Watertown Planning Board
Wednesday July 9, 2025
The order of items in transcripts appear in the chronological order in which they were taken up. Some Agenda items may have been skipped.
JANET16.34 BUCK16.34 -16.34 PLANNING16.34 BOARD16.34 CHAIR16.34 -16.34 Okay.16.34 This16.89 is17.14 a17.21 meeting17.3 of17.61 the17.77 planning17.94 board.18.26 And,23.7 oh,24.18 we24.41 have24.65 not24.81 met25.05 for25.3 two25.54 months,25.77 so26.1 we're26.34 approving26.65 the27.65 meeting27.81 minutes28.13 from28.61 April.29.01
31.41 PAYSON31.41 WHITNEY31.41 -31.41 PLANNING31.41 BOARD31.41 MEMBER31.41 -31.41 I'll31.41 make31.57 a31.81 motion31.89 to32.21 approve32.37 the32.77 meeting32.93 minutes33.25 from33.49 April33.81 9.34.22
35.49 JASON35.49 COHEN35.49 -35.49 PLANNING35.49 BOARD35.49 MEMBER35.49 -35.49 I'll35.49 second.35.65
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE
43 BUCK43 -43 And43 the43.72 other43.88 item44.2 on44.59 tonight's44.91 agenda45.4 is,46.52 I47.08 believe47.23 this47.55 might47.8 be47.95 our48.12 first48.27 accessory48.76 dwelling49.32 unit.49.72 7652.04 Hovey52.68 Street53.16 request53.88 for54.36 a54.59 by54.68 right54.91 site55.4 plan55.72 review56.12 approval57.21 to57.69 convert57.93 a58.25 portion58.33 of58.73 the58.89 first59.37 floor59.77 and59.77 the59.93 entire60.09 second60.89 floor61.77 of61.77 an61.93 existing62.17 carriage62.73 house63.13 used63.45 for63.77 storage64.01 and64.49 office64.73 space65.05 to65.93 a66.17 protected66.25 use66.89 accessory67.45 dwelling68.17 unit.68.65 Do69.88 we70.03 have70.19 somebody70.44 here70.83 representing?71.4 Okay.72.59
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE
148.45 EMIL148.45 JACOB148.45 -148.45 RESIDENT148.45 -148.45 Yeah.148.45 Okay.148.77 So,150.78 this161.01 is161.25 what161.5 was161.9 submitted.162.29 It's163.5 basically163.74 a164.13 PowerPoint164.29 with164.94 the165.34 overview,165.85 and167.37 I'm167.69 just167.85 gonna168.01 expand168.33 it.168.73 And171.77 this172.01 is172.25 the172.41 first172.49 page,173.45 this173.69 is173.69 the173.85 location.174.01 I174.73 put174.89 the175.05 visuals175.13 to175.61 make175.77 it175.93 easy176.09 to176.41 see176.57 what's176.81 currently177.77 there.178.25 This179.05 is179.29 the179.45 carriage179.61 house180.01 in180.25 the180.41 back180.57 that's180.81 been182.1 there,182.26 I182.66 think,182.75 since182.98 the183.31 beginning.183.47 And192.42 this192.42 is192.66 just193.14 additional193.47 views194.03 from194.42 different195.47 sites,196.19 this196.35 is196.35 the196.51 street.196.99 And198.99 the199.71 permit201.95 that202.27 I'm202.43 looking202.67 for202.99 is203.39 to203.71 allow204.03 to204.27 use204.43 the204.75 space,204.99 the205.55 existing205.63 space,206.19 as206.67 a206.83 living206.99 space207.39 without208.14 changing208.46 anything209.01 externally,209.81 meaning210.53 nothing211.34 changes211.66 in212.06 the212.22 parking,212.3 not212.94 even213.09 a213.25 heating213.42 system213.74 or214.14 anything.214.22 So215.58 the215.81 other215.9 condo216.22 owners,216.53 the216.78 way216.94 they217.09 use217.25 the217.5 driveway217.58 right218.06 now,218.3 the218.86 parking219.09 space,219.5 the219.97 outdoor220.14 space220.53 will221.09 be221.25 exactly221.5 as221.97 is.222.22 And225.48 by225.88 the226.04 way,226.12 they226.52 are226.68 here226.84 if227.08 you227.24 would227.32 like227.48 to227.64 meet227.8 my227.96 neighbors.228.12
233 So,233 the233.56 only233.8 exterior235 change,235.56 and235.88 even236.04 that236.28 will236.44 be236.68 minimal,236.76 where237.32 the237.64 garage238.47 door238.94 is.239.19 I'm240.31 considering240.63 putting,241.43 like,241.75 a241.99 glass242.22 wall243.34 with243.75 glass244.06 doors244.47 as244.94 an245.19 entrance,245.26 just247.03 to247.26 make247.43 it247.59 brighter.247.99 And250.06 on252.05 the252.37 second252.77 floor253.01 where253.01 there253.17 is253.33 a253.49 window,253.65 it254.05 would254.21 just254.45 be,254.69 it's256.29 a256.61 closed256.93 in,257.25 walled258.37 in,258.61 like,258.85 or259.01 it's259.33 a259.49 wood259.65 paneling259.89 that's260.29 closing260.69 it261.09 up261.25 with261.73 just261.89 a262.13 regular262.21 window.262.61 And266.48 this266.63 is266.88 another266.95 view267.27 with268.79 some269.04 additional269.44 details,270.07 again273.68 from273.91 the274.07 front.274.24 And274.56 then274.71 the274.88 second275.44 floor,277.8 currently277.8 has278.2 about278.44 442278.68 square280.6 feet.280.92 Basically,283.24 I'm283.64 looking283.8 to284.04 take284.2 the284.36 existing284.52 space,285 add285.88 the286.12 bathroom,286.28 and288.36 split288.6 it288.92 into289 two289.32 bedrooms.289.48 I290.2 have290.36 other290.6 views.290.84 One291.24 second.291.56 Bear298.71 with299.02 me299.26 one299.5 second.299.82 This300.23 is300.46 how302.23 the302.38 second302.79 floor303.02 would303.02 look.303.19 This303.43 is303.5 where303.67 the303.9 window304.06 is.304.38 And306.7 I307.02 didn't307.1 include307.74 the308.14 design308.3 here308.62 because308.78 that309.02 will309.18 be309.34 in309.5 the309.66 work310.54 permit310.86 and311.34 will312.7 be312.86 submitted313.02 by313.34 an313.5 architect,313.66 and314.14 developer,314.46 and314.94 so315.1 on.315.26 But,315.42 for316.22 zoning316.46 purposes,316.86 this317.66 second318.46 floor319.93 would319.93 have320.09 two320.25 bedrooms320.49 and320.88 a321.13 bath.321.29 I'm323.29 gonna323.44 go323.69 back323.85 a324 little324.09 bit324.32 to324.56 where324.65 we324.88 were324.96 in325.29 the325.44 last,329.61 this329.61 is329.76 just329.93 additional330.25 views.330.73 This331.05 is331.21 the331.37 parking331.53 spaces332.09 as332.96 they333.13 are333.29 currently.333.53 So334.49 Unit336.07 3,336.55 which336.79 has337.03 exclusive337.19 use337.67 of337.91 the338.07 carriage338.63 house,339.03 has339.75 these340.07 two340.39 parking340.71 spaces,341.11 where343.51 the343.83 red343.91 line344.15 is344.39 showing.344.63 And345.43 also345.83 in346.31 the346.55 carriage346.71 house,347.03 there347.19 is347.43 a347.59 parking347.67 space348.07 as349.13 well349.38 as349.46 the349.77 one,349.94 there350.98 are352.1 two352.33 parking352.33 spaces,352.65 but353.06 one353.21 will353.46 be353.54 your353.77 living353.94 room354.25 where354.9 the355.13 first355.3 garage356.01 is.356.42
