because1394.6 I1394.84 heard1394.99 you1395.15 talk1395.39 about1395.55 talking1395.95 to1396.43 councilors,1396.6 why1397.71 do1397.95 you1398.19 do1398.36 this1398.43 work,1399.79 you1399.95 know.1399.95 And1400.6 you1400.99 don't1401.23 want1401.55 them1401.79 to,1402.19 you1403.07 know,1403.15 not1403.71 be1404.11 appreciated,1404.35 lose,1405.63 you1406.43 know,1406.51 income1407.07 someplace1407.63 else.1408.19 But1408.59 this1408.75 is1408.99 not1409.15 a,1409.31 it1410.11 becomes1410.51 a1411.07 passion1411.23 and1411.71 a1411.87 part1412.03 time1412.27 job,1412.59 but1412.91 I1413.15 wouldn't1413.31 look1413.63 it1413.87 as1414.11 needing1415.04 a1415.36 living1415.52 wage,1415.91 which1416.32 is1416.56 what1416.63 the1416.88 cost1417.04 of1417.28 living1417.43 is1417.91 trying1418.15 to1418.47 keep1418.56 up1418.8 with.1419.04 So1419.76 I,1420.47 in1422.95 most1423.28 places,1423.67 you1424.8 will1424.95 see,1425.19 occasionally,1425.99 there1427.38 is1427.62 a1428.18 COLA.1428.34 You1428.82 can1428.9 see1429.14 by1429.38 the1429.54 round1429.7 numbers1430.02 that1430.5 some1430.9 of1431.14 these1431.3 have1431.46 been1431.7 given1431.86 COLAs,1432.34 but1433.14 I1433.54 wouldn't1433.78 link1434.42 it1434.74 in1434.98 an1435.14 ordinance1435.46 to1436.02 anything.1436.18 I1436.66 would1436.82 have1437.06 that1437.22 conversation1437.54 fresh1438.34 every1439.06 few1439.38 years.1439.62

1440.42 SPEAKER11440.42 -1440.42 Thank1440.42 you,1440.58 Mary.1440.82 Christine?1441.22 1443.48 CHRISTINE1443.48 COLE1443.48 -1443.48 BLUE1443.48 RIBBON1443.48 COMMITTEE1443.48 MEMBER1443.48 -1443.48 Thank1443.48 you,1443.64 Mary,1443.88 for1444.21 being1444.45 here1444.68 and1444.92 sharing1445.01 your1445.33 thoughts1445.57 with1445.81 us.1446.05 On1447.48 this1447.73 point1448.05 about1448.45 how1448.85 rates1449.09 are1449.33 being1449.48 determined,1449.97 the1451.24 data1452.37 that1452.68 you1452.85 shared1453.09 with1453.4 us1453.64 next1454.29 to1454.53 the1454.77 row1455.45 for1455.57 Worcester1455.69 in1457.77 the1458.09 column1458.41 how1458.97 pay1459.29 rates1459.53 are1459.85 determined,1460.17 it1461.45 says1461.69 the1461.93 city1462.09 uses1462.49 a1462.89 formula1463.13 provided1463.85 by1464.49 the1464.73 Commonwealth1464.97 to1465.85 determine1466.09 annual1466.65 rate1467.13 adjustments.1467.45 I1468.77 was1468.93 curious1469.17 about1469.73 that1470.21 formula.1470.53 I1471.73 was1471.82 curious1472.05 why1472.86 it1473.65 seems1474.05 to1474.45 be1474.62 unique1474.86 to1475.34 Worcester,1475.58 which1476.53 is1476.77 obviously1476.93 their1477.49 choice,1477.73 but1478.05 if1478.29 a1478.38 formula1478.53 is1478.93 out1479.1 there,1479.26 I1479.58 would1479.97 be1480.13 curious1480.29 about1480.69 it.1480.93 And1481.17 then1481.34 finally,1481.58 in1482.94 contrast1483.26 to1483.74 the1483.9 language1484.22 you've1484.62 used1484.94 here1485.34 with1485.58 us,1485.82 you've1486.54 talked1487.18 very1487.58 carefully1487.82 about1488.3 it1488.46 being1488.62 a1488.86 stipend1489.1 or1489.58 an1489.82 honorarium,1490.06 and1491.26 this1491.42 specifically1491.74 says1492.38 pay1492.78 adjustment.1493.1 So1493.82 I've1494.38 got1494.54 three1494.78 questions1495.02 in1495.42 there.1495.58 1495.98 AICARDI1495.98 -1495.98 That's1496.54 great.1496.78 I1497.34 need1497.5 to1497.74 check1497.9 my1498.28 notes1498.43 because1498.67 clearly1498.99 the1499.39 form,1500.12 the1500.36 line1500.6 didn't1500.84 fit1501.15 in1501.39 this1501.56 box.1501.8 So1502.12 I1502.36 need1502.43 to1502.67 check1502.76 my1502.99 notes1503.15 on1503.39 what1503.63 formula1503.96 they're1504.43 referring1504.67 to.1505.08 Whether1505.8 it's,1506.2 you1506.76 know,1506.99 a1507.32 state1507.56 formula,1508.84 I1509.32 will1509.47 check1509.71 that.1509.96 The1511.66 salary1513.42 is1513.9 a1514.06 carryover1514.22 because1514.86 it1515.1 is1515.18 the1515.42 mayor's1515.58 salary1515.98 and1516.46 it1516.62 is1516.78 the1517.02 manager's1517.26 salary,1518.7 so1519.66 that1519.66 probably1519.98 should1520.62 say1520.86 stipend.1521.26 I1521.9 refer1522.14 to1522.86 them1523.02 as1523.18 stipend1523.42 but1523.82 the1524.47 data1524.55 we1524.88 collected1525.12 in1525.51 the1525.67 survey1525.84 said1526.23 salary.1526.55 1527.12 COLE1527.12 -1527.12 Okay.1527.12 1527.84 AICARDI1527.84 -1527.84 Yeah,1529.19 because1529.6 nobody's1529.6 salary1530.08 is1530.47 87001530.95 for1531.99 the1532.15 year.1532.32 1533.27 COLE1533.27 -1533.27 Do1533.27 you1533.43 have1533.51 any1533.76 sense1533.99 of1534.32 why1534.55 Worcester1535.03 is1535.84 using1536.08 that?1536.47 Was1538.32 that1538.55 a1538.88 special1539.32 request1539.72 of1540.12 Worcester?1540.36 Is1540.92 this1541.08 a1541.32 formula1541.48 that1542.04 exists1542.36 and1542.84 they1543.24 are1543.48 the1543.64 only1543.72 ones1543.88 who've1544.12 chosen1544.44 to1544.84 afford1545 themselves1545.32 of1545.72 this?1545.88 1546.2 AICARDI1546.2 -1546.2 I1546.2 will1546.36 find1546.52 out1546.76 for1546.92 you1547.08 and1547.24 get1547.4 back1547.56 to1547.72 you.1547.8 1547.8 COLE1547.8 -1547.8 Perfect.1547.88 Thank1548.12 you.1548.36

1553.82 SPEAKER11553.82 -1553.82 Susan.1553.82

1554.93 FALKOFF1554.93 -1554.93 Thanks.1554.93 So1555.49 you1556.54 confused1556.78 me1557.26 a1557.49 little1557.58 bit1557.82 with1558.13 what1558.29 you1558.45 were1558.62 saying.1558.86 What1560.69 I1560.93 think1561.1 would1561.41 be1561.58 the1561.73 problem1561.89 with1562.21 using1562.45 union1562.86 increases1564.38 is1564.93 that1565.17 not1565.79 all1566.03 the1566.27 unions1566.43 are1566.75 the1566.99 same,1567.15 and1567.47 they're1567.71 all1567.95 done1568.99 at1569.23 different1569.39 times1569.71 of1569.95 the1570.03 year.1570.19 And1570.43 so1570.75 that1570.99 doesn't1571.23 seem1571.63 good.1571.79 And1572.03 I1573.23 thought1573.39 Jim's1573.79 original1574.27 or1575.47 I1575.71 remember1575.87 Jim's1576.43 original1576.83 suggestion1577.8 as1578.37 just1578.68 increase1578.92 it1579.33 by1579.48 21579.72 and1579.88 a1580.04 half1580.13 a1580.28 year1580.37 because1581.24 we1581.96 do1582.13 have1582.28 this1582.44 21582.85 and1583.09 a1583.16 half1583.24 percent1583.48 thing.1583.8 And1584.92 I1585.16 wonder1585.24 if1585.88 that1586.04 makes1586.2 any1586.44 sense1586.68 to1586.92 you.1587.09 1588.44 AICARDI1588.44 -1588.44 Again,1588.44 you1588.85 could1589.09 do1589.33 that.1589.57 I1590.28 think1590.44 when1590.76 you,1591.09 that's1593.22 where1593.54 the1593.86 small1594.02 p,1594.5 political1594.82 issue,1595.46 comes1595.86 in,1597.02 you1597.38 know.1597.54 You1597.54 can1597.54 guarantee1597.86 a1598.42 21598.58 a1598.82 half1598.98 percent1599.22 increase.1599.78 Now,1602.18 are1602.74 you1602.98 tying1603.3 the1603.62 city1603.86 manager's1604.34 hands1604.98 in1605.38 any1605.54 way1605.86 in1606.5 bargaining1608.51 if1608.66 it's1608.66 a1608.83 21608.98 a1609.31 half1609.46 percent1609.63 increase1610.11 every1610.74 year1610.98 with1611.79 no1612.03 caveats1612.35 not1613.14 to1613.38 give1613.46 it?1613.7 Does1616.59 that1616.83 become1617.07 the1617.46 floor1617.63 for1618.03 the1618.27 unions?1618.42 I1619.46 just1620.99 wouldn't1621.55 necessarily1622.11 do1622.83 that.1623.07 1624.35 FALKOFF1624.35 -1624.35 Okay.1624.35 Thanks.1624.67

1627.39 SPEAKER11627.39 -1627.39 Sarah.1627.39

1628.67 SARAH1628.67 BAKER1628.67 -1628.67 BLUE1628.67 RIBBON1628.67 COMMITTEE1628.67 MEMBER1628.67 -1628.67 Thanks.1628.67 Have1630.03 you1630.19 observed1630.43 any1630.91 patterns1631.31 in1633.12 the1633.28 compensation1633.6 linked1635.12 to1635.43 geography,1636.24 population,1636.88 value1638.63 of1639.04 commercial1639.12 property,1639.52 budget1640.24 size,1642.39 any1643.2 correlations1643.52 that1644.08 you1644.32 see?1644.56 1646.32 AICARDI1646.32 -1646.32 I1646.32 think1646.79 when1647.03 you1647.43 look1647.59 at1647.75 the1649.43 rate,1649.67 and1650.07 if1650.55 you1650.79 look1650.87 at1651.03 them1651.11 in1651.43 descending1651.59 order,1652.95 there1653.75 really1653.99 is1654.39 no1654.71 rhyme1654.95 or1655.19 reason.1655.43 I1655.83 did1655.99 look1656.31 at1656.47 that1656.63 and1656.87 some1657.19 of1657.35 the1657.51 ones1657.67 that1658.07 are,1658.39 you1659.1 know,1659.17 you've1659.26 got1659.65 Worcester1659.89 and1660.38 Revere1660.54 in1661.26 the1661.49 30s.1661.73 You've1662.3 got1662.54 Quincy,1663.65 you1663.82 know,1663.82 Quincy1664.3 may1664.7 be,1664.86 you1665.17 know,1665.41 expensive1666.21 to1666.78 live,1667.65 although,1668.38 the1668.38 mayor,1668.54 in1670.06 Quincy1670.21 does1671.1 fairly1671.34 well1671.73 at1672.06 $285,000.1672.13 So1674.99 it1675.71 becomes,1675.95 when1676.67 you1676.91 look1677.07 at1677.39 this,1677.55 you1677.95 see1678.11 the1678.43 salaries1678.67 within1679.23 are1680.43 either1680.75 high1681.15 or1681.39 low1681.55 universally,1681.95 which1682.75 means1682.99 these1683.87 are1684.11 internal1684.51 climate1685.39 decisions,1686.19 which1687.72 is1687.96 why1688.2 it1689.09 really1689.33 is1690.13 me1690.85 serving1692.45 the1692.77 ball1692.92 back1693.33 to1693.64 you1693.81 to1693.96 say,1694.13 what1694.85 feels1695.16 right?1695.64 What's1696.13 your1696.45 gut,1697.72 you1697.88 know?1697.88 1699.39 BARTLEY1699.39 -1699.39 But1699.39 Quincy,1699.63 you1700.03 would1700.11 say,1700.27 Mary,1700.43 I1700.83 mean,1700.91 that1700.99 just1701.23 happened.1701.39 You1701.71 know,1701.79 Mayor1702.03 Koch1702.27 would1702.51 try1702.67 to1702.91 get,1703.07 there1704.11 was1704.35 a1704.59 commission1705.15 that1705.55 brought1705.79 in1706.11 1706.51 AICARDI1706.51 -1706.51 They1706.51 doubled1706.67 his1706.99 pay1707.31 recently,1708.43 right.1708.75 So1708.75 that's1708.91 a1709.15 good1709.31 point1709.55 that's1709.87 recent,1710.11 but1710.51 I1710.75 don't1710.83 know1711.15 when1711.31 their1711.63 council1712.75 member1713.55 rates1713.95 changed.1714.43 I1715.47 don't1715.56 think1715.71 they1716.04 changed1716.28 at1716.67 the1716.84 same1716.99 time.1717.23 1718.36 BARTLEY1718.36 -1718.36 I1718.36 was1718.67 not1718.84 privy1718.99 to1719.23 that,1719.32 but1719.39 I1719.56 did1719.63 1720.12 AICARDI1720.12 -1720.12 Yeah.1720.6 I1720.99 do1721.15 not1721.32 know1721.47 the1721.63 answer1721.88 to1722.19 that.1722.36 But1723.88 when1724.12 you1724.28 see,1724.52 like1725.71 Chelsea,1726.12 the1729.8 traditional1729.88 older1730.68 cities,1731.32 if1731.72 you1731.96 look1732.04 at1732.28 that,1732.36 some1733.16 of1733.4 those1733.48 council1733.8 salaries1734.6 are1735.08 higher1735.32 in1735.96 those,1736.12 you1736.76 know.1737 And1737.56 you1738.52 could1738.76 certainly,1739.08 you1739.64 all1739.8 know1740.04 the1740.68 politics1740.92 in1741.48 this1741.64 town,1741.88 in1742.96 this1743.04 city,1743.76 pardon1744.16 me.1744.16 You1746.24 know,1746.4 what's1746.8 gonna1747.13 sell,1748.96 what's1749.28 gonna1749.28 fly,1749.76 what1749.76 makes1750 the1750.24 most1750.4 sense?1750.72 What1751.37 is1751.52 our1751.76 goal1752.09 in1752.64 paying?1752.8 You1755.1 know,1755.34 you1755.74 can1755.9 kind1756.3 of1756.7 come1756.7 up1756.86 with1757.1 a,1757.66 oh,1758.14 how1758.46 many1758.62 hours1758.94 a1759.26 week,1759.34 but1759.74 what1759.98 is1760.22 the1760.38 value1760.62 of1761.02 time?1761.26 It's1761.66 not1761.9 the1762.22 same1762.38 as1762.86 a1763.02 salary,1763.18 which1764.14 is1764.38 why1764.54 I1765.26 tend1765.42 to1765.74 use1765.82 my1766.22 own1766.38 vernacular1766.7 of1767.99 a1768.15 stipend.1768.39 When1769.36 you1769.6 look1769.84 at,1770.15 you1771.99 know,1772.15 Lowell,1773.28 25,000,1773.84 Lynn,1775.36 25,000,1775.91 you1778.08 know,1778.24 115,0001778.72 population,1780.15 1001781.04 population,1781.43 Lawrence,1782.91 89,000,1786.51 Malden,1786.51 Waltham.1787.07 You1788.03 know,1788.19 those1788.51 are1791.47 larger1791.47 but1792.67 not1792.99 much1795.08 more1795.32 sophisticated1795.63 or1796.52 complex1796.84 as1797.39 Watertown1797.72 is.1798.28 So1798.6 those1799.15 are1799.39 the1799.56 things1799.72 that1800.04 I1800.28 would1800.52 look1800.84 at1801.08 as1801.8 you're1802.12 trying1802.36 to1802.67 decide.1803.08 1804.28 Certainly,1804.28 when1806.04 you1806.28 see,1806.6 if1807.48 you're1807.63 looking1807.88 at,1808.36 you1809.09 know,1809.17 whether1809.33 the1810.05 document1810.45 that1811.01 has1811.17 the1811.57 mayor1811.81 and1812.45 the1812.61 mayor1812.77 manager,1813.17 all1814.13 of1814.29 them.1814.45 If1815.17 you1815.41 start1815.57 at,1815.81 you1816.53 know,1816.69 the1817.49 top1817.73 with1817.97 the1818.21 council1818.37 member1818.77 salary,1819.17 that's1819.73 how1819.97 it1820.13 is1820.37 sorted,1820.69 by1821.51 the1821.74 way,1822.54 it's1822.78 by1822.78 the1823.03 council1823.11 member,1823.51 not1823.98 the1824.14 council1824.3 president,1824.78 or1826.3 vice1826.63 president,1827.83 and1828.07 you1828.07 can1828.22 see1828.54 descending,1829.18 amounts.1831.18 You'll1832.14 see1832.46 that1832.7 in1833.03 many1833.27 times1833.66 the1836.02 council1836.26 president1836.74 Haverhill,1837.38 for1837.94 example,1838.1 3,0001838.82 more.1839.54 Some1840.26 are1840.5 always1840.74 the1841.22 same1841.38 so1841.7 maybe1841.94 they1842.26 do1842.42 get1842.66 the1842.9 school1843.06 stipend1843.46 that's1843.86 not1844.18 listed1844.42 here.1844.82 It1845.06 really1845.3 does1845.54 depend1845.7 on1846.1 how1846.58 the1846.74 data1846.98 is1847.7 reflected.1848.1 Certainly,1849.71 you1852.28 know,1852.43 nobody's1853.96 asked1854.36 me1854.6 my1854.91 opinion.1855.08 Certainly,1855.71 I1856.12 would1856.28 believe1856.84 you1857.15 need1857.32 an1857.56 increase1858.76 and1858.99 that1859.23 I1859.56 think,1859.63 would1859.88 be1860.12 at1860.67 a1860.84 minimum.1860.99 How1861.96 much1862.2 of1862.52 an1862.67 increase1862.99 is1863.56 up1863.88 to1864.08 you1864.32 because1864.56 there1865.44 is1865.92 not1866.24 necessarily1866.8 a1867.84 correlation1868.16 to1869.04 population1869.28 but1871.04 there1871.28 is1871.6 a1871.84 difference1872.08 when1872.72 it's1872.96 manager1873.44 council1874.08 versus1874.4 mayor1874.88 council.1875.2 That1875.68 is1875.92 very1876.13 clear.1876.29 1877.48 BARTLEY1877.48 -1877.48 Thank1877.48 you,1877.64 Mary.1877.81 And1878.29 as1878.77 you1879.09 use1879.24 the1879.4 word1879.48 stipend,1879.81 a1880.29 lot1880.37 of1880.53 people1880.61 here1880.85 use1881.09 the1881.24 word1881.4 adjustment1881.81 as1882.2 opposed1882.44 to1882.77 a1882.92 raise.1883.09 1884.13 AICARDI1884.13 -1884.13 Right.1884.13

1884.68 SPEAKER11884.68 -1884.68 Any1884.68 other1884.92 questions?1885.16

1886.29 SPEAKER31886.29 -1886.29 I1886.29 would1886.37 1886.64 SCOTT1886.64 -1886.64 I1886.64 would1886.66 say1886.67 that1886.68 it's1886.69 a1886.7 stipend1886.72 because1886.73 it's1886.74 not1886.75 a1886.76 full1886.77 salary,1886.79 but1886.8 we're1886.81 adjusting1886.82 the1886.83 stipend,1886.89 you1886.9 know?1886.9 1886.91 BARTLEY1886.91 -1886.91 I1886.91 think1886.92 that's1888.44 what1890.72 we're1890.88 talking1891.76 about.1892.24 1892.24 SCOTT1892.24 -1892.24 Yeah.1892.24

1894.56 SPEAKER31894.56 -1894.56 Yeah.1894.56 Yeah.1894.88

1895.2 SPEAKER71895.2 -1895.2 Marcy?1895.2

1896.72 MURNINGHAN1896.72 -1896.72 My1896.72 question1896.96 is1897.52 about1900.56 things1900.56 that1900.88 don't1901.2 involve1901.52 money.1901.92 And1902.24 I1902.4 know1902.48 it's1902.72 not1902.96 within1903.36 our1903.92 domain1904.59 here,1905.14 but1905.55 I1906.27 come1906.51 from1906.83 the1907.07 position1907.22 of1907.7 looking1907.87 at1908.27 the1909.22 value1909.46 proposition1909.95 to1910.51 the1910.66 city1910.83 of1911.07 Watertown1911.31 of1912.59 someone1912.9 being1913.22 elected1913.55 to1913.95 the1914.11 city1914.27 council.1914.59 And1916.42 part1916.83 of1917.07 that1917.22 value1917.55 proposition1917.95 is1918.98 what1919.31 they1919.55 bring1919.79 to1920.24 the1920.48 table.1920.64 They've1921.12 been1921.36 elected,1922.16 so1922.48 presumably,1922.48 the1923.12 voters1923.28 say1923.84 that1924.08 there's1924.32 something1924.56 good1925.44 that1925.76 will1925.92 happen1926.16 for1926.56 Watertown1926.72 if1927.76 so1928 and1928.24 so1928.4 is1928.72 elected1928.88 and1930.96 they1931.2 become1931.36 a1931.76 member1931.84 of1932.16 the1932.24 council.1932.4 Having1934.64 a1935.04 stipend1935.2 or1935.76 an1935.92 honorarium,1936.16 I1936.88 appreciate1937.2 that1937.68 and1937.92 like1938.16 it1938.4 because1938.8 it1939.28 does1939.52 sort1939.85 of1940.09 recognize1940.33 the1941.04 wholeness1941.28 of1941.68 the1941.85 person1942 who1942.4 won1942.64 in1942.96 the1943.2 election1943.61 rather1944.72 than1945.13 a1945.85 more1946 mechanical1947.52 how1947.92 many1948.09 widgets1948.4 can1948.8 they1949.04 make,1949.2 you1949.74 know,1949.82 in1949.98 an1950.06 hour1950.38 on1950.7 an1950.86 assembly1951.1 line.1951.58 1953.18 But1953.18 that1953.74 said,1954.14 in1954.62 terms1954.78 of1955.02 whatever1955.26 the1955.66 number1955.9 is1956.22 and1956.54 however1956.78 frequently1957.58 we1958.14 adjust1958.38 it,1958.78 there1959.98 are1960.3 other1960.62 pieces1961.42 to1962.14 the1962.38 job1962.54 that1964.23 I1964.79 think1964.95 are1965.27 worth1965.51 highlighting1966.38 even1967.18 if1967.42 we1967.75 do1968.07 not1968.31 have1969.18 the1969.42 mandate1969.59 to1970.14 recommend1970.47 anything1971.03 on1971.51 them.1971.59 And1972.38 they1972.71 involve,1973.03 I'm1976.15 not1976.39 gonna1976.63 get1976.79 into1976.95 the1977.19 benefits1977.35 conversation1977.83 because1978.47 you1978.79 all1978.95 know1979.19 that1979.35 better1979.51 than1979.91 I1980.07 do,1980.23 but1981.03 subscriptions1981.83 to1982.87 relevant1983.03 publications1983.75 on1984.79 city1985.11 issues1985.51 that1986.15 are1986.39 current1986.79 and1987.27 real1987.59 for1987.99 the1988.15 city,1989.98 a1990.3 dedicated1990.3 cell1991.02 phone1991.35 that1991.74 is1992.14 only1992.38 for1992.63 council1992.94 use,1993.42 opportunities1995.59 for1996.63 learning1997.26 credits,1997.83 what1999.02 would1999.26 be1999.51 called1999.66 continuing1999.98 education2000.7 credits2001.26 in2001.66 another2001.83 field.2002.3 In2003.65 other2003.73 words,2004.05 in2005.09 your2005.25 experience2005.73 of2006.29 looking2006.45 at2006.85 the2007.17 various2007.41 incentive2008.53 structures2009.01 around2009.57 the2009.89 state2010.05 at2010.45 the2010.53 Collins2010.61 Center,2011.09 what2012.53 do2012.77 you2012.93 see2013.17 regarding2013.89 other2014.61 incentives2015.17 besides2016.36 pay,2017.15 besides2017.79 financial2018.52 incentives,2019.15 that2021.47 cities2022.12 are2022.67 talking2022.91 about2023.32 insofar2024.12 as2024.6 helping2026.67 councilors2027.47 get2028.86 smart2029.18 on2029.82 some2030.06 of2030.3 the2030.46 challenges2030.7 that2031.34 they're2031.5 facing2031.74 so2032.3 they're2032.54 not2032.78 just2033.02 relying2033.34 on2033.82 their2034.94 own2035.26 devices2035.58 literally2036.7 and2037.5 figuratively,2037.74 or2038.86 what2039.1 a2039.34 lobbyist2039.5 tells2040.06 them,2040.38 that2041.9 they2042.14 actually,2042.38 you2043.51 know,2043.66 I2043.83 mean,2043.98 is2044.22 there2044.38 any2044.54 discussion2044.87 about2045.35 that2045.66 kind2046.07 of,2046.3 I2047.74 guess,2047.98 more2048.3 quality2051.66 part2051.66 to2051.98 the2052.14 job2052.3 rather2052.7 than2053.03 the2053.18 quantitative2053.43 part2054.14 to2054.39 the2054.55 job?2054.7 2055.44 AICARDI2055.44 -2055.44 Sure.2055.44 That's2055.6 a2055.84 great2056.08 question.2056.32 We2057.12 see2057.52 varying2059.36 degrees2059.84 of2060.24 that.2060.4 In2061.2 my2061.44 experience,2061.76 many2064.08 city2065.52 councilors,2065.84 select2066.96 board2067.36 members2067.76 have2069.07 municipal2070.27 issued2070.91 tablets,2072.59 cell2073.86 phones.2074.18 It's2076.03 rare2076.66 not2077.07 to.2077.3 So2078.34 that2078.59 is2078.82 a2079.39 very2079.63 common2080.03 practice.2080.43 Meeting2083.11 agendas2083.75 are2084.23 on2084.47 their2084.63 tablets,2086.71 you2086.95 know.2086.95 That2086.95 is2086.95 becoming2087.19 more2087.83 and2088.15 more2088.39 common2088.71 so2089.35 that2089.51 everybody2089.75 has2090.31 their2090.55 tablets,2090.79 we're2091.83 not2092.07 using2092.31 as2092.63 much2092.87 paper,2093.11 cell2094.86 phones2095.18 provided2095.74 by2096.31 the2096.47 municipality.2096.7 Certainly,2098.22 membership2099.43 in2100.7 the2101.91 city2102.14 councilors2102.47 associations,2103.18 the2104.47 mayors2104.95 associations,2105.43 the2106.07 select2106.31 board2106.7 associations,2107.03 conferences,2108.51 the2109.15 MMA,2109.39 the2109.87 new2110.03 MMA2110.19 meeting2110.83 this2111.15 year,2111.31 351.2111.79 That's2113.71 very2114.27 common2114.83 and2115.39 rare2115.71 not2116.19 to2116.59 have2116.83 that.2117.15 The2118.11 issue2118.43 of2120.11 health2120.43 insurance2120.75 is2123.24 messy,2123.48 I2124.28 do2124.45 not2124.68 opine2124.93 on2125.41 that.2125.57 That2126.05 has2126.28 to2126.53 do2126.68 with,2126.84 you2127.09 know,2127.32 what2127.57 is2127.72 the2127.97 structure?2128.28 2129.32 Some2129.32 have2129.72 it,2129.89 some2130.2 don't.2130.53 The2131.32 rules2131.48 have2131.89 changed.2132.2 Time2133.24 in2133.57 the2133.72 pension2133.89 system.2134.36 That's2135.16 really2135.4 something2135.88 I2136.84 don't2137.24 feel2137.48 comfortable2137.8 opining2138.52 on.2139.16 Conferences2141.32 and2142.6 learning,2142.84 yes.2143.88 The2145.16 way2145.4 that,2145.72 in2146.52 terms2146.76 of2147.32 credits2149.63 and2150.18 educational,2150.51 there's2151.86 a2152.11 fine2152.26 line2152.51 between2152.82 professional2153.22 development2153.95 and2154.43 staying2154.59 in2154.91 the2155.14 know,2155.3 and2155.7 having2155.86 an2156.26 education2156.59 benefit.2157.47 So2158.18 I2158.51 would2158.66 hold2158.98 back2159.3 from2159.63 anything2160.43 like2160.98 that.2161.22 But2161.47 if2161.7 you're2161.78 going2162.18 to2162.59 the,2164.2 you2165.16 know,2165.4 City2166.12 Managers2166.44 Association's2167 conference2167.96 on2168.68 good2169 legislation,2169.32 or2170.04 the2170.2 Fair2170.6 Labor2170.76 Standards2171.08 Act,2171.64 or2171.88 something2172.04 like2172.36 of2172.76 course,2173 that's2173.32 professional2173.64 development2174.92 related2175.56 to2176.12 your2176.36 position2177.78 as2178.66 an2178.89 elected2179.05 official.2179.53 So2181.3 I2182.26 see2183.05 it's,2183.86 I2185.14 can2185.3 tell2185.45 by2185.69 the2185.93 looks2186.01 not2186.34 everybody2186.49 gets2186.89 a2187.21 cell2187.3 phone2187.53 or2187.69 a2187.93 tablet.2188.01 So,2188.57 I'm2189.63 sure2189.87 I'm2190.11 making2190.27 friends2190.59 left2191.07 and2191.39 right.2191.55