358.9 And358.9 then359.06 these359.3 are359.46 the359.62 parking359.77 spaces360.1 for360.5 the360.65 other360.81 units.362.47 That362.79 will362.79 not363.03 be363.19 impacted363.43 in363.75 any363.99 way.364.15 Everything364.47 will364.95 stay365.27 as365.51 is.365.75 So371.75 this371.99 is372.15 the372.39 first372.95 floor.375.29 There375.29 is375.61 a375.76 wall376.96 between377.52 the378.56 garage380.08 and380.56 the380.81 first381.29 floor.383.2 There's383.2 a383.52 space,383.76 an384.08 opening384.25 here384.56 that384.73 goes384.88 to385.13 the385.2 garage385.29 that's385.61 gonna385.85 be386.08 closed386.25 in.386.64 And389.1 other389.34 than389.58 that,389.74 except390.06 for390.38 the390.62 plumbing390.94 that391.34 will391.58 need391.74 to391.98 be392.06 added392.22 for393.02 the393.26 kitchen393.42 in395.9 this396.06 area,396.3 and397.98 the398.3 plumbing398.46 for398.86 the399.1 bathroom399.26 on399.66 the399.82 second400.3 floor,402.06 there402.06 shouldn't402.38 be403.18 any403.41 additional403.65 changes.404.06 And404.38 the405.1 place405.97 already406.29 had406.69 the408.13 toilet,408.62 and408.62 full408.85 plumbing410.29 in410.69 place,410.85 and411.1 electric.411.25 That's414.2 the414.68 second415.24 floor,415.64 which415.64 is415.88 currently416.04 an416.36 attic.416.6 This421.64 is421.88 just422.28 another422.52 view.422.84 This423 is423.16 how423.24 it423.4 looks423.56 in423.8 the423.88 interior.424.04 Right425.08 now,425.24 it's425.48 raised425.72 for426.04 whatever426.2 reason,426.6 but427 the427.24 architect428.36 or428.75 developer429.07 will429.63 specify430.27 in430.83 the430.92 permit431.07 what431.48 needs431.71 to431.95 be432.04 done432.19 to432.44 have433 it433.15 corrected433.39 and433.8 keep434.04 it434.19 up434.36 to434.51 code.434.68 One440.19 second.440.51
444.37 And444.37 this444.53 is444.77 just444.85 the445.01 site445.17 view445.49 that446.61 I447.01 was447.17 advised447.41 to447.81 submit.448.05 This449.41 is449.57 the449.73 space.449.89 So450.29 these450.69 are450.93 common451.17 areas.451.57 See452.13 where452.37 the452.61 20452.85 feet453.25 are453.49 between453.65 the453.97 carriage454.13 house454.45 and454.69 the,454.85 so456.13 again,456.3 that456.62 will456.69 not456.86 be456.94 impacted.457.18 There457.5 is457.65 a457.81 door457.89 there458.13 that's458.3 used.458.62 I459.18 wouldn't459.42 use459.74 it459.89 as460.21 a460.38 regular460.54 entry461.42 and461.74 exit.461.89 I'd462.21 probably462.38 use462.69 the463.01 front463.65 one.464.06 And,465.98 again,466.21 this466.54 is466.69 a466.77 common466.86 area467.18 in467.42 the467.57 back467.74 for467.98 gardening468.13 that's468.62 being468.86 used,469.1 and469.42 it469.65 will469.81 stay470.06 exactly470.29 the470.77 same.470.94 And474.49 this474.81 is,475.13 oh,475.77 this476.17 is476.33 what476.49 I476.65 submitted476.81 for477.29 the477.53 zoning477.85 review.478.25 Any484.25 questions,484.56 including484.88 from485.37 our485.52 neighbors?485.76
494.08 BUCK494.08 -494.08 Okay.494.08 Should496.4 we496.56 hear496.72 from496.8 the497.12 neighbors497.28 first497.68 or498 the498.72 staff498.88 report?499.2
499.6 GIDEON499.6 SCHREIBER499.6 -499.6 CITY499.6 OF499.6 WATERTOWN499.6 -499.6 Yeah.499.6 Let499.76 me499.92 just500.56 give500.8 a500.96 little501.04 bit501.2 of501.36 a501.52 background501.6 before501.92 we502.24 have502.32 a502.56 public502.64 aspect,503.68 since504 this504.24 is504.4 our504.48 first504.72 state506.08 requirement,506.4 unless507.36 you507.68 wanna507.84 do508.08 it.508.24 I508.32 just508.4 wanted508.93 to509 at509.09 least509.32 note509.56 that509.73 this509.88 is510.13 a510.69 site510.85 plan511.17 review511.49 only512.29 project,512.68 meaning513.33 that513.64 it514.13 has514.37 to514.61 be514.68 by514.85 right,515.09 and515.33 there's515.49 only515.73 very516.37 minimal516.61 criteria518.29 that518.85 can519 be519.17 considered519.33 by519.73 the519.88 planning520.04 board,520.76 to521.8 limit521.8 things522.21 in523 a523.17 reasonable523.33 way.523.8 So524.36 in524.52 an524.68 existing524.92 building525.4 with525.8 the526.2 existing526.36 site,526.76 there's527.16 very,528.12 very528.44 limited528.76 aspects529.96 that530.44 can530.92 be534.92 changed.534.92 So537.25 our537.4 staff537.57 report537.88 was538.2 suggesting539.08 for539.57 a539.8 conditional539.88 approval540.37 so540.76 you540.85 can541 put541.08 reasonable541.49 conditions,542.04 and543.32 that's543.57 it.543.8 You544.04 cannot544.2 vote545.08 no545.49 or545.8 deny546.04 it.546.37 And546.85 because547.08 it's547.4 not547.57 a,547.8 it's548.37 a548.85 40A549 approval,551.68 but552 it's552.16 site552.32 plan.552.56 So,552.88 with553.68 site553.84 plan554.08 in554.32 which554.4 is554.56 not554.72 in554.96 40A,556.72 you557.68 as558 the558.24 board558.4 do558.88 not559.12 have559.28 to559.44 have559.68 the560.08 standard560.32 super560.8 majority.561.12 With562.75 four562.99 members563.14 present,563.63 three564.58 members564.82 would565.23 have566.02 to566.18 vote566.26 yes.566.5 If566.75 there566.9 had566.99 been567.14 three567.3 members,567.46 which567.87 was568.02 the568.26 minimum568.35 to568.82 have568.99 a569.23 quorum,569.3 there569.95 would570.18 only570.35 need570.58 to570.7 be570.82 two571.07 to571.23 vote571.38 yes.571.7 So,572.82 with573.7 that,573.87 you574.26 can574.42 continue575.95 the576.51 public576.67 hearing.576.99 It577.23 is577.39 a577.55 public577.63 hearing577.87 but578.11 I578.27 did578.35 wanna578.51 make578.75 sure578.91 it579.15 was579.23 clear579.39 that579.63 it's580.43 a580.67 protected580.83 use,581.31 similar581.87 to582.19 schools582.35 and582.67 daycares,582.83 but583.87 with584.51 even584.67 further584.99 restrictions585.63 on.586.75 It586.91 has586.91 to587.15 be587.23 treated587.31 like587.63 a587.79 single587.87 family588.11 from588.51 that588.67 perspective.588.83 So590.03 thank591.38 you.591.54
592.18 BUCK592.18 -592.18 Okay.592.18
596.74 WILLIAMS596.74 -596.74 RESIDENT601.77 -601.77 So601.77 I601.77 am602.01 the602.58 owner602.74 and603.06 occupant603.22 of603.77 number604.01 1604.34 at604.97 76605.13 Hovey605.77 Street,606.09 and606.41 I606.65 have606.73 a606.89 letter607.05 from607.45 the608.65 owner608.97 of609.93 76610.17 Hovey611.05 Street611.29 Number611.53 2.611.85 And612.41 I612.57 believe612.73 you613.05 have613.21 a613.45 letter613.77 from614.57 the614.81 neighbor614.97 at615.53 82615.93 Hovey616.73 Street,617.21 and618.45 we618.85 are619 all619.33 in619.57 opposition619.8 of620.45 this620.61 plan620.85 for622.04 various622.61 reasons.623.09 I'm623.57 happy623.8 to624.04 read625.16 the625.49 letter625.64 from626.04 the627.16 neighbor627.4 at627.73 Number627.88 2628.21 if628.61 you'd628.76 like,629 or629.16 I629.33 can629.49 pass629.73 it630.04 to630.28 you630.45 so630.61 you630.85 can630.92 read631.16 it.631.33 My633.97 objection634.05 is635.09 simply635.81 density.636.45 This638.21 is638.45 a638.61 two638.85 family639.09 zone639.73 area.640.13 The641.25 house641.41 is641.65 already641.89 three642.45 condo642.69 units643.17 and644.45 this646.45 would647.68 just647.85 add648.57 to649.21 the649.92 traffic,650.57 if651.21 you651.45 will,651.52 in652.73 our652.97 driveway,653.21 the654.09 construction654.33 noise.655.05 And655.92 while657.52 it's657.76 not,658.09 I661.02 suppose,661.42 very661.98 close662.3 to662.7 our662.78 dwelling,663.02 it's663.42 extremely663.74 close664.54 to664.94 the665.1 dwelling665.18 at665.66 82.665.82 And667.26 we,668.3 actually,668.78 as669.26 neighbors,669.5 moved670.22 in670.46 after670.94 Number671.42 82671.74 was672.3 built.672.54 Had673.18 we673.42 been673.66 here,673.82 we674.06 would674.22 have674.38 opposed674.54 the674.94 building675.02 of675.42 82,676.88 as677.13 it's677.13 becoming677.61 more678.25 and678.49 more678.73 dense679.13 as679.92 time680.49 goes680.88 on.681.21 And681.68 so681.92 there682.25 should682.73 be682.96 a683.28 limit683.45 on683.76 the683.92 density684.09 in684.8 a685.04 neighborhood685.21 that's685.61 zoned685.92 for686.25 two686.4 family.686.57 And689.76 if690 you690.4 would690.8 like691.04 to691.28 hear691.44 from691.76 the692.16 second692.4 floor692.8 neighbor,693.2 I694.08 don't694.16 know694.32 how694.4 you694.56 wanna694.72 do694.96 that.695.04 But695.28
696.16 BUCK696.16 -696.16 Is696.16 that696.4 the696.64 one696.72 we696.96 already697.2 saw?698.08
698.08 WILLIAMS698.08 -698.08 I698.08 don't698.16 believe698.4 so.698.64
703.17 SCHREIBER703.17 -703.17 You703.17 have703.41 letters703.57 there704.13 from704.38 them?704.53
704.93 WILLIAMS704.93 -704.93 I704.93 have705.01 a705.17 letter705.25 from705.57 the706.45 owners706.86 of707.33 Number707.57 2.707.89 They708.38 reside708.86 out709.25 of709.5 state,709.57 and709.89 they710.05 were710.21 visiting,710.86 and711.01 they're711.01 on711.17 a711.33 plane711.41 now,711.81 but712.05 they712.21 did712.38 bring713.17 this713.5 to714.21 me.714.38
718.23 SCHREIBER718.23 -718.23 Is718.23 it718.35 the718.47 one718.71 at718.95 82719.11 Hovey?719.59
719.99 WILLIAMS719.99 -719.99 It719.99 is720.15 not.720.31 This720.71 is721.03 the721.35 owners721.59 of721.99 Number722.15 2722.79 at723.27 76723.51 Hovey724.23 Street.724.55
725.27 BUCK725.27 -725.27 Okay.725.27 Yeah.725.59 You725.83 can725.91 share726.15 that726.31 with726.47 us.726.71
727.27 SCHREIBER727.27 -727.27 So,729.03 you730.09 could730.25 summarize730.49 what731.37 they're731.61 saying731.85 into732.25 the732.57 record,732.73 and733.04 then733.21 you733.52 can733.61 give733.76 a734 copy734.09 to735.37 our735.45 staff,735.61 and735.85 then736 we'll736.16 make737.85 sure738 to738.33 add738.57 it738.73 to738.97 the739.04 record.739.21
739.68 WILLIAMS739.68 -739.68 So,739.68 what740.49 they740.73 are740.88 saying741.04 in741.37 their741.45 letter741.68 is741.92 that742.16 this742.4 does742.57 not742.8 conform743.04 with743.61 the743.76 existing743.92 two744.54 family744.7 zoning745.02 in745.42 the745.5 district.745.66 They746.86 believe747.1 that747.5 additional747.9 rental748.3 unit748.62 erodes749.02 the749.42 essential749.58 character749.98 of750.3 the750.38 property750.54 and750.94 neighborhood.751.74 And751.98 will751.98 have752.14 negative752.38 consequences752.78 for753.42 residents,753.66 including754.14 but754.54 not754.7 limited754.94 to755.26 alteration755.58 of756.06 neighborhood756.22 character756.62 and757.68 potential757.84 negative758.39 impact758.88 on759.51 property759.75 values.760.15
763.84 BUCK763.84 -763.84 Thank763.84 you.764.15
766.96 SCHREIBER766.96 -766.96 Madam766.96 chair,767.27 can767.68 I767.92 just768.08 clarify?768.32 I769.2 just769.6 wanted769.75 to770 clarify.770.15 You770.96 are772.07 Unit772.39 1772.71 of772.95 this773.19 property?773.35
774.31 WILLIAMS774.31 -774.31 Yes.774.31
774.87 SCHREIBER774.87 -774.87 And774.87 that775.59 letter775.83 is776.07 from776.23 Unit776.47 2776.79 of776.95 this777.11 property?777.27
777.75 WILLIAMS777.75 -777.75 Correct.777.75
778.71 SCHREIBER779.19 -779.19 So,779.19 neither779.19 of779.59 you779.75 as779.99 owners780.31 of780.71 the780.79 Condo781.83 Association782.71 have782.71 agreed783.19 to783.67 allow783.91 this786.75 unit788.12 to788.6
789.48 WILLIAMS789.48 -789.48 In789.48 the790.67 sale790.83 of791.39 this791.79 unit792.67 we792.91 agreed792.91 to793.55 that795.24 possibility.795.71 We796.75 did796.91 not797.15 agree797.39 to797.79 having798.03 it798.43 done.798.6 And798.91 at799.15 the799.32 time,799.48 the799.88 ADU800.12 regulations801.55 weren't802.19 in802.43 place.802.59 We802.83 didn't802.99 know803.23 what803.39 was803.55 gonna803.71 be803.95 in804.03 place.804.19 We804.91 agreed806.19 to806.59 have806.75 it806.91 reviewed807.23 but807.63 we807.79 did808.03 not808.19 agree808.35 to808.67 have808.83 it808.99 done.809.15
816.97 SCHREIBER816.97 -816.97 This816.97 is817.13 the817.29 public817.37 hearing817.76 part,818 but818.25 after818.49 that819.29 we819.52 can819.68 try819.85 to820.09 speak820.25 to820.49 this820.64 because821.29 it's821.61 a821.68 unique822.49 situation822.8 with823.21 condo823.45 ownership.823.85
824.8 BUCK824.8 -824.8 Right.824.8 Right.825.29
827.45 SCHREIBER827.45 -827.45 After827.45 the827.76 public827.92 testimony,828.25 I828.73 don't828.97 wanna829.13 have829.45 a829.52 conversation829.61 back830.09 and830.25 forth,830.4 but830.57 I830.73 wanna830.8
831.21
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE
WILLIAMS886.11 -886.11 And886.11 my886.9 partner887.46 who887.87 lives888.02 with888.26 me888.42 at888.58 Number888.75 1889.07 also889.3 has889.54 some890.08 comments890.4 to890.8 make.890.88
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE
STUART905.33 WAX905.33 -905.33 RESIDENT905.33 -905.33 Hi.905.33 Good905.81 evening.906.13 My906.93 name907.09 is907.25 Stuart907.4 Wax,907.81 and908.13 I908.29 live908.93 at909.33 the909.57 Number909.73 1910.05 with911 Miss911.33 Williams911.64 here,912.05 as912.37 the912.52 owner.912.68 I'd913.64 like913.81 to913.97 thank914.13 the914.37 committee915.5 for915.9 giving916.14 us916.38 the916.54 opportunity916.78 to917.42 discuss918.06 the918.46 issue918.62 as919.5 it919.74 is919.82 an920.06 important920.22 one920.62 to920.86 not921.1 only921.34 us,922.3 but923.9 also924.14 to924.54 the924.7 neighbors924.94 around925.34 us925.66 who925.9 may926.06 not926.22 be926.46 able926.7 to927.02 be927.18 here927.42 today927.66 to928.7 speak928.93 on929.25 the929.74 behalf929.98 of932.62 this933.25 position933.42 that934.46 we934.7 have.934.93 I939.82 live940.05 on940.3 the940.46 first940.86 floor941.5 and941.5 I941.74 work942.13 from942.38 home.942.7 And944.52 I944.84 spend945.08 a945.32 lot945.4 of945.56 time945.72 at945.96 the946.12 condo.948.16 And949.48 any949.48 noise,949.88 anything952.12 that952.52 happens952.76 within953.16 the953.56 premises,954.68 I'm955.08 keenly955.32 aware955.72 of.956.12 By957.39 allowing958.04 this958.51 to958.84 happen958.92 would960.2 affect960.84 us961.24 greatly.962.51 Our963 mental964.84 health,965.24 even966.75 my967.08 financial967.39 health967.88 could968.2 be968.36 affected968.51 because969.08 any969.63 noise969.96 could971.07 certainly971.31 hurt972.51 my973.55 chances973.79 of976.19 being976.43 financially,976.75 you977.71 know,977.87 stable.978.43