2193.71 SPEAKER12193.71 -2193.71 12193.71 second.2193.95 Yeah.2194.35 2195.07 FALKOFF2195.07 -2195.07 Clarification.2195.31 In2195.87 Watertown2196.11 we2196.59 get2196.67 computers.2196.91 2197.55 AICARDI2197.55 -2197.55 You2197.55 get2197.79 computers.2197.95 Okay,2198.91 a2199.07 laptop2199.07 or2199.71 something2199.87 like2200.19 that.2200.43 2200.75 FALKOFF2200.75 -2200.75 Even2200.75 when,2200.99 like2201.56 Doug,2201.95 I2202.11 spilled2202.43 water2202.76 all2203.08 over2203.24 my2203.47 computer2203.64 and2204.11 broke2204.28 it,2204.68 they2204.91 just2204.91 gave2205.08 me2205.24 a2205.36 new2205.47 one.2205.64 2206.04 AICARDI2206.04 -2206.04 Excellent.2206.28 2210.11 SCOTT2210.11 -2210.11 Thank2210.11 you.2210.43 2211.08 AICARDI2211.08 -2211.08 Sure.2211.08

2220.36 SPEAKER82220.36 -2220.36 I2220.36 love2220.52 it.2220.76 2233.16 AICARDI2233.16 -2233.16 Yeah.2233.16 Absolutely.2233.64 And2234.2 I2234.36 am2234.51 going2234.68 to2234.84 follow-up2234.99 with2235.39 Worcester,2235.55 and2235.95 that's2236.11 a2236.36 specific2236.51 question2236.91 that2237.32 I2237.47 will2237.64 get2237.8 answered2237.95 for2238.28 you2238.51 and2238.68 send2238.91 it2239.07 to2239.23 you.2239.32 Great.2240.03 Well,2240.28 I2240.43 wish2240.51 you2240.76 luck2240.91 in2241.07 all2241.23 of2241.39 your2241.55 deliberations.2241.72

2243 SPEAKER52243 -2243 Thank2243 you2243.24 very2243.4 much,2243.56 Mary.2243.72 You're2244.04 very,2244.12 very2244.36 helpful.2244.52

2245.56 SPEAKER12245.56 -2245.56 Thank2245.56 you.2245.72 Thank2246.04 you.2246.12

2249.4 SPEAKER102249.4 -2249.4 Oh,2249.4 yes,2249.72 Mary.2250.04 She2250.44 is.2250.68 2253.32 BARTLEY2253.32 -2253.32 Okay.2253.32 The2254.28 next2254.44 item2254.68 on2255 the2255.08 agenda2255.24 is2255.72 really,2257.08 we're2257.34 gonna2257.34 start2257.51 to2257.59 have2257.66 a2257.99 discussion,2258.14 you2259.18 know,2259.34 as2259.51 far2259.66 as2259.91 where2259.99 we're2260.22 gonna2260.39 go.2260.55 I2261.51 think2261.66 that,2261.99 I2263.59 wanna2263.91 hear2264.14 from2264.47 the2265.03 committee2265.18 members2265.51 as2265.91 far2266.07 as,2266.31 you2266.55 know,2266.7 what2266.95 you2267.51 see2267.74 as2267.91 the2267.99 next2268.14 steps.2268.39 There2268.95 have2269.11 been2269.27 some2269.43 committee2269.59 members2269.82 who2270.14 have2270.39 provided2270.63 analysis.2271.99 I2273.26 think2273.5 it2273.66 behooves2273.82 us2274.14 that2274.38 we2274.54 go2274.78 through2275.02 that2275.18 and2277.82 then2278.06 look2278.62 at2278.86 next2279.1 steps2279.34 from2279.66 there.2279.82 Does2280.06 that2280.46 make2280.62 sense2280.86 to2281.26 the2281.42 committee?2281.5 So,2283.42 Sarah2284.54 and2284.78 Linda,2284.94 you2285.26 both2285.34 had2285.58 give2285.74 proposals.2285.98 Does2287.1 anyone,2287.34 and2289.14 Jim.2289.3 I'm2289.61 sorry.2289.7 Does2290.26 anyone2290.49 prefer2291.3 to2291.61 go2291.78 first2291.93 or2292.18 how2292.41 do2292.97 you2293.14 wanna2293.22 do2293.38 it?2293.54 2295.38 SCOTT2295.38 -2295.38 We2295.38 could2295.54 just2295.7 have2295.86 a2296.09 conversation.2297.06 I2297.61 think2297.78 that2298.02 makes2298.26 sense2298.49 too,2298.89 don't2299.14 you?2299.3 2300.49 BARTLEY2300.49 -2300.49 Well,2300.49 I2300.74 think2300.82 some2301.3 of2301.45 the2301.54 analysis2301.7 was2302.18 different,2304.23 but,2304.63 Linda,2304.87 you2305.11 2306.31 SCOTT2306.31 -2306.31 I2306.31 think2306.55 we2306.55 were2306.55 pretty2306.71 close2306.95 on2307.19 some2307.43 things.2307.59 2307.59 BARTLEY2307.59 -2307.59 Oh,2307.99 I2308.15 think2308.47 you2308.63 were2308.79 very2308.95 close.2309.11 I2309.43 think2309.59 the2309.75 numbers2309.83 were2310.23 very2310.39 close,2310.55 but2310.79 I2310.95 just2311.19 think2311.35 that,2311.51 you2311.75 know,2311.91 getting2312.15 to2312.31 yes2312.95 was,2313.11 you2313.11 know,2313.27 people2313.59 looked2313.91 at2314.07 different2314.23 factors,2314.55 I2315.03 thought,2315.19 anyway.2315.43 But,2315.91 Linda,2316.07 why2316.39 don't2316.55 we2316.71 begin2316.87 with,2317.78 your2318.18 thoughts2318.49 and2318.89 it's2320.02 part2320.18 of2320.41 the2320.49 conversation.2320.66 2321.7 SCOTT2321.7 -2321.7 The2321.7 report,2321.93 I2322.34 was2322.49 telling2322.66 Doug,2322.97 the2323.22 report2323.38 I2323.78 sent2324.26 in2324.58 was2326.09 missing2326.41 three2327.78 municipalities,2328.41 and2329.22 they2329.3 all2329.45 got2329.61 back2329.86 to2330.02 me2330.18 the2330.34 day2330.41 after2330.66 I2331.06 submitted2331.3 the2331.54 report,2332.5 so2332.74 I2332.74 have2332.9 a2333.06 new2333.14 report2333.38 to2333.78 submit2334.26 for2334.58 that.2334.74 And2335.06 I2335.3 agree2335.46 with2336.58 Mary2336.82 that2337.22 you2337.54 can2338.02 certainly2338.26 see2338.82 by2339.14 whether2341.06 people2342.18 work2342.5 for2342.82 no2342.98 money,2343.14 or2343.62 a2344.1 small2344.34 amount,2344.66 or2345.2 a2345.45 very,2345.68 you2346.09 know,2346.24 there2346.49 are2346.81 different2346.97 philosophies2347.36 about,2348.16 and2349.29 I2349.45 think2349.61 we2349.84 kind2350.09 of2350.57 fall2350.89 into2351.13 the2351.45 middle2351.53 of2351.84 it.2351.93 We2352.24 fall2352.49 into2352.72 we're2353.61 not2353.84 so2354.09 rich2354.24 that2354.49 we2354.72 can't2354.89 have2355.29 a2355.77 few2355.84 dollars2356.16 for2356.49 all2356.64 the2356.81 work2356.97 we2357.13 do2357.29 and2357.61 we're2358.16 doing2358.41 it2358.64 for2358.81 the2358.97 town2359.13 too.2359.36 I2359.68 think2359.77 it's2360.18 a2360.34 combination2360.5 of2361.06 things.2361.3 Whereas,2361.86 you2362.5 look2362.74 at2362.9 some2363.06 very2363.86 old2364.18 communities2364.66 that2365.22 are2365.38 very2365.62 affluent,2366.1 and2366.82 there2367.06 you2367.3 find2367.46 a2368.34 lot2368.42 of2368.58 times2368.74 it's2369.14 done2369.38 for2369.62 free,2369.78 but2370.18 maybe2370.74 it's2371.14 because2371.3 no2372.02 one2372.18 needs2372.34 that2372.74 extra2372.98 money2373.38 too,2373.94 you2374.02 know,2374.02 it2374.34 may2374.42 be2374.66 that.2374.82 So,2375.36 anyway,2375.59 on2376.32 the2376.39 first2376.55 page2376.8 of2377.03 that2377.2 document,2377.43 I2377.99 went2378.16 from2378.39 average2379.84 councilor,2380.24 stipend2381.36 for2381.76 neighboring2381.99 communities2382.72 was2383.68 $9,375.2384.32 Average2387.03 council2387.59 salary2388.34 stipend2388.66 for2389.14 the2389.38 same2389.54 government2389.86 was2390.34 $9,259.2390.5

2392.42 SPEAKER102392.42 -2392.42 Sorry,2392.42 Linda.2392.66 Can2393.06 I2393.22 ask2393.38

2393.86 SPEAKER32393.86 -2393.86 Oh,2393.86 I'm2394.1 sorry?2394.18 I2394.58 mean,2394.66 you're2394.82 hearing2395.06 me?2395.3 2395.46 BAKER2395.46 -2395.46 Yeah.2395.46 Which2395.7 communities,2396.98 when2397.46 you2397.62 said2397.78 neighboring2397.94 communities,2399.3 which2399.54 communities2399.78 did2400.34 you2400.5 use2401.46 for2401.63 that2401.78 average?2402.18 And2402.51 then2402.74 the2402.82 same2402.98 government2403.22 communities,2403.7 which2404.26 communities2404.51 did2404.91 you2405.14 use2405.22 for2405.39 that?2405.55 2406.26 SCOTT2406.26 -2406.26 For2406.26 neighboring2406.59 communities,2407.07 I2408.34 used2408.59 the2408.82 things2409.07 around2409.39 us2409.7 who2409.94 basically2410.18 were2410.74 in2410.98 the2411.3 chamber.2411.55 What2414.34 is2414.59 it2414.74 called?2414.91 The2415.3 Charles2416.74 River2416.98 Chamber.2417.22 So2417.54 we2417.7 had2417.78 Arlington,2418.02 Belmont,2418.5 Needham,2418.98 Newton,2419.78 Waltham,2420.34 Watertown,2421.06 Wellesley,2421.62 and2422.02 Weston.2422.18 2425.14 BAKER2425.14 -2425.14 Can2425.14 I2425.3 ask,2426.1 so2426.34 all2426.34 of2426.5 those2426.66 don't2427.06 have2427.38 2428.1 SCOTT2428.34 -2428.34 I2428.34 included2428.5 contiguous2429.68 communities2430.24 but2430.81 you're2430.97 right,2431.2 Elodia.2431.36 I2432.72 also2432.97 included2433.36 Wellesley2433.84 and2434.57 one2434.81 of2434.97 the2435.13 others2435.29 because,2437.36 and2437.53 Needham,2437.53 they2437.53 weren't2437.53 contiguous2437.77 but2438.72 they're2438.97 part2439.13 of2439.36 the2439.53 chamber2440.16 so2440.41 I2440.41 thought2440.57 they2440.89 are2441.13 part2441.84 of2442.16 our2442.32 surrounding2442.92 community.2443.48 And,2444.52 you2446.92 know,2447.08 when2447.4 I2447.64 did2448.2 the2448.52 numbers2449.08 on2449.48 those,2449.72 they2450.2 came2450.44 out2450.6 fairly2450.92 low.2451.32 When2452.44 I'm2453.8 looking2453.96 at2454.28 the2454.44 government2454.6 community,2455.16 the2455.96 government,2456.12 I2458.43 used2458.66 the2459.47 MMA2459.95 designation2461.87 for2462.51 government.2462.74 So2463.14 we2463.31 have2463.47 Amherst,2463.7 believe2464.43 it2464.74 or2464.91 not,2464.99 Barnstable,2465.31 Bridgewater,2466.03 Chelsea,2466.74 Long2467.39

2467.79 SPEAKER42467.79 -2467.79 East.2467.79

2468.18 BAKER2468.18 -2468.18 Can2468.18 I2468.43 ask2468.59 one2468.83 more2468.99 question2469.14 about2469.39 those2469.55 neighboring2469.79 communities?2470.11 Those2470.99 don't2471.4 all2471.4 have2471.64 city2471.8 councils.2472.2 So2472.92 you2473.16 were2473.24 just2473.4 looking2473.64 at2473.96 2474.44 SCOTT2474.44 -2474.44 I2474.44 was2474.6 just2474.84 looking2475.08 at2475.4 what's2475.48 around2475.8 us.2476.12 2476.68 BAKER2476.68 -2476.68 And2476.68 but2476.92 what2477.16 numbers2477.4 did2477.72 you2477.96 pull2478.12 from2478.36 what's2478.6 around2478.92 us2479.16 to2479.4 do2479.48 the2479.72 average?2479.8 2481.48 SCOTT2481.48 -2481.48 I2482.6 was2482.84 pulling2483.16 things2483.64 like,2483.96 population2484.6 for2485.78 two2485.93 years.2486.18 I2486.74 pulled2486.97 the,2487.3 let2487.93 me2488.09 look2488.26 at2488.41 the,2491.22 I2491.22 pulled2491.38 residential2491.78 tax2492.41 rate.2492.66 2492.97 BAKER2492.97 -2492.97 Oh,2492.97 sorry.2493.14 I'm2493.38 sorry.2493.54 When2494.18 you2494.34 say2494.49 your2494.66 that2495.06 first2496.02 number,2496.34 the2496.66 salary,2496.82 you're2498.19 looking2498.51 at2498.75 the2498.91 average2499.07 salary.2499.47 Not2499.95 all2500.27 of2500.35 those2500.51 communities2500.75 have2501.47 city2501.87 councils2502.27 like2502.83 we2503.07 do,2503.79 so2504.03 what2504.03 salaries2504.43 were2504.91 you2505.15 averaging2505.39 to2506.35 get2506.51 to2506.75 that2506.91 93.75?2507.23 2509.91 SCOTT2509.91 -2509.91 Whatever2510.47 their2510.95 stipend2511.27 was,2511.74 whatever2512.07 their2512.47 salary2512.7 was,2513.11 I2513.51 called2513.91 around2514.14 and2514.47 I2514.63 found2514.78 out2515.03 yearly2515.18 what2516.14 they2516.39 got2516.55 for2516.86 doing2517.03 their2517.34 job.2517.59 2518.14 BAKER2518.14 -2518.14 So2518.14 whether2518.39 that2518.63 was2518.86 a2519.99 different2520.07 form2520.39 of2520.55 government,2520.7 whoever2521.03 2521.34 BAKER2521.34 -2521.34 That's2521.34 right.2521.59 It2521.91 wasn't2522.3 related2523.56 to2524.04 kind2524.28 of2524.52 government.2524.68 I2525.08 just2525.32 said,2525.48 okay,2526.2 who's2526.52 around2526.52 us2526.84 in2527.16 our2527.32 area?2527.56 What2528.12 are2528.28 they2528.44 making?2528.68 Let's2529.32 figure2529.56 that2529.8 out.2530.04 2530.28 BARTLEY2530.28 -2530.28 And2530.28 the2530.44 basis2530.6 you2531 had2531.16 was2531.4 using,2531.88 your2532.92 criteria2533.16 was2533.88 to2534.12 use2534.28 the2535.64 business,2535.88 the2536.36 chamber,2536.52 those2537.08 communities2537.32 in2537.72 the2537.88 chamber?2537.96 2538.28 SCOTT2538.28 -2538.28 Well,2538.28 no,2540.72 Elodia2540.73 is2540.73 right,2540.75 I2540.76 misspoke.2540.92 I2542.05 used2542.28 contiguous2543.01 communities2543.64 like2544.28 Arlington2544.92 and,2545.48 you2546.28 know,2547.09 Belmont.2547.48 But2548.28 I2548.44 also2548.61 said,2548.92 let2549.24 me2549.4 include2549.57 Wellesley2550.05 and2551.01 Needham2551.24 because2551.64 they're2552.05 in2552.28 the2552.44 chamber2553.24 and2553.73 they're2553.73 part2554.05 of2554.29 some2554.45 of2554.61 the2554.69 decisions2554.85 that2555.33 happened.2555.49 So2555.81 let2555.97 me2556.13 just2556.29 throw2556.53 them2556.77 in2556.93 to2557.09 see2557.17 what2557.41 happens.2557.57 And2558.85 then2558.93 I2559.09 got2559.33 their2560.21 compensation.2561.81 Wellesley2564.21 and2564.69 Weston2564.85 don't2565.41 give2565.73 their2565.97 councilors2566.21 anything.2566.77 I2567.81 got2568.05 the2569.7 total2569.94 that2570.66 was2571.3 spent2571.63 on2571.94 councilors2572.11 and2573.7 then2573.94 I2574.18 was2574.34 able2574.59 to2574.82 get2575.07 a2575.46 percentage2575.7 of2577.55 the2577.78 budget2578.03 that2578.98 these2579.55 salaries2579.78 go2580.34 to,2580.59 and2580.91 it2581.14 was2581.22 pretty2581.7 small.2582.64 I2584.08 talked2584.32 to2584.56 a2584.8 councilor2585.12 in2585.52 another2585.68 town2586 and2586.24 he2586.48 asked2586.56 me2586.8 this2586.96 question.2587.2 He2587.44 said,2587.6 while2587.84 you're2588.08 looking2588.24 at2588.56 this,2588.64 what's2592.16 the2592.48 dent2592.64 in2592.88 the2593.04 budget2593.2 to2593.68 have2593.92 these2595.14 particular,2595.45 you2596.34 know,2596.57 rates,2596.82 these2597.54 particular2597.86 amounts2598.82 of2599.14 money?2599.3 2600.18 And2600.18 so2600.41 I2600.57 did2600.74 that2600.97 too.2601.22 And2601.61 so2602.26 it's2602.41 a2602.66 really2602.74 odd2603.05 number.2603.3 It's2603.7 a2603.93 loose2604.09 number.2604.41 But2605.22 I2605.7 think2605.86 it's2606.18 something2606.85 that2608.21 Councilor2609.33 Piccirilli2609.65 and2609.65 the2609.81 group2609.89 can2610.21 use2610.37 when2610.77 they're2611.01 justifying2611.25 how2613.41 much2613.65 the2614.05 raise2614.21 is.2614.53 Because2614.85 for2615.89 instance,2616.13 in2616.61 Arlington,2616.77 every2618.13 man,2618.45 woman2618.69 and2619.09 child,2619.17 if2619.65 that2620.05 were2620.21 the2620.45 only2620.53 revenue2620.85 was2621.86 everyone2622.17 in2622.57 town2622.82 had2623.53 to2623.78 give2623.93 a2624.17 tax2624.34 toward2625.3 the2625.61 town,2625.78 we2626.09 didn't2626.26 have2626.57 commercial,2626.73 we2627.14 had2627.3 nothing,2627.45 it2628.41 would2628.66 still2628.89 be2629.21 33¢2629.45 in2630.26 Arlington2630.49 that2630.97 every2631.21 man,2631.53 woman2631.69 and2632.01 child2632.17 would2632.49 pay2632.73 in2633.05 a2633.3 year2633.38 to2634.17 have2634.33 a2634.57 council,2634.73 to2635.53 support2635.77 a2636.09 council.2636.25 By2637.69 the2637.93 time2638.01 you2638.17 get2638.33 to2638.49 Watertown,2638.97 it's2639.21 $2.31.2639.45 Again,2640.73 it's2641.53 a2641.77 silly2641.93 number2642.25 but2642.73 it's2642.97 a2643.21 number2643.37 in2643.77 the2643.93 sense2644.09 that2644.41 if2646.04 we2646.11 have2646.36 revenue2646.68 numbers2647.16 for2647.47 all2647.72 of2647.88 it,2647.95 we2648.28 can2648.52 figure2648.68 out,2649.08 we2649.95 spend2650.2 this2650.43 much2650.59 a2650.84 year2650.99 on2651.24 salaries.2651.39 How2652.36 much2652.59 does2652.76 that2652.99 really2653.24 mean2653.56 in2653.95 terms2654.11 because2654.43 people2654.68 are2654.99 going,2655.08 our2655.32 taxes2655.47 are2655.95 going2656.11 up?2656.36 Well,2656.68 if2656.99 your2657.16 taxes2657.39 for2658.04 this2658.2 are2658.59 going2658.76 up2658.99 81¢,2659.32 is2661.03 that2661.19 really2661.43 something2661.75 you2662.07 should2662.23 worry2662.39 about?2662.71 You2663.43 know,2663.59 so2663.91 I2664.15 thought2664.31 that2664.55 might2664.79 be2665.03 something2665.19 that2665.75 people2665.91 wanna2666.23 use2667.43 as2667.91 one2669.51 way2669.67 to2669.91 look2669.99 at2670.23 this.2670.39 2670.71 We2670.71 are2671.11 not2671.35 taking2672.15 a2672.47 major2672.63 hit2672.64 on2672.66 the2672.67 budget2672.69 when2672.7 we2672.71 do2672.73 something2672.74 like2672.76 this.2672.77 This2672.79 is2672.8 what2672.84 the2672.86 amount2672.87 is.2673.27 I2674.32 then2674.61 went2675.05 on2675.05 to2675.05 government.2675.05 And,2675.05 again,2675.05 I2675.05 used2675.05 MMA2675.05 for2675.05 the2675.05 same2675.05 kind2675.05 of2675.05 government.2675.05 I2675.05 stopped2675.07 short2675.1 of2675.13 Cambridge,2675.15 Lowell,2675.18 and2675.2 Worcester2675.76 because2676.05 they2676.32 are2676.6 slightly2676.88 different2690.72 in2691.6 the2691.68 MA2692.32 notification2694.72 on2695.36 it.2695.52 And2696 we2697.04 were2697.28 told2697.52 that2697.84 Cambridge2698.08 and2698.56 Boston2698.8 were2699.2 communities2699.84 that2700.16 we2700.47 probably2700.64 shouldn't2701.03 include2701.43 because2701.84 they2702.07 were2702.23 so2702.39 different.2702.64 So2702.88 I2703.11 figured2703.28 that2703.59 was2703.76 okay.2703.99 Again,2704.72 residential2707.03 tax2707.76 rates,2708.07 square2709.36 miles,2709.84 you2711.77 can2711.93 see2712.09 on2712.65 page2713.45 10,2713.93 you2714.33 can2714.49 see2714.73 same2714.97 form2715.21 of2715.53 government.2715.69 You2716.41 can2716.49 go2716.65 down2716.81 the2716.97 list2717.13 and2717.37 you2717.49 can2717.61 see2717.77 what2717.93 the2718.17 salaries2718.33 are2718.81 for2719.53 each2719.69 of2719.93 these.2720.01 You2721.61 know,2721.77 some2722.01 of2722.25 them2722.41 came2722.65 in2722.89 very2723.13 late2723.45 to2723.61 me2723.77 but2724.01 I2724.33 did2724.41 get2724.65 them.2724.89 So,2725.21 you2725.93 can2726.09 see2726.41 same2727.28 form2727.53 of2727.76 government,2728.01 very2728.89 different2729.13 attitude2729.53 depending2730.01 on2730.32 what2730.48 community2731.05 you're2731.76 from.2732.01 It2732.96 goes2733.13 from2733.36 a2733.76 lot2733.84 of2734.09 zeros2734.24 all2735.36 the2735.61 way2735.68 up2735.84 to2736.01 $28,000,2737.28 Okay?2738.8 2739.89 So2739.89 when2740.69 I2741.01 started2741.17 doing2741.49 averaging,2742.37 I2742.85 took2743.01 the2743.17 zeros2743.41 off2743.81 because2743.97 I2744.21 just2744.37 didn't2744.53 think2744.77 they2745.01 counted2745.17 and2745.97 I2746.29 averaged2746.77 those.2747.17 It2748.13 is2749.33 not2749.49 the2749.73 strongest2749.89 way2750.37 to2750.53 look2750.61 at2750.85 things2750.93 but2751.25 I2751.41 just2751.49 thought,2751.73 let's2751.89 look2752.13 at2752.37 it.2752.53 It2753.09 doesn't2753.25 hurt2753.49 to2753.73 look.2753.89 And2754.7 then2754.86 it2755.09 started2755.26 to2755.66 get2755.82 more2755.97 into2756.22 the2756.53 range2756.7 when2756.93 I2757.18 looked2757.26 at2757.49 the2757.57 compensation2757.82 communities2758.53 because2759.18 then2760.14 it's2760.53 it's2760.86 raising2761.26 into2761.66 the,2762.3 you2764.3 know,2764.45 the2764.7 12,000,2764.93 which2766.3 is2766.53 where2766.86 your2767.26 data2769.43 started2769.83 to2770.15 come2770.23 in2770.47 into2770.79 the2771.03 12,0002771.27 as2771.99 well.2772.23 So2772.63 I2772.87 think2772.95 we2773.19 weren't2773.43 that2773.83 far2774.07 off,2774.39 Yours2774.71 is2774.95 a2775.11 little2775.27 higher.2775.51 And2776.07 by2776.31 the2776.55 way,2776.63 I2776.95 went2777.03 through2777.35 also,2777.75 and2778.79 I2778.95 can2779.11 give2779.27 you2779.43 a2779.59 copy2779.75 of2779.99 it,2780.15 and2780.39 I2780.63 went2780.79 through2781.11 all2782.49 those2782.73 communities2787.05 and2787.05 Waltham2787.86 actually2788.49 is2788.89 1%2789.21 off2789.78 from2790.01 the2790.34 calculation2790.57 you2791.21 have2791.38 for2791.61 what2791.86 they2792.01 should2792.18 be2792.41 making2792.57 based2793.3 on2793.61 that2793.78 budget2794.01 that2795.23 you,2795.71 that2796.03 budget2796.27 ratio.2796.59 Waltham2797.47 evidently2798.11 is2799.47 doing2799.63 that,2800.27 nobody2800.67 else2800.67 is2800.91 quite2801.07 doing2801.31 that.2801.55 And2801.87 we're2802.03 68%2802.35 of2803.47 what2803.71 we2804.03 should2804.19 be2804.43 making2804.59 according2805.07 to2806.11 that2806.27 budget.2806.43 So2806.75 I2806.99 went2807.07 through2807.23 and2807.47 did2807.55 the2807.71 percentages2807.87 on2808.51 that.2808.75 So2809.57 I2809.89 mean,2809.97 she's2810.37 given2810.68 us,2810.93 Mary's2811.16 given2811.49 us2811.72 some2811.89 more2812.05 food2812.29 for2812.53 thought2812.77 in2814.05 terms2814.37 of2814.68 we2816.45 can2816.68 kind2816.93 of2817.24 throw2817.24 it2817.49 out2817.64 and2817.81 say2817.97 we2818.13 think2818.2 they2818.45 deserve2818.61 this.2819.09 2819.41 However,2819.41 if2820.85 we2821.01 don't2821.16 have2821.41 some2821.64 numbers,2821.81 some2822.2 solid2822.45 numbers,2822.77 they're2824.15 gonna2824.39 have2824.55 a2824.79 very2824.87 hard2825.19 time2825.35 convincing2825.75 people2826.15 in2826.47 town2826.55 they2826.87 deserve2827.11 that.2827.43 And2828.07 that2828.55 was2828.71 your2828.87 first2829.03 point2829.27 when2829.59 we2829.83 were2829.99 talking2830.07 about2830.39 that.2830.63 It2834.31 will2834.47 be2834.71 lovely2834.87 to2835.35 say2835.43 to2835.59 them,2835.75 you2835.99 deserve2836.63 the2837.11 world,2837.27 but2837.83 it2837.99 isn't2838.15 gonna2838.47 help2838.79 them,2839.89 you2840.13 know?2840.13 It's2840.13 not2840.13 gonna2840.29 help2840.61 them2840.77 get2841.01 a2841.16 raise.2841.33 So,2842.2 we2843.09 need2843.24 to2843.49 have2843.57 some2843.72 backup2843.97 on2844.29 it.2844.45 And2844.61 then2844.77 the2844.93 last2845.01 one2845.33 was2845.57 the2845.72 comparison2845.97 of2846.45 the2846.53 communities2846.68 for2847.81 the2848.05 compensation2848.2 study,2848.85 and2849.16 that's2849.41 where2849.72 the2849.97 numbers2850.13 started2850.53 to2850.93 get2851.09 into2851.24 the2851.49 12s.2851.64 They2852.29 started2852.53 to2852.93 get2853.09 into2853.24 30%2854.38 higher2855.1 just2855.42 like2855.66 the2856.3 salaries2856.54 went2857.1 up2857.34 30%.2857.5 So2858.94 I2859.5 thought2859.66 that2859.9 was2860.14 a2860.38 real2860.54 connection2860.86 there.2861.26 Do2863.58 we2863.82 figure2864.14 out,2864.46 the2864.7 other2864.78 thing2865.02 I2865.18 found2865.34 was2865.66 that2865.9 in2867.42 terms2867.66 of2867.9 population2868.14 with2868.94 this2869.1 group,2869.42 we're2870.91 below2871.95 the2873.88 middle2874.91 but2875.07 when2875.07 it2875.32 comes2875.39 to2875.64 density,2875.8 we're2876.43 really2876.91 near2877.24 the2877.55 top.2877.72 So2878.11 we2878.51 might2878.76 wanna2878.99 think2879.39 about2879.72 that2880.03 in2880.28 terms2880.43 of2880.68 complexity.2881.55 And2881.72 do2881.72 we2881.88 wanna2882.03 add2882.28 more2882.51 to2882.68 it2882.84 because,2882.99 you2884.25 know,2884.41 that2884.65 density2884.89 is2885.37 worth2885.53 something2885.77 too2886.17 in2886.49 terms2886.65 of2887.61 the2887.77 difficulty2888.01 of2888.57 making2888.65 decisions.2888.97 So2890.57 at2891.29 any2891.45 rate,2891.69 that's2891.93 what2892.41 I2892.57 have.2892.65 2892.97 BARTLEY2892.97 -2892.97 That's2892.97 great.2893.13 Thank2895.45 you,2895.69 Linda,2896.25 for2896.57 talking2896.73 about2896.97 your2897.29 analysis2897.45 and2898.09 your,2901.34 you2901.66 know,2901.73 the2902.05 document2902.3 that2902.7 you2902.86 put2903.01 together.2903.18 What2904.3 I'd2904.61 like2904.7 to2904.86 do2904.93 is2905.09 is2905.26 turn2905.49 it2905.73 over2905.89 to2906.14 Sarah2906.38 for2907.97 her2908.21 to2908.45 talk2908.61 about2908.78 the2910.05 analysis2910.3 that2910.86 she2911.09 had2911.26 done.2911.41 Sarah,2912.21 the2912.93 floor2913.01 is2913.26 yours.2913.41 2914.32 BAKER2914.32 -2914.32 Thanks,2914.32 Linda.2914.56 And2914.96 I2915.04 love2915.2 your2915.36 point2915.6 that2915.84 we're2916.24 all2916.48 kind2916.64 of2916.88 convening,2918.64 and2918.8 that2918.8 was2918.96 my2919.2 thought.2919.36 Basically,2919.84 first,2920.32 Jim,2920.56 based2920.88 on2921.12 your2921.28 proposal,2921.52 which2922.48 to2922.8 me2922.96 just2923.28 kind2923.6 of2923.76 made2923.92 sense.2924.24 And2924.8 I2924.96 think2925.04 all2925.28 of2925.44 us,2925.6 if2925.76 we2925.92 had2926 to,2926.16 like,2926.32 write2926.56 a2926.72 number2926.88 down,2927.2 and2927.44 put2927.52 it2927.68 in2927.84 a2928 hat,2928.08 and2928.41 you2928.49 pulled2928.57 out2928.8 the2928.89 numbers2929.13 from2929.45 the2929.61 hat,2929.77 I2930.09 don't2930.16 think2930.41 we'd2930.64 have2930.89 that2931.13 wide2931.36 a2931.68 range.2931.68 But2933.13 to2933.36 the2933.53 point2933.68 of2933.93 saying,2934.09 okay,2934.32 there's2934.72 the2934.97 top2935.13 down2935.36 and2935.61 the2935.77 bottom2935.84 up,2938.01 my2938.24 thought2938.24 here2938.57 was2938.89 to2939.53 look2939.68 at2939.93 a2940.16 few2940.24 different2940.49 ways2940.8 of2941.28 doing2941.45 a2941.77 bottom2941.93 up.2942.24 I,2942.91 for2943.23 the2943.55 record,2943.63 do2944.03 not2944.19 recommend2944.43 that2944.91 we2945.07 calculate2945.31 a2946.03 number,2946.19 to2947.23 what2947.39 Mary2947.71 said2948.03 and2948.35 also2948.59 to2948.83 the2948.99 fact2949.15 that2949.39 if2949.63 we2949.79 were2949.95 to2950.03 calculate2950.19 a2950.59 number,2950.67 we'd2950.91 have2951.15 to2951.31 do2951.39 all2951.55 the2951.71 same2951.87 work2952.11 to2952.35 justify2952.51 the2953.31 methodology2953.55 we're2954.19 using.2955.09 And2955.17 there2955.17 are2955.41 holes2955.49 in2955.73 any2955.97 methodology2956.21 you2956.78 use2956.93 because2957.17 there2957.49 are2957.65 so2957.89 many2958.14 variables,2958.38 as2958.86 you2959.01 said.2959.17 2960.14 So2960.14 my2960.38 point2960.53 here2961.01 was2961.97 to2962.3 start2962.45 looking2962.93 at2963.26 a2963.82 range.2963.97 And2965.01 the2965.17 reason2965.34 I2965.57 like2965.73 ranges2965.97 is2966.78 because2966.93 when2967.49 the2968.45 city2968.61 did2968.93 their2969.09 compensation2969.65 and2970.05 salary2970.37 study,2970.69 I2971.49 think2971.65 they2971.81 arrived2971.97 at2972.13 a2972.29 range2972.37 and2972.61 then2972.69 they2972.85 wanted2973.01 to2973.25 go2973.33 to2973.49 the2973.57 75th2973.73 percentile2974.29 of2975.65 what2975.89 the2976.13 range2976.29 was2976.61 and2976.93 say,2977.17 hey,2977.33 this2977.49 is2977.65 where2977.81 we2978.05 as2978.21 a2978.37 community2978.53 want2979.01 to2979.17 put2979.25 our2979.57 salaries.2979.81 I2980.53 could2980.69 be2980.77 misremembering2980.93 this,2981.57 so2981.89 somebody2982.05 correct2982.29 me2982.53 if2982.69 I'm2982.85 wrong.2982.93 My2983.59 thought2983.84 was,2983.99 hey,2984.15 we2984.39 get2984.47 to2984.64 a2984.71 range,2985.11 we2985.28 roughly2985.28 agree2985.51 on2985.84 the2985.91 range,2986.23 we2986.39 go2986.39 to2986.64 the2986.71 75th2986.88 percentile2987.36 of2987.76 the2987.91 range.2987.99 And2988.23 it's2989.03 just2989.28 a2989.51 way2989.59 of2989.91 being2989.99 ultimately2990.64 reasonable.2991.19 So2993.03 I2993.67 wanted2993.91 to2994.15 put2994.23 numbers2994.55 on2995.19 the2995.36 paper2995.59 for2996.07 all2996.23 of2996.39 us2996.55 just2996.8 to2997.59 have2997.76 a2998.32 common2998.47 framework2999.38 for2999.7 us2999.78 to3000.1 start3000.18 discussing3000.34 these3000.9 numbers.3001.06 Reasonable3003.06 assessment,3003.54 we3004.02 could3004.1 also3004.26 throw3004.58 darts3004.98 at3005.38 a3005.7 dart3006.1 board3006.34 to3006.66 get3006.74 there.3006.9 But3007.14 I3007.3 said,3007.46 okay,3007.7 we've3008.5 heard3008.74 that3009.06 what3009.22 the3009.46 compensation3009.62 is3010.18 right3010.34 now3010.58 is3010.9 out3011.14 of3011.3 sync3011.94 with3012.26 the3012.42 complexity3012.58 of3013.14 the3013.22 job.3013.38 It's3014.1 the3014.42 COLA3015.28 extension3015.59 from,3015.84 what,3016.16 19823016.32 or3016.95 something3017.11 like3017.43 that.3017.59 Hand3019.2 wavy3019.52 with3019.76 numbers3019.99 here.3020.32 3022.16 So3022.16 if3022.32 you3022.56 multiply3022.8 that3023.28 by3023.52 1.53023.68 or3024.32 by3024.56 2,3024.72 just3025.04 to3025.28 say,3025.36 hey,3025.59 the3025.76 job3025.91 has3026.16 gotten3026.32 50%3026.72 or3027.36 100%3027.52 more3028.07 complicated,3028.24 where3030.31 does3030.6 that3030.9 stipend3031.19 go?3031.49 And3032.07 so3032.37 that,3032.66 there3033.25 are3033.55 pros3033.84 and3034.14 cons3034.43 to3034.73 that.3035.02 All3035.61 of3035.9 you3036.2 could3036.49 add3036.79 to3037.08 the3037.38 pros3037.67 and3037.97 cons.3038.26 But3038.85 you'll3039.14 see3039.44 if3039.73 we're3040.03 a3040.32 baseline3040.62 8,900,3040.91 1.5,3041.36 a3043.41 50%3043.68 raise3044.33 gets3044.64 you3044.81 to3044.89 13,350.3045.53 The3047.84 middle,3048.09 1.753048.49 is3049.45 15,575,3050.81 that's3051.13 a3051.13 little3051.13 close3051.13 to3051.45 Jim's3051.61 proposal.3051.93 And3052.81 the3052.97 high3053.13 end3053.29 would3053.53 be3053.68 just3054.01 under3054.24 18,000.3054.64 The3056.69 next3057.97 one,3058.21 and3058.45 I3058.53 feel3058.61 like3058.77 this3058.85 is3059.09 in3059.17 some3059.33 ways3059.41 the3059.89 weakest3060.13 approach,3061.81 is3062.85 to3063.09 say,3063.17 hey,3063.41 if3063.65 you3063.81 were3063.97 looking3064.21 at3064.77 hourly3065.25 compensation,3065.73 how3067.81 would3068.05 that3068.29 calculate?3068.78 I3070.18 think3070.22 there3070.47 are3070.55 too3070.7 many3070.86 variables3071.11 here.3071.43 I3071.66 think3071.82 figuring3072.7 out3073.03 what's3073.18 your3073.43 hourly3073.59 baseline3073.99 is,3075.03 you3076.63 have3076.86 to3077.03 nail3077.18 that3077.43 one3077.51 down3077.74 and3077.91 justify3078.14 it,3078.55 and3079.03 then3079.18 there's3079.99 no3080.14 sense3080.55 in3082.38 the3082.62 hourly3082.78 rates3083.18 you3083.5 would3083.58 apply.3083.82 But,3084.54 if3085.74 some,3085.98 and3086.38 Dunkin'3086.62 Donuts3087.02 doesn't3087.42 pay3087.66 $153087.9 an3088.38 hour.3088.46 So,3088.7 you3089.5 know,3089.66 if3090.38 you3090.54 want3090.62 to3090.74 go3090.86 work3091.02 at,3091.26 I3091.66 see3091.66 the3091.66 signs3091.74 at3091.98 Target,3092.14 you3092.54 can3092.7 make3092.86 more3093.02 at3093.18 Target.3093.34 3094.7 But3094.94 just3094.94 to3095.1 see3095.18 where3095.34 the3095.58 ranges3095.66 arrive,3096.3 if3097.43 people3097.67 worked3097.99 153098.47 hours3098.8 a3099.11 week,3099.19 which3099.43 was,3099.67 I3100.23 think3100.39 universally3100.8 from3101.36 our3101.59 interviews3101.76 with3102.07 the3102.16 councilors,3102.39 the3103.19 low3103.36 end3103.59 estimate3103.91 of3104.39 hours3104.55 was3104.88 15.3105.11 And3106.23 since3106.39 we've3106.64 always3106.88 said3107.11 there's3107.99 the3108.23 minimum3108.39 job3108.8 you3108.95 have3109.11 to3109.28 do,3109.36 which3109.43 is3109.67 showing3109.84 up,3110.46 and3110.7 then3110.86 there's3111.02 the3111.26 value3111.42 add3111.74 job3111.9 you3112.14 do.3112.46 But3112.62 let's3112.62 just3112.78 look3112.86 at3113.02 the3113.1 minimum3113.26 because3113.66 the3116.22 rest3116.3 you're3116.54 compensated3117.02 by3117.5 reelection.3117.74 That3120.38 came3120.54 to3120.78 6903120.94 hours3121.82 and3122.14 that3122.38 was,3122.54 Councilor3123.66 Feltner's3124.14 463124.78 weeks3126.41 per3126.64 year,3126.89 I3127.13 believe,3127.29 and3127.84 then,3128.09 153128.97 hours3129.29 a3129.61 week.3129.77 Minimum3130.97 wage3131.45 would3131.84 get3132.09 you3132.24 north3132.32 of3132.44 $10,0003132.57 1.53134.89 minimum3135.53 wage,3135.93 which3136.24 is,3136.41 just3137.2 22.503137.68 an3138.32 hour,3138.49 gets3138.97 you3139.2 to3139.36 15,000.3139.53 You're3140.87 gonna3141.19 notice3141.35 some3141.75 similarities3142.31 to3142.87 the3143.11 reasonability3144.23 range3145.11 here,3145.59 and3145.67 then3145.67 high3145.91 end3146.07 is3146.31 about3146.47 20,700.3147.59 3150.31 And3150.31 the3150.47 third,3150.63 this3151.03 is3151.19 where3151.35 I3151.59 just3151.67 started3151.91 to3152.23 have3152.39 fun3152.55 and3152.79 used3153.03 all3153.27 the3153.35 data,3153.51 Doug,3153.75 that3154.07 you3154.23 gave3154.39 to3154.63 us.3154.71 So3154.87 thank3155.03 you3155.19 so3155.43 much.3155.59 This3157.57 was3157.8 saying,3158.05 all3158.44 right,3158.61 if3158.76 we3159.01 had3159.09 a3159.32 scatter3159.57 plot,3159.96 every3160.61 single3160.84 community3161.57 in3162.28 Massachusetts3162.53 that3163.64 had3163.8 the3163.96 same3164.13 form3164.36 of3164.61 government.3164.76 So3165.09 I3165.24 focused3165.4 just3165.8 on3166.05 the3166.2 manager3168.44 council3168.84 structure,3169.57 and3170.72 took3171.04 I3171.28 think3171.36 there3171.52 are3171.68 463171.84 communities3172.24 in3172.72 that3172.88 data,3173.04 which3173.44 is3173.68 a3173.84 nice3173.92 data3174.8 set.3175.04 And3175.6 said3175.76 just3176.08 look3176.24 at3176.4 that,3176.56 I3177.52 originally3177.76 had3178.32 thought3178.48 that3178.72 some3178.96 sort3179.2 of3179.36 percentage3179.68 of3180.48 the3180.72 industrial3180.96 base3181.6 relative3182.16 to3182.64 the3182.8 residential3182.96 revenue3184.08 would3185.02 be3185.09 a3185.26 really3185.34 good3185.41 proxy3185.66 for3186.06 the3186.22 complexity3186.38 of3186.93 the3187.09 work3188.06 but3188.22 the3188.22 councilors3188.38 disagreed.3188.86 Most3189.74 of3189.97 the3190.06 councilors3190.22 said3190.61 a3190.86 really3190.93 good3191.09 proxy3191.34 for3191.82 the3192.06 complexity3192.22 of3192.7 the3192.86 work3193.02 is3193.18 the3193.34 budget3193.41 size.3193.66 And3194.61 since3194.86 that3195.02 was3195.18 what3195.34 they3195.57 told3195.74 us3196.38 was3197.91 their3198.23 preferred3198.63 point3200.07 of3200.31 reference3200.47 for3200.95 how3202.07 hard3202.31 the3202.55 job3202.63 is,3202.87 I3203.35 said,3203.51 okay,3203.75 let's3204.07 look3204.39 at3204.71 the3205.11 ratio3205.27 of3206.07 councilor3206.31 salaries3206.95 for3207.91 all3208.15 of3208.31 the3208.39 communities3208.55 that3209.11 have3209.35 this3209.51 form3209.67 of3209.91 government,3209.99 the3210.76 ratio3210.92 of3211.4 the3211.57 councilors3211.72 salary3212.2 to3212.53 the3212.76 budget.3212.84 3213.72 And3213.72 if3213.89 you3214.05 can3214.13 imagine3214.28 a3214.68 scatter3214.84 plot,3215.09 you're3215.4 going3215.64 to3215.72 have3215.8 on3215.96 your3216.13 x3216.36 axis3216.61 the3217.57 councilor's3217.8 salary3218.28 and3218.76 the,3219.16 it3219.57 doesn't3219.64 matter,3219.8 the3220.05 y3220.2 axis3220.44 the3222.59 budget.3223.24 And3223.94 you're3224.02 going3224.26 to3224.3 have3224.34 a3224.74 cloud3224.9 of3225.3 numbers3225.54 and3226.1 then3226.34 you3226.5 say,3226.66 okay,3226.82 what's3227.06 that3227.3 line3227.46 of3227.62 best3227.86 fit?3228.1 And3229.78 there's3229.94 a3230.18 really3230.34 nice3230.58 trend3230.82 in3231.14 there.3231.3 So3231.86 I3232.1 did3232.18 that3232.42 line3232.58 of3232.82 best3233.06 fit.3233.54 And3235.38 just3235.38 because3235.62 the3235.86 ratio,3236.02 the3236.74 councilor3236.98 salaries3237.54 are3237.94 so3238.02 small3238.34 compared3239.39 to3239.56 the3239.72 budget,3239.88 I3240.28 did3240.36 the3240.52 ratio3240.68 and3241.08 then3241.24 multiplied3241.39 by3241.8 100,0003241.95 just3242.6 to3242.84 make3242.99 the3243.16 numbers3243.39 intelligible,3244.91 basically.3245.56 And3246.76 so3246.99 that's3247.16 what3247.32 my3247.56 budget3247.72 ratio3248.12 score3248.6 is.3248.91 It's3249.24 the3249.95 councilor3250.52 salary,3250.99 not3251.64 cumulative,3251.8 but3252.43 the3252.6 individual3252.84 councilor3254.2 salary,3255.8 I3255.8 didn't3255.96 look3256.12 at3256.28 the3256.36 number,3256.44 you3256.84 know,3257 divided3258.36 by3258.76 the3258.92 budget3259 times3259.32 100,000.3259.64 And3261.16 I3261.48 think3261.64 I3261.88 shared3262.04 the3262.36 Excel3263.16 document3263.56 that3264.04 had3264.2 that.3264.44 3269.05 Okay,3270.55 great.3270.93 I3271.13 might3271.28 hear3271.53 it.3271.76 But3271.84 I3272.01 need3272.57 to3272.64 make3272.8 eye3272.96 contact3273.13 with3273.44 all3273.61 my3273.76 colleagues3273.84 here.3274.24 But3274.4 thank3274.57 you.3274.72 So3275.76 I'm3276.09 going3276.32 to3276.57 I'm3276.8 going3277.05 to3277.2 continue3277.28 with3277.68 my,3277.92 we3278.64 can3278.89 take3279.05 questions3279.2 later,3279.61 but3279.92 I3280.09 will3280.24 continue3280.32 with3280.72 my3280.89 conversation3281.28 here.3281.92 That3282.95 budget3283.19 ratio3283.51 score,3283.99 I3285.83 looked3285.99 at3286.23 it.3286.39 You3287.43 can3287.59 drop,3287.75 there3287.99 are3288.15 a3288.23 couple3288.31 of3288.55 outliers3288.71 on3289.27 the3289.43 high3289.51 end,3289.99 there3290.15 are3290.15 a3290.23 couple3290.31 outliers3290.55 on3290.95 the3291.11 low3291.27 end.3291.51 So3292.55 I3292.79 took3292.95 out3293.19 the3293.43 high3293.51 and3293.75 the3293.91 low,3294.07 but3294.31 you3294.47 know3294.55 what,3294.87 it3294.95 was3294.95 immaterial,3295.11 to3296.36 that3296.59 average3296.84 number.3297.16 And3297.47 then3297.64 I3297.72 also3297.88 looked3298.11 at3298.28 the3298.43 median,3298.51 which3298.99 is3299.24 your3299.39 middle3299.72 number3300.03 of3300.43 all3300.59 of3300.76 them3300.84 in3301.8 addition3301.95 to3302.36 the3302.51 average.3302.76 Because3303.24 when3303.47 you're3303.72 averaging3303.88 them,3304.43 sometimes3304.84 the3305.32 higher3305.47 low3305.8 can3306.11 dilute3306.99 the3308.01 number.3308.33 But3308.89 the3309.13 median3309.29 and3309.69 the3309.93 average3310.01 were3310.41 roughly3310.57 the3310.97 same.3311.05 And3311.85 that's3312.01 what3312.17 that3312.33 chart3312.57 is3312.97 there.3313.21 3314.33 And3314.33 the3314.57 average3314.73 score3315.13 was3315.53 6.28.3315.85 Again,3317.05 that's3317.37 the3317.69 ratio3317.85 times3318.33 100,000.3318.65 And3319.69 Watertown3319.93 you3320.49 can3320.57 see3320.81 is3321.05 43321.29 there.3321.61 And3322.59 then3322.76 you3322.99 have3323.07 the3323.23 max3323.39 once3324.51 you3324.67 drop3324.91 Cambridge3326.36 out3326.91 of3327.07 there.3327.16 Boston3328.11 is3328.32 not3328.51 included3328.76 in3328.99 this3329.23 dataset3329.55 because3329.55 they3329.8 have3329.88 a3329.95 mayor.3330.11 But3330.99 Cambridge3331.23 well,3332.76 they3333.23 are,3333.39 actually,3334.19 don't3334.36 they3334.36 have3334.51 a3334.67 mayor?3334.76 I3334.91 don't3334.99 know.3335.23 Anyhow3336.31 yeah.3337.35 Yeah.3337.59 Okay.3337.99 But3338.39 it3338.79 was3339.03 the3339.83 city3339.99 manager.3340.23 There3340.63 we3340.87 go.3340.95 So3342.31 then,3342.55 Linda,3343.35 to3343.75 your3343.91 point,3344.07 I3344.31 applied3344.55 that3344.95 just3345.35 as3345.59 a3345.83 gut3346.55 check,3346.79 basically.3347.11 I3347.51 said,3347.59 okay.3347.83 Here's3348.15 your3348.55 ratio,3348.79 but3349.91 let's3350.15 look3350.47 at3350.79 the3351.57 153351.72 communities3352.68 that3353.49 were3353.72 used3353.97 for3354.36 the3355.89 compensation3356.05 study3356.77 and3357.64 apply3358.05 that3358.45 ratio3358.77 to3359.24 those3359.41 communities3359.64 to3360.13 say,3360.2 does3360.36 this3360.53 make3360.68 sense?3360.84 Is3361.09 this3361.24 anywhere3361.57 within3361.97 range?3362.36 Just,3363.57 again,3363.97 to3364.29 check3364.61 that3364.84 number.3365.09 And3366.11 that's3366.27 that3366.59 chart3366.91 there3367.15 where3367.47 you'll3367.63 see3367.79 first,3368.35 1,3368.99 2,3369.23 3,3369.55 4,3369.87 5,3370.19 6,3370.59 7.3370.91 Seven3371.79 of3372.11 the3372.27 153372.43 communities3372.83 have3373.95 the,3374.27 or3374.59 if3374.83 you3374.91 take3374.99 out3375.15 Watertown,3375.31 six,3377.71 so3377.95 that3377.95 have3378.19 city3379.87 councils.3380.19 And3381.28 then3381.44 I3382.57 just3382.72 compared3383.05 what3383.44 would3383.76 their3384.32 salary3384.57 be3385.13 or3385.61 stipend3385.84 be3386.32 based3386.8 on3387.05 that3387.2 budget3387.36 ratio3387.68 score3388.09 compared3389.05 to3389.36 where3389.44 it3389.68 is.3389.84 3391.2 There3391.2 are3391.36 some3391.53 outliers3391.84 which3392.32 I3392.57 discussed.3392.72 Newton3393.92 is3394.88 an3395.04 outlier3395.2 but3395.6 somebody3395.84 pointed3396.16 out3396.48 that3396.72 they're3397.84 compensated3398.16 as3398.72 a3398.88 percentage3399.04 of3400.08 somebody's3400.24 salary.3400.72 There3402.24 are3402.4 a3402.48 couple3402.56 other3402.88 outliers3403.12 but3403.68 it3403.92 often3404.08 checks3404.4 out3404.64 pretty3404.88 well.3405.12 If3405.84 you3406 look3406.16 at3406.4 Waltham3406.8 and3407.44 Woburn,3407.84 now3409.76 I'm3409.99 cherry3410.16 picking3410.39 my3410.55 data.3410.64 But3410.88 you3411.11 see3411.36 where3411.43 it3412.16 would3412.39 end3412.64 up.3412.88 So3414.55 all3414.8 that3415.11 to3415.28 say,3415.76 if3416.64 you3416.8 scroll3416.95 up3417.28 to3417.36 the3417.51 top,3417.59 if3417.84 you're3417.99 looking3418.16 at3418.39 it3418.55 or3418.71 look3418.95 at3419.11 the3419.28 very3419.43 front3419.59 page,3419.91 if3420.8 you3420.95 applied3425.01 the3425.01 median,3425.25 I3426.29 think3426.37 that's3426.53 what3426.77 I3426.85 used,3427.01 for3427.17 the3427.41 low,3427.57 the3428.77 average3429.09 for3429.65 the3429.89 middle,3429.97 and3430.37 then3430.61 that3430.93 highest3431.25 from3432.05 the3432.29 dataset3432.37 for3432.85 the3433.09 high,3433.17 you3433.89 get3434.13 a3434.29 range3434.45 from3434.93 11,7003435.33 for3436.61 the3436.85 low3436.93 to3437.25 a3437.41 high3437.57 of3437.73 23,400,3440.07 and3440.14 the3440.14 middle3440.3 is3440.63 12,800.3441.18 Lots3443.43 of,3443.74 if3444.3 we3444.55 said,3444.79 oh,3445.18 we3445.43 want3445.59 to3445.82 use3445.99 that3446.22 methodology3446.55 to3447.11 determine3447.27 a3447.66 number,3447.82 we3448.95 would3449.11 be3449.27 setting3449.34 ourselves3449.66 up3450.07 for3450.3 a3450.47 lot3450.55 of3450.7 ridicule3450.86 because3451.43 this3451.91 is,3452.14 again,3452.39 just3452.7 a3453.03 way3453.34 of3453.66 looking3453.99 at3454.3 data3454.55 to3455.36 get3455.52 a3455.76 sense3456.04 of3456.32 what3457.68 are3457.92 the3458 trends3458.16 in3458.48 the3458.56 state3458.64 if3458.96 you're3459.2 looking3459.36 at3459.6 budget.3459.76 But3461.2 that3461.36 helps3461.52 kind3462.96 of3463.2 put3463.36 parenthesis3463.68 around3464.96 possible3465.28 methodologies.3465.68 Any3468.43 questions?3468.6 I3469.16 just3469.32 ran3469.47 through3469.72 numbers3470.04 without3470.91 anything3471.39 in3471.88 front3472.04 of3472.28 you3472.36 all,3472.52 so3472.6 that's3472.99 hard3473.24 to3473.39 follow.3473.56 Any3474.52 questions?3474.76