981.55 I've981.55 been981.79 here982.03 for982.27 the982.43 past982.59 seven982.91 years.983.23 And984.65 while985.22 I985.46 have985.62 no985.93 qualms986.65 and987.13 no987.46 personal987.93 problems988.82 with989.29 the989.54 owner990.17 of990.58 the990.74 third992.89 floor,993.38 or993.38 his993.62 dwelling993.86 outside,994.41 this995.86 would996.17 create996.74 a997.46 problem997.7 for998.1 us.998.34 And1001.22 I'd1001.3 like1001.62 to1003.06 explain1003.22 why1003.62 that1003.86 would1004.1 be.1004.34 First1005.62 of1005.94 all,1006.1 the1006.5 noise1006.66 would1007.22 be1007.46 harmful,1008.18 and1010.5 anything1012.02 that1012.42 happens1012.66 outside1013.47 the1013.95 house1014.5 itself1014.99 onto1016.11 this1017.47 other1017.71 dwelling,1018.02 you1020.26 know,1020.42 would1020.83 create1021.14 an1021.71 impact,1022.02 in1024.1 many1024.34 ways.1024.5 One1024.98 of1025.22 them1025.38 also1025.94 would1026.34 be1026.58 trash1027.3 collection,1027.7 for1028.34 example.1028.5 It1029.14 would1029.3 create1029.3 more1029.7 trash,1030.02 and1033.06 the1033.38 people1033.54 who1034.26 would1034.5 potentially1035.22 live1035.7 there1035.94 would1036.1 create1036.5 more1037.41 noise1037.58 for1037.98 us.1038.13 And1039.17 I've1039.41 been1039.65 there,1039.82 and1040.22 the1040.46 neighborhood's1040.7 rather1041.34 quiet,1043.02 and1043.34 it's1043.34 rather1043.89 pleasant1044.22 to1044.62 live1044.78 there1045.02 but1045.17 it1045.34 would1045.49 affect1045.74 us1046.06 and1046.86 our1047.1 quality1047.26 of1047.74 living1047.89 quite1048.54 a1048.86 bit.1048.93 You1053.16 know,1053.4 I1053.96 understand1054.28 that1055 the1055.32 owner1056.92 wants1057.32 to1057.72 create1058.12 this1058.52 in1059.32 order1059.56 to1059.8 profit1061.08 from1061.48 it.1061.72
1062.36 He1062.36 wants1062.6 to1062.92 build,1063.08 you1065.54 know,1065.63 separate1066.27 dwelling1066.74 apartments,1067.14 condos1067.79 in1068.35 order1068.51 to,1068.83 you1069.87 know,1070.18 make1070.59 money1070.9 from1071.22 it.1071.38 This1072.9 is1073.14 not1073.3 our1073.54 concern.1073.79 Our1075.38 concern1075.54 is1076.03 our1076.27 well-being1076.51 in1076.98 the1077.14 neighborhood1077.3 around1077.87 us.1078.27 While1079.46 I1079.7 sympathize1079.87 with1081.28 this1081.6 idea1081.92 that,1082.48 you1083.04 know,1083.2 it's1083.52 hard1083.76 to1084 afford1084.24 to1085.28 keep1085.52 it1086.32 all1086.64 together,1087.12 you1088.56 know,1088.72 nobody1089.12 else1089.6 has1089.84 done1090.08 this1090.24 in1090.48 the1090.56 past.1090.72 And1091.84 I1092.16 feel1092.32 like1092.72 this1092.96 is1093.2 not1093.36 a1093.6 worthy1093.76 reason1094.32 to1095.04 build1096.39 something1096.63 that1097.84 would1097.99 cause1098.32 so1098.63 much1098.8 concern1099.84 to1100.72 the1101.04 people1101.2 that1101.52 live1101.67 there1101.91 and1102.39 the1102.63 neighbors1102.88 around1103.28 us.1103.6 So1105.04 I'm1105.28 asking1105.52 the1106.08 board1106.32 here1106.63 to1107.52 deny1107.76 the1108.15 application1108.32 or1108.96 whatever1109.12 it1109.52 takes1109.67 to1109.99 make1110.47 sure1110.63 it1110.88 doesn't1111.04 happen.1111.43 Thank1112.83 you1112.99 very1113.15 much.1113.39
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE
1143.84 BUCK1143.84 -1143.84 Okay.1143.84 At1144.64 this1144.88 point,1145.04 I'll1145.28 close1145.44 the1145.76 public1145.84 hearing1146.24 and1146.8 open1147.84 it1148.08 up1148.32 for1148.48 our1149.92 own1150.16 discussion1150.4 here.1150.96 Gideon,1153.54 did1154.58 you1154.82 want1155.05 to1155.38 add1156.26 to1156.49 what1156.73 you1156.97 said?1157.21
1164.34 SCHREIBER1164.34 -1164.34 So1164.34 this1164.41 is1164.58 probably1164.82 one1165.29 of1165.54 the1165.62 more1165.78 complicated1166.02 situations,1166.82 and1167.14 it's1167.46 always1167.62 great1167.86 to1168.1 have1168.18 the1168.42 first1168.58 ADU1168.82 be1169.54 in1169.94 more1171.06 of1171.3 a1171.38 complicated1171.46 situation.1171.94 This1173.7 is1173.86 in1174.82 a1175.14 T1175.46 zone1175.7 which1175.94 allows1176.26 two1176.66 families.1176.9 There's1177.7 approval1179.94 to1181.14 allow1181.31 that1181.63 Third1181.87 Floor1182.18 unit.1182.59 So1183.07 a1183.31 three1183.38 family1183.71 is,1184.03 I1184.35 think1184.42 it1184.59 was1184.66 a1184.9 use1184.98 variance?1185.14
1186.35 MATTHEW1186.35 NEUBACHER1186.35 -1186.35 CITY1186.35 OF1186.35 WATERTOWN1186.35 -1186.35 Yeah.1186.35 There1186.59 was1186.74 a1187.07 variance1187.31 approving1187.95 the1188.35 creation1188.42 of1188.83 a1188.98 third1189.07 dwelling1189.38 unit1189.71 on1190.03 this1190.11 lot.1190.35
1190.66 SCHREIBER1190.66 -1190.66 So1190.66 when1190.83 the1191.07 city1191.14 was1191.79 a1192.03 town1192.11 and1192.42 still1192.59 allowed1192.9 use1193.14 variances,1193.38 there1193.87 was1194.03 an1194.18 approval1194.35 to1194.66 allow1194.74 the1195.07 third1195.38 floor1195.63 to1195.63 become1195.71 a1196.03 third1196.83 unit,1197.47 and1198.03 then1198.27 the1198.43 property1198.83 was1199.23 condoed.1199.79 And1200.91 so1201.07 that1201.23 means1201.31 that1201.63 there's1201.79 a,1202.11 you1202.35 know,1202.51 a1202.75 condo1202.91 association.1204.99 And1206.11 applications1206.11 before1206.83 the1207.15 board1207.31 are1208.27 supposed1208.99 to1209.32 indicate,1209.71 you1210.03 know,1210.27 for1210.6 any1210.67 exterior1210.99 changes,1211.39 you1211.88 have1212.03 to1212.19 have1212.36 the1212.84 condo1213.08 association,1214.27 someone1214.84 is1214.84 aware1215.55 of1215.88 and1216.12 signing1216.27 off1216.52 on1216.67 it.1216.84 That1217.63 is1217.79 definitely1217.95 relevant1218.52 to1219.08 the1219.23 building1219.39 permit.1219.79 Here1222.17 there's1222.49 an1222.65 acknowledgement1222.89 that1223.69 they1223.85 have1224.25 the1224.49 right1224.57 to1224.81 apply1225.05 for1225.37 something.1225.53 So1226.01 they1226.33 have1226.49 applied,1226.73 but1227.37 the1228.41 condo1228.65 association1229.05 has1229.61 language1229.93 specifically1230.57 outlining1231.61 that1232.09 they1232.33 have1233.29 control1233.53 over1233.93 a1234.81 unit,1234.89 it's1235.21 a1235.21 three1235.37 unit1235.61 condo1235.93 association.1236.33 So1237.83 their1238.14 language1238.47 would1239.11 limit1239.35 the1240.07 ability1240.23 to1241.51 allow1241.75 the1242.14 conversion,1242.38 but1243.51 that's1243.75 not1244.07 what1244.55 was1244.79 applied1244.95 for1245.35 here.1245.66
1246.14 What1246.14 was1246.38 applied1246.55 for1246.95 was1248.35 an1249.42 allowance1249.59 for1250.07 you1250.31 can1251.42 condition1251.66 it1252.14 to1253.63 reflect1253.95 that1254.35 but1254.59 it1254.83 the1255.87 request1256.03 is1256.27 to1256.51 allow1256.75 an1257.07 ADU.1257.31 But1257.71 if1257.87 they1258.11 don't1258.27 have1258.43 the1258.67 legal1259.55 mechanism,1260.27 it's1260.99 not1261.31 the1261.55 city's1261.71 role1263.55 to1264.03 decide1264.27 that.1264.59 So,1268.32 there's1268.55 three1268.55 separate1268.55 ownership1269.52 units1270.32 and1271.84 there1272.08 is1272.23 language1272.47 that1272.88 says1273.12 that1273.28 this1273.52 can1273.67 only1273.91 be1274.15 used1274.32 for,1274.63 what1275.99 it's,1276.23 you1276.47 know,1276.63 storage,1276.95 recreation1279.74 studio.1280.46 There's1281.1 a1281.34 bathroom1281.42 in1281.82 there1281.9 today,1283.74 there's1284.62 a1284.94 basement.1285.5 There's1285.5 limitations1285.5 but1285.5 it1285.74 has1285.82 nothing1286.14 to1286.54 do1286.7 with1286.78 the1287.34 city's1287.5 role1287.82 and1288.06 how1288.38 that1288.7 was1288.86 created.1289.1 We1289.58 don't1289.74 review1289.98 condo1290.46 documents.1291.02 So1292.85 they1293.16 could1293.4 modify1293.57 that1293.96 but1294.2 they1294.44 obviously1295.16 couldn't1295.72 move1296.28 forward1296.44 with1296.77 a1297.4 accessory1297.57 dwelling1298.04 unit1298.28 construction1299.33 project1299.8 without1300.2 a1300.68 building1300.77 permit,1301.09 and1301.48 they1301.72 need1301.88 the1303.01 express1303.09 authorization,1303.48 is1304.92 my1305.09 understanding.1305.24 But,1306.14 again,1306.38 that's1306.54 not1306.94 the1307.34 planning1307.5 board's1307.82 role1308.22 to1308.46 decide1308.62 that.1308.86