3480.6 SPEAKER53480.6 -3480.6 Jack?3480.6

3481.06 SPEAKER13481.06 -3481.06 Yeah.3481.06

3482.02 COLE3482.02 -3482.02 Not3482.02 particularly3482.34 a3482.82 question3482.9 but3483.38 just3483.54 admiration3485.38 for3486.1 the3486.5 three3488.58 different3488.82 strategies3489.14 and3489.7 three3489.86 different3490.02 strategies3490.42 that3490.9 you3491.06 both3491.3 did.3491.54 I3492.1 think3492.18 it's3492.42 great.3492.66 I3493.78 love3493.93 that3494.18 so3495.86 much3496.09 of3496.26 it3496.41 comes3496.74 close3497.38 to3497.93 a3498.09 range.3498.26 It3498.74 sort3498.97 of3499.22 gives3499.38 me3499.61 a3500.82 sense3500.97 of3501.3 comfort3501.54 and3502.18 confidence3502.82 that3503.45 we're3503.61 not3503.86 doing3504.09 anything3504.34 crazy,3505.7 it's3506.26 all3506.58 within3506.74 range.3507.06 And3507.3 I3507.54 particularly3508.38 appreciate3509.74 the3513.74 way3513.9 you've3514.06 described3514.46 it,3515.02 Sarah,3515.42 which3515.9 is3516.22 it's3516.86 a3517.1 gut3517.34 check3517.74 for3518.94 what3520.38 we'll3520.73 ultimately3520.97 decide.3521.7 And3522.57 you're3522.89 not3523.21 recommending3523.53 particularly,3524.26 if3524.89 I3525.05 heard3525.21 you3525.45 correctly,3525.61 using3526.57 any3526.97 one3527.21 of3527.45 these3527.61 methodologies.3527.93 The3529.21 methodologies3529.53 help3530.73 us3530.97 sort3532.09 of3532.34 standardize3533.05 these3533.86 various3534.34 locations3534.97 and3536.79 understand3537.11 the3538.15 salary3538.39 in3539.11 a3539.27 way3539.43 that3539.67 makes3540.07 it3540.39 more3540.55 like3540.79 apples3541.03 to3541.35 apples.3541.59 Is3542.55 that3542.71 fair?3542.87 3544.87 BAKER3544.87 -3544.87 Yeah.3544.87 I3545.11 think3545.27 the3545.43 different3545.59 methodologies3545.91 or3546.63 different3546.79 approaches3547.35 are3549.51 fair3549.75 to3550.07 take.3550.23 And3550.71 then3550.87 if3551.11 you3551.27 see3551.43 convergence3551.67 using3552.76 different3553.07 approaches,3553.64 that3554.99 lends3555.47 credibility3556.04 to3556.59 each3557.39 of3557.56 them3557.72 or3557.95 to3558.04 them3558.11 collectively.3558.36 3564.88 MURNINGHAN3564.88 -3564.88 Yeah.3564.88 I3565.12 wanna3565.44 thank,3565.84 both3566.88 Linda3567.52 and3568.24 Sarah3568.64 for3569.12 helping3569.84 us3570.24 to,3570.64 and3570.88 Jim3571.2 too,3571.68 for3572.16 helping3572.56 us3572.88 to3573.28 ground3573.6 what3574.56 ultimately3574.8 is3575.6 a3575.92 judgment3576.64 call3577.28 in3577.68 the3577.84 fullest3578 sense3578.4 of3578.72 the3578.8 word.3579.36 And3579.6 that3579.6 is3579.76 both3580 normative,3581.18 I'm3581.66 going3581.82 to3581.97 use3582.14 some3582.3 fancy3582.54 words3582.86 here,3583.26 but3583.49 normative3583.82 and3584.38 empirical.3584.7 You3585.66 know,3585.82 that3586.06 there's3586.22 a3586.54 numbers3586.7 part3587.26 that3587.57 rationale.3587.97 We3589.26 believe3589.41 this3590.06 number3590.38 is3590.7 valid3590.93 because3591.41 a,3592.22 b,3592.45 c,3592.7 d,3593.02 and3593.41 we've3593.66 done3594.06 our3594.3 homework.3594.78 But3595.71 at3595.95 the3596.19 same3596.27 time,3596.67 as3597.79 Mary3598.11 said,3598.51 there3598.91 is3599.07 a3599.23 level3599.39 of3599.71 discretion.3599.95 And3601.55 I'm3601.95 so3602.27 mindful3602.51 of3603.15 how3603.63 the,3604.83 with3605.71 the3605.95 charter3606.19 changes3606.67 and3607.39 with3607.87 the3608.27 just3608.83 changes3609.91 in3610.63 policy3611.26 making3611.82 and3612.34 the3612.86 interrelated3613.59 disciplines3615.26 and3615.82 domains3616.14 that3616.78 go3617.03 into3617.18 things3617.66 such3618.07 as3618.22 rapid3619.98 transit,3620.47 or3621.18 climate3621.51 change,3621.91 or3622.3 any3622.55 number3622.78 of3623.03 things3623.18 that3623.74 are3624.46 beyond3624.94 the3625.26 borders3625.42 of3625.9 Watertown,3626.06 but3626.62 are3626.86 things3628.38 that3628.7 affect3628.94 this3629.42 town3629.66 for3630.38 future3630.62 generations.3631.1 3631.82 But3631.82 there3631.98 are3632.38 so3632.54 many3632.7 judgments3632.94 that3633.5 are3633.74 based3633.9 in3634.22 normative3635.82 concerns,3636.46 not3637.1 just3637.34 the3638.06 empirical3638.14 ones.3638.62 So3638.86 I3639.02 appreciate3639.18 helping3640.51 us3640.84 to3641.07 ground3641.23 our3641.71 decision3641.95 in3643.23 ways3643.47 that3644.03 help3644.67 us3644.91 do3645.39 both,3645.95 that3646.43 this3646.67 is3646.91 a3647.07 number3647.23 based3647.64 on3647.95 a3648.43 numbers3648.59 analysis,3649.07 and3650.11 this3650.36 is3650.51 a3650.67 number3650.84 based3651.32 on3651.71 our3652.59 judgment3652.99 about3653.8 what3654.6 that3654.84 job3655.08 is3655.48 these3655.72 days,3655.96 what3656.92 it3657.16 takes3657.32 to3658.84 do3658.92 it3659.16 in3659.48 the3659.72 sense3659.8 of3660.12 the3660.84 challenges3661.08 that3661.56 are3661.8 faced,3661.96 and3663 how3663.56 we3663.72 can3663.88 stay3664.12 ahead3664.44 of3664.68 the3664.84 curve3665 so3665.4 that,3665.64 you3666.2 know,3666.36 we3666.68 attract3666.92 people3667.48 to3667.88 run3668.04 for3668.28 office3668.44 that3668.84 are3669.08 likely3669.24 to3670.11 be3670.27 very3671.07 interested3671.22 in3671.7 ways3672.59 that3672.91 they3673.14 might3673.31 not3673.55 have3673.79 thought3673.95 of3674.18 before.3674.34 That3675.07 raises3675.31 a3675.63 question,3675.79 we3676.11 may3676.27 get3676.43 to3676.59 this3676.74 later,3676.91 but3677.22 I3677.47 know,3677.55 Linda,3677.79 you3678.11 had3678.34 some3679.07 of3679.31 the3679.39 other3680.27 points3680.59 to3681.07 ponder.3681.22 And3681.7 I3681.86 was3682.03 wondering,3682.18 Sarah,3682.74 if3683.14 you3683.31 had3683.47 any3683.63 too3684.03 in3684.34 terms3684.59 of3684.99 other3686.06 recommendations3686.46 that3687.42 fall3687.66 more3687.98 under3688.22 the3688.7 normative3689.1 domain3689.58 rather3690.06 than3690.38 the3691.1 financial3691.34 one.3692.06 That3692.54 is,3692.78 what3693.66 did3693.82 you3693.98 seem3694.22 to3694.46 pick3694.62 up,3694.86 you3695.42 know,3695.5 that3695.82 you3696.06 think3696.3 we3696.54 should3696.78 be3697.02 thinking3697.18 about3697.58 either3698.78 in3699.01 terms3699.17 of3699.49 other3699.66 incentives3699.97 or3700.78 how3701.41 best3701.66 to3701.89 communicate3702.14 this3702.61 to3702.86 the3703.01 public?3703.17 I3703.89 think3703.97 we're3704.21 beginning3704.45 to3704.78 move3704.93 into3705.09 the3705.41 work3705.66 plan3705.97 discussion3706.45 and3707.57 what3707.73 it3707.89 should3708.14 contain.3708.45 But3709.26 I3709.41 was3709.49 curious3709.73 before3710.21 we3710.53 do3710.69 that3710.86 formal3711.17 setting3712.21 up3712.53 a3712.69 work3712.78 plan,3713.01 what3713.97 your3714.21 sort3714.69 of3714.85 additional3715.09 thoughts3715.57 might3715.89 be.3716.13 3717.65 BARTLEY3717.65 -3717.65 On3717.65 that,3718.45 Marcy,3718.61 I3718.61 agree3718.77 with3719.01 you3719.09 wholeheartedly.3719.25 I3719.81 think3719.97 that3720.13 what3720.29 we3720.45 can3720.61 do3720.77 is3720.93 have3721.01 a3721.13 discussion3721.25 on3721.73 the3722.45 data3722.61 that3723.01 they've3723.17 given3723.41 us,3723.73 and3723.97 then3724.13 we3724.37 can3724.53 talk3724.77 about3725.01 the3725.57 gut3725.73 check3726.05 and3726.29 what3726.69 did3727.09 we3727.33 hear3727.41 from3727.57 councilors3727.81 and3728.29 what3728.53 other3728.69 things3729.36 that3730.77 Tracy3731.68 had3732.16 told3732.41 us3732.64 about3733.13 the3733.36 change3733.53 in3733.84 the3733.92 council3734.09 and3734.41 things3734.57 like3734.8 that.3734.89 I3735.05 think3735.13 but3735.36 I3735.53 think3735.68 we3735.92 should3736.09 have3736.24 a3736.48 healthy3736.57 discussion3736.89 on3737.36 on3737.53 that.3737.76 3738.57 BAKER3738.57 -3738.57 Jack,3738.57 I3738.8 can3738.89 add3739.13 to3739.2 that.3739.36 Marcy,3740.09 I'm3740.96 looking3741.05 just3741.36 at3741.53 numbers3741.68 because3742.16 I'm3742.57 really3743.09 focused3743.33 on3743.49 what3743.81 our3744.05 mandate3744.21 is,3744.53 which3744.93 is3745.17 a3745.33 number.3745.49 But3746.61 I3746.85 did3747.01 quickly,3747.89 actually,3748.53 right3748.77 now3749.01 do3749.25 some3749.49 calculations.3749.73 With3753.41 each3753.65 of3753.89 the,3754.05 you3754.77 know,3754.93 low,3755.17 medium,3755.49 high3755.97 changes3756.79 when3757.34 you3757.59 multiply3757.74 that3758.14 by3758.31 nine,3758.47 I'm3758.79 right3759.03 now3761.11 extrapolating,3761.43 take3761.43 stepping3761.43 back3761.59 from3761.74 there3761.99 being3762.14 a3762.39 differential3762.47 for3762.86 the3763.11 council3763.27 president,3765.43 what3765.74 percentage3765.74 of3766.14 the3766.31 total3766.47 budget3766.7 would3767.27 that3767.59 new3767.91 total3769.04 salary3769.44 be3769.84 and3770.88 what3771.12 is3771.36 the3771.52 percentage3771.68 increase3772.32 or3773.04 what3773.2 is3773.36 that3773.44 increase3773.6 as3774 a3774.08 percent3774.16 of3774.4 the3774.48 budget?3774.56 And3774.88 the3775.12 numbers3775.28 are3775.6 so3775.84 small.3776.08 I3777.36 think3777.52 those3777.68 numbers3777.92 will3778.24 be3778.4 really3778.56 important3778.88 for3779.6 this3779.84 communication3780.08 strategy3780.72 that3781.2 you're3781.36 talking3781.6 about.3781.84 But3782.64 at3783.8 the3783.89 high3784.13 end3784.36 of3784.61 these3784.77 ranges,3785.09 it's3785.89 just3786.53 not3786.84 much3787.16 money,3788.13 you3788.36 know,3788.53 relative3788.84 to3789.24 the3789.41 overall3789.57 budget.3789.97 3790.45 MURNINGHAN3790.45 -3790.45 Life3790.84 is3791.09 a3791.24 challenge.3791.41

3794.61 SPEAKER13794.61 -3794.61 Okay.3794.61 Any3795.41 other3795.64 discussion3795.89 on3796.45 the3796.61 on3796.84 the3797.09 on3797.32 the3797.41 numbers?3797.64 Jim?3798.68 3801.4 MELLO3801.4 -3801.4 I'm3801.4 handing3801.72 out3802.04 mine3802.28 that3803.16 everybody3803.4 got3803.88 anyway.3804.2 It3804.84 was3804.92 emailed3805.24 out3805.64 to3805.88 everybody.3805.96 The3808.52 way3808.68 I3808.92 came3809.08 up3809.32 with3809.48 my3809.64 numbers,3809.8 and3810.2 I'll3810.36 just3810.52 state3810.76 them3810.92 right3811.16 here,3811.32 city3812.03 council3812.28 compensation,3812.76 $15,000.3814.11 City3816.03 council3816.43 president3816.84 slash3817.32 school3817.64 committee3817.95 member3818.28 compensation,3818.76 25,000.3819.47 I'm3821.24 also3821.47 recommending3821.95 to3822.68 the3822.84 city3822.99 council3823.39 they3824.2 consider3824.51 adjusting3825.24 the3826.03 school3826.28 committee3826.59 compensation3827.66 to3828.22 $10,000.3829.18 Overall,3829.74 these3830.78 numbers3831.02 I3831.42 came3831.58 up3831.82 with3832.06 based3832.3 on3832.62 the3832.86 history3832.94 of3833.34 what's3833.5 going3833.74 on3833.98 in3834.62 Watertown,3836.3 from3836.54 the3836.78 time3837.02 we3837.26 went3837.42 from3837.66 board3837.9 of3838.06 selectmen3838.22 to3839.02 town3839.18 meeting,3839.42 and3839.9 yes,3840.14 I3840.46 was3840.62 a3840.86 town3840.94 meeting3841.26 member.3841.58 I3842.82 was3842.97 in3843.14 the3843.3 last3843.45 town3843.78 meeting3843.93 that3844.26 Watertown3844.41 ever3844.97 had.3845.22 So3846.02 I3846.26 remember3846.41 why3846.97 we've3847.22 changed3847.54 the3847.93 form3848.09 of3848.34 government,3848.41 I3848.82 was3848.97 very3849.22 active3849.45 in3850.02 getting3850.18 that3850.49 done.3850.82 3851.86 And3851.86 that3852.02 was3852.26 the3852.41 thing3852.57 because3852.82 we3853.14 felt3853.38 that3853.61 town3854.34 government3854.57 at3855.06 that3855.22 time3855.38 was3855.61 part3855.86 time.3856.18 Board3856.93 of3857.25 selectmen3857.25 met3857.73 Monday3858.29 afternoons3858.77 from,3859.33 like3859.49 they3860.85 had3861.09 closed3861.33 sessions3861.65 from,3862.29 like,3862.53 33862.93 to3863.17 4,3863.33 then3863.57 they3863.81 opened3863.89 to3865.09 public3865.33 and3865.33 about3865.33 three3865.57 people3865.81 showed3866.13 up3866.37 at3866.45 the3866.61 meeting.3866.69 Usually,3867.01 somebody3867.41 from3867.81 the3867.97 local3868.13 media3868.45 and3869.14 a3869.3 couple3869.38 crazy3870.01 townies3870.41 like3870.89 myself3871.14 and3871.45 this3871.61 guy,3871.78 Bob3872.09 Chase.3872.34 Jack3873.3 will3873.53 remember3873.86 Bob3874.26 Chase.3874.57 But,3874.97 anyway,3876.18 and3877.21 they3877.53 had3877.78 dealt3877.93 with3878.18 everything.3878.34 They3878.73 were3878.82 the3878.97 licensing3879.05 board.3879.69 They3879.93 did3880.73 everything3882.41 and3882.66 they3882.66 had3882.73 an3882.97 administrative3882.97 assistant3884.94 who3885.18 was3885.18 like3885.42 the3886.94 not3888.46 even3888.62 a3888.86 manager,3889.02 but3889.34 he3889.58 was3889.66 the3889.9 guy3889.98 in3890.22 charge3890.38 at3890.7 city3890.94 hall3891.18 here.3891.42 Your3891.9 treasurer3892.22 was3892.62 elected,3893.42 your3893.82 town3894.06 clerk3894.3 was3894.62 elected,3895.26 the3895.42 auditor3895.42 was3895.82 elected.3895.98 You3896.88 know,3897.11 all3897.28 these3897.59 positions3897.84 were3898.24 all3898.39 elected.3898.56 The3898.88 planning3899.04 board3899.36 was3899.52 elected.3899.76 All3900.08 the3900.24 boards3900.32 were3900.56 elected3900.8 back3901.2 then.3901.36 So3902.08 when3902.32 we3902.47 changed3902.64 the3902.95 form3903.11 of3903.36 government3903.43 on3903.84 our3904.08 350th3904.8 birthday3905.91 in3906.64 1980,3906.8 that's3908.16 when3908.47 it3908.64 took3908.72 effect,3908.95 which3909.28 was3909.43 funny3909.68 that3909.91 we3910.16 did3910.32 it3910.47 on3910.56 that3910.72 anniversary,3911.68 but3912.08 we3912.08 went3912.32 to3912.48 the3912.72 town3912.96 council.3913.28 3914 In3914 the3914.16 beginning,3914.32 it3915.2 wasn't3915.44 as3915.76 active3916 as3916.32 the3916.64 city3916.8 council3917.2 as3917.6 now3917.84 and3918.48 what3918.64 it's3918.8 become.3919.04 The3920.16 meetings3920.4 would3920.8 be3920.96 long3921.2 at3921.44 times3921.68 but3922.08 they3922.24 didn't3922.4 have3922.72 all3922.88 these3923.04 subcommittee3923.28 meetings.3923.92 They3924.16 just3924.32 didn't3924.56 really3924.96 have3925.2 them,3926.05 and3926.21 it's3926.21 evolved3926.61 into3927.26 that.3927.49 So3927.97 I3928.21 looked3928.3 at3928.53 this.3928.7 I3928.86 said,3929.01 you3929.26 know3929.34 something?3929.57 Let's3930.38 double3930.61 it,3931.97 how3932.21 we3932.21 adjust3932.45 the3932.78 pay,3933.09 and3933.34 I3933.34 understand3933.41 what3933.89 Mary3934.14 was3934.45 saying.3934.7 I3934.93 can3935.09 sort3935.26 of3935.49 get3935.66 that3935.82 point.3936.05 So3937.18 but3937.57 that's3937.82 where3938.05 I3938.3 went3938.38 from3938.61 and3938.86 I3939.01 took,3939.09 like,3939.34 the3939.49 council3939.66 president.3940.05 If3940.95 the3941.11 school3941.27 committee3941.59 does,3941.99 and3942.47 that's3942.87 doubling3943.19 their3943.59 salary3943.83 also3944.31 because3944.63 they3944.87 now3945.11 meet3945.27 instead3945.59 of3945.83 once3945.91 a3946.15 month,3946.31 they3946.79 meet3946.95 twice3947.19 a3947.59 month,3947.67 which3948.23 they've3949.59 been3949.91 doing3949.99 recent3950.39 the3950.71 last3950.87 few3951.03 years.3951.27 And3952.07 they've3952.31 got3952.55 more3953.35 subcommittees3953.51 like3954.31 the3954.95 council3955.11 has.3955.59 3955.99 So3955.99 I3957.89 came3958.05 up3958.2 with3958.36 the3958.53 council3958.68 president's3959.09 salary3959.64 based3960.05 on3960.29 the3960.45 city3960.77 council's3961.32 salary3961.89 plus3962.61 school3963.16 committee,3963.57 and3965.09 they3965.41 do3965.57 a3965.81 lot3965.89 more3966.13 than3966.29 that3966.53 anyway.3966.77 So3968.05 my3968.68 recommendation3969.01 was,3970.13 you3970.45 know,3970.61 when3972.02 the3972.34 chatter3972.5 review3972.9 in3973.3 2025,3973.7 I3975.62 put3976.1 the3976.26 actual3976.42 change3976.82 where3977.14 it3977.38 would3977.46 be3977.62 on3977.78 the3977.94 salary3978.1 increases,3978.5 would3979.54 be3979.78 on3979.94 a3980.1 cost3980.18 of3980.5 living3980.66 increase3980.98 of3981.38 rank3981.62 and3981.94 file3982.1 city3982.26 employees.3982.5 That's3983.06 what3983.22 I3983.38 proposed3984.49 we3984.64 can3984.64 look3984.8 at3985.05 that3985.13 but3985.36 that's3985.53 only3985.84 because3986.01 I3986.16 understand3986.32 what3986.8 Mary's3986.97 saying.3987.36 But3989.68 I3989.93 think3990.09 this3990.32 is3990.57 a3990.64 good3990.72 start3991.05 for3991.77 a3992.09 number3992.16 at3992.49 least.3992.89 And3993.05 I3993.05 agree,3993.93 what3994.49 Linda3994.64 did3995.05 and3995.29 Sarah3995.45 did3995.77 excellent3998.06 but3998.3 this3998.3 is3998.46 me3998.62 looking3998.86 at3999.18 it3999.34 from3999.5 my4000.3 history4000.54 and4001.34 coming4001.58 up4001.9 with4002.06 it4002.14 this4002.38 way.4002.62 4004.38 BARTLEY4004.38 -4004.38 Yeah.4004.38 Jim,4005.34 as4005.74 a4006.06 former4006.62 town4007.18 meeting4007.42 member4007.74 myself,4007.98 I4008.38 remember4008.54 those4009.42 those4009.74 meetings.4009.98 But4010.38 with4011.64 respect4011.89 to4012.2 the4012.36 school4013.01 committee,4013.24 it4013.57 is4013.64 outside4013.89 our4014.93 charge,4015.16 and4015.57 so4015.64 we4015.81 can't4015.89 do4016.05 it.4016.13 4016.29 MELLO4016.29 -4016.29 That's4016.29 why4016.45 I'm4016.68 only4016.77 recommending4017.09 that4018.05 the4018.2 council4018.45 look4018.84 at4019.09 that.4019.16 Not4019.41 that4019.57 we4019.81 put4020.29 it4020.53 down.4020.68 You4021.01 know,4021.09 there's4021.32 a4021.64 recommendation4021.81 to4022.53 the4022.61 council.4022.77 Just4023.16 like4023.41 the4023.42 charter,4023.44 there's4023.46 a4023.48 recommendation4023.5 to4023.51 the4023.53 council4023.55 and4023.57 there's4023.59 a4023.6 the4023.64 charter4023.66 commission4023.68 will4023.69 be4023.71 in4023.73 the4023.98 4036.78 FALKOFF4036.78 -4036.78 I4036.78 think4037.02 it's4037.41 great,4037.74 the4038.22 people4038.45 that4038.78 can4039.02 get4039.26 down4039.49 in4039.74 the4039.89 weeds4039.97 with4040.3 the4040.45 numbers.4040.61 I4042.06 am4042.3 not4042.45 that4042.78 kind4043.09 of4043.26 a4043.41 person.4043.58 And4044.06 I4044.7 start4044.93 with4045.26 the4045.49 gut4045.66 check.4045.97 And4046.78 I4047.34 feel,4047.66 and4048.06 I4048.3 really4049.69 admire4050.33 Jim4050.89 for4051.21 having4051.45 the4051.77 courage4052.01 right4052.41 away4052.65 to4052.89 say,4052.97 this4053.21 is4053.45 what4053.53 I4053.69 think4053.77 it4053.93 should4054.01 be,4054.25 of4054.65 which4054.81 you4054.97 said4055.13 right4055.53 at4055.85 the4056.01 beginning,4056.89 and4057.85 I4057.85 come4058.01 out4058.17 in4058.41 a4058.57 place4058.73 close4058.97 to4059.21 that.4059.37 What4059.53 I4059.77 like4059.93 about4060.17 the4060.41 numbers4060.57 is4060.97 nothing4061.61 in4062.01 the4062.17 numbers4062.25 made4063.54 me4063.86 think4063.93 my4064.66 gut4064.89 and4065.22 Jim's4065.45 gut4065.78 were4066.09 way4066.82 out4067.06 of4067.22 base.4067.3 We're4068.09 okay.4068.89 And4070.26 I4070.82 guess4070.89 my4071.3 gut4071.7 check4071.93 is4072.18 based4073.7 less4074.82 on4075.14 the4075.3 history4075.45 than4075.86 my4076.02 experience4076.26 as4076.82 a4076.97 councilor4077.14 and4078.02 my4078.26 feelings4078.42 about4078.82 how4079.22 that4079.62 jobs4080.34 changed4080.74 in4081.3 the4081.46 time4081.62 that4081.86 I4082.02 was4082.18 there4082.34 and4083.22 since4083.46 then,4083.7 and4084.1 just4084.74 what4085.14 feels4085.46 fair4085.86 to4086.1 me.4086.26 So4086.5 I4086.98 appreciate4087.22 all4087.86 the4088.02 ways4088.18 that4088.58 people4088.74 have4089.46 come4089.7 to4089.94 the4090.18 same4090.34 more4091.28 or4091.51 less4091.59 thing.4091.84 And4092.16 I4093.03 would4093.2 I4095.28 guess4095.36 my4095.76 compensation4096.15 number4096.88 would4097.6 be4098.72 14,5004099.03 to4099.76 15,000.4099.99 I'm4100.8 okay4100.95 with4101.19 15,000.4101.52 I4102.48 might4102.64 go4102.8 with4102.95 14,500.4103.27 And4103.84 I4104.07 would4104.15 just,4104.31 adjust4105.59 what4105.99 you4106.15 said4106.31 about4106.63 the4107.43 president4108.79 by4109.75 saying4109.99 it4110.39 should4110.55 be4110.71 the4111.59 council4111.91 plus4112.39 the4112.63 school4112.79 committee,4113.03 plus4113.67 I4113.99 would4114.07 say4114.23 a4114.47 $2,0004114.55 stipend4116.23 on4116.71 top4116.95 of4117.11 that,4117.43 so4117.51 that's4117.51 how4117.75 I4117.91 would4117.99 calculate4118.23 that.4118.79 So4119.19 I4119.91 think4119.99 it's4120.31 great4120.85 that4121.09 you4121.48 can4121.65 come4121.81 up4121.97 with4122.13 all4122.52 these4122.85 many,4123.56 many,4123.81 many4124.13 ways4124.44 to4126.85 verify4127.09 our4127.97 gut4128.2 feelings.4128.44 4129.65 BARTLEY4129.65 -4129.65 Thank4131.16 you,4131.32 Susan.4131.56 And4131.89 you4132.36 know,4132.52 when4132.69 they4132.85 use4132.92 the4132.99 word4133.24 gut,4133.48 and,4134.06 you4134.26 know,4134.34 we're4134.42 hearing4134.66 Mary4134.9 talking4135.3 about,4135.62 you4136.42 know,4136.58 throwing4137.94 a4138.26 dart,4139.78 I4139.94 take4140.18 a4140.3 little4140.42 umbrage4140.9 of4141.3 of4141.38 that4141.54 because4141.7 I4141.94 think4142.02 we4143.38 all4143.54 have4143.78 different4143.94 perspectives4144.34 of,4144.82 you4145.06 know,4145.22 our4145.38 living4145.62 in4145.94 Watertown.4146.1 But4146.58 I4146.74 think4146.82 we've4147.3 all4147.54 listened4147.78 to4148.02 the4148.18 city4148.34 council,4148.58 and4149.03 I4149.27 thought4149.35 that4149.59 was4149.74 really4150.07 helpful4150.31 to4151.35 hear4151.99 firsthand4152.31 what4153.11 their4153.35 job4153.99 has4154.31 entailed4154.55 over4155.03 the4155.35 years.4155.51 I4156.86 thought4157.35 that4157.59 Tom4157.91 Tracy's4158.23 comments4158.78 were4159.19 extremely4160.23 helpful4160.78 because4161.71 he4161.87 gave4162.11 a4162.43 historical4162.59 perspective4163.23 not,4163.79 you4164.03 know,4164.19 as4164.43 an4164.59 employee4164.75 to4165.71 talk4165.87 about4166.11 something4166.75 changed.4167.23 And4167.87 we're4168.11 able4168.43 to4168.67 see,4168.83 oh,4169.23 and4169.95 then4170.11 the4170.59 development4170.83 of4171.47 the4171.79 subcommittees,4171.95 Jim,4172.67 that4172.83 you4172.99 had4173.15 mentioned.4173.39 And4174.03 that4174.19 the4174.43 meetings4174.59 aren't4175.47 as4175.71 long,4176.03 you4177.38 know,4177.61 as4177.85 they4178.09 had4178.34 been4178.41 in4178.57 the4178.73 past.4178.81 And4179.05 we4179.22 say,4179.38 why4179.69 didn't4179.94 that4180.26 well,4180.41 it's4180.65 because4180.73 the4181.05 work4181.22 was4181.38 done4181.45 at4181.61 the4181.77 subcommittee.4181.85 The4182.49 work4182.73 was4182.9 done4183.05 by4183.3 the4183.45 council4184.49 president4184.9 working4185.38 with4185.61 them,4185.77 and4185.94 it4186.09 it4186.34 seemed4186.41 to4186.73 be4186.9 much4187.14 more4187.38 effective.4188.41 So4188.73 it's,4188.98 you4189.3 know,4189.38 it's4189.53 not,4190.73 I4191.22 mean,4191.3 that4191.53 gut4191.77 is4192.01 based4192.18 on4192.49 the4193.19 analysis4193.43 and4194.63 the4194.71 testimony4194.87 that4195.35 we've4195.59 received.4196.23 4197.59 MURNIGHAN4197.59 -4197.59 Informed4197.59 gut.4198.23 4198.71 BARTLEY4198.71 -4198.71 Yeah.4198.71 Informed4198.95 gut.4199.51 4200.07 MURNINGHAN4200.07 -4200.07 Oh,4200.07 wise.4200.23 We're4201.35 trying4201.59 to4201.91 find4202.07 common4202.39 ground4202.79 with4203.11 the4203.35 wise4203.43 gut.4203.83 That's4204.79 what4204.95 we4205.11 are,4205.56 that's4205.64 our4205.64 goal.4205.88

4206.27 SPEAKER104206.27 -4206.27 Sarah?4206.27

4206.76 BAKER4206.76 -4206.76 When4206.76 I4206.99 say4207.16 gut,4207.4 I4207.64 think4207.72 about4207.95 cows4208.35 or4208.99 ruminants.4209.16 They're4210.03 four4210.52 stomachs,4210.91 and4211.31 the4211.44 word4211.56 ruminant4211.88 comes4212.35 from4212.68 that.4212.84 So4212.99 a4213.31 gut4213.48 check4213.72 actually4214.03 is4214.35 a,4214.48 it's4214.76 not4214.91 a4215.72 fly4215.95 by4216.2 night.4216.44 It's4216.84 a4217.07 it's4217.72 a4217.95 calculated4218.2 and4218.99 kind4219.48 of4219.64 sat,4219.8 we've4219.8 sat4219.8 on4220.84 it4221 for4221.16 a4221.32 while.4221.4

4221.72 Cool.4221.72

4222.68 SPEAKER14222.68 -4222.68 Can4222.68 I4222.84 Yes?4223.16

4223.4 SPEAKER44223.4 -4223.4 Go4223.4 ahead,4223.56 Susan.4223.8 4224.28 FALKOFF4224.28 -4224.28 So4224.28 I4225.4 was4225.64 using4225.8 the4226.04 word4226.12 gut,4226.52 it's4226.84 Sarah's4227.08 word4227.4 and4227.72 okay.4228.2 I4229.16 guess4229.32 my4229.64 understanding4232.14 of4232.77 what4232.94 you're4233.9 calling4234.06 gut4234.38 is4234.69 common4234.94 sense.4235.26 It's4235.9 just4236.14 what4236.53 makes4236.94 sense,4238.22 and4238.38 that's4238.38 that's4238.69 where4239.02 I4239.26 start.4239.41

4240.94 SPEAKER74240.94 -4240.94 Amen.4240.94

4243.18 SPEAKER44243.18 -4243.18 Get4243.18 really4243.49 far4243.73 on4243.98 common4244.22 sense.4244.61 Christine?4245.34 4250.76 COLE4250.76 -4250.76 You're4250.76 asking4251.16 me?4251.48 4251.96 BARTLEY4251.96 -4251.96 No.4254.04 I'm4254.28 just4254.44 looking4254.68 to,4255 you4255.24 know,4255.32 to4255.72 further4255.88 the4256.2 discussion4256.36 if4256.84 you4257 have4257.08 a,4257.48 you4257.64 know,4257.8 a4257.96 range.4258.12 4260.81 COLE4260.81 -4260.81 My4260.81 range4261.13 that4261.52 I4261.85 came4262.01 up4262.24 with4262.41 having4263.2 reviewed4263.6 all4264.89 of4265.13 these4265.28 various4267.85 computations4268.41 is4270.41 quite4270.65 close4270.97 to4271.36 what4271.6 Jimmy4272.31 came4272.63 up4272.87 with4273.03 at4273.43 the4273.67 outset.4274.07 I4275.51 had4275.67 12,0004280.15 and4280.15 22,000.4280.15 I'm4280.15 not4280.47 gonna4280.71 have4280.95 any4281.19 heartburn4281.43 if4281.91 it4282.07 goes4282.95 up4283.19 a4283.43 little4283.51 bit.4283.75 That's4284.07 sort4284.31 of4284.55 where4284.71 I4284.95 started4285.11 with4286.14 some4286.45 of4286.69 the4286.77 same4286.94 reasons4287.18 that4287.57 we4287.73 all4287.98 had.4288.14 I4288.77 looked4288.94 at4289.18 the4289.49 other4289.81 communities,4290.06 I4290.94 looked4291.09 at4291.34 the4291.49 reasonableness,4291.73 what4292.53 I4292.77 think4292.94 the4293.81 public4294.3 here4294.77 would4295.09 endorse4296.45 with4297.26 a4297.49 lot4297.57 of4297.73 explanation4297.98 from4298.61 us.4298.85 It4299.9 gives4300.14 room4300.61 for4301.09 growth4302.11 over4302.67 time.4302.99 I4304.43 really4304.67 appreciated4305.31 Mary's,4306.67 sort4307.79 of,4308.03 caution4310.03 about4311.23 linking4311.63 a4312.51 COLA4313.95 or,4314.63 in4314.63 spite4314.86 of4314.94 your4315.19 earlier4315.51 good4315.98 idea,4316.22 Jimmy,4316.63 to4318.06 the4318.39 existing4318.7 contracts.4319.34 I4319.9 think4319.98 there's4320.22 a4320.47 real4320.55 danger4320.78 in4321.1 that4321.26 that4321.98 I4322.15 hadn't4322.3 considered4322.63 until4323.59 she4323.98 said4324.15 it.4324.39 And4325.66 I4325.98 also4326.15 played4326.55 with4326.78 those4327.02 numbers4327.34 with4327.82 plus4328.22 24328.55 and4329.02 a4329.02 half4329.02 percent4329.29 just4329.69 as4329.93 a4330.25 factor4331.29 to4332.25 experiment4332.57 with.4333.13 So4333.45 I4334.25 think4334.33 we're4334.57 very4334.81 close4335.05 and4335.29 on4335.45 the4335.53 same4335.69 page.4335.85

4337.93 SPEAKER14337.93 -4337.93 Linda?4337.93

4339.45 SCOTT4339.45 -4339.45 I4339.45 was4339.45 agreeing4340.49 with4340.89 her,4341.13 but4341.45 I'm4343.31 throwing4343.48 something4343.72 entirely4344.6 different4345.06 into4345.52 it.4345.98 I4346.6 was4346.76 talking4346.99 to4347.48 the4348.52 clerk4348.76 in4349.07 Dedham4349.4 and4350.84 she4351.31 was4351.56 saying4351.8 they've4353.48 taken4353.8 away4354.11 their,4354.35 I4354.76 think4354.84 they4355.07 must4355.31 be4355.56 in4355.64 trouble4355.8 in4356.2 terms4356.28 of4356.52 finances4356.68 in4357.24 Dedham,4357.4 but4358.32 their4358.48 councilors4358.72 don't4359.28 get4359.84 anything4360.08 anymore.4360.56 However,4361.36 what4361.76 they4362 do4362.16 have4362.4 they4362.72 don't4362.8 have4363.04 to4363.2 show4363.28 up4363.44 at4363.6 work4363.76 either.4363.92 It's4364.16 all4364.4 on4364.56 Zoom.4364.8 And4365.76 they4367.12 have4367.44 a4368 minute4368.24 service.4368.64 They4369.28 send4369.52 the4369.76 audio4370 out4370.4 and4371.43 it4371.74 gets4371.98 done4372.31 for4372.55 them.4372.7 And4373.02 I'm4373.27 wondering4373.43 if4374.47 somewhere4374.78 along4375.1 the4375.43 line,4375.59 something4376.23 that4376.63 we4377.98 can4378.15 try4378.39 to4378.63 add4378.78 to4379.02 sweeten4379.27 the4379.66 pot4379.74 for4379.98 these4380.15 people4380.39 because4380.7 a4381.1 lot4381.27 of4381.51 people4381.66 are4383.02 having4383.19 trouble4383.51 with4383.82 those4383.98 minutes.4384.23 This4385.28 gentleman4385.52 is4386.64 a4386.88 minute4387.04 master,4388.24 however,4389.2 not4389.2 everyone4389.44 is4389.92 and4390.24 it4390.48 takes4390.64 a4390.88 while.4390.96 And4391.28 when4391.44 it4391.6 takes4391.76 a4392 while,4392.08 it4392.48 slows4392.64 down4392.88 government4393.12 until4393.6 you4393.92 get4394.08 your4394.24 minutes4394.4 out.4394.72 So4395.44 I'm4395.84 wondering4396 if4396.56 we4396.8 could4396.96 even4397.12 consider4397.44 that.4397.92 Is4398.72 there4399.44 something4399.68 that4400.08 we4400.24 could4401.57 throw4401.66 in4401.98 if4402.22 someone4402.45 wants4402.78 to4403.02 do4403.1 a4403.26 little4403.34 more4403.57 research4403.74 on4404.22 it?4404.3 There4404.78 is4405.18 one4405.41 committee4405.98 now4406.53 using4407.98 a4408.78 minute4408.94 service.4409.34 So4409.9 and4410.45 this4410.94 other4411.26 group4411.49 that4411.81 Dedham's4411.98 using,4412.45 they4412.7 seem4412.94 to4413.18 be4413.34 happy4413.41 with.4413.74 But4414.77 if4415.65 we4415.89 take4416.45 away4416.77 some4417.09 of4417.25 the4417.41 workload,4417.57 does4418.21 that4418.45 help4418.69 too?4418.93 You4419.65 know4419.89 what4419.97 I4420.13 mean?4420.21 4420.93 BARTLEY4420.93 -4420.93 And4420.93 that4421.49 doesn't4421.65 preclude4421.97 the4422.77 council4423.01 in4423.49 its4423.65 annual4423.89 budget4424.21 to4424.61 have4424.93 that4425.17 discussion4425.33 and4425.89 to4426.05 have4426.85 it4427.09 percolate4427.3 up4427.77 through4428.09 the4428.26 through4428.49 the4428.73 council4428.81 and4429.22 have4429.3 full4429.53 discussion4429.69 on4430.09 that,4430.26 which4431.14 may4431.38 be4431.53 different4431.69 than4432.02 it4432.73 may,4432.9 as4433.3 you4433.45 pointed,4433.61 it's4433.94 an4434.09 incentive4434.26 versus4434.81 the4435.38 the4435.69 stipend.4436.02 4436.81 SCOTT4436.81 -4436.81 Except4436.81 that4437.14 it4437.38 came4437.45 up4437.69 what4437.94 was4438.34 it,4438.57 Jimmy,4439.05 four4439.3 years4439.3 ago4439.45 and4440.43 it4440.51 disappeared4440.67 or4441.23 was4441.39 it4441.55 longer?4441.63 4443.95 MELLO4443.95 -4443.95 Yeah.4443.95 What4444.19 I4444.67 know4444.83 what,4444.99 well,4445.63 the4445.87 council4446.35 has4446.83 a4447.07 clerk,4447.47 they4447.63 always4447.63 have,4448.43 that4448.59 takes4448.59 the4448.83 minutes4448.99 of4449.31 the4449.47 council4449.63 meetings.4450.03 The4451.15 thing4451.39 is4451.55 when4451.87 you4452.03 get4452.11 to4452.35 subcommittees,4452.51 councils4453.47 were4453.95 taking4454.19 minutes.4455.07 And4455.76 some4455.91 of4456.16 them4456.31 didn't4457.6 like4457.99 doing4458.16 it4458.4 or4458.56 whatever.4458.72 It4459.11 became4459.35 a4459.68 burden4459.76 to4460.23 some4460.31 of4460.56 them4460.72 at4460.8 the4461.03 times,4461.11 and4461.52 some4461.76 of4461.91 them4461.99 didn't4462.23 mind.4462.48 Some4463.11 of4463.35 them4463.6 were4463.84 very4464.16 thorough4464.4 like,4464.8 Council4465.68 Piccirrelli.4466.16 I4466.8 mean,4466.95 he4467.11 is.4467.27 Many4467.6 of4467.76 you4467.91 are4468.16 very4468.31 good4468.56 at4468.8 your4468.88 minutes.4469.27 But,4470.24 you4470.56 know,4470.72 that's4470.88 the4471.2 thing4471.36 is4471.6 now4472.08 I4472.32 mean,4472.56 that4472.56 service4472.88 for4473.28 the4473.44 subcommittees,4473.6 I4474.24 could4474.4 see4474.56 that.4474.8 That4474.96 makes4475.2 sense.4475.44 Because4476.08 then4476.24 it4476.48 gets4476.64 away4476.88 from4477.2 because4477.36 they've4477.6 looked4477.84 to4478.08 bring4478.56 in4478.8 part4479.04 time4479.28 people4479.52 to4479.92 do4480 that4480.16 work,4480.4 and4480.56 I4480.8 don't4480.88 think4481.04 it's4481.28 ever4481.44 panned4481.76 out.4482 4482.72 SCOTT4482.72 -4482.72 Yeah.4482.72 And4482.96 I4483.12 just4483.52 think,4483.76 here's4484.91 an4485.15 opportunity4485.4 even4486.19 if4486.52 we're4486.68 not4486.84 giving4487.88 them4488.27 the4488.6 pathway4488.84 to4489.31 bring4489.88 the4490.11 topic4490.27 up4490.6 again4490.84 and4491.07 say,4491.23 by4491.56 the4491.72 way,4491.88 you4492.91 know,4493.07 your4493.88 work4494.03 could4494.27 be4494.52 a4494.68 lot4494.76 less4495.4 cumbersome.4495.64 You4497.12 wanna4497.28 bring4497.44 this4497.68 up4497.92 again.4498.16 We're4498.48 bringing4498.96 it4499.28 up4499.44 in4500 this4500.24 document4500.48 just4501.04 to4501.2 let4501.36 you4501.6 know4501.68 we're4502.24 aware4502.48 that4502.88 you've4503.04 gone4503.36 nowhere4503.6 on4503.92 this,4504.16 and4504.32 it's4504.56 to4504.88 your4505.04 advantage4505.28 to4505.92 go4506.08 somewhere4506.24 on4506.64 this.4506.8 4507.12 BARTLEY4507.12 -4507.12 Yeah.4507.12 My4507.52 other4507.76 comment,4508 Linda,4508.56 would4508.88 be4509.04 that4509.28 we're4509.52 very4509.84 close4510.08 with4510.48 AI.4510.72 I've4511.6 used4511.84 it4512.08 for4513.48 committee4513.73 minutes,4515.48 and4516.05 it's4516.6 not4517.01 refined4517.32 as4517.73 far4517.89 as4518.13 picking4518.2 up4518.52 who4518.6 said4518.84 what.4519.01 And4519.24 sometimes4519.4 you4519.8 don't4519.97 get4520.13 the4520.28 right4521.09 person.4521.24 But4521.56 I4521.97 think4522.05 AI4522.52 is4522.84 just4523.09 around4523.32 the4523.65 corner4523.73 that4524.93 that4525.24 may4525.4 be4525.65 a4525.8 helper4527.65 that's4529.46 there.4529.78 Marcy?4530.58 4532.02 MURNINGHAN4532.02 -4532.02 Yeah.4532.02 I4532.34 agree.4532.5 I4532.9 know4533.06 in4533.38 some4533.62 of4533.86 my4534.02 other4534.18 involvements4534.98 that4535.54 AI4535.94 tools4536.5 are4536.98 getting4537.38 better4537.7 and4538.02 we4538.18 know,4538.42 you4538.82 know,4538.98 this4539.22 is4539.38 something4539.94 that's4540.42 really4540.81 going4541.05 to4541.13 change4541.2 just4541.69 about4541.85 everything.4542.09 I4543.13 think4543.28 that's4543.93 where4544.24 now4544.89 we're4545.2 moving4545.45 into4545.85 the4546.24 category4547.05 of4547.77 things4548.09 that4548.41 would4548.56 attract4548.89 people4549.36 and4549.77 help4550.09 make4550.32 the4550.56 job4550.73 better.4551.2 You4551.93 know,4552.09 they're4552.24 sort4552.48 of4552.73 like,4552.89 what4553.45 is4553.6 the4553.85 stipend?4554.09 What4555.39 is4555.47 our4555.87 rationale4556.19 for4556.83 making4557.07 the4557.39 recommendation?4557.55 That4558.43 is4558.67 our4558.91 brief.4559.31 That4559.71 is4559.95 our4560.11 mandate.4560.35 But4561.39 I4561.63 think4561.71 also4562.03 we're4562.51 in4562.75 a4562.99 great4563.15 position,4563.55 especially4564.19 with4564.59 the4564.83 charter4564.99 review4565.39 happening4565.87 again4566.43 next4566.91 year4567.15 and4567.95 just4568.11 the4568.35 reality4568.51 of4568.99 what's4569.15 happening4569.47 around4569.95 us,4570.19 to4570.74 do4570.91 some4571.06 future4571.31 forecasting4571.86 and4572.51 some4573.15 kind4573.31 of4573.47 discussion4573.78 about4574.27 things4575.47 that4575.7 are4575.94 not4576.1 stipend4576.66 related4577.15 that4577.7 might4577.94 help4578.51 or4578.82 facilitate4579.15 the4581.15 job4581.39 of4581.63 representing4581.86 the4582.43 public4582.59 at4582.98 a4583.15 time4583.23 in4583.47 our4583.55 history4583.7 that's4584.1 very4584.35 complex,4584.66 and4585.44 also4585.68 things4586.32 that4586.64 are4586.8 down4587.04 the4587.28 road4587.44 or4587.76 around4588 the4588.24 corner4588.4 that4588.88 could4589.04 help4589.28 us4589.52 do4589.76 that,4589.92 like4590.32 AI4590.8 and4591.44 other4591.68 tools4591.92 so4592.32 that,4592.48 you4592.72 know,4592.88 we're4593.12 not4593.36 using4593.6 yesterday's4593.92 solutions4596.88 to4598.24 apply4598.56 to4599.12 today's4599.44 problems.4600 4603.97 BARTLEY4603.97 -4603.97 I4603.97 looked4604.22 at4604.45 the4605.34 numbers4605.97 and4605.97 it4605.97 was4606.14 interesting4606.3 when4607.18 I4607.34 was4607.41 looking4607.57 at4607.81 Sarah's,4608.38 that4608.85 was4609.01 around4609.49 the4609.81 range4609.97 that4610.38 I4610.93 was4611.09 looking4611.26 at.4611.49 You4611.81 know,4611.9 I4612.05 was4612.22 looking4612.38 at4612.61 something4612.69 in4612.89 the4613.09 154614.43 and4615.31 with4615.47 the4615.63 adjustment4616.27 for4616.83 the,4616.99 council4617.47 president.4617.87 And4618.27 I4618.43 didn't4618.51 think4618.75 until4618.99 tonight,4619.31 when4620.19 Jim,4620.43 you4620.67 had4620.75 made4621.15 reference4621.39 to4621.87 or4622.51 suggestion4622.75 saying,4623.23 or4623.95 was4624.11 it4624.35 was4624.51 you,4624.75 Susan,4624.91 that4625.31 he4625.71 gets,4625.95 and4626.36 I4626.53 agree4626.69 with4626.77 you.4627.16 The4627.56 council4627.73 president4628.13 would4628.45 get4628.6 whatever4629.16 the4629.56 stipend4629.73 is4630.13 for4630.28 school4630.45 committee4630.77 member4631.09 and4631.65 an4631.89 adjustment4632.05 for4632.77 the4633.49 job4633.65 of4633.97 running4636.45 the4636.69 councils.4636.93 That's4637.32 kind4637.81 of4638.13 where4638.13 my4638.45 head4638.93 is4639.09 at.4639.24 And4639.49 so4639.65 I4639.89 think4639.97 we're4640.2 we're4640.53 fairly4640.93 close.4641.32 Has4642.51 anyone4642.59 not4643.07 thrown4643.39 out4643.63 a4643.87 number?4644.19