1310.94 COHEN1310.94 -1310.94 can1310.94 I1311.1 ask1311.26 you1311.42 a1311.5 question1311.66 about1312.06 this?1312.22 So1312.46 the1312.86 carriage1314.3 house,1316.38 and,1316.86 you1316.86 know,1317.02 I1317.26 think1317.34 probably1317.66 when1318.14 the1318.7 ADU1318.86 zoning1320.18 change1320.83 was1321.38 made,1321.7 it1323.3 anticipated1323.87 as,1324.66 I1326.51 guess,1326.66 a1326.98 single1327.14 or1327.46 a1327.7 two1327.79 family1327.87 house1328.42 that1328.9 had1329.22 a1330.42 carriage1330.66 house1331.14 on1331.38 the1331.55 property.1331.7 I1333.88 guess1333.92 what1334.16 I'm1334.32 saying1334.4 is1334.64 that,1334.72 if1334.88 it's1335.04 a1335.28 condo,1335.44 if1335.84 it's1336 a1336.16 three1336.32 unit1336.64 condo,1337.04 who1338.8 owns1339.2 the1339.68 carriage1339.92 house1340.32 at1340.56 the1340.72 moment,1340.8 or1341.12 is1341.2 it1341.36 a1341.52 common1341.68 area1342 of1342.32 the1342.48 condo?1342.72
1343.44 SCHREIBER1343.44 -1343.44 It's1343.44 specifically1344 assigned1344.64 to1345.04 the1345.36 third1346.04 floor1346.37 unit1346.37 but1347.72 expressly1348.13 identified1349.72 as1350.28 not1350.53 for1350.77 living1351.01 space.1351.33
1352.85 COHEN1352.85 -1352.85 Okay.1352.85 But1353.09 it1353.33 does,1354.37 it's1354.61 deeded1354.85 to1355.33 Unit1356.13 3.1356.44 Right.1356.92
1357.09 SCHREIBER1357.09 -1357.09 And1357.09 the1357.24 state1358.92 regulations1359.33 have1360.8 made1361.04 it1361.12 clear1361.28 that1361.6 the1363.28 ADU1363.52 law1365.12 applies1365.68 to1366.16 any1367.6 type1367.92 of1368.16 building1368.48 within1369.28 a1369.76 single1371.12 family1371.52 resident1372.56 zone,1373.04 which1373.36 is1373.6 any1373.84 zone1374.53 that1374.77 we've1375.01 put1375.24 into1375.48 the1375.72 ordinance1375.88 that1376.29 allows1376.61 a1377.01 single1377.16 family.1377.48 And1378.53 so,1378.77 this1379.64 zone1379.88 allows1380.21 a1380.61 single1380.77 family,1381.72 so1381.97 therefore,1381.97 no1383.4 matter1383.57 how1383.81 many1383.97 units1384.29 are1384.68 on1384.85 the1384.92 site,1385.16 someone1385.88 can1386.29 apply1386.45 for1386.85 a1387.88 single1388.13 ADU.1388.61 So1390.42 in1390.58 a1390.82 condo,1390.98 you1391.62 know,1391.7 we've1391.86 talked1392.1 about1392.26 scenarios1392.5 in1392.98 a1393.14 condo1393.22 situation,1395.46 only1396.98 one1396.98 ADU1396.98 can1397.38 be1397.54 as1397.7 a1398.02 protected1398.26 use.1398.66 ADU1398.98 could1399.38 be1399.54 added1400.26 to1400.66 a1400.82 site1400.98 like1401.22 this.1401.38 And1402.86 that1403.49 ADU,1405.82 the1406.21 condo1406.45 association1406.93 has1407.34 to1407.58 decide1407.89 who1408.93 gets1409.1 that1409.49 use1410.86 or1411.17 that1411.34 right.1411.65 And1412.45 so1412.77 that's1412.93 something1413.17 that1413.49 they1413.73 have1413.89 to1414.05 work1414.13 out1414.38 amongst1415.01 themselves.1415.25
1416.05 NEUBACHER1416.05 -1416.05 Or1416.05 if1416.37 it's1416.53 tied1416.85 to1417.17 the1417.41 association1417.65 as1418.29 a1418.37 whole.1418.53
1419.09 SCHREIBER1419.09 -1419.09 Whatever1420.61 the1421.01 mechanism1421.17 is,1421.65 that's1422.13 the1423.09 condo1423.25 association.1423.65 But1426.29 in1426.61 this1426.77 case,1426.93 you1428.22 know,1428.31 the1428.55 owner1428.7 of1428.94 the1429.03 unit1429.18 that1429.59 has1429.66 the1429.9 building1430.07 structure,1430.79 which1431.51 is1431.66 a1431.83 existing1433.59 structure1434.07 on1434.55 the1434.7 property1434.87 line1435.18 has1436.07 requested,1436.31 you1437.27 know,1437.42 the1438.14 board1438.31 to1438.63 provide1439.83 the1440.22 by1440.38 right1440.7 allowance1441.03 to1441.59 move1441.74 forward1441.9 with1442.22 the1443.42 design1443.58 details1443.98 and1444.38 getting1445.34 all1445.66 of1445.82 the1445.9 paperwork1446.06 in1446.38 place1446.54 to1446.86 allow1447.02 it1447.26 to1447.42 proceed1447.74 through1448.06 the1448.22 building1448.38 permit1448.7 process.1449.02 As1450.86 he's1451.1 noted,1451.34 there's1452.3 a,1453.26 you1453.5 know,1453.66 he1453.74 sketched1453.98 out1454.38 some1454.54 interior1454.78 designs.1456.3 And1456.54 ultimately,1456.54 you1457.66 know,1458.98 you1459.22 have1459.3 to1459.46 look1459.63 at1459.78 this1459.87 in1460.11 a1460.26 professional1460.35 way1460.74 because1460.9 it1461.14 is1461.22 a1461.38 conversion1461.46 from1462.11 one1463.14 use1463.46 to1463.7 a1463.94 new1464.02 use1464.18 which1464.42 is1464.59 a1464.74 residential1464.9 use.1465.3 So1465.63 you1465.87 have1466.11 to1466.26 meet1466.35 building1466.59 code1466.9 for1467.22 a1467.54 building1467.63 to1469.87 the1470.11 level1470.26 that1470.59 the1470.83 building1470.9 commissioner1471.22 makes1472.02 a1472.35 determination.1472.42 So,1474.48 this1475.28 is1475.52 a1475.76 stepping1476 stone1476.4 to1476.88 it1478.4 but1478.56 it1478.8 doesn't1478.88 mean1480.08 there1481.76 will1482 be1482.16 an1482.24 ADU1482.48 built.1482.88
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE
1486.72 BUCK1486.72 -1486.72 Just1486.72 for1487.9 further1488.07 clarification,1488.55 if1489.51 this1489.74 three1490.38 unit1490.71 building1491.11 was1491.59 owned1491.9 by1492.38 a1492.63 single1492.71 owner,1493.18 we1494.46 wouldn't1494.71 have1495.03 this1495.27 issue?1497.35 That1497.59 owner,1497.59 would1499.18 be1499.59 able1499.74 to1500.14 convert1500.31 the1501.9 carriage1502.14 house1502.55 to1503.4 an1503.48 ADU?1503.64
1504.12 SCHREIBER1504.12 -1504.12 That's1504.12 correct.1504.28 And1504.84 what1506.12 we1506.36 are1506.76 identifying1508.04 is1508.68 that,1508.84 if1509.08 you1509.16 have1509.32 an1510.92 ADU,1511.32 it1512.36 needs1512.52 to1512.84 be1513.08 connected1513.48 to1513.96 a1514.2 primary1514.36 use.1516.36 So1517.64 if1517.8 someone1519.23 was1519.55 developing1519.79 the1520.27 site,1521.15 you1521.63 know,1521.88 and1522.27 they1522.43 had1522.67 three1522.84 units1523.08 and1523.47 they1523.55 were1523.71 turning1523.79 it1524.12 into1524.19 condos,1524.43 or1526.12 they1526.36 just1526.51 owned1526.76 them,1526.91 they1527.08 could1527.23 build1527.39 a1528.19 fourth1528.43 unit1529.71 after1531.87 getting1532.27 the1532.59 approval,1532.75 but1534.11 that1534.35 unit1534.67 couldn't1535.07 be1535.39 sold1535.55 separately.1535.87 It1536.59 would1536.83 have1537.07 to1537.23 remain1537.47 connected1537.95 to1538.35 the1538.83 primary1538.99 use.1539.63 So1540.75 and1540.99 that's1541.31 where1541.55 Matthew1541.79 had1542.11 noted,1543.79 it1543.95 could1544.11 be1544.27 shared1545.81 by1545.81 the1545.81 association1545.81 or1546.45 it1546.61 could1546.68 be1546.77 connected1547.64 to1548.13 a1548.37 unit.1548.53 And1550.05 there's1550.61 a1551.01 lot1551.09 of1551.25 other1551.49 clarifications1553.64 in1554.37 the1554.53 law1554.61 but1554.85 that1555.01 isn't1555.33 relevant1555.73 to1556.21 this1556.37 particular1557.34 discussion1557.82 tonight.1558.22