4645.31 Me.4645.31 Fassie.4646.35 4647.39 MURNINGHAN4647.39 -4647.39 Yeah.4647.39 I'm4647.79 the4648.03 ethics4648.27 person.4648.67 15,0004650.27 sounds4651.07 good4651.31 to4651.55 me.4651.63 I4652.19 mean,4652.27 again,4652.75 this4653.31 is4653.55 sort4654.52 of4654.69 like4654.93 a4655.16 lot4655.24 of4655.56 data4655.73 swimming4656.05 around,4656.36 but4656.69 it's4656.93 very4657.09 reasonable,4657.89 it's4658.2 common4658.2 sense,4659.09 it's4659.48 wise4659.73 gut.4660.05 I4660.69 want4660.93 to4661.09 hear4661.16 that4661.32 story4661.56 again4661.89 about4662.2 the4662.44 cow4662.6 and4662.85 the4662.93 gut4663.09 and4663.32 everything.4663.4 I4663.81 was4663.89 trying4664.13 to,4665.65 cows4666.22 have4666.54 four4666.62 guts4667.02 and4667.26 there's4667.42 a,4667.54 you4667.78 know,4667.9 everything4668.14 has4668.46 a4668.7 purpose,4669.26 right?4670.46 And4670.46 Jim4670.62 has4670.94 done4671.42 a4671.66 good4671.74 job4671.98 with4672.22 that.4672.38 I4672.94 think4673.1 provisionally,4673.34 we4673.98 might4674.14 flag4674.7 and4675.02 include4675.58 this4676.06 part4676.38 about4676.7 school4677.1 committee4677.42 because4677.98 they're4678.54 also,4678.86 like,4679.66 really4680.22 doing4680.54 a4680.86 lot.4680.94 And4681.95 being4682.27 council4682.76 president4683.15 is4683.8 kind4684.03 of4684.19 a4684.35 double4684.59 job4684.84 in4685.64 the4685.88 sense4685.95 that4686.19 it4686.51 has4686.68 dual4686.91 responsibilities4687.31 even4688.27 as4688.51 the4688.76 work4689.55 demands4689.88 are4690.27 different.4690.43 But4691.23 on4691.55 the4691.8 number4691.88 15,4692.99 baby.4693.55

4694.11 SPEAKER14694.11 -4694.11 Okay.4694.11 Christine.4695.88 4697.32 COLE4697.32 -4697.32 I'd4697.72 like4697.96 to4698.12 propose4698.2 a4698.6 motion4698.68 that4699.08 we4699.24 endorse4700.12 the4700.6 proposal4701.32 offered4702.28 first4702.68 by4702.92 Jimmy4703.16 Mello4703.48 with4704.68 the4705 councilor's4705.24 salary4705.8 at4706.2 154706.44 and4706.84 the4707.72 council4707.8 president's4708.2 salary4708.68 at4709 25.4709.24

4711.84 SPEAKER14711.84 -4711.84 Do4711.84 we4712.16 have4712.24 a4712.4 second?4712.56 4715.76 MELLO4715.76 -4715.76 I'll4715.76 second4716.01 it.4716.4

4717.05 SPEAKER14717.05 -4717.05 Discussion4717.05 on4717.52 the4717.68 motion?4717.84 Susan.4718.56 4719.36 FALKOFF4719.36 -4719.36 Yeah.4719.36 I4719.76 like4721.6 the4721.84 15.4723.59 Again,4723.99 I4723.99 would4724.31 not4724.71 give4725.03 that4725.35 figure4725.67 for4726.87 the4727.75 council4727.99 president.4728.39 I4728.87 would4728.95 say4729.11 council4729.43 president4729.75 gets4730.31 council4730.87 salary4731.35 plus4731.75 school4732.07 committee4732.31 salary4732.71 plus4733.27 $2,000.4733.51 So4734.87 I4735.03 would,4735.75 I4735.83 don't4735.99 know4736.15 if4736.23 that's4736.39 an4736.55 amendment4736.71 to4737.44 the4737.6 motion.4737.76 4738.64 MELLO4738.64 -4738.64 I4738.64 as4739.11 the4739.35 second4739.52 would4739.84 accept4740.07 that4740.48 amendment.4740.8 4741.35 BARTLEY4741.35 -4741.35 Well,4741.35 Christine,4741.52 would4741.84 you4741.95 take4742.07 that4742.31 as4742.48 a4742.64 friendly4743.03 amendment?4743.44 4745.99 COLE4745.99 -4745.99 Yes.4745.99 I4746.64 don't4746.95 know4747.19 what4747.44 that4747.68 figure4747.91 would4748.31 be4748.48 and4749.03 I'd4749.27 be4749.44 curious4749.68 about4750.16 it.4750.4 It4751.95 would4752.11 go4752.19 to4752.44 27.4752.69

4752.94 It4752.94 would4753.19

4753.44 SPEAKER54753.44 -4753.44 go4753.44 to4753.69

4753.94 SPEAKER44753.94 -4753.94 27.4753.94 Well,4754.19 if4754.43

4754.93 SPEAKER14754.93 -4754.93 Well,4754.93 would4755.18 ma'am,4755.68 we4755.93 do4756.18

4756.59 SPEAKER114756.59 -4756.59 I4756.59 just,4756.67 it's4757.31 $4,900.4757.47 Okay.4759.31

4760.59 SPEAKER14760.59 -4760.59 4,0004760.59 that's4761.15 it.4761.31 That4761.47 okay.4761.71

4762.19 SPEAKER44762.19 -4762.19 Now4762.19 and4762.59

4762.99 SPEAKER14762.99 -4762.99 Thank4762.99 you.4763.23 4763.71 FALKOFF4763.71 -4763.71 That's4763.71 why4763.95 maybe4764.74 it4765.7 should4765.94 go4766.1 to4766.27 10,000,4766.43 maybe4766.98 it4767.15 should4767.23 go4767.39 to4767.55 6,000,4767.7 but4768.43 that4768.66 isn't,4768.82 as4769.47 Sarah4770.02 said,4770.34 that's4770.59 not4770.9 our4771.06 charge.4771.39 That's4772.1 why4772.27 I4772.51 would4772.59 just4772.74 make4773.06 the4773.47 amendment4774.19 to4774.66 be4774.82 whatever4775.15 the4775.55 school4775.63 committee4775.94 salary4776.27 is.4776.59 4776.9 BARTLEY4776.9 -4776.9 Yes.4776.9 So4776.9 it4776.98 would4777.06 be4777.15 the4777.23 school4777.31 committee4777.55 salary4777.86 plus4778.27 an4780.35 additional4780.59 $2,0004780.91 stipend.4781.87 4783.39 COLE4783.39 -4783.39 I4783.39 accept4783.55 the4783.87 friendly4784.03 amendment.4784.35

4785.23 SPEAKER14785.23 -4785.23 Alright.4785.23 Motion4786.27 has4786.75 been4787.07 made.4787.23 It's4787.71 been,4787.87 it's4788.67 been4788.91 amended.4789.15 It4789.87 and4790.43 so4791.15 so4792.19 the4792.43 motion4792.66 has4792.98 been4793.3 made4793.63 as4794.26 amended.4794.51 4794.9 SCOTT4794.9 -4794.9 Can4794.9 I4795.22 ask,4795.94 I'm4796.02 not4796.19 clear?4796.34 What4797.55 is4797.7 the4797.94 motion4798.02 again?4798.26 Say4798.66 it4798.82 again.4798.98

4799.39 SPEAKER14799.39 -4799.39 But4799.39 but4799.55 let4799.78 me4799.86 just4800.1 so4800.43 then4800.59 we'll4800.74 have4800.9 we're4801.15 gonna4801.3 have4801.55 discussion4801.78 on4802.1 that4802.26 now.4802.51

4802.59 SPEAKER34802.59 -4802.59 Oh,4802.59 okay.4802.74

4803.06 SPEAKER14803.06 -4803.06 Make4803.06 it.4803.15 Okay.4803.3 Alright.4803.55 4803.78 BARTLEY4803.78 -4803.78 So4803.78 the4803.94 motion4804.02 has4804.74 been4804.9 made4805.06 as4805.55 amended,4805.78 and4806.43 it4806.59 has4806.74 been4806.98 seconded.4807.15 Okay.4808.21 So,4809.45 Susan,4810.69 do4811.09 you4811.17 wanna,4813.09 my4813.33 understanding,4813.57 the4815.73 recommendation4815.97 is4816.61 for4816.77 the4817.01 councilors4817.17 to4817.65 be4817.81 $15,000,4818.05 the4820.77 council4822.36 president4822.77 to4823.16 be4823.32 25,0004823.56

4824.77 doll4824.77 no?4825.01

4825.48 SPEAKER34825.48 -4825.48 No.4825.48 Okay.4825.97

4827.16 SPEAKER14827.16 -4827.16 No.4827.16 No.4827.41 No.4827.48 I4827.65 just4827.73 so4828.28 I4828.52 just4828.6 alright.4828.93 So4829.24 Okay.4829.73

4829.89 SPEAKER94829.89 -4829.89 Okay.4829.89

4830.6 SCOTT4830.6 -4830.6 What4830.6 were4830.6 you4830.77 gonna4830.93 say,4831.16 Susan?4831.41 4831.73 FALKOFF4831.73 -4831.73 I4831.73 think4831.89 the4832.52 motion4832.69 is4833.01 the4833.56 councilors'4833.81 salary4834.13 is4834.6 $15,000.4834.77 The4836.23 council4836.39 president's4836.79 salary4837.35 is4837.83 15,0004838.63 plus4839.35 2,0004839.83 plus4840.95 whatever4841.35 the4842.07 current4842.23 school4842.87 committee4843.19 salary4843.83 is4844.55 at4845.03 that4845.91 year.4846.15 4846.71 BARTLEY4846.71 -4846.71 Thank4846.71 you.4846.87 I4847.19 sit4848.31 corrected.4848.55 That4849.51 is4849.66 the4849.82 4850.47 MELLO4850.47 -4850.47 I4851.91 did4851.98 the4852.23 calculation.4852.39 Right4853.19 now,4853.43 the4853.66 school4853.74 committee's4853.98 salary4854.47 is4854.86 4900.4855.91 So4856.15 on4856.31 that,4856.39 it'd4856.63 be4856.78 19,9004857.1 plus4857.74 the4857.98 $2,000.4858.15 It'd4859.35 bring4859.66 it4859.82 up4859.98 to4860.15 21,9004860.39 for4861.5 the4861.5 council4861.66 president.4862.06

4863.9 SPEAKER14863.9 -4863.9 Marcy.4863.9

4864.78 MURNINGHAN4864.78 -4864.78 Yeah.4864.78 We4865.1 haven't4865.26 talked4865.5 about4865.74 the4865.98 school4866.14 committee4866.46 part4866.86 until4867.18 tonight,4867.5 so4867.98 I'm4868.22 feeling4868.46 a4868.78 little4868.86 pushed4869.18 into4869.5 making4869.82 a4870.22 decision4870.46 about4871.1 both4871.42 of4871.74 those.4871.9 I4872.22 feel4872.38 far4872.78 more4873.02 confident4873.34 about4874.38 a4875.38 decision4875.53 regarding4876.1 the4876.57 city4877.22 councilors.4877.53 I4881.69 feel4881.94 I'm4882.49 making4882.73 a4882.98 decision4883.14 about4883.53 the4883.77 council4883.94 president4884.34 without4884.9 I4885.53 mean,4885.61 the4885.85 numbers4885.94 are4886.26 flying4886.41 around4886.73 in4886.98 terms4887.14 of4887.38 school4887.53 committee,4888.41 we4888.57 haven't4888.57 even4888.81 talked4889.14 about4889.38 the4889.61 school4889.77 committee.4890.02 4890.26 BARTLEY4890.26 -4890.26 So,4890.7 I4890.94 think4891.02 your4891.26 point4891.34 is4891.5 well4891.74 taken,4891.9 but4892.14 what4892.46 we4892.7 looked4892.94 at4893.1 is4893.34 saying,4893.5 alright,4893.9 that4894.54 the4894.7 council4894.86 president4895.18 gets4896.46 the4896.7 council4897.5 salary4897.9 or4898.3 stipend.4898.54 And4899.74 what's4901.1 the4901.42 other4901.58 role4901.82 of4902.14 the4902.3 council4902.46 president4902.94 is4903.58 to4903.74 be4903.9 a4903.98 school4904.14 committee4904.38 member.4904.7 They're4905.1 not4905.35 chair,4905.51 but4905.59 they're4905.74 a4906.06 school4906.23 committee4906.47 member.4906.78 So4907.27 we4907.43 would4907.66 give4907.74 them4907.9 that4908.23 stipend,4909.51 and4909.66 so4909.66 that's4909.9 where4910.15 it4910.31 is.4910.47 And4910.7 however4911.35 that4911.74 is4911.98 adjusted,4912.15 that's4912.86 the4913.1 stipend4913.27 that4913.66 they4913.82 would4913.98 get,4914.15 would4914.39 be4914.55 the4914.63 school4914.78 committee4915.02 stipend.4915.43 And4916.15 then4916.39 the4916.55 third4916.7 factor4917.02 was,4917.51 should4918.73 there4918.89 be4919.13 a4919.29 stipend4919.45 for4919.85 the4920.17 council4920.33 president4920.65 above4921.53 and4921.85 beyond4921.93 the4922.25 regular4922.41 council4922.81 one4923.13 for4923.69 the4923.93 duties4924.09 as4924.57 council4924.65 president,4925.05 i.e.,4925.93 presiding,4926.41 i.e.,4927.69 you4928.09 know,4928.25 negotiations4928.73 and4929.53 discussions4929.69 and4930.33 things4930.49 of4931.05 that4931.37 nature.4931.53 And4932.09 so4932.25 that's4932.41 where4932.85 this4933.16 amendment4933.19 comes4933.22 from.4933.24 So,4935.24 it's4935.73 not4935.89 within4936.13 our4936.45 purview4936.6 to4937.01 talk4937.16 about4937.49 the4938.2 the4938.45 school4938.6 committee,4938.85 but4939.56 we're4939.81 saying4940.05 whatever4940.69 the4941.09 school4941.24 committee4941.41 gets,4941.81 the4942.28 council4942.45 president4942.85 would4943.16 get4943.32 as4943.56 a4943.81 member,4943.89 you4944.28 know,4944.36 as4944.6 a4944.77 member4944.85 of4945.09 the4945.16 school4945.24 committee4945.49 given4945.81 his4946.05 title.4946.2

4947.73 Jack?4947.73 Yes.4948.28

4949.14 SPEAKER44949.14 -4949.14 May4949.14 I?4949.3

4949.7 SPEAKER14949.7 -4949.7 Yes.4949.7 Go4950.02 ahead,4950.18 Christine.4950.42 4951.3 COLE4951.3 -4951.3 I4951.3 think4951.54 that,4951.78 because4953.06 the4953.46 school4953.62 committee4953.86 discussion4954.26 is4954.74 not4954.9 within4955.14 our4955.46 purview,4955.62 I'm4956.9 comfortable4957.14 making4958.74 a4959.06 recommendation4959.22 for4959.94 the4960.1 council4960.12 president's4960.13 salary4960.15 that's4960.16 contingent4960.18 on4960.2 something4960.21 over4960.23 which4960.24 we4960.26 have,4988.99 so4989.23 what4989.23 I'd4989.23 like4989.23 to4989.23 propose4989.23 is4989.23 that4989.23 the4989.23 council4989.23 president4989.23 be,4989.23 as4989.23 Susan4989.23 mentioned,4989.23 the4989.23 council4989.23 salary4989.23 plus4989.23 the4989.23 school4989.23 committee4989.23 salary4989.23 plus4989.23 2,0004989.23 or4989.23 no4989.23 less4989.23 than4989.63 25%4991.23 because4991.47 we4991.78 can't4992.02 control4992.35 the4993.39 school4993.55 committee4993.78 salary.4994.27 4996.19 BAKER4996.19 -4996.19 So4996.19 currently,4996.51 you'd4996.82 be4996.99 giving4997.15 an4997.27 $8,0004997.39 bump4998.35 to4998.74 the4998.91 president,5001.95 so5002.11 they'd5002.11 be5002.35 making5002.51 50%5002.83 more5003.47 than5003.71 the5003.95 standard5004.67 city5006.03 councilor.5006.27

5007.95 I5007.95 can't5008.19 hear5008.43 you.5008.67

5008.99 SPEAKER55008.99 -5008.99 Can5008.99 you5009.15 just5009.23 speak?5009.39 Yeah.5009.71

5010.03 SPEAKER105010.03 -5010.03 Oh,5010.03 I'm5010.19 sorry.5010.35 Yeah.5010.67 5011.63 BAKER5011.63 -5011.63 Can5011.63 I5011.87 clarify?5012.03 The5013.23 council5013.39 president5013.79 currently5014.35 makes5014.91 the5015.55 council5015.79 salary5016.27 the5016.75 council5016.83 stipend5017.23 plus5017.93 the5018.09 school5018.24 committee5018.32 stipend.5018.81 So5019.85 we5020.32 could5020.57 say5020.81 5021.2 BARTLEY5021.2 -5021.2 Does5021.2 he5021.36 do5021.53 that?5021.69 5021.93 BAKER5021.93 -5021.93 Yes.5021.93 That's5022.73 the5022.97 current5023.2 setup.5023.6 So5024.01 I5024.32 believe5024.57 that5024.89 the5025.13 recommendation5025.28 here5026.01 is5026.24 to5026.41 take5026.57 the5026.81 current5026.97 setup5027.28 but5028.49 insert5028.81 a5029.2 new5029.36 city5029.93 council5030.32 stipend5031.05 and5031.69 then5031.85 add5032.24 the5032.49 bump.5032.65 But5033.32 the5033.4 Plus5033.64 School5034.12 Committee5034.36 is5034.84 a5035.08 continuation5035.24 of5036.04 what's5036.28 actually,5037.24 what's5037.64 in5037.96 place.5038.04 5041.72 SCOTT5041.72 -5041.72 Yeah.5041.72 5042.04 COLE5042.04 -5042.04 But5042.04 I5042.28 don't5042.36 think5042.52 it5042.76 is.5042.92 The5043.32 current5045.57 councilor5046.14 salary5046.69 is5047.01 8700,5049.73 the5050.38 school5050.38 committee5050.69 salary5051.09 is5051.57 4900.5052.05 Is5053.97 that5054.05 what5054.22 I5054.45 heard?5054.53 5054.85 MELLO5054.85 -5054.85 Yes.5054.85 5056.69 COLE5056.69 -5056.69 My5056.69 Excel5056.93 sheet5057.26 says5057.57 that's5057.81 13,600.5058.3 5060.88 FALKOFF5060.88 -5060.88 For5060.88 the5061.84 president5062.16 only?5062.64 5063.36 COLE5063.36 -5063.36 Correct.5063.36 5066.24 MELLO5066.24 -5066.24 That's5066.24 as5066.24 of5066.48 right5066.64 now.5066.8 That's5067.04 the5067.36 salaries5067.52 based5068 now.5068.24 5068.48 COLE5068.48 -5068.48 But5068.48 I5068.64 thought5068.8 his5068.96 salary5069.2 was5069.52 12,000.5069.92 5069.92 MELLO5069.92 -5069.92 I5071.16 don't5071.2 think5071.36 the5071.52 council5071.76 president's5072.4 salaries5072.88 ever5073.36 include5073.6 what5074.08 the5074.32 school5074.48 committee's5075.12 is.5075.12 That's5075.12 never5076.6 been.5076.93 This5077.56 is5077.81 something5077.97 unprovoked.5078.2 5078.69 BARTLEY5078.69 -5078.69 Okay.5078.69 We're5079.81 throwing5080.36 things.5081.41 Doug,5081.65 as5081.65 the5081.65 subject5081.81 matter5082.2 expert,5082.45 can5082.77 you5082.93 help5083.81 us5083.97 here?5084.2 5084.85 NEWTON5084.85 -5084.85 So5084.85 I5085.09 think5085.24 that5085.56 may5086.05 have5086.28 been5086.53 part5087.81 of5088.05 what5088.2 that5088.45 salary5088.69 was5089.16 trying5089.32 to5089.65 accomplish5089.81 but5090.36 there's5090.77 no5091.01 ordinance5091.57 that5092.21 says5092.37 the5093.25 council5093.41 president's5093.81 salary5094.29 must5094.77 be,5095.09 you5095.73 know,5095.89 the5096.13 the5096.37 council5096.53 base5096.93 salary5097.17 plus5097.65 school5098.61 committee,5102.05 so5102.45 yes.5102.45 A5104.47 quick5104.7 thought,5104.95 noting5105.59 that5105.82 I'm5106.06 not5106.15 on5106.39 the5106.47 committee5106.63 but5106.95 just5107.1 based5107.35 on5107.59 what5107.74 I'm5107.91 hearing,5108.06 what5108.63 you5108.78 could5108.86 theoretically5109.1 do5109.66 is5109.91 make5110.23 that5110.63 recommendation5110.95 noting5111.74 that5112.06 it's5112.23 based5112.39 on5112.63 what5112.78 the5112.95 school5113.03 committee5113.27 salary5113.66 was5114.15 at5114.47 the5114.63 time5114.7 of5114.95 the5115.1 deliberations5115.27 and5116.82 saying5117.06 any5117.38 future5117.62 school5117.94 committee5118.26 increases5118.66 are5118.98 outside5119.14 the5119.46 purview5119.62 of5120.1 this5120.26 committee.5120.5 So5121.06 it's5121.3 not5121.46 as5121.62 if5121.78 if5121.86 the5122.02 school5122.18 committee5122.42 salary5122.66 then5123.06 goes5123.22 up,5123.38 the5123.62 council5123.78 president's5124.1 salary5124.58 goes5124.98 up5125.22 before5125.54 that,5125.86 which5126.18 would5126.42 be5126.58 logistically5126.74 difficult5127.22 because5127.54 that5127.78 would5127.86 need5128.02 to5128.18 be5128.26 a5128.34 whole5128.42 new5128.66 ordinance5128.82 to5129.95 increase5130.11 the5130.44 council5130.52 president's5130.84 salary.5131.23