1558.62 WHITNEY1558.62 -1558.62 And1558.62 the1558.78 state1558.86 law1559.26 just1559.58 basically,1560.22 the1560.7 use1560.78 has1561.02 to1561.18 be1561.34 a1561.5 dwelling,1562.06 right?1562.3 So1562.3 it's1562.46 gotta1562.62 be1562.78 a1562.94 residential1563.1 use.1563.58 There's1563.9 no1564.14 restriction1564.3 on1564.78 whether1564.94 it1565.26 can1565.42 be1565.58 rented1566.86 or1567.42 whether1567.66 it's1567.98 family.1568.14 There's1568.62 no,1568.94 is1569.66 that1569.74 correct?1569.9
1570.22 SHCREIBER1570.22 -1570.22 Correct.1570.22
1570.46 WHITNEY1570.46 -1570.46 How1570.46 I1570.46 understand1571.93 it1572.02 the1572.02 first1572.02 time.1572.17 So1572.49 if1573.46 a1573.7 ADU1573.86 gets1574.41 approved1574.73 here1575.22 or1575.46 on1575.62 some1575.78 other1575.93 property,1576.17 how1577.62 it1578.02 gets1578.26 used,1578.58 who1579.06 dwells1579.3 in1579.62 it1579.86 is1580.02 of1580.26 no1580.41 concern.1580.65
1581.46 SCHREIBER1581.46 -1581.46 Nope.1581.46 The1582.58 only1582.82 determination1584.31 that1584.95 we1585.11 have1585.35 suggested1585.51 is1585.91 that1586.07 it1586.23 has1586.31 to1586.55 remain1586.79 in1588.31 ownership1588.95 with1590.47 one1590.71 of1590.87 the1590.95 units.1591.11
1591.51 WHITNEY1591.51 -1591.51 With1591.51 one1591.75 of1591.91 the1591.99 units.1592.15 Right.1592.47
1592.87 SCHREIBER1592.87 -1592.87 So1592.87 you1593.03 couldn't1593.51 create1594.39 a1594.71 ADU1596.38 in1596.7 a1596.93 single1597.1 family1597.34 and1598.21 then1598.38 sell1599.1 two1599.34 condos.1599.49
1600.38 WHITNEY1600.38 -1600.38 Mhmm.1600.38 Right.1601.02
1601.82 NEUBACHER1601.82 -1601.82 Right.1601.82 Also1602.54 to1602.78 clarify,1602.93 there's1603.34 no1603.65 exception1604.3 for1604.86 short1605.17 term1605.41 rentals.1605.65 The1606.21 city1607.17 law1607.97 and1608.13 short1608.21 term1608.45 rentals1608.54 applies1608.93 to1609.34 ADUs1609.49 as1609.89 well.1609.97
1610.05 SCHREIBER1610.05 -1610.05 It1610.05 could1610.13 not1610.3 be1610.45 used1610.62 as1610.78 a1611.73 short1611.81 term1611.89
1612.51 NEUBACHER1612.51 -1612.51 It1612.51 could1612.51 not1612.51 be1612.72 used1612.92 as1613.13 short1613.33 term1613.54 rentals.1613.75
1613.95 SCHREIBER1613.95 -1613.95 And1613.95 so1614.16 that's1614.37 explicitly1614.57 suggested1614.78 in1614.98 the1615.19 conditions.1615.81
1624.37 BUCK1624.37 -1624.37 Yeah.1624.37 Okay.1624.61
1627.8 JACOB1627.8 -1627.8 I1627.8 just1628.04 wanted1628.28 to1628.52 say1628.67 that1628.84 the1629 condo1629.72 association1630.12 issue1630.6 is1630.84 news1631.08 to1631.48 me1631.56 because1631.8 when1632.43 I1632.67 bought1632.84 the1633 place,1633.15 you1633.72 see1633.88 it1634.04 in1634.12 your1634.28 packet1636.67 at1637 the1637.15 very1637.32 end,1637.56 we1639.26 made1639.42 an1639.5 agreement1639.74 that1640.22 in1640.38 exchange1640.7 for1640.94 a1641.18 certain1641.34 amount,1641.58 both1644.14 condo1644.54 owners1644.94 or1645.34 the1645.5 other1645.66 owners1645.82 would1646.3 agree,1646.54 for1647.9 any1648.22 conversion1648.46 that1649.1 the1649.26 city1649.42 would1649.82 allow.1650.06 And,1650.94 honestly,1651.26 this1651.66 is1651.82 news1651.98 to1652.22 me.1652.3 I1652.46 didn't1652.54 know1652.78 you1652.94 guys1653.1 were1653.84 opposed1654.15 to1654.39 it.1654.56 That's1654.63 why1654.8 I1654.88 would1654.96 have1655.12 talked1655.2 to1655.36 you1655.43 about1655.6 it.1656 But1656.32 I1656.32 assumed1656.48 that1656.72 when1656.96 that1657.28 was1657.43 agreed1657.67 at1658.96 the1659.04 time1659.2 of1659.43 the1659.52 purchase1659.67 that1660.96 that's1661.36 not1661.67 gonna1661.84 be1662.15 an1662.24 issue.1662.39 And1663.76 that's1663.91 why1664.08 I1664.24 included1664.39 that1664.8 in1664.96 the1665.12 package.1665.2 Otherwise,1665.6 I1666.08 wouldn't1666.24 have1666.48 bought1666.56 the1666.8 place,1666.88 honestly,1667.12 not1667.52 for1667.76 the1667.91 price1668.08 that1668.32 I1668.48 did.1668.56
1672.35 BUCK1672.35 -1672.35 So1672.35 it1672.67 seems1672.99 to1673.31 me,1673.39 unless1673.55 there's1673.71 other1673.87 comments1675.47 specific1676.43 to1676.91 the1677.07 project,1677.23 what1678.67 I'm1678.91 hearing1679.07 is1679.55 that1679.79 our1681.23 only1682.67 right1684.94 as1685.42 a1685.66 planning1685.74 board1686.22 is1687.02 to1687.35 make1687.66 a1687.98 determination1688.14 as1689.18 to1689.35 whether1689.59 or1689.9 not1690.07 this1690.87 site1692.63 plan1692.94 review,1693.26 site1694.54 plan1694.87 violates1696.38 anything1697.18 that1700.07 the1701.03 code1701.19 requires.1701.67 And1702.79 I1703.27 think1703.51 we1704.15 will1704.39 probably1704.63 have1705.35 to1705.59 say1706.15 that,1706.39 no,1706.63 it1706.95 doesn't1707.27 because1707.59 what1709.11 we1709.43 have1709.75 to1710.07 read1711.35 has1711.75 nothing1711.99 to1712.39 do1712.63 with1712.79 condo1714.49 boards,1714.89 density,1715.45 neighbors.1716.41 This1717.45 is1717.69 all1717.86 the1718.97 ADU1719.38 regulations1720.41 were1721.93 given1722.17 to1722.49 us1722.73 by1722.89 the1723.05 state1723.3 and1724.17 we1724.89 can1725.05 only1725.3 deal1725.54 with1725.78 those1726.02 regulations.1726.26 So,1727.36 we1728 can1728.24 be1728.4 sympathetic1728.56 to1729.44 density,1729.92 we1730.48 can1730.64 be1730.8 sympathetic1731.04 to1731.52 the1732.16 issues1732.48 that1732.88 you're1733.12 bringing1733.52 up1734.08 for1734.4 sure,1734.64 but1734.88 we1735.04 can't1735.12 do1735.44 anything1735.6 about1736.08 it1736.24 as1736.72 a1736.88 planning1737.04 board,1737.44 I1737.76 believe.1737.92
1740.22 COHEN1740.22 -1740.22 Would1740.22 it1740.31 be1740.63 fair1740.7 to1740.94 say1741.11 that1741.27 it's1742.55 sort1742.87 of1743.03 a,1743.98 the1744.22 decision1744.38 that1744.79 we're1744.94 gonna1745.11 come1745.35 to1745.51 is1745.74 completely1745.9 agnostic1746.31 of1746.79 the1746.87 ownership1747.11 structure1747.59 of1748.22 this1748.38 condo?1749.03 Like,1749.83 we1752.63 could1752.79 assume,1753.03 without1754.25 changing1754.57 anything1755.05 here,1755.45 that1755.61 this1755.77 is1756.01 a1756.17 single1757.37 family1757.69 three1758.33 story1758.65 house1759.13 and1760.25 make1760.49 the1761.45 determination1761.69 on1762.41 the1762.57 basis1762.73 of1763.29 that,1763.53 and1764.33 then1764.49 the1764.73 rest1764.89 is1765.13 just1765.29 gonna1765.45 play1765.69 itself1765.93 out1766.33 outside1766.57 of1766.97 our1767.13 purview.1767.37
1768.85 SCHREIBER1768.85 -1768.85 Yeah.1768.85 I1769.33 mean,1769.57 in1769.81 an1770.05 ideal1770.29 world,1770.68 there1771.16 would1771.4 already1771.64 have1771.88 been1772.05 an1772.29 agreement1772.37 in1772.85 place.1773.01
1773.72 COHEN1773.72 -1773.72 An1773.72 agreement1773.88 in1774.29 place.1774.45 Yeah.1774.77