5135.88 SPEAKER15135.88 -5135.88 Let's5135.88 further5136.2 let's5136.68 keep5136.91 talking.5137.4 5140.35 COLE5140.35 -5140.35 So5140.35 my5141.64 intent5142.44 in5142.91 endorsing5143.4 Jimmy's5144.65 proposal5144.97 was5145.61 to5145.93 have5146.41 a5146.73 set5146.97 dollar5147.29 amount5147.61 for5147.93 both5148.17 positions,5148.49 for5149.05 the5149.29 council5149.53 and5150.57 the5150.89 council5151.37 president.5151.77 I5152.65 understand5152.89 the5153.53 amendment5154.01 but5155.61 that5155.85 doesn't5156.01 achieve5156.33 the5156.81 goal5156.97 right5158.09 now,5158.41 of5159.69 reaching5160.6 a5161.09 higher5161.24 salary5161.56 for5162.13 the,5166.05 go5166.05 ahead.5166.28 5167.03 FALKOFF5168.28 -5168.28 Yes,5168.28 I5168.69 believe5168.77 it5169.09 does,5169.56 and5169.81 perhaps5169.81 things5170.85 have5171.16 changed.5171.32 Maybe5172.77 it's5173.01 $12,0005173.24 Vinny5174.36 might5174.69 know,5174.93 as5175.51 a5175.75 set5175.91 salary.5176.39 Now5176.79 I5177.19 always5177.35 thought5177.75 it5178.39 was5178.55 the5178.79 council5178.95 salary5179.35 plus5179.75 the5180.07 school5180.15 committee5180.47 salary.5180.79 That's5181.75 not5181.99 the5182.95 case.5183.11 Okay.5183.43 I5183.99 think5184.07 it5184.39 should5184.55 be5184.79 the5184.95 case.5185.11 He5185.35 is5185.59 a5185.75 school5185.83 committee5186.15 member,5186.55 just5187.03 a5187.27 regular5187.43 school5187.91 committee5188.15 member.5188.55 And5189.57 I5190.14 don't,5190.3 and5190.77 we're5191.49 adding5191.81 a5192.93 $2,0005193.18 bonus5194.45 for5194.93 being5195.09 the5195.34 president,5196.14 so5196.38 it5196.38 is5196.53 more.5196.77 5198.69 COLE5198.69 -5198.69 I5198.69 guess5199.09 my5199.34 point5199.49 is5199.73 I5199.9 think5199.97 it5200.22 should5200.61 be5200.85 higher5201.01 than5201.26 that5201.49 based5201.73 on5201.97 what5202.22 I5202.7 was5202.86 not5203.02 present5203.26 during5203.66 the5203.9 conversations5204.94 with5205.58 the5206.38 councilors,5206.54 but5207.02 I5207.26 read5207.34 the5207.58 materials5207.82 and5208.46 the5208.62 notes.5208.78 And5209.26 I5209.74 think5210.14 it5210.38 seems5210.7 like5210.94 it's5211.18 a5211.34 lot5211.42 more5211.66 work5211.82 than5212.06 that.5212.22 5212.7 BARTLEY5212.7 -5212.7 So5212.7 what5214.06 we5214.3 have5214.46 here5214.7 is5214.86 that,5215.1 what5215.9 you're5216.14 proposing5216.46 is5217.1 less5217.34 than5218.26 what5219.06 Jim5219.38 has5219.61 proposed5219.85 for5220.18 the5220.41 council5220.49 president.5220.81 Is5221.14 that5221.3 correct?5221.45 5222.41 MELLO5222.41 -5222.41 That's5222.41 correct.5222.65

5223.22 But5223.22 Yeah.5224.65 Go5224.9 ahead.5225.06 5225.3 FALKOFF5225.3 -5225.3 Clarification.5225.3 Your5226.41 $25,0005228.02 figure,5229.38 I5229.77 thought,5230.25 was5230.65 based5230.89 on5231.21 assuming5232.01 a5232.49 $10,0005232.57 salary5233.69 for5234.09 the5234.17 school5234.33 committee,5234.57 which5235.21 we5235.45 can't5235.61 give.5236.01

5241.85 SPEAKER15241.85 -5241.85 Marcy5241.85 and5242.59 then5242.74 and5242.82 then5243.39 Sue5243.55 and5243.86 then5244.1 Sarah.5244.26 5244.59 MURNINGHAN5244.59 -5244.59 I5244.59 guess5244.66 we've5245.55 spent5245.94 a5246.43 lot5246.59 of5246.82 time5246.9 over5247.3 the5247.63 course5247.78 of5248.18 the5248.51 last5248.66 several5248.98 months5249.3 focusing5249.7 on5250.26 city5250.51 councilor5250.9 salaries5252.66 and5252.9 tonight5252.9 is5253.22 the5253.47 first5253.63 time5253.86 that5254.1 we've5254.26 talked5254.51 about5254.82 the5255.15 city5255.39 council5255.7 president.5256.1 It5257.29 wasn't5257.45 even5257.93 known5258.17 to5258.73 Mary5258.97 that5259.29 the5259.85 city5260.09 council5260.33 president,5260.73 until5261.13 Susan5261.53 mentioned5261.93 it,5262.33 that5262.65 the5262.97 city5263.13 council5263.45 president5263.93 serves5264.49 on5264.81 the5264.97 school5265.13 committee.5265.45 I'm5267.29 feeling5267.53 like5267.93 we're5268.33 biting5268.73 off5269.13 more5269.29 than5269.53 we5269.77 chew5270.01 right5270.97 now5271.13 in5271.37 this5271.53 moment,5272.11 November5272.19 4,5273.07 2024.5273.88 I5275.4 don't5275.48 know5275.72 why5275.95 we5276.76 can't5276.99 just5277.31 vote5277.55 on5278.11 a5278.27 stipend5280.52 for5281.07 city5281.31 councilors5281.64 and5282.91 then5283.07 continue5283.64 to5284.27 discuss5284.52 the5285.37 council5285.61 president,5286.01 because5286.57 I'm5286.89 hearing5287.13 different5287.61 assumptions5288.01 that5288.97 people5289.13 have5289.53 about5289.93 what5290.81 the5291.05 council5291.29 president5291.69 does,5292.25 how5293.13 he5293.37 does5293.53 it,5293.77 how5294.41 the5294.73 numbers5296.17 work.5296.65 And5297.61 to5298.22 load5298.45 all5298.61 of5298.93 that5299.18 into5299.49 a5299.89 motion5300.05 and5300.45 an5300.69 amendment,5300.93 I5301.65 think,5301.73 is5302.14 to5302.38 undermine5302.69 our5303.41 commitment5304.05 to5304.61 integrity.5304.85 It5305.49 just5305.65 feels5305.89 rushed5306.3 and5307.26 I5308.14 don't5308.3 like5308.53 it.5308.69 5309.49 BARTLEY5309.49 -5309.49 Okay.5309.49 As5309.81 the5310.05 chair,5310.99 I5311.39 don't5311.47 want5311.71 anyone5311.87 to5312.11 feel5312.27 rushed,5312.51 number5312.91 1.5313.23 You5313.79 know,5314.19 I5314.43 don't.5314.67 I've5315.63 tried5315.79 to5316.03 have5316.19 it,5316.43 you5316.51 know,5316.59 the5316.91 the5317.15 the5317.27 input.5317.39 We5320.11 didn't5320.43 even5320.75 you5321.15 know,5321.31 this5321.79 is5322.03 a5322.19 discussion5322.35 that5322.75 we5322.91 had5323.07 on5323.23 the5323.39 agenda.5323.47 It5324.03 was5324.11 really5324.43 holistic5324.91 and5325.47 a5325.94 good5326.66 discussion5326.9 that5327.3 we5327.55 came5327.7 to5327.94 close5328.26 to5328.59 numbers.5328.98 So,5330.74 you5331.3 know,5331.47 with5331.7 that,5332.43 you5332.98 know,5333.15 just5334.02 hold5334.26 off5334.59 on5334.74 that.5334.9 I5335.15 think5335.3 that5335.55 let's5335.86 have5336.51 a5336.66 further5336.74 discussion.5337.15 I'm5338.26 not5338.51 gonna5338.66 entertain5339.06 the5339.55 motion5341.3 as5341.89 of5342.05 now.5342.21 It's5342.37 on5343.09 the5343.25 floor5343.41 but5343.57 I5343.73 think5344.69 we5345.01 still5345.49 have5345.73 to5345.85 have5345.97 some5346.21 further5346.61 discussions.5346.93 But5347.41 your5347.89 point5348.05 is5348.37 very5348.61 well5348.85 taken.5349.09 No5350.21 one5350.37 is5350.53 gonna5350.69 be5350.85 rushed,5351.25 no5351.41 one's5351.41 gonna5351.57 be5351.81 forced.5351.97 And5352.21 if5352.45 we5352.61 have5352.69 to5352.85 bifurcate5353.01 it,5353.41 we'll5353.65 bifurcate5353.89 the,5354.61 you5354.77 know,5354.85 the5355.09 motion.5356.05 5356.77 MURNINGHAN5356.77 -5356.77 Yeah.5356.77 I5356.94 was5357.18 suggesting5357.41 that5357.9 we5358.06 bifurcate5358.3 it5359.49 and5359.66 then5359.66 we5359.9 can5360.06 at5360.3 least5360.45 get5361.34 resolved.5361.66 It5362.3 seems5362.53 we5362.85 have5362.94 consensus5363.34 on5363.98 the5364.14 city5364.3 council5364.61 piece.5365.1 Let's5365.98 build5366.3 on5366.61 our5366.85 strengths.5367.1 And5368.3 then5368.45 the5369.02 next5369.18 piece5369.63 of5369.95 that,5370.03 which5370.51 I5370.75 think5370.91 we5371.15 can5371.23 do,5371.47 it5371.79 just5371.95 warrants5372.19 more5372.59 discussion,5372.91 but5373.55 it's5373.79 already5374.03 eight5374.59 o'clock,5374.83 and5375.39 it's5376.35 election5376.67 tomorrow.5377.15 So5377.55 I'm5377.71 very5377.95 concerned5378.19 about,5378.67 you5378.99 know,5379.07 the5379.31 time5379.47 we5379.79 need5379.95 to5380.19 take5380.27 to5380.59 talk5380.67 about5380.91 our5381.23 planning.5381.39 But5382.27 if5382.51 we5384.57 have5384.65 a5385.93 related5386.18 discussion5386.81 of5387.38 the5387.53 council5387.69 president5388.09 role5388.65 that5390.65 would5390.81 allow5391.14 me5391.45 to5391.61 take5391.77 a5392.01 deep5392.09 breath.5392.34 5392.9 BARTLEY5392.9 -5392.9 True.5392.9 Again,5393.85 my5394.9 role5395.05 is5395.3 not5395.45 to5395.61 force5395.77 anything5396.01 on5396.34 anyone,5396.49 just5396.81 have5396.97 a5397.14 free5397.22 discussion,5400.37 but5400.38 I5400.38 know,5400.38 Sarah,5400.39 you5400.39 wanted5400.4 to5400.41 have5400.41 a5400.42 further5400.44 comment.5400.44 5400.85 BAKER5401.01 -5401.01 Yeah,5401.01 two5401.01 points.5401.01 1,5402.45 Doug,5403.01 maybe5403.33 you5403.49 can5403.65 look5403.89 into5404.13 this5404.29 for5404.53 us,5404.85 but5405.09 is5405.09 it5405.25 possible5405.33 for5406.21 us5406.45 to5406.69 determine5407.73 the5408.13 city5408.29 council5408.53 president5408.93 salary5409.41 for5409.89 the5410.05 city5410.21 council5410.53 president5410.85 role5411.41 and5412.18 then5412.49 any5412.74 increase5413.06 in5413.3 the5413.45 school5413.61 committee5413.77 is5414.1 compensated5414.66 separately5415.3 as5415.77 a5415.94 school5416.02 committee5416.26 member5416.74 as5417.53 opposed5417.7 to,5418.1 so5418.41 we5419.38 don't5419.53 touch5419.85 that,5420.26 we5420.41 can5420.41 effectively5420.66 get5421.3 to5421.45 the5421.61 city5421.77 council5422.1 president5422.41 plus5422.81 school5423.14 committee5423.38 by5423.94 not5424.1 speaking5424.34 to5424.66 the5424.81 school5424.9 committee5425.22 part5425.61 at5426.02 all?5426.18 5428.03 NEWTON5428.03 -5428.03 You5428.03 can.5428.27 I5428.83 just5429.07 wanna5429.15 make5429.39 sure5429.47 I'm5429.63 understanding5429.79 the5430.19 question.5430.35 Are5430.75 you5430.99 asking5431.15 that5431.71 any5433.31 future5433.63 school5433.95 committee5434.19 increases5434.59 would5434.99 then5435.15 be5435.39 built5435.47 into5435.71 the5435.95 council5436.11 president's5436.43 salary?5436.91 5438.67 BAKER5438.67 -5438.67 No.5438.67 Could5438.91 the5439.15 school5439.23 committee,5440.35 sorry.5440.59 Could5440.99 the5441.23 city5441.47 council5441.71 president5442.11 receive5443.28 compensation5443.68 as5444.24 a5444.4 school5444.48 committee5444.72 member5445.91 and5446.07 that5446.07 happens5446.31 in5447.03 one5448.36 piece5448.49 and5448.49 then5448.49 the5448.64 city5448.72 council5448.95 president,5452.24 okay.5452.24 I'm5452.56 very5453.03 sorry.5453.28

5455.72 SPEAKER15455.72 -5455.72 No.5455.72 Okay.5456.52

5457.16 SPEAKER105457.16 -5457.16 So5457.16 that5457.32 that's5457.56 So5458.52

5458.68 SPEAKER15458.68 -5458.68 what5458.68 Now,5459

5459.16 SPEAKER105459.16 -5459.16 I'll5459.16 do5459.24 that.5459.4 I5459.56 have5459.64 another5459.72 another5460.04

5460.52 SPEAKER55460.52 -5460.52 point.5460.52 Yep.5460.92 5461.4 BAKER5461.4 -5461.4 I5461.4 just5461.56 quickly5462.36 pulled5462.84 up5463.16 Mary's5465.56 data,5466.04 and5467.4 looked5467.72 at5467.96 the5468.12 differential5468.36 between5469.08 the5469.48 city5469.64 council5469.96 president5470.44 and5471.18 the5471.34 city5471.41 council5472.77 member5473.02 in5474.22 her5474.45 spreadsheet5474.85 here.5476.53 About5476.85 half5476.85 of5477.1 the5477.26 communities,5477.41 and5477.81 this5478.06 is5478.38 quick5478.61 and5478.85 dirty,5479.26 about5479.49 half5479.49 the5479.66 communities,5479.81 there's5480.22 no5480.53 difference5480.77 at5481.1 all5482.06 and5482.22 I5482.22 could5482.3 assume5482.53 that's5482.85 because,5483.1 for5483.41 example,5483.66 our5484.06 city5484.38 council5484.69 president5485.02 doesn't5485.41 have5485.66 any5485.81 committee5486.06 assignments.5486.38 So5486.91 I5487.15 could5487.31 understand5487.63 that5487.87 there's5488.11 an5488.35 offset5488.51 there.5488.83 And5489.95 then5490.11 this5490.91 is5491.15 eyeball,5491.47 not5491.95 averaging,5492.19 but5493.39 it's5493.71 usually5493.95 a5494.43 25494.59 to5494.83 $3,0005494.99 differential.5496.03 The5498.43 data5498.67 that5498.99 we5499.15 have5499.31 here5499.47 does5499.71 not5499.95 indicate5500.11 it's5500.51 a5500.67 large5500.75 differential.5501.07 5503.63 BARTLEY5503.63 -5503.63 Okay.5503.63 What5506.82 I'm5507.15 gleaning5507.39 here5507.78 is5508.1 that,5508.27 you5509.23 know,5509.39 we5509.55 have5509.94 some5510.1 people5510.35 feel5510.59 that5510.74 being5510.9 rushed5511.15 on5511.39 the5511.47 council5511.63 president.5511.94 I5513.15 think5513.31 that5513.55 we5513.78 have5514.02 a5514.94 consensus5515.02 on5515.58 the5515.74 council.5516.46 So5517.98 if5518.78 we5518.94 could5519.1 withdraw5519.42 that5519.9 amended5520.94 motion5521.58 and5521.98 just5522.38 deal5522.62 with5522.86 the5523.1 council,5523.18 I5524.38 think5524.54 that5524.78 we'll5525.02 get5525.34 to5525.58 yes5525.82 on5526.06 that.5526.3 And5526.95 then5527.03 we5527.28 can,5528.07 I5529.11 think5529.2 what5529.52 I'm5529.68 hearing5529.84 is5530.16 schedule5530.4 our5530.8 next5530.88 meeting5531.11 to5531.52 talk5531.6 about5531.76 the5532.07 council5532.48 president5532.88 and5534.72 what5534.95 compensation.5537.2 So5537.2 is5537.52 5537.84 FALKOFF5537.84 -5537.84 I'll5537.84 withdraw5537.99 my5538.4 motion.5538.56 5539.29 BARTLEY5539.29 -5539.29 So5539.29 motion's5540.25 withdrawn.5541.69 Okay.5542.17 5543.13 FALKOFF5543.13 -5543.13 I5543.13 move5543.29 that5543.61 we5543.93 make5544.33 this,5544.97 we5545.53 recommend5545.93 a5546.65 $15,0005546.89 a5548.57 year5548.73 compensation5549.69 for5550.57 city5550.97 councilors.5551.29

5552.65 SPEAKER15552.65 -5552.65 Motion5552.65 made.5553.13 5554.33 MELLO5555.8 -5555.8 Second.5555.8 5555.8 Hearing5557.64 none,5558.11 what5560.6 I'll5560.84 have5560.99 is5561.07 a5561.31 a5561.56 roll5561.64 call.5561.88

5564.91 SPEAKER25564.91 -5564.91 Marcy5564.91 Murningham.5565.4

5566.27 SPEAKER75566.27 -5566.27 Yes.5566.27

5568.6 SPEAKER25568.6 -5568.6 Linda5568.6 Scott.5568.99 Yes.5569.56 Susan5571.1 Falcoff?5571.42 Yes.5572.14 Jimmy5573.18 Mello?5573.58

5574.22 SPEAKER65574.22 -5574.22 Yes.5574.22

5575.18 SPEAKER25575.18 -5575.18 Christine5575.18 Cole?5575.74

5576.22 SPEAKER85576.22 -5576.22 Yes.5576.22

5577.42 SPEAKER25577.42 -5577.42 Sarah5577.42 Baker?5577.82

5578.46 SPEAKER105578.46 -5578.46 Yes.5578.46

5579.5 SPEAKER25579.5 -5579.5 And5579.5 Jack5579.9 Bartley?5580.06 5580.7 BARTLEY5580.7 -5580.7 Yes.5580.7 It's5580.94 unanimous.5581.26 I5582.22 wanted5582.86 to5582.98 have5583.1 a5583.26 roll5583.34 call5583.58 of5584.22 members5584.22 because5584.62 as5585.36 you'll5585.52 see,5585.69 I'm5585.85 very5586.09 quick5586.32 on5586.56 all5586.81 in5586.97 favor,5587.13 opposed,5587.45 no.5587.85 I5588.16 just5588.32 wanted5588.56 to5588.69 make5588.81 sure5588.97 that5589.2 for5589.45 the5589.69 record5589.77 and5590.09 for5590.16 the5590.32 public5590.41 and5590.65 everyone5590.81 to5591.2 see5591.69 it5591.85 that5592.01 way.5592.09 Okay.5593.36 So5594.01 we5594.65 have5594.89 that.5595.13 Any5595.93 further5596.32 discussion?5596.65 5598.73 FALKOFF5598.73 -5598.73 I5598.73 think5599.13 that5600.17 there5600.41 may5600.57 be5600.81 a5600.97 law5601.05 that5601.29 if5601.85 it's5602.09 about5602.33 a5602.73 number5602.89 like5603.37 that,5603.61 that5603.93 it5604.09 has5604.25 to5604.41 be5604.57 a5604.65 roll5604.81 call.5605.05 So5605.21 that's5606.17 another5606.41 reason5606.73 you5607.05 did5607.13 the5607.29 right5607.45 thing.5607.61 And5608.41 I5608.65 think5608.73 that5609.05 Vinny5609.29 might5609.69 have5609.85 some5610.09 clarifications5610.33 about5611.61 salary5612.01 for5612.49 us.5613.32 5614.2 BARTLEY5614.2 -5614.2 What5614.44 we5614.6 can5614.68 do5614.84 now5615.09 is5615.32 we5615.48 can5615.65 open5615.8 up5616.05 to5616.2 the5616.36 public5616.44 if5617.56 if5617.97 we've5618.28 done5618.44 our5618.68 job5618.84 doing5619.16 that.5619.4 Alright.5619.56 So5619.8 when5619.97 we5620.05 open5620.13 the5620.36 public,5620.44 we'll5620.68 have5620.93 Vinny5621.09 and5621.4 the5621.89 Elodia5622.2 if5622.2 you5622.36 wanna5622.44 speak,5622.68 glad5623.09 to5623.32 have5623.48 it.5623.56 5624.52 VINCENT5624.52 PICCIRILLI5624.52 -5624.52 WATERTOWN5624.52 CITY5624.52 COUNCIL5624.52 -5624.52 Sure.5624.52 I5624.84 just5626.11 wanna5626.35 point5626.59 out,5626.75 so5626.91 under5627.07 the5627.63 charter,5627.79 the5628.83 position5628.99 is5629.39 the5630.11 president5630.27 and5630.75 school5630.99 committee5631.31 members.5631.63 It's5631.95 not5632.03 two5632.19 separate5632.35 positions,5633.79 so5634.43 there's5634.43 one5634.67 salary.5634.99 So5635.63 you're5636.03 not5636.11 it's5636.35 not5636.59 like5636.75 you5637.97 get5638.13 two.5638.28 And5638.6 I5638.84 just5638.93 wanna5639.09 point5639.32 out5639.56 in5639.72 most5639.97 cities,5640.28 it's5640.76 the5641.16 mayor5641.4 who's5641.89 the5642.2 chief5642.36 executive5642.68 officer5643.16 who's5643.72 a5644.05 member5644.2 of5644.44 the5644.48 school5644.52 committee.5644.84 In5646.2 Watertown,5646.44 it's5647.01 not5647.16 the5647.4 manager,5647.56 it's5648.13 the5648.44 president.5648.6 So5649.09 it's5649.24 just,5649.97 not5650.36 every5650.6 city5650.84 is5651.32 set5651.56 up5651.8 the5651.89 same5652.05 way.5652.28 5654.86 FALKOFF5654.86 -5654.86 What5655.98 you5656.22 said,5656.38 does5656.86 that5657.1 mean5657.34 that,5657.82 does5659.5 what5659.82 you5660.06 say5660.22 prohibit5661.26 us5661.98 saying5662.54 that5662.94 the5663.26 president's5663.5 salary5664.14 equals5664.94 the5665.58 councils5665.74 salary5666.3 plus5666.86 a5667.56 stipend5667.8 plus5668.13 a5668.44 school5668.6 committee5668.93 salary?5669.24 5670.93 PICCIRILLI5670.93 -5670.93 The5670.93 ordinance5671.32 has5671.72 to5671.89 say,5672.68 effective5673.09 this5673.56 date,5673.89 the5674.2 council5674.28 president's5674.68 salary5675.48 is5675.89 x.5676.13 You5677.72 can5677.72 have,5678.28 in5678.52 your5678.68 committee5679.09 report,5679.48 you5679.8 can5679.89 say,5680.13 well,5680.2 we5680.44 arrived5680.6 at5680.93 this5681.09 number.5681.32 Here's5681.8 the5682.2 logic5683.47 we5683.91 took5683.91 the5684.35 15,0005684.75 you5685.39 voted5685.55 on,5685.79 plus5686.51 x5687.47 for5687.71 work5688.35 in5688.59 the5688.75 school5688.83 committee,5688.99 plus5689.31 x5689.63 for5689.79 work5689.95 for5690.11 being5690.27 a5690.51 chair,5690.59 and5690.99 that5691.23 number5691.47 so,5692.27 basically,5692.59 like,5692.99 if5693.15 you5693.31 look5693.39 at5693.55 what5693.63 Jimmy's5693.79 proposal,5694.19 he5694.75 had5694.91 two5695.07 numbers,5695.23 15,000,5695.71 25,000.5696.35 The5697.76 ordinance5697.99 would5698.31 say,5698.55 city5698.95 council5699.27 salary5699.59 is5699.99 set5700.07 at5700.23 15,000,5701.76 city5701.99 council5701.99 president's5702.31 salary5702.64 is5702.95 set5703.03 at5703.19 25,0005704.47 but5704.64 the5704.8 logic5705.43 about5705.91 how5706.23 you5706.4 got5706.72 to5706.95 it5707.03 would5707.19 not5707.35 be5707.51 part5707.68 of5707.91 the5707.99 ordinance.5708.15 5708.8 FALKOFF5708.8 -5708.8 But5708.8 that5708.95 would5709.19 mean5709.43 that5710.22 the5710.54 city5710.94 council5712.22 president5712.62 would5713.58 not5713.74 get5713.98 the5714.14 same5714.3 raise5714.54 as5714.78 school5714.94 committee5715.18 members5715.5 if5715.98 that5716.22 salary5716.46 were5716.94 increased.5717.18 5718.14 PICCIRILLI5718.14 -5718.14 Right.5718.14 Yes,5719.42 two5719.58 separate5719.58 ordinances,5719.98 two5720.94 separate5721.1 things.5721.42 And5721.66 I'll5721.82 just5722.14 point5722.38 out5722.62 that5722.7 there5723.94 was5724.1 quite5724.26 a5724.43 bit5724.51 of5724.66 discussion5724.82 when5725.22 the5725.39 school5725.55 committee5725.86 salary5726.18 was5726.59 increased5726.74 to5727.06 $4,9005727.22 in5728.66 2019.5728.98 Under5732.34 state5732.74 law,5732.98 having5734.34 an5734.82 elected5734.98 official5735.39 with5735.7 a5735.78 salary5735.86 over5736.26 $5,0005736.43 triggers5737.55 a5739.19 series5739.43 of5739.83 events5739.99 that5740.47 we5740.71 did5740.87 not5740.95 want5741.19 to5741.43 trigger,5741.51 including,5743.67 like,5744.07 pension5744.55 benefits5745.03 and5745.59 other5745.75 things.5745.99 So5746.47 that's5746.95 why5747.27 it's5747.67 not5748.47 $5,000,5749.43 it's5749.59 $4,900.5749.59 5751.74 BARTLEY5751.74 -5751.74 And5751.74 a5751.98 single5752.06 individual5752.39 getting5752.86 two5753.1 different5753.43 stipends,5753.82 you5754.7 know,5754.78 it's5755.27 5755.9 PICCIRILLI5755.9 -5755.9 Well,5755.9 so5756.63 stipends5756.94 so5757.51 state5757.66 law,5757.98 you5758.63 know,5758.7 under5760.39 state5760.63 law5760.86 it's5761.02 considered5761.19 salary.5761.74 Under5762.7 state5763.02 law5763.34 if5764.8 you're5765.04 getting5765.28 paid5765.52 more5765.68 than5765.84 $5,000,5766 it's5766.72 considered5766.96 to5767.44 be5767.6 a5768 full5768.16 time5768.32 job5768.64 even5769.12 if5769.44 you5770.72 never5770.96 show5771.28 up5771.44 for5771.52 work5772.88 and5773.04 that5773.04 has5773.2 to5773.44 do5773.52 with,5773.76 for5774.08 the5774.24 purposes5774.4 of5774.88 getting5775.04 benefits.5775.36 You5776.8 can't5777.04 collect5777.44 two5779.73 different5779.9 salaries.5781.34 So5782.06 if5782.3 you5782.45 were5782.53 a5782.69 firefighter5782.85 who5783.34 ran5783.41 for5783.65 city5783.73 council5784.06 and5784.94 got5785.1 elected,5785.34 you5786.06 would5786.22 have5786.38 to5786.45 choose,5786.61 you're5786.85 gonna5787.02 get5787.18 the5787.34 city5787.41 council5787.57 salary5787.98 or5788.22 you're5788.38 gonna5788.53 get5788.77 your5788.85 firefighter5789.1 salary.5789.57 5789.9 BARTLEY5789.9 -5789.9 That's5791.34 what5791.57 I5791.73 meant.5791.81 5792.37 PICCIRILLI5792.37 -5792.37 You5792.93 can't5793.09 get5793.33 two,5793.41 a5794.21 municipal5794.37 employee5794.85 cannot5795.25 collect5795.57 two5795.81 salaries5796.05 from5796.45 the5796.61 same5796.69 municipality.5796.93 I5799.97 would5800.13 just5800.29 keep5800.45 it5800.61 simple.5800.69

5801.17 SPEAKER15801.17 -5801.17 Oh,5801.17 no.5801.33 Thank5801.49 you.5801.81

5804.85 Okay.5804.85 Elodia?5806.13 Sure.5807.15 5810.1 ELODIA5810.1 THOMAS5810.1 -5810.1 RESIDENT5810.35 -5810.35 Well,5810.35 after5810.35 what5810.59 Vinny5810.82 has5811.15 said,5811.31 that5811.47 keeps5811.63 it5811.94 pretty5812.1 clean5812.43 and5813.06 what5813.39 Jimmy5813.63 was5814.02 going5814.27 for5814.59 because5814.98 if5815.31 you5815.47 added5815.7 5,5817.55 the5817.86 495818.1 was5818.59 gonna5818.74 come5818.98 to5819.23 21,900,5819.47 and5820.27 as,5820.74 Sarah5821.39 said,5821.78 the5822.1 differential5822.27 was5822.74 25823.05 to5823.13 30005823.45 between5825.13 the5825.53 councilors5825.69 and5826.57 the5828.01 president.5828.57 So5828.57 you5828.73 could5828.89 make5829.05 it5829.21 if5829.45 you5829.61 added5829.77 it5830.17 the5830.33 3,5830.57 that'd5830.89 be5831.13 another5831.21 one,5831.69 so5831.85 it'd5831.85 be5831.93 almost5832.17 23,000.5832.49 But5834.65 if5834.81 you5834.97 can't5835.05 separate5835.64 those5836.03 things5836.2 out,5836.52 we'd5836.84 be5837.16 addressing5837.31 this5837.72 again5838.03 in5838.35 five5838.52 years5838.76 when5839.07 you5839.24 all5839.4 come5839.56 back5839.8 together5840.03 again.5840.44 I5841.24 think5841.4 what5841.64 I5841.88 look5842.03 for5842.2 in5842.52 this5842.76 whole5842.99 process5843.31 was5843.8 the5844.28 intellectual5844.52 exercise5845.4 that5845.95 I5846.2 think5846.28 Linda5846.6 did5846.99 a5847.16 fabulous5847.31 job5847.88 and5848.11 Sarah5848.35 as5848.76 well,5848.84 and5849.07 they5849.24 came5849.4 at5849.56 it5849.8 from5849.88 two5850.11 different5850.35 angles.5850.76 Then5851.89 I5852.13 looked5852.29 for5852.53 the5852.61 gut5852.85 check5853.09 because5854.37 you5855.09 all5855.25 feel5855.49 comfortable5855.81 with5856.45 this5856.69 255857.25 for5858.45 Mark,5858.77 let's5859.01 say,5859.33 for5859.57 the5859.81 council5859.97 president5860.37 and5861.25 the5861.41 15.5861.65 And5862.29 then5862.53 I5862.69 think5862.85 about5863.09 how5863.33 you5863.57 sell5863.73 it5863.97 on5864.13 the5864.29 street.5864.45 And5865.74 so5866.06 to5866.55 me,5866.78 it's5867.02 like5867.27 when5867.51 you5867.74 add5867.9 the5868.23 work5868.55 that5868.94 our5870.23 president5870.55 does,5870.94 which5871.27 is5871.43 extensive,5871.82 plus5873.35 the5873.9 salary5874.15 and5874.63 all5874.78 that,5875.02 you5875.19 really5875.82 have5876.06 a5876.23 rationale5876.31 to5876.94 present5877.02 to5877.43 people5877.59 that's5877.82 pretty5878.15 clean5878.47 and5878.78 simple.5879.02 And5879.93 I5880.09 think5880.25 you5880.57 want5880.73 that5881.05 for5881.53 whatever5881.77 reverb5882.25 goes5882.81 on.5883.05 So5884.25 I5884.65 really5884.89 like,5885.21 maybe5885.77 you5886.09 should5886.17 go5886.33 back5886.49 to5886.65 that5886.81 rounded5887.05 figure5887.53 that5888.09 Christine5888.33 certainly5889.05 is5889.45 smiling5889.69 about5890.09 because5891.13 it's5891.37 clean,5891.61 and5891.93 it's5892.09 simple,5892.33 and5893.01 incorporates5893.48 everything,5893.97 and5894.36 it5894.52 gives5894.69 that5894.93 little5895.16 wiggle5895.4 room5895.8 should5896.13 something5896.44 change,5897.01 but5897.48 it's5898.2 solid.5898.52 5899.32 BARTLEY5899.32 -5899.32 Thank5899.32 you5899.56 for5899.65 your5899.8 suggestions.5900.05 Okay.5902.28 So,5902.84 I5905.67 think5905.83 our5906.07 our5906.47 next5906.55 discussion5906.87 should5907.35 be5907.43 our5907.67 next5907.75 meeting.5908.07 Doug?5908.71 5910.87 NEWTON5910.87 -5910.87 Sure.5910.87

5911.35 SPEAKER15911.35 -5911.35 Linda?5911.35

5911.75 SCOTT5911.75 -5911.75 I'm5911.75 sorry.5911.99 Could5912.23 I5912.39 just5912.55 mention5912.71 one5913.11 more5913.19 thing?5913.43 One5913.91 of5914.15 the5914.23 things5914.31 that5914.55 was5914.71 mentioned5914.95 to5915.27 us,5915.43 and5915.67 I5915.83 hate5915.91 to5916.15 bring5916.23 this5916.47 up5916.63 because5916.87 we're5917.35 all5917.67 happy5917.83 right5918.23 now,5918.39 but5919.19 one5920.26 of5920.49 the5920.53 things5920.57 they5921.06 asked5921.22 us5921.45 to5921.61 do5921.85 was5922.34 think5922.66 about5922.9 a5923.14 strategy5923.3 going5923.85 forward.5924.26 And5925.22 I5925.61 don't5925.78 know5926.02 if5926.41 we're5926.82 gonna5927.06 get5927.3 to5927.45 it5927.53 or5927.7 not,5927.85 but5928.1 I5928.41 would5928.57 just5928.74 like5928.98 to5929.14 put5929.3 this5929.45 in5929.61 people's5929.78 minds5930.26 that5930.74 I5931.45 mean,5931.53 Mary5931.85 wasn't5932.18 really5932.9 thrilled5933.22 with5933.7 going5935.04 with5935.44 a5935.68 COLA5935.84 or5936.24 whatever.5936.4 But5937.52 they5937.68 do5938 not5938.16 wanna5938.48 be5938.88 facing5939.28 this5939.68 every5940 couple5940.32 of5940.64 years.5940.8 So5941.28 if5942.24 people5942.48 could5942.8 think5942.96 about5943.2 that5943.52 before5943.84 our5944.24 next5944.4 meeting,5944.72 maybe5945.12 that's5945.36 something5945.68 we5946 could5946.16 discuss5946.4 too5946.8 because5947.04 it5947.74 was5947.9 one5948.3 of5948.39 the5948.55 things5948.7 on5949.1 the5949.26 agenda.5949.43 5949.9 BARTLEY5949.9 -5949.9 I5949.9 think5949.98 we5950.15 can5950.22 put5950.7 that5950.86 on5951.1 there5951.18 as5951.51 well.5951.9 I5952.15 think5954.06 there's5954.22 a5954.55 lot5954.63 of5954.86 positions5955.02 that5955.51 we5955.82 have5955.98 on5956.15 that.5956.3 So,5958.47 Doug,5958.7 you5959.18 look5959.43 at5959.59 meetings.5959.66 Elodia,5959.98 do5960.18 you5960.39 wanna5960.55 say5960.7 something?5960.86 5961.3 THOMAS5961.3 -5961.3 One5961.46 more5961.7 thing.5961.78 I5962.02 just5962.1 thought5962.34 about5962.58 this,5962.82 Jack.5963.62 I5964.02 believe5964.18 that5964.58 the5964.82 manager5965.06 makes5965.54 2505966.34 something.5967.06 So5967.94 this5968.18 council5968.34 president's5968.82 salary5969.46 then5969.86 is5970.1 almost5970.26 10%5970.58 of5971.22 the5971.38 manager's5971.54 salary5972.02 is5972.58 kind5972.82 of5972.98 a5973.22 ceiling.5973.7 That's5974.18 just5974.5 another5974.74 thought.5975.14 5975.46 BARTLEY5975.46 -5975.46 Yeah.5975.46 That's5975.62 a5975.86 good5976.02 point.5976.1 We5980.07 can5980.23 do5980.4 the5981.27 survey5983.59 as5983.91 far5984.07 as5984.19 with5984.64 what's5984.8 available.5985.11 Does5985.91 that5986.15 work5986.31 for5986.55 folks?5986.64 5987.68 FALKOFF5987.68 -5987.68 Yes.5987.68 5987.99 BARTLEY5987.99 -5987.99 Okay.5987.99 So,5988.4 Doug,5988.64 you5988.88 wanna5989.11 throw5989.27 out5989.52 some5989.68 numbers5989.99 and5990.31 then5990.48 we'll5990.55 work5991.27 on5991.44 that?5991.52 5992.17 NEWTON5992.17 -5992.17 Sure.5992.17 Yes.5992.41 So5992.81 I5992.89 can5992.97 definitely5993.21 send5993.61 out5993.85 the5994.01 doodle5994.09 polls5994.49 that5994.65 we've5994.73 been5994.89 sending5995.05 out.5995.29 Before5995.69 I5996.01 do5996.09 that,5996.25 I5996.41 think5996.57 it5996.73 might5996.81 be5996.97 helpful5997.05 to5997.37 just5997.53 get5997.69 a5997.85 sense5997.93 from5998.25 the5998.41 committee5998.57 what5999.13 we're5999.37 thinking.5999.53 Do6000.09 we6000.33 wanna6000.49 do6000.73 another6000.81 meeting6001.13 in6001.45 November,6002.33 do6002.41 we6002.41 want6002.57 it6002.81 to6002.97 not6003.05 be6003.21 until6003.37 December?6003.77 I6004.66 would6004.9 note,6005.06 and6005.3 there6005.39 was6005.55 some6005.78 discussion6005.94 of6006.34 this6006.51 at6006.66 the6006.82 very6006.98 beginning6007.22 of6008.1 this6008.26 process,6008.59 that6009.47 it6010.34 was6010.51 just6010.66 initially6010.9 suggested6011.39 that6011.94 the6012.1 committee6012.26 report6012.66 to6013.06 the6013.22 council6013.3 in6013.7 December.6013.86 However,6014.59 I've6015.06 been6015.15 told6015.39 by6015.63 the6015.78 council6015.94 that6016.76 it6017 doesn't6017.16 need6017.64 to6017.88 come6017.96 by6018.12 then.6018.28 It6020.12 could6020.36 come6020.6 as6020.76 late6020.92 as6021.16 next6021.4 June.6021.96 Obviously,6022.44 we6022.84 are6023.24 not6023.4 going6023.56 to6023.8 do6023.88 that,6024.04 and6024.2 we6024.36 don't6024.52 want6024.76 to6025 do6025.08 that.6025.24 But6026.04 just6026.28 to6026.52 say6026.68 that6026.92 if6027.08 the6027.24 next6027.4 meeting,6027.64 for6027.88 example,6027.96 were6028.28 to6028.4 be6028.52 in6028.68 December,6028.76 we6029.24 wouldn't6029.4 be6029.64 violating6029.8 any6030.28 kind6030.44 of6030.68 law.6030.76 That's6030.92 the6031.16 only6031.32 reason6031.56 I6031.8 bring6031.96 that6032.12 up.6033.06 6033.06 BARTLEY6033.06 -6033.06 I6033.3 think6033.45 we6033.61 just6033.69 see6033.94 with6034.02 the6034.18 poll6034.34 and6034.73 what6034.98 our6035.14 our6035.45 collective6035.61 schedules6036.1 are6036.49 and,6036.66 you6036.9 know,6037.06 we'll6037.3 deal6037.45 with6037.61 it6037.77 accordingly.6037.94 6038.98 NEWTON6038.98 -6038.98 That6038.98 works.6039.22

6040.34 SPEAKER16040.34 -6040.34 Marcy?6040.34

6041.45 MURNINGHAN6041.45 -6041.45 Okay.6041.45 Are6041.85 we6042.1 gonna6042.34 spend6043.53 any6043.77 time6044.1 on6044.41 our6044.57 work6044.81 plan6044.98 this6045.53 evening6047.57 or6047.73 are6047.73 we6047.81 gonna6047.89 adjourn6048.37 soon?6048.69 Is6049.57 that6049.73 where6049.97 we're6050.13 going?6050.37 6051.97 BARTLEY6051.97 -6051.97 Well,6053.09 we6053.33 can6053.49 talk6053.57 about6053.81 that.6054.13 Fine.6055.01 6055.73 MURNINGHAN6055.73 -6055.73 Okay.6055.73 Here's6056.05 what6056.29 6056.61 BARTLEY6056.61 -6056.61 You6056.61 had6056.77 mentioned6056.93 about,6057.25 you6057.57 know,6057.73 the6057.89 elections6058.05 and6058.45 whatnot.6058.61 6059.25 MURNINGHAN6059.25 -6059.25 No.6059.25 No.6059.41 I6059.57 understand.6059.65 And6060.45 we're6060.93 all6061.17 under6061.89 that,6064.16 but6064.23 I6064.23 for6064.31 one,6064.56 and6064.88 that's6065.03 useful.6065.35 I6065.91 mean,6065.99 even6066.31 if6066.64 we6066.8 just6067.03 have,6067.35 like,6067.68 a6069.2 general6069.35 moving6071.2 backwards,6071.84 like6072.48 backward6072.8 mapping,6073.35 what6073.91 would6074.07 be6074.31 the,6074.48 when6075.03 is6075.35 the6075.6 deliverable?6075.84 What6076.64 is6076.88 the6077.03 last6077.2 possible6077.52 date6077.99 for6078.38 the6078.54 deliverable6078.78 so6079.58 that6079.9 then6080.14 the6080.38 other6080.46 things6080.7 can6081.1 happen6081.34 in6081.66 terms6081.82 of6082.14 ordinance?6082.3 And6083.42 then6083.58 if6084.3 we6084.46 can6084.62 think6084.78 about6085.1 for6085.66 the6085.82 next6086.06 meeting,6086.38 what6087.82 do6088.06 we6088.22 need6088.38 to6088.62 do6088.78 between6089.1 now6089.66 and6089.9 then6090.14 to6090.54 produce6090.7 a6091.34 report6091.58 that6092.3 I6093.47 would6093.63 like6093.78 to6094.02 also6094.27 have6094.66 some6095.06 sort6096.02 of6096.27 appendices,6096.59 not6097.31 just6097.55 the6098.74 quantitative6098.82 ones,6099.55 but6099.86 some6100.1 of6100.27 the6100.35 ones6100.43 that6100.74 address,6100.99 you6101.95 know,6102.19 what6103.55 else6103.78 can6104.1 we6104.27 do6104.51 that6104.99 falls6105.23 outside6105.55 the6105.95 jurisdiction6106.19 of6106.82 a6106.99 salary?6107.15 I6108.98 always6109.22 operated,6109.7 I6110.5 was6110.66 operating6110.98 until6111.62 very6112.02 recently6112.42 on6113.3 the6113.46 assumption6113.7 that6114.26 we6114.42 had6114.66 to6114.82 have6114.98 our6115.14 report6115.38 done6115.7 by6115.94 December.6116.26 Now6117.86 that's6118.1 next6118.42 month.6118.74 And6119.62 we6119.86 haven't6120.1 talked6120.42 at6120.74 all6120.9 about,6121.14 you6122.06 know,6122.15 backward,6122.55 you6123.02 know,6123.19 if6123.35 we6123.59 are,6124.39 I'm6124.78 used6124.94 to6125.27 having,6125.35 like,6125.74 a6125.98 planning6126.47 sheet6126.94 that6127.27 this6127.51 is6127.74 this6127.82 is6127.98 just6128.15 straightforward6128.39 project6128.94 planning.6129.43 It's6129.82 a6129.98 punch6130.15 list6130.39 of6131.1 what6131.35 needs6131.66 to6131.98 happen6132.15 between6132.63 now6133.02 and6133.27 when6133.43 it's6133.66 submitted,6133.98 and6135.02 then6135.19 who's6135.43 gonna6135.74 do6136.06 that,6136.31 and6136.93 is6137.65 there6137.73 enough6137.97 opportunity6138.61 for6139.09 editorial6139.41 review6140.05 and6140.45 particular6141.57 changes6142.29 and6142.69 so6142.85 on?6143.01 That's6143.17 the6143.41 part6143.57 that's6143.81 making6144.13 me6144.37 nervous6144.61 because6145.33 we6145.57 haven't6145.73 talked6146.05 about6146.29 that6146.53 yet.6146.85

6147.17 SPEAKER16147.17 -6147.17 Okay.6147.17 To6147.49 that,6147.65 Sarah.6148.45 6149.6 BAKER6149.6 -6149.6 I'm6149.6 gonna6149.76 make6150.15 a6150.48 controversial6150.64 statement6151.44 here,6151.84 which6151.99 is6152.15 I6152.48 think6152.88 we6153.11 could6153.19 probably6153.35 make6153.76 a6153.91 one6153.99 to6154.15 two6154.31 page6154.56 report,6154.72 because6155.84 what6156.15 we're6156.31 reporting6156.56 on6157.03 is6157.27 the6157.52 numbers6157.68 we're6158.15 voting6158.4 on.6158.8 And6159.35 having6159.6 a6159.91 justification6160.15 for6160.8 those6161.03 numbers6161.35 is,6161.99 I6163.36 think,6163.52 sufficient.6164 I6165.76 would6166.16 not6166.56 be6166.8 excited6167.04 to6167.52 sign6167.68 off6167.92 on6168.16 a6168.32 report6168.48 that6168.88 had6169.04 a6169.28 lot6169.36 of6169.52 other6170.24 recommendations6170.56 that6171.28 we6171.52 have6171.68 not6171.92 deliberated6172.4 about6173.04 on6173.44 this6173.6 panel,6174.32 on6175.12 this6175.2 committee.6175.44 And6176 I6177.41 don't6177.57 believe6177.9 we6178.22 have6178.38 time6178.53 or,6179.18 again,6179.49 the6179.81 mandate6180.06 to6180.45 deliberate6180.53 on6181.02 all6181.18 sorts6181.34 of6181.49 other6181.57 kind6182.61 of6183.02 comments.6183.26 So,6183.66 from6186.14 my6186.38 perspective,6186.61 I6186.9 think6187.18 the6187.66 report,6188.06 we6188.06 certainly6188.22 need6188.53 to6188.78 write6189.66 it6189.9 and6190.27 review6190.59 it,6190.83 but,6191.07 I6191.79 would6191.95 be6192.11 interested6192.19 in6192.51 a6192.67 report6192.75 that6193.15 justifies6194.03 the6194.67 numbers6194.83 and6195.23 stops6195.47 there.6195.95 6199.31 MURNINGHAN6199.31 -6199.31 Well,6199.31 then6199.63 my6199.87 second6200.11 question6200.43 would6200.83 be6200.99 would6201.31 that6201.55 include6201.79 an6202.35 opportunity,6202.59 I6203.31 don't6203.47 want6203.63 to6203.79 use6203.95 the6204.11 word6204.27 dissent,6204.73 but6205.13 at6205.52 least6205.69 as6206.09 an6206.32 addendum6206.65 in6207.36 terms6207.52 of6207.77 future6207.93 questions6208.73 to6209.2 think6209.36 about,6209.6 given6210.09 the6210.32 fact6210.48 that6210.73 we6210.97 have6211.13 the6211.28 public6211.44 eye,6211.85 we're6212.56 doing6212.81 what6213.13 we've6213.36 been6213.69 asked6213.93 to6214.09 do6214.24 as6214.4 the6214.56 blue6214.65 ribbon6214.89 committee,6215.2 but6216.01 these6216.16 things6216.48 do6216.81 not6216.97 have6217.2 clear6217.6 borders6218.16 and6218.56 boundaries.6218.81 They6219.71 speak6220.03 to6220.19 the6220.43 nature6220.59 of6220.91 the6221.07 job,6221.15 the6221.47 charter6221.63 revisions6222.03 that6222.43 will6222.67 be6222.83 coming6222.99 up6223.23 soon.6223.47 As6224.19 we6224.35 found6224.59 ourselves6224.91 tonight,6225.39 we6225.87 ended6226.19 up6226.51 talking6226.67 about6227.07 the6227.31 joint6227.47 connection6227.87 to6228.35 the6228.59 council6228.75 president,6229.63 to6229.71 the6230.27 school6230.35 committee6230.67 president.6231.07 And,6232.81 again,6232.98 I6233.53 think6233.69 that6234.02 part6234.49 of6234.65 what6235.38 we're6235.61 trying6235.85 to6236.1 do6236.26 is6236.57 educate6236.9 ourselves6237.45 but6238.34 also6238.57 the6238.9 general6239.14 public6239.61 about6240.49 the6241.22 true6241.53 nature6241.85 of6242.26 the6242.41 city6242.57 council6242.9 position,6243.38 what6244.55 it6244.71 warrants6245.11 in6245.59 terms6245.75 of6245.99 a6246.15 stipend,6246.39 but6247.51 that6247.91 there6248.07 are6248.31 other6248.47 pieces6249.27 related6250.15 to6250.55 that6250.71 that6251.43 are6251.67 part6252.15 of6252.39 attracting6253.27 people6253.83 or6254.23 could6254.55 be6254.79 part6254.95 of6255.11 attracting6255.35 people6255.91 to6256.95 take6257.27 that6257.51 on6257.83 and6258.23 to6258.47 help6258.63 them6258.87 do6259.19 a6259.35 good6259.51 job.6259.75

6264.85 SPEAKER16264.85 -6264.85 Any6264.85 other6265.16 discussions?6265.48

6268.6 Alright.6268.6 Why6269.97 don't6270.13 we,6270.36 have6271.97 someone6272.76 entertain6273 a6273.48 motion6273.56 to6273.96 adjourn?6274.28 6275.08 FALKOFF6275.08 -6275.08 Motion6275.08 to6275.48 adjourn.6275.72

6276.52 SPEAKER16276.52 -6276.52 2nd?6276.52

6277.16 SCOTT6277.16 -6277.16 Yes.6277.16 Second.6277.72

6278.12 SPEAKER16278.12 -6278.12 All6278.12 in6278.36 favor,6278.44 signify6278.76 by6279.16 saying6279.32 aye.6279.56 Aye.6279.96 Opposed,6280.44 no.6280.84 The6281.16 ayes6281.4 have6281.64 it.6281.8 Thank6282.04 you.6282.2