1775.09 SCHREIBER1775.09 -1775.09 And1775.09 so1775.24 we,1775.96 for1776.13 this1776.13 one,1776.29 we1776.61 put1776.77 a1777.09 condition1777.33 that1779.16 we1779.33 felt1779.57 was1779.81 exactly1780.29 reasonable1780.77 and1781.24 is1781.48 actually1781.57 just1781.88 what1782.13 is1782.29 required1782.45 to1783.13 pull1783.29 a1783.45 building1783.53 permit.1784.49 That1784.65 there1784.81 has1785.05 to1785.21 be,1785.37 they1786.17 have1786.33 to1786.57 submit,1786.73 you1787.13 know,1787.29 the1787.53 proof1787.61 that1787.93 they1788.17 have1788.57 the1788.73 right1788.89 to1790.09 proceed1790.25 with1790.65 the1790.89 ADU.1791.05 The1792.57 petitioner1792.81 shall1793.29 submit1793.53 documentation1793.93 to1794.57 the1794.73 city1794.89 that1795.13 the1795.37 condominium1795.45 owners1796.25 consent1798.97 to1799.29 the1799.45 approved1799.61 development,1800.01 basically,1801.13 at1801.68 the1801.92 time1802.01 of1802.24 the1802.4 building1802.48 permit.1802.81 So1803.21 what1804.57 we1805.53 don't1805.77 want1806.01 is1806.24 for1806.4 them1806.57 to1806.73 go1807.37 through1807.53 all1807.68 the1807.85 work1807.92 to1808.16 do1808.33 the1808.57 process,1808.73 submit1809.37 a1810.48 building1810.57 permit,1810.81 and1811.13 then1811.29 to1811.53 have1811.61 it1811.85 just1812.01 become,1813.09 but,1813.17 again,1813.41 it's1813.65 up1813.89 they,1814.77 ultimately,1815.49 he1816.13 could1816.45 try1816.69 to1816.93 apply1817.25 for1817.49 a1817.73 building1817.81 permit.1818.13 So1818.53 this1818.77 is1819.01 a1819.57 reasonable1819.73 condition1820.21 to1820.61 make1820.85 sure1821.01 it's1821.17 clear1821.33 that1821.57 they1821.97 do1822.13 need1822.37 buy1824.61 in1824.77 from1825.01 the1825.25 condo1826.16 structure.1827.13
1827.13 COHEN1827.13 -1827.13 So,1827.13 like,1827.29 your1827.77 agreement1827.85 could1828.24 become1828.48 to1828.8 after1829.29 the1829.61 fact,1829.77 after1830.16 whatever1831.53 we1831.92 decide,1832.8 say1832.96 we1832.96 approve1833.13 it.1834.09 And1834.33 then1834.33 it's1834.57 for1834.88 them1835.04 to1835.2 figure1835.37 out1835.61 whether1836.33 or1836.64 not1836.8 they1837.04 can1837.29
1838.24 SCHREIBER1838.24 -1838.24 Yeah.1838.24 And1838.4 I1838.57 guess1838.88 to1839.13 try1839.44 to1839.68 explain1839.77 this,1840.16 this1841.84 is1842.08 an1842.24 add1842.48 on1842.64 step.1844.48 So1845.12 normally,1845.12 by1845.68 right,1845.92 like,1846.72 was1846.96 noted1847.28 about1847.76 the1848 property1848.16 next1848.56 door,1849.12 by1849.36 right1849.36 means1849.6 you1850.24 apply1850.48 for1850.72 a1850.88 building1850.96 permit,1853.04 you1853.68 build1853.84 what1854.24 is1854.4 allowed1854.64 in1854.96 zoning.1855.12 So1856.1 the1856.26 property1856.41 next1856.73 door1856.97 built1857.21 an1857.45 addition1857.69 on1858.1 the1858.26 rear1858.34 that's1859.29 close1859.93 to1860.17 the1860.41 property1860.49 line1860.82 by1861.53 right1861.77 with1862.34 a1862.58 building1862.73 permit.1862.97 The1864.01 only1864.17 recourse1864.58 would1865.13 be1865.38 for,1865.77 you1866.1 know,1866.26 an1866.65 appeal1866.82 of1868.49 the1868.65 building1868.82 permit,1869.13 which1869.45 has1869.69 nothing1869.86 to1870.17 do1870.34 with1870.49 the1870.65 planning1872.28 board.1872.68 It1873.56 may1873.72 have1873.72 something1873.88 to1874.12 do1874.28 with1874.36 the1874.52 zoning1874.6 board1874.92 but1875.24 it1875.4 would1875.56 have1875.72 to1875.88 be1875.96 based1876.04 on1876.28 zoning.1876.44 So1877.48 in1877.72 this1878.2 case,1878.36 we've1878.84 added1879.16 an1880.36 additional1880.52 step1881.08 as1881.32 an1881.48 interim1881.72 measure1882.12 for1882.76 ADUs,1883.16 which1884.04 is1884.2 to1885.05 allow,1885.29 to1887.2 have1887.85 a1889.61 hearing1889.77 in1890.33 this1890.57 site1891.13 plan1891.37 review1891.68 approval,1892.33 which1892.81 is1892.96 by1893.2 right,1893.37 but1893.77 has1894.16 the1894.48 board's1894.64 review.1895.05
1895.53 But,1895.53 ultimately,1895.68 as1896.57 Matthew1896.81 had1897.13 noted,1897.37 this1898.88 is1899.2 a1899.53 building1899.85 permit1900.24 issue.1901.31 Many1902.75 ADUs,1905.47 and1905.79 will1906.43 often1906.67 be1906.99 the1907.15 case,1907.23 may1907.95 be1908.19 a1908.43 building1908.59 permit1908.91 only1909.23 in1909.47 the1909.63 future,1909.71 because1910.51 it1910.83 really1910.91 is1911.15 a1911.31 building1911.47 permit1911.79 process.1912.11 The1912.83 state1913.07 did1913.39 not,1913.55 you1914.11 know,1914.27 you1914.96 can't1915.21 reasonably1915.61 create1916.4 a1916.72 barrier1916.81 to1917.29 it.1917.37 And1918.09 so1918.24 we're1918.4 just1918.64 noting1918.81 the1919.77 logical1919.92 facts,1920.57 which1920.88 is1921.13 we1921.53 can't1921.68 require1921.92 parking1922.24 because1922.64 there's,1922.88 you1923.21 know,1923.29 nowhere1923.53 in1923.92 Watertown1924.09 can1924.72 require1924.96 a1925.37 parking1925.53 space.1925.85 This1926.72 ADU1927.29 actually1927.53 has1927.93 a1928.17 parking1928.25 space1929.85 but1930.17 you1930.17 can't1930.41 require1930.65 it.1931.93 And1932.17 it1932.17 meets1932.33 all1932.57 the1932.81 conditions1932.97 from1933.85 the1934.09 state's1934.73 mandated1935.29 requirements.1935.85
1937.13 COHEN1937.13 -1937.13 Can1937.13 I1937.29 ask1937.37 one1937.53 more1937.69 question1937.85 and1938.17 then1938.25 I'll1938.49 stop1938.65 talking1938.97 because1939.29 I'm1939.53 sure1939.69 you1940.01 guys1940.17 also1940.41 have1940.73 questions?1940.89 But1941.29 when1942.38 we1942.7 talk1942.78 about1943.11 the1943.42 restrictions1943.74 on1944.38 our1944.63 ability1944.78 to1945.42 condition1945.74 or1946.14 make1946.3 any1946.54 changes1946.78 to1947.18 it,1947.35 is1947.66 that1947.83 akin1947.98 to1948.3 the1948.46 Dover1948.63 amendment?1948.94 Is1949.51 it1949.59 sort1949.74 of1949.98 the1950.14 same1950.22 situation1952.54 that1953.35 we1953.59 find1953.74 ourselves1953.9 in1954.38 in1954.54 terms1954.7 of1955.02 how1955.26 much1955.51 we1957.73 can1957.97 affect?1958.21
1959.09 SCHREIBER1959.09 -1959.09 The1959.09 so1959.33 called1959.57 Dover1959.97 amendment.1960.37 It's1962.45 in1962.61 the1962.77 same1962.85 section1964.93 but1965.17 it1965.17 is1965.49 different1967.09 than1967.57 others1968.21 in1968.85 that1969.01 it1969.17 is1969.99 also1970.23 connected1970.71 to1971.12 what1971.36 a1971.6 single1971.67 family1971.91 has1972.23 for1972.47 rights,1972.63 which1972.95 are1973.2 more.1973.36
1976.56 COHEN1976.56 -1976.56 Okay.1976.56 Thank1977.04 you.1977.2 Gotcha.1977.52
1978.47 SCHREIBER1978.47 -1978.47 Without1978.47 getting1978.8 into1979.04 a1979.36 lot1979.43 more1979.6 detail,1979.84 perhaps1980.47 one1980.88 of1981.04 the1981.43 board1981.52 members1981.76 has1982.08 thoughts1982.47 on1982.88 it.1982.95
1983.44 WHITNEY1983.44 -1983.44 So,1983.44 Gideon,1983.6 maybe1983.84 on1984.4 condition1984.96 7,1985.28 just1985.6 to1985.84 make1985.92 it1986.08 clear,1986.16 because1986.32 I1986.56 think1986.64 what1986.8 you1986.96 were1987.04 saying1987.2 is1987.52 that1987.6 this1988 consent1988.32 from1988.88 the1989.12 condo1989.44 association1989.84 needs1991.04 to1991.28 be1991.44 provided1991.52 at1992 the,1992.64 right1992.8 now,1992.88 it1993.04 says1993.2 at1993.44 the1993.6 time1993.76 of1994 building1994.16 permit.1994.48 Shouldn't1995.38 it1995.69 be1995.78 at1995.86 the1995.93 time1996.02 of1996.34 applying1996.49 for1996.89 a1996.98 building1997.06 permit?1997.38 You're1997.78 trying1998.1 to,1998.34 are1998.65 you1998.82 saying1998.97 that1999.54 needs1999.69 to1999.86 be1999.93 part2000.02 of2000.26 the2000.34 application2000.41 for2002.41 the2002.58 building2002.73 permit?2002.97
2005.13 SCHREIBER2005.13 -2005.13 I2005.45 mean,2005.54 someone2006.82 can2007.3 apply2007.45 for2007.78 a2008.02 building2008.1 permit,2008.41 but2008.89 it2009.13 won't2009.21 get2009.45 issued.2009.62
2011 WHITNEY2011 -2011 Without2011 that?2011.24
2011.64 SCHREIBER2011.64 -2011.64 Yeah.2011.64 Alright.2011.88
2012.12 WHITNEY2012.12 -2012.12 As2012.12 long2012.28 as2012.44 that2012.52
2012.76 SCHREIBER2012.76 -2012.76 It's2013.64 not2013.96 my2014.2 process2014.36 that,2016.6 we2016.68 can2016.68 get2016.84 incomplete2017.08 building2017.8 permits2018.12 or2018.76 building2019 permits2019.4 that2019.8 don't2019.88 comply,2020.04 and2020.52 they2020.68 just2020.84 sit.2021 And2021.24 then2021.32 eventually,2021.48 they2021.96 make2023.49 that2023.73 expire.2023.73
2023.73 WHITNEY2023.73 -2023.73 I2023.73 just2023.89 wanted2023.89 to2023.89 make2023.97 that2024.05 more2024.93 clear.2025.17 And2025.41 I2025.65 just2025.89 wanna,2026.13 just2026.45 for2026.69 the2026.86 record2026.93 as2027.17 well,2027.34 just2027.58 note2027.82 that2027.97 in2028.93 the2029.1 application,2029.34 there's2029.89 a2030.13 statement2030.29 in2030.69 here2030.78 about2031.02 the2032.54 project.2033.1 It2033.34 says,2033.34 the2033.34 project2033.41 would2033.73 keep2033.97 the2034.13 carriage2034.29 house2034.62 in2034.86 its2035.02 current2035.26 shape,2036.03 that2036.27 is2036.27 no2036.67 additions2036.99 or2037.39 any2037.55 changes2037.79 to2038.19 the2038.27 exterior,2038.43 but2038.91 the2039.55 applicant2039.63 was2040.11 talking2040.27 about2040.59 potentially2040.83 changing2041.31 that2041.71 garage2042.11 door2042.51 into2042.91 a2043.23 glass2043.39 sliding2044.11 door.2044.59 So2044.91 that2045.39 would2045.55 be2045.71 an2045.87 exterior2046.03 change,2046.67 so2046.83 just2046.83 for2047.47 the2047.63 record,2047.79 it's2048.03 what2048.7 the2048.86 application2049.03 says2049.59 didn't2050.22 really2050.47 match2050.7 what2050.86 was2051.03 in2051.18 the2051.34 plan.2051.43 So,2051.82 at2052.78 least2052.95 it's2053.34 clear2053.59 that's2053.91 what2054.14 we're2054.3 talking2054.39 about,2054.7 that2054.86 that's2055.03 included2055.82 in2056.39 there.2056.55 And2058.7 I2058.95 think2059.03 just2059.26 in2059.51 terms2059.66 of,2059.91 like,2060.07 the,2060.22 I2060.47 walked2060.55 around2060.78 the2061.03 neighborhood2061.18 this2061.91 evening.2062.07 I2062.39 met2062.47 the2062.63 abutters2062.78 there2063.43 when2063.74 I2063.82 walked2064.54 up.2065.26 And,2065.42 you2067.5 know,2067.58 the2067.82 spacing2068.06 between2068.46 the2069.02 various2069.18 homes2069.58 in2069.98 that2070.14 neighborhood,2070.46 they're2071.42 all,2071.74 it's2073.9 fairly2074.14 tight.2074.54 There's2075.18 some2075.98 variance2076.3 in2076.78 it,2076.94 but2077.02 they're2077.26 all2077.42 fairly2077.58 tight2077.98 as2078.22 you're2078.54 walking2078.78 down2078.78 that2079.7 street2080.66 there.2080.82 So2080.97 it2081.14 is2081.22 a2081.38 relatively2081.7 dense2083.22 neighborhood.2083.53
2083.93 And2083.93 I2084.09 look2084.26 back2084.49 in2084.66 the,2084.89 back2085.45 behind2085.86 it,2086.18 and2086.49 there's2086.74 two2087.05 homes.2087.3 It2088.49 was2088.57 kinda2088.74 hard2088.89 to2089.05 see2089.22 with2089.3 the2089.45 trees,2089.53 but2089.86 it2090.01 seems2090.09 like2090.26 the2090.82 homes2090.97 themselves2091.3 are2091.61 offset2091.78 a2092.09 little2092.26 bit,2092.41 but2092.74 the2092.98 gap2093.14 in2093.22 between2093.54 the2094.58 carriage2094.82 house2095.22 and2095.86 the2096.02 762096.18 Building2096.74 and2097.46 the2098.26 black2098.42 was2098.74 that2098.9 82?2099.06 It2099.46 was2099.54 a2099.7 black2099.78 building.2099.94 82.2100.34 It2101.14 seemed2101.38 like2101.62 it2101.78 was2101.94 more2102.34 or2102.66 less2102.74 the2103.06 same,2103.14 in2104.66 there.2104.82 Because2105.14 that2105.3 was2105.46 one2105.62 of2105.7 the2105.78 things2105.86 you're2106.18 when2106.34 you2106.58 when2106.9 you2107.14 were2107.22 driving2107.46 outside,2107.63 you2107.74 know,2107.86 if2107.98 you2108.11 look2108.59 at2108.82 the2108.98 proximity2109.3 between2109.86 the2110.11 2,2110.26 that2110.51 I2110.74 did2110.91 pay2111.14 some2111.3 extra2111.46 attention2111.7 to2112.11 that.2112.26 And2113.07 it's2113.22 a2113.39 cool2113.46 building.2113.78 It's2114.98 I2115.14 would2115.22 love2115.39 to2115.55 have2115.63 seen2115.78 what2115.94 that2116.11 building2116.26 looked2116.51 like,2116.66 like,2116.91 in2117.14 the2117.3 1800s2118.51 or2118.59 so2118.59 with2118.82 the2118.94 shingles2119.07 and2120.43 horses2120.74 probably2120.74 in2121.07 there.2121.14 So2121.84 just2122.16 a2122.48 really2122.64 cool2122.8 building2122.96 with2123.28 architecture.2123.44
2125.6 BUCK2125.6 -2125.6 Yeah.2125.6 Well,2128.8 I2129.28 think2129.44 Sarah,2130.16 do2130.56 you2130.72 have2130.8 any?2130.96 Okay.2131.68 As2135.78 I2136.09 said,2136.18 we2136.49 can2136.66 only2136.82 rule2137.05 on2137.38 what2137.45 we're2137.61 allowed2137.78 to2138.09 rule2138.18 on.2138.49 So,2138.66 I2140.34 think2140.49 we2141.05 will2141.3 go2141.61 ahead2141.86 with2142.18 a2143.45 conditional2146.34 recommendation,2146.34 and2147.7 it's2150.04 back2150.28 in2150.44 your2150.68 court2150.92 to2151.24 figure2151.88 out2152.28 how2152.6 to2152.76 proceed.2153.88
2154.44 WHITNEY2154.44 -2154.44 So2155.32 I'll2155.64 make2155.8 a2155.96 motion2156.04 that2156.6 the2156.84 planning2157 board2157.32 conditionally2157.56 approve2158.2 the2158.52 petitioner's2158.76 request2159.4 for2159.88 by2160.2 right2160.44 site2160.92 plan2161.32 review2161.56 to2162.61 install2162.77 protected2163.09 use2163.72 accessory2164.13 dwelling2165.57 unit2165.97 within2166.36 the2166.68 existing2166.84 carriage2167.24 house2167.57 at2168.2 762168.45 Hovey2169.41 Street2169.97 Hovey2170.53 Street,2171.16 right?2172.68 As2172.68 it2172.93 meets2173.09 the2173.32 requirements2173.41 set2173.89 forth2174.05 in2174.29 the2174.36 Watertown2174.45 zoning2175.01 ordinance2175.32 and2175.75 a2175.83 Massachusetts2175.91 general2176.63 laws2176.95 Chapter2178.23 40A2178.63 Section2178.63 3.2178.63
2180.95 COHEN2180.95 -2180.95 I'll2180.95 second2181.19 the2181.51 motion.2181.59
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE
2202.16 BUCK2202.16 -2202.16 And2202.16 if2202.47 there's2202.64 nothing2202.88 further2203.28 on2203.67 our2203.76 agenda,2203.99 I2204.55 will2204.71 adjourn2204.88 the2205.28 meeting.2205.